It isn’t possible for me to review a second book in a series without comparing it to the first. I will do so now. There were a few bits of book one that troubled me, mainly the overly dark villain, but as a whole, the story was well done. The world of Karov has a solid basis, and its clear that the author has gone out of her way to explain every little detail we readers might call into question. That is true for both books. Book two, unfortunately, is not as good as the first (at least in my opinion).
The second book in a series is often a gamble. Typically, you have the same hero on a continuing quest. That is not the case here. As some other fantasy authors have done, Salpeter places this story in the future, and gives us a new cast of characters. That is easy to accept, though I personally would have preferred carrying on with the same storyline.
This book could easily be read without reading book one of the series. There is enough explanation of what happened in book one, and there is plenty of information to fill in the gaps. Unfortunately, those explanations slow down the action of this book dramatically. In fact, they pretty much take over. There is so little action to this book that I hardly wanted to finish it. Having read this author before, I hoped it would get better, so I continued to read. Sadly, my wish never came true. The vast majority of this book involves the main characters standing around being told stories of what has been going on in the world of Karov. That was a disappointment.
There are problems with the characters as well. First off, Josh, the main character, is a college student, but he is immensely articulate. He must be an English major. I have never read a book with a male protagonist of his age being so well-spoken. Secondly, his companion Sean was required to come along, but he plays no major part and he could have been left out entirely. Also, the villain Effram goes from bad to good randomly, and his dialogue and actions kept me confused through most of his scenes. He is far too inconsistent for my tastes.
The author couldn’t escape without detailing actions of Alec, the ruthless villain who appeared in book one. Though he is not present in the story, I was forced to relive some of his vile, treacherous acts. There is still no explanation for why he is the way he is, and he has no redeeming qualities nor a reason to act the way he does. I know a story needs a villain, and I do enjoy hating them, but this guy is evil for the purpose of being evil. There is not past act nor current reason for him to be the way he is. He is not charismatic, and I’ve never heard of a mental condition like his. I still hate him, as I did in the first book. A look inside his head might be in order should he appear in subsequent books. I’d like to know what his problem is.
The last chapter or two finally brings in a tiny bit of action. The war is begun and completed within that short span, and there isn’t enough action to call it a war. It’s more like a petty squabble with big consequences. I finished the book without ever thinking that the story had begun. Instead of telling me what happened over the years, show me. Those missing books would be far better than cramming everything into this one. Then skip to Josh and Sean somewhere down the road and have them do something more than stand around talking for ninety percent of the book.
The writing is done well, but it is a bit lacking in description. I have no idea what the main character looked like. I may have overlooked a line or two while I was searching for action, though. This book could use an experienced proofreader. There aren’t many typos, but some phrases are not grammatically correct. The author sometimes writes the way people talk rather than the way that is correct, and it was noticeable. I am no expert, but I do know the basic rules. Any author should know just as much.
I was given a free copy in exchange for an honest review.