3.0 of 5 stars – Enjoyable Sword & Sorcery With Standard Good vs. Evil.
(I'm excited to have won this as part of a Goodreads Giveaway – so thanks, Michael!)
This was a nice adventure fantasy of good vs. evil, with some creative magic and world-building. While this is the first in the series that I’ve read, it’s okay as a standalone (in the sense that it didn’t take me long to catch up on what happened previously); but beware that the ending will leave you without a solid conclusion to take you into book 4.
Michael Ploof has a nice writing style, with decent descriptions of the action and surroundings that helped you picture it (yet, while I usually don’t comment about this, it did have quite a few typos and errors). The plot also flowed at a fairly fast pace, with a few storylines going to keep it interesting.
For me, it read like it was for YA readers, and indeed at the end I saw that it grew out of a story for his kids. I’m fine with that as far as keeping the language and violence PG, but also in this case it ended up not being as believable or interestingly gritty, nor as complicated in its plot and characters (e.g., the simplicity in strategizing for the battles, and the sword play being pretty straightforward without the good detail as some I’ve read). Thus, the characters and plot were fairly predictable and standard (entertaining, not much new or much depth), with basic black and white, good vs. evil, and little gray in between. I did find the characters likable, but I wasn’t fully invested in them.
Overall, I found it an easy, fun read; and probably best for those who are looking for a more basic, traditional type of sword and sorcery/hero fantasy.