In Robert Louis Stevenson’s short writing career it is certain that we cannot help but admire him for his great style and his imagination as he wrote some of the most classic children's stories that have passed through the centuries and have managed to remain, even today, quite well-known.
However, one of the most important stories of Stevenson’s career, which came to him - even if it was somewhat strange - through a dream, is definitely ‘The Strange Case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde’ as he created one of the most famed personalities that left its mark in the Horror genre.
Along in this volume we see also and Stevenson’s 1887 collection, ‘The Merry Men & Other Tales and Fables’; a collection of stories of mystery, crime and madness.
The Strange Case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde
The story of this novella follows Utterson, a lawyer and close friend of Dr Jekyll’s, as, after an unfortunate incident, he discovers along with his cousin that Hyde, a strange and an entirely unusual guy, lives in Dr Jekyll’s residence. But, despite his efforts to discover his origins, he will discover that Hyde is a much more mysterious personality than he had expected.
However, all that will change when after a horrendous incident he will have to seek Hyde and bring him to justice. Only that, what he will discover later is something, entirely, unreal and he will find himself against with something that he would had never believed possible and will change his life forever.
I must admit that before this novella I hadn’t had the chance before to read any of Stevenson’s stories. Nevertheless though, the story proves that it certainly deserves its fame as Stevenson has managed to create one of the strongest, and most important, personalities in the history of the Horror genre and to make, through his characters, a magnificent atmosphere.
Coming to its end I must say that it, indeed, leaves with a feeling that it could, certainly, have been developed a little more if Stevenson wanted it, but either way we cannot help but admire him for his ideas and for his, truly, unique and wonderful style. 8/10
The Merry Men
The second story of this collection focuses on Charles who, after his studies in Edinburgh, returns to his home in Aros, an isolated isle at the coasts of Scotland, to seek the treasures of a lost Spanish Armada.
However, Aros is an isle that is well-known for its wild waves and when a ship, as he will discover that is seeking too these lost treasures, gets caught in the waves of “The Merry Men” he will find himself against with his peculiar Uncle, and also with a black man that he believes he is the Devil himself.
It is a story, I could say, of mystery and madness with Stevenson showing his influences from his travel to the Isle of Erraid who went with his father when he was a young kid. As far as it comes to his writing it still remains quite good but, even though I certainly can’t say that it is a great story, what stands out here is Stevenson's, wonderful, descriptions that show his love and his passion for the sea. 7/10
Will O 'the Mill
The third story focuses on Will, a young man who lives with his foster parents in an isolated village in the mountains, and who dreams from his childhood to seek his own adventures in the world. But one day, as he will meet a traveller, he will begin to see things with a different perspective and, renouncing any commitment of marriage and of the life itself, he find himself on a lonely path that would later put him in Death’s hands.
It is a sad, and slightly strange, story but, even though Stevenson tries to pass some philosophical messages, it greatly lacks both with its plot and with this, particular, protagonist as we see him going through the stages of life and renouncing everything. 6/10
Markheim
The next story focuses on Markheim who, after being late to get a Christmas present for his girlfriend, finds himself in an antique shop. Only, despite the dealer’s good will to sell to him a rare item, he will be faced with a murder and with an, unusual, creature that will try to offer him back his life as he knew it and discharge him of his vicious acts.
It’s a story of an unspeakable murder that manages to combine pretty well also and the supernatural element with Stevenson putting the protagonist in an internal battle of Good-vs-Evil. It is definitely not an impressive story as much as ‘The Strange Case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde’, but it is cleverly enough written as to become in the end, at least, satisfying. 6.5//10
Thrawn Janet
This story follows, through an unnamed narrator, the events of Reverend Soulis in a small village as he comes up against with a witch that he believes she is possessed by the Devil himself.
This story is, one of the two that Stevenson wrote, completely in the Scottish dialect and this will, perhaps, make it a little more difficult than it actually is (especially for those who will read it in its original form). Nevertheless, it is a fairly small and quite strange story with a, relatively, good central idea but without succeeding to impress as much as the rest stories of this collection. 5/10
Olalla
The next story follows an, unnamed, soldier who, after recovering from his wounds from the battle of the Peninsular War, will be sent to reside temporarily with a noble family. Only that in this house he will discover that something very odd is happening and he will be faced with a beautiful girl, that he could not help but fall in love with her, and also with an unusual creature that its only desire is to drink his blood.
It is a very beautiful story, written in the same wonderful style as ‘The Strange Case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde’, and with Stevenson creating an, incredibly, dreamlike atmosphere. It is definitely one of the best stories in this collection and personally, I believe, perhaps also and the most magical one that Stevenson wrote in his career. 8.5/10
The Treasure of Franchard
The last story is a little different from the rest of this collection as it is the only one that doesn’t have any supernatural element.
It follows Desprez, a provincial French doctor who, after an accident with a stable-master, meets an orphan child and, seeing that he is much wittier than he shows, he will invite him to stay in his home.
However, Desprez is a man who always wanted to build his simple life to something better and when, luckily, he discovers a lost treasure in an deserted place his dreams perhaps might come true. But when, after a strange incident, this treasure disappears as suddenly as it came the young Jean-Marie will find himself against with the guiltiness of this theft, and also with the possibility to return once again back to his orphan life. Only that, what Desprez hadn’t counted on is that when one day his fate turns against him, the young Jean-Marie will surprise him with the most unique way and will show him something that he had forgotten.
The story, even though it doesn’t have any supernatural elements, proves a very beautiful and sweet story as Stevenson takes us through the life of that era in France, and showing us that there can be love even when you least expect it. It’s a beautiful story and, probably, the sweetest of all too. 7.5/10
Closing, I would only add that this collection has certainly a quite different variety of stories, with some being good and others not so much, but most of them, definitely, show Stevenson’s true talent and, that, I believe makes the biggest difference here.