I am a fan of Test Kitchen, and used to get the magazine until I decided I really have enough recipes for a lifetime. This is the first cookbook I’ve bought in, possibly, three years. I bought it for two reasons, 1) it is recipes for 2, which suits my life, and, 2) I’m a fan of Test Kitchen. But, after buying the book and doing some recipes, I recalled all the things about Test Kitchen that aren’t good enough to make this a great (or even very good) cookbook.
The idea of this book - as advertised by the title - was to present smaller recipe sizes. Yet a fair number of those I’ve done just seem to halve the ingredients (1/2 a fennel bulb for example). What am I going to do with the other half? Throw it out? Let it rot in my frig? while I feel guilty about not being a grand enough cook to know the perfect dish to create with 1/2 a fennel bulb. I bought the book to avoid waste. Very annoying. Not all recipes are like this, and some are portions of ingredients I can otherwise use up. (I would be a sad cook indeed if I could use up 1/2 an onion before it goes bad. But, it is still pressure to find a use for it in 2 days. (Every time I find a way to use up leftover ingredients I find myself quietly proud. I’ve stuck more things into an omelette than God intended.)
I also wish the recipes had both metric and Imperial measurements. Metric is just more precise. (Williams Sonoma cookbooks - which I reliably adore - tend to have this, so I’ve gotten accustomed to expecting this.). All it will take is measuring out the difference between a larger dosage of food X in metric and the Imperial equivalent and you will notice the difference.
Even more importantly, none of the recipes have nutritional information. In this day that is inexcusable. (Williams-Sonoma doesn’t tend to do this either, to be fair.) (The few recipes color coded as ‘light’ have nutritional information in the back. Why not all? And why not place the info with the recipe?) We all should be able to know the calorie intake, fat grams, protein, and tidbits about the dish being a good source of vitamin D and iron, for example.
Also, not every recipe has a picture. That just is not okay. Come on people.
Also, none of the dishes guide you with estimated active prep time, and cooking time. Very frustrating. I’m a pretty knowledgeable cook, so I can work my way into figuring this out - and often recipes with these guides are off. But they still help. You don’t want to be half way through a recipe only to read the next line (which you’d overlooked earlier - and I have done this more than once) which says, “let sit for 2 hours.”
Final complaint - some of these recipes are laden-down with little ingredients. And not ingredients you’d store in your pantry. This can equate to a lot of time and investment in food, just to make dinner. For example, the stuffed acorn squash with barley, page 196, has a total of 13 ingredients not including salt and pepper. That can be a lot to ask for a Monday night main dish. And this isn’t a special occasion dish, worthy of a lot of work - yet this recipe will require adding a lot of ingredients to my shopping list -many of which will not be used in full in this recipe (2 tablespoons fresh parsley; 1/4 cup pearl barley, 1/4 teaspoon fresh thyme, and 2 tablespoons pine nuts). It also, is a devotion of time. On average the main dishes have been 10-16 ingredients (excluding salt, pepper, and basic oils). Given that the premise of this book is cooking for two - there is a whole lot of work and waste going on.
The simple things I’ve noted: metric, nutrients, photos, and cook/prep times should be in every cookbook. They only aren’t because we let publishers get away with it. I bought this on Amazon. From now on I’m going to the bookstore to check it out first. I’m going to try to stick to my own advice.
All those complaints being said, the recipes are top notch. I love that there is a whole section on vegetation meals, in addition to a section on vegetable sides. I’m not a vegetarian but I rarely eat meat, so I love a book like this with so many new recipes.
Bon appetite!