From Harvard Business School Professor and Co-Director of the Harvard Kennedy School’s Center for Public A guide to making better decisions, noticing important information in the world around you, and improving leadership skills.
Imagine your advantage in negotiations, decision-making, and leadership if you could teach yourself to see, and evaluate, information that others overlook. The Power of Noticingprovides the blueprint for accomplishing precisely that. Max Bazerman, an expert in the field of applied behavioral psychology, draws on three decades of research and his experience instructing Harvard Business School MBAs and corporate executives to teach you how to notice and act on information that may not be immediately obvious.
Drawing on a wealth of real-world examples, from the Challenger Space Shuttle disaster to Bernie Madoff’s Ponzi scheme, Bazerman diagnoses what information went ignored in these situations, and why. Using many of the same case studies and thought experiments designed in his executive MBA classes, he challenges readers to explore their cognitive blind spots, identify any salient details they are programmed to miss, and then take steps to ensure it won’t happen again. While many bestselling business books have explained how susceptible to manipulation our irrational cognitive blindspots make us, Bazerman helps you avoid the habits that lead to poor decisions and ineffective leadership in the first place. His bookprovides a step-by-step guide to breaking bad habits and spotting the hidden details that will change your decision-making and leadership skills for the better, teaching you pay attention to what didn’t happen; acknowledge self-interest; invent the third choice; and realize that what you see is not all there is.
With The Power of Noticing at your side, you can learn how to notice what others miss, make better decisions, and lead more successfully.
Max H. Bazerman is the Jesse Isidor Straus Professor of Business Administration at the Harvard Business School and the Co-Director of the Center for Public Leadership at the Harvard Kennedy School. Max's research focuses on decision making, negotiation, and ethics. He is the author, co-author, or co-editor of twenty books and over 200 research articles and chapters. His latest book, The Power of Noticing: What the Best Leader See, is now available from Simon and Schuster.
This is a book about how the ability to see things that others don't and use such insight to make decisions is a competitive advantage for leaders. The premise is that the best leaders have an ability to notice additional information that is otherwise invisible to others and thus is essential to their success. There are a few valuable nuggets such as not limiting your options to just the data that is placed in front of you, being mindful of overconfidence and staying vigilant against misdirection. There is also an interesting chapter on how group think can undermine the best decisions when members of a cross-functional team fail to share with the team the very data they were brought in to share: unique information that they alone possess and potentially their most important contribution to the team goes unshared. Also, the idea of seeing missing information (which re-enforces the benefit of seeking out data that isn't otherwise present) is well told using a Sherlock Holmes story, "Silver Blaze," in which a dog's doing nothing (i.e., failing to bark) was the key to solving a crime. Lastly, there are some good tidbits regarding thinking ahead and connecting dots in advance that are indirectly related.
All in all it was an interesting read. Most of the examples used drew heavily from financial frauds (i.e., Enron, 2008 Mortgage crisis, Madoff's ponzi scheme, JPMorgan Chase's London Whale, Barclay's LIBOR scandal, etc.). These made up most of the book in terms of its 191 pages, which I thought was a little too much. I would have liked a little more on how to apply the lessons vs. just showcasing instances that apply by looking backwards at events with 20:20 hindsight.
The author made good points but those points could've been made in perhaps a quarter of the book or less. Based on the amount of highlighting I did, the key thoughts made up less than about 20 pages and the rest was stories used to prove the key points, over and over again. There was a fair amount of repetition and although the author took a stab at sounding self-deprecating once in awhile, his references to himself predominantly fell under, "See? I've been right all along." The first 11 chapters lay out the problems. Chapter 12 very quickly reviews, in just 10 pages, a few bullet points on how to improve your own ability to notice. I am disappointed--the points made are interesting and good, but I'd have liked more actual attention to them, and more attention to how these points can be applied in a multitude of settings rather than focusing on Bernie Madoff, the mortgage industry, and ivy league schools.
How could that have happened? Why did I not see that coming? Why did I not notice the signs that are so clear in retrospect?
Professor Brazerman offers insights into why this happens, how it happens and how to get better at noticing. This book, he promises, “will provide you with the tools you need to open your eyes and truly notice for the first time— and for the rest of your life.”
The type of noticing Brazerman is referring to is not of a trivial type. Consider this example taken from the book:
JPMorgan Chase, the venerable financial institute lead by the brilliant Jamie Dimon failed to notice the bank’s exposure in their London branch. By September 2013, these huge bets failed, creating trading losses in excess of $ 6 billion.
I recall seeing a billboard outside a church that read: “If you love God, hoot. If you want to meet Him, text.” Accidents happen when drivers are focusing on tasks other than driving, such as talking on a cell phone or texting.
Not noticing has many causes, some of which relate to focusing on something else. Chapter 5 has the title: What Do Magicians, Thieves, Advertisers, Politicians, and Negotiators Have in Common? Magicians, Brazerman explains have mastered the skill of “keeping entire groups of people from noticing what should be clearly visible to them.” Magicians distract your attention and then take advantage of the short time when your mind is attending to other information. Advertisers do the same thing when they compare the specs of one product with another. Their product always has advantages the others do not.
Having a personal interest in not noticing does impair one’s ability to notice. Psychologists refer to this impairment as “motivated blindness.” It stops business people noticing when they are being defrauded by people they have trusted, and parents noticing that their children are on drugs. We are motivated by our emotional relationships not to notice.
In 2012 Barclays paid fines of $ 450 million after admitting to manipulating the calculation of the London InterBank Offered Rate. This manipulation that cost many investors dearly was committed by a number of huge banks and with the knowledge of many members of staff. Journalist Naomi Wolf wrote in the Guardian: “It is very hard… to ignore the possibility that this kind of silence…is simply rewarded by promotion to ever higher positions, ever greater authority.”
There is also “moral blindness,” where people ignore the abuse of others when they could have reported it and stopped it. In many cases, there is an incentive not to notice. Jamie Dimon commented on the costly error at JPMorgan Chase: “The big lesson I learned: Don’t get complacent despite a successful track record.” Brazerman takes this lesson wider and asserts “successful leadership is defined by vigilance.”
A good place to start is to notice whether there are processes in your company that encourage the wrong behaviour.
One of my favorite parts of the book discusses indirect affects of decisions and how leaders usually do not think about adverse affects when making decisions. A decision by US department store chain Sears in the 1990s elucidates the need to consider indirect effects:
Sears management set a quota for auto repair employees to book $147 hourly in sales. Although it seemed like a straightforward, profitable idea, the quota essentially encouraged employees to sell customers unnecessary repairs and equipment just to fill their quota. Sears should have more thoroughly considered the problem of motivation with such a quota system. Instead, management thought only of money and didn't consider how the policy might push employees to cheat the system.
I'd recommend this for anyone who wants to improve their decision-making skills especially for people in leadership positions with high-stake outcomes.
Readability: Hard --o-- Easy Practicality: Low ---o- High Insights: Few --o-- Many Length: Long ---o- Short Overall: Bad ---o- Amazing
Interesting premise, but this book was a bit sloppy. In each chapter, the author tends to introduce a vague idea (generally pulled from others' work, rather than a new concept) and details a couple real-world examples that are sometimes interesting, but only superficially linked to the original concept. Then the chapters conclude with passing references to other concepts that are introduced earlier in the book or later on. I learned a lot more in this genre from more focused and comprehensive books like "Thinking Fast and Slow" and "Mistakes Were Made (But Not by Me)".
The underlying principle of this book pivots on the human tendency to think in terms of WYSIATI (What You See Is All There Is). The power of noticing is the antidote to this limitation, directing us to seek information we do not initially see or notice, and demonstrating how we can uncover information that could be imperative for astute decision-making. It requires the awareness that What You See Is Not All There Is (WYSINATI). Bazerman uses examples of “predictable surprises” to illustrate how past disastrous events could have been foreseen and mitigated if information hidden in plain sight had been recognized and addressed, such as the sub-prime mortgage crisis, Hurricane Katrina’s devastation of New Orleans, and the 9/11 attack.
We are often presented with what seems like all the information we need to make a decision, when in fact we should be asking for additional information. We fall victim to inattentional blindness—failing to notice fully visible, unexpected information because our attention is focused on other considerations. What's in front of you is rarely all there is. Developing the practice of asking questions, like “What do I wish I knew?” and “What additional information would help inform my decision?” can make all the difference. Instead, we limit our analysis to easily available data, or whatever is at hand or made available to us. We can also fail to confront disconfirming evidence or seek only evidence that supports what we want to be true, all forms of confirmation bias.
This book is a little dated now, but still has relevance and offers powerful concepts for better decision making.
Instead of the Power of Noticing it might better be called the Danger of Not Noticing. He tells several stories (many of which have probably crossed your Facebook newsfeed over the past 10 years) illustrating different forms of blindness and the consequences. It's value is in making us more aware of our blind spots, but you could have come to the same conclusions by paying attention to the news and seeing how many have failed, been led astray, or treated unfairly because they did not see the full picture.
Demerits: It was a very easy read, however, it read more like a piece of pop-science. It constantly harps on how we should notice things that may occur in the future and the consequences of short-termism. However, the book doesn't adequately address criticisms to his theories like a lack of resources, or the existence of hindsight bias. While the editorial aspect could have worked out, the mere references to studies were not enough to make it substantive enough.
He mentions helpful exercises for developing the skill of noticing, but I did not **notice** any concrete advice other than anecdotes. As another reviewer said, this book is about learning through telling versus instruction. Dislike... About halfway through, I skipped to the last chapter, which summarizes all of his again in a nice, concise manner and called it good.
Irritating book that is mainly comprised of stories that reveal the author's hindsight bias. Lots of stories full of 'should of' commentary that does little to give the reader a plan for avoiding issues in their own business. This is not a book written to give the reader insight, it is a book written to give the author an outlet for Monday morning quarterbacking popular news events.
Nothing but anecdotes; there's no "meat" to this book. He just repeats that you--as a leader--should look beyond the normal, or outside of the box. Wow. Revolutionary. Thank you. This was a waste of time. Not even Kindle shows reader highlights past the first 70 pages. That should tell you something.
You're not going to come away from reading this book with any new insights. It's a collection of relatively mundane observations, in retrospect, of how some executives apparently made the right choices. If I was the author I would be somewhat embarrassed if this was the depth of my insight. I don't recommend it.
It's an interesting concept at first, but it's both written in rather too self-adulatory a tone, and also gets a bit repetitive, towards the end. It's also a touch too anecdote-driven - there are 12 chapters, but it isn't always clear what distinct concept each chapter is organised around, because the author is often more interested in telling a story than making an argument.
The concept of this book is a good one and there were valuable nuggets of insight but I think it could have been a much, much shorter book to convey them. I ended up skimming through most of the book.
Should be titled "Horrible things that will happen if you don't notice." Not sure that I picked up any skills as a leader, but the last chapter was the most useful in terms of skills to develop.
Picked up two things to remember: 1. What are my choices (what other choices am I not considering)? 2. What more information do I need? Close the gaps.
Tbh I was expecting more of Bazerman. Maybe it was because I was expecting (and hoping for) something completely different, I couldn't really get into this.
After reading the recently released Negotiation: The Game Has Changed, I wanted to read more negotiation books by Max H. Bazerman. So I picked up The Power of Noticing, without noticing that it was not a negotiation book. Instead, it was more of a general management book on being aware to notice important signposts. Even though it is not a book on negotiation, I still enjoyed and learned from it. And because it was written in 2014, I enjoyed the trip down memory lane when Bazerman discussed businesses that were in the news back then. Even though the book written more than a decade ago, the lesson it contains are timeless and still applicable today.
Could the housing bubble have been predicted? What about Hurricane Katrina? Other major events for businesses and individuals? "The Power of Noticing" is all about paying attention and taking a step back to pause, reflect, and then selecting the best path forward. The author is a bit self-aggrandizing, but it is worth a read.
Interesting in the first half - moves to a lot more of common Sense in latter part
I liked the first half. Second half was ok - it says common sense things like paying attention to warning signs of some impending disaster though it does not really tell how to do it - just that you should be on the lookout
Memorable takeaway: When crisis happens, self-reflect and self-develop by focusing on factors within your control, don't attribute everything to external factors.