What do you think?
Rate this book
The Iceberg Trilogy #1
Seldom Come By
If you crave epic, adventurous love stories, if Jamie and Claire, Alexander and Tatiana or Nathaniel and Elizabeth mean something to you, then meet Samuel and Rebecca and the iceberg that started it all.
Two years after the sinking of the Titanic, fifteen year-old Rebeca Crowe’s fascination with icebergs leads her to save a shipwrecked survivor, Samuel Dalton, the nineteen-year old son of a Toronto medical family. Love sparks in the crystal cave of an iceberg but is thwarted by an unreasonable father and the Great War that drags Samuel and his brother, Matthew, to the Western Front as medical officers.
Knowing Rebecca is home safe in Newfoundland brings Samuel great comfort. But as the war moves towards its final harrowing days, they both discover that tragedy and terror can strike anywhere, setting their love on an unforeseen path. Only when Samuel and Rebecca can fully come to terms with such devastating loss and their impossible choices can their love soar. With an emotional intensity reminiscent of The Bronze Horseman, Seldom Come By, named after an actual place in Newfoundland, is an unforgettable journey across waves and time and the full spectrum of human emotions.
"Seldom Come By is a haunting love story set against the windswept coast of Newfoundland. The story draws you in from the opening lines and takes you on a compelling journey across time and continents, through love, loss, heartache and healing. It is a beautiful and memorable story — a great accomplishment and a wonderful read."
Julie Fison, author of teenage romances in the Hardie Grant 'Smitten' series
"I read the first chapter of Seldom Come By in the Romance Writers of Australia's Ripping Start Competition and was immediately taken in by the beautiful descriptions, world building and the unique and soulful characterisation. And now that I’ve had the opportunity to read it all, I can say the whole book is wonderful, a real pleasure to read. The quality of writing is excellent and the story atmospheric and intriguing. Brilliant, absolutely beautiful."
Babette Furster, Romance Writers of Australia, Ripping Start Judge 2013
"Great job on creating that ‘fogged-in’ atmosphere that Newfoundland is famous for. I have lived that ‘fogged-in’ feeling many times. The iceberg was an amazing scene to experience. That sense of longing and yearning that followed was palpable. And from there the tension and excitement just grew, with scenes that were wrenching, breathtaking and moving."
Leah Sparkes, native Newfoundlander
"I loved the style of this book and the blossoming romance between Samuel and Rebecca. Their intense love for each other reminded me of Tatiana and Alexander. This book has a slow build then at a certain point it takes off and it is absolutely gripping. You are on the very edge of you seat. Your mouth is open. I so admire Rebecca — her strength to prevail through heartache and sadness, tragedy and loss, her toughness as a younger woman living in Newfoundland, and then later how she managed to come to terms with everything. Some scenes were particularly moving — tears down my face. This book has it all. I was enthralled. I simply could not put it down!"
Su Sprott, reader
"Set on the edge of Newfoundland, Seldom Come By tells the love story of shipwreck survivor Samuel Dalton and his rescuer, teenage Rebecca Crowe. The author's breathtaking descriptions of sea and landscapes and the historical setting drew me into the first few pages of the book but the relationships between the characters kept me reading.
Two years after the sinking of the Titanic, fifteen year-old Rebeca Crowe’s fascination with icebergs leads her to save a shipwrecked survivor, Samuel Dalton, the nineteen-year old son of a Toronto medical family. Love sparks in the crystal cave of an iceberg but is thwarted by an unreasonable father and the Great War that drags Samuel and his brother, Matthew, to the Western Front as medical officers.
Knowing Rebecca is home safe in Newfoundland brings Samuel great comfort. But as the war moves towards its final harrowing days, they both discover that tragedy and terror can strike anywhere, setting their love on an unforeseen path. Only when Samuel and Rebecca can fully come to terms with such devastating loss and their impossible choices can their love soar. With an emotional intensity reminiscent of The Bronze Horseman, Seldom Come By, named after an actual place in Newfoundland, is an unforgettable journey across waves and time and the full spectrum of human emotions.
"Seldom Come By is a haunting love story set against the windswept coast of Newfoundland. The story draws you in from the opening lines and takes you on a compelling journey across time and continents, through love, loss, heartache and healing. It is a beautiful and memorable story — a great accomplishment and a wonderful read."
Julie Fison, author of teenage romances in the Hardie Grant 'Smitten' series
"I read the first chapter of Seldom Come By in the Romance Writers of Australia's Ripping Start Competition and was immediately taken in by the beautiful descriptions, world building and the unique and soulful characterisation. And now that I’ve had the opportunity to read it all, I can say the whole book is wonderful, a real pleasure to read. The quality of writing is excellent and the story atmospheric and intriguing. Brilliant, absolutely beautiful."
Babette Furster, Romance Writers of Australia, Ripping Start Judge 2013
"Great job on creating that ‘fogged-in’ atmosphere that Newfoundland is famous for. I have lived that ‘fogged-in’ feeling many times. The iceberg was an amazing scene to experience. That sense of longing and yearning that followed was palpable. And from there the tension and excitement just grew, with scenes that were wrenching, breathtaking and moving."
Leah Sparkes, native Newfoundlander
"I loved the style of this book and the blossoming romance between Samuel and Rebecca. Their intense love for each other reminded me of Tatiana and Alexander. This book has a slow build then at a certain point it takes off and it is absolutely gripping. You are on the very edge of you seat. Your mouth is open. I so admire Rebecca — her strength to prevail through heartache and sadness, tragedy and loss, her toughness as a younger woman living in Newfoundland, and then later how she managed to come to terms with everything. Some scenes were particularly moving — tears down my face. This book has it all. I was enthralled. I simply could not put it down!"
Su Sprott, reader
"Set on the edge of Newfoundland, Seldom Come By tells the love story of shipwreck survivor Samuel Dalton and his rescuer, teenage Rebecca Crowe. The author's breathtaking descriptions of sea and landscapes and the historical setting drew me into the first few pages of the book but the relationships between the characters kept me reading.
511 pages, Kindle Edition
First published December 10, 2013
7 people are currently reading
662 people want to read
About the author
Sherryl Caulfield
3 books31 followersAustralian-born Sherryl Caulfield is a marketer, writer and traveller. After twenty years working for some of the world’s leading technology brands and a stint with Outward Bound, she longed to write about the human experience and the redemptive qualities of nature.
In 2006, haunted by an encounter with a woman she met in Canada, Sherryl started what has now become known as The Iceberg Trilogy. From her home in the Marlborough Sounds, New Zealand, she distilled the lives of three generations of women – Rebecca, Evangelene and Lindsay – over the course of a century. In the telling of their stories she crafted a series rich in landscapes – of sea, land and the human soul. Book 1 of The Iceberg Trilogy, Seldom Come By will be available in December 2013.
In 2006, haunted by an encounter with a woman she met in Canada, Sherryl started what has now become known as The Iceberg Trilogy. From her home in the Marlborough Sounds, New Zealand, she distilled the lives of three generations of women – Rebecca, Evangelene and Lindsay – over the course of a century. In the telling of their stories she crafted a series rich in landscapes – of sea, land and the human soul. Book 1 of The Iceberg Trilogy, Seldom Come By will be available in December 2013.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 58 reviews
March 14, 2014
I received this ARC from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
4.5 stars
I was a little daunted by the size of this book and the fact that it was part of a trilogy. Used to books that were half this size, I wondered if my attention would last the full book (it did--in fact it grew as I continued to read!) Then, there was the summary that the author provided where she mentioned Tatiana and Alexander and Jamie and Claire. Okay, you got my attention, but can you really pull that off?? These are some literary power couples and those names should not be tossed around lightly. I'll admit--I had a bit of a chip on my shoulder after that. Above all this, I had the encouragement from Hildy, my book boss, telling me to give this book a try and I try to listen to her suggestions. :)
This book was a real treat to read. Caulfield's writing was refreshing in that if she's writing about a scene, it's valuable to the story. There are no wasted scenes or superfluous descriptions in this prose. (Though I love her, Diana Gabaldon might take note. *cough* Echo in the Bone *cough*) Caulfield gives you only what you need to understand and feel the characters--and feel you do! By 30% in this book, I was completely invested in the characters. I was excited to get back to reading and postponed lunch dates because I needed to return to Newfoundland!
Are Rebecca and Samuel the Canadian Tatiana and Alexander? I wouldn't go that far. I liked how reading this book *reminded* me of The Bronze Horseman (because I like being reminded of that book), but Seldom Come By is not a rewrite of TBH, not by a long shot. The strength, passion and adversity that the couple have to endure are reminiscent of TBH, but beyond that, Rebecca and Samuel find their own way of handling things.
I have already found myself recommending this book to others that have loved The Bronze Horseman. I do believe that if you enjoy an epic love story, this will make a fine reading suggestion.
4.5 stars
I was a little daunted by the size of this book and the fact that it was part of a trilogy. Used to books that were half this size, I wondered if my attention would last the full book (it did--in fact it grew as I continued to read!) Then, there was the summary that the author provided where she mentioned Tatiana and Alexander and Jamie and Claire. Okay, you got my attention, but can you really pull that off?? These are some literary power couples and those names should not be tossed around lightly. I'll admit--I had a bit of a chip on my shoulder after that. Above all this, I had the encouragement from Hildy, my book boss, telling me to give this book a try and I try to listen to her suggestions. :)
This book was a real treat to read. Caulfield's writing was refreshing in that if she's writing about a scene, it's valuable to the story. There are no wasted scenes or superfluous descriptions in this prose. (Though I love her, Diana Gabaldon might take note. *cough* Echo in the Bone *cough*) Caulfield gives you only what you need to understand and feel the characters--and feel you do! By 30% in this book, I was completely invested in the characters. I was excited to get back to reading and postponed lunch dates because I needed to return to Newfoundland!
Are Rebecca and Samuel the Canadian Tatiana and Alexander? I wouldn't go that far. I liked how reading this book *reminded* me of The Bronze Horseman (because I like being reminded of that book), but Seldom Come By is not a rewrite of TBH, not by a long shot. The strength, passion and adversity that the couple have to endure are reminiscent of TBH, but beyond that, Rebecca and Samuel find their own way of handling things.
I have already found myself recommending this book to others that have loved The Bronze Horseman. I do believe that if you enjoy an epic love story, this will make a fine reading suggestion.
January 5, 2016
First read 2/20/14-3/3/14
Reread 12/27/15-1/4/16
4.5 Stars loved this book even more the second time around!
*Historical Fiction is my favorite genre and Seldom Come By did NOT disappoint. I have read many books with events accruing around WWII but not WWI and I knew nothing about Newfoundland before starting. I loved being able to glean information while wrapped up in this beautifully woven story of family, loss, courage, forgiveness, redemption and love.
The story flows in an almost "snap shot" fashion, breathlessly catapulting from one main (sometimes heartbreaking) event to the next without a lot of useless dribble in-between. Some authors feel it necessary to describe every blooming flower or spend 200 pages on a single days event, Caulfield chooses to let the reader's imagination fill in the blanks. I found this style of writing refreshing. Even though, at times, it seem to keep me from completely connecting with the characters.
I was a little nervousness to begin this book knowing it was the first in a trilogy. I usually wait until all the books are available so I don't have to wait for the next installment. But this book is strong enough to stand on it's own. Although, I have to say . . . I cant wait for the next book!!!
Reread 12/27/15-1/4/16
4.5 Stars loved this book even more the second time around!
*Historical Fiction is my favorite genre and Seldom Come By did NOT disappoint. I have read many books with events accruing around WWII but not WWI and I knew nothing about Newfoundland before starting. I loved being able to glean information while wrapped up in this beautifully woven story of family, loss, courage, forgiveness, redemption and love.
The story flows in an almost "snap shot" fashion, breathlessly catapulting from one main (sometimes heartbreaking) event to the next without a lot of useless dribble in-between. Some authors feel it necessary to describe every blooming flower or spend 200 pages on a single days event, Caulfield chooses to let the reader's imagination fill in the blanks. I found this style of writing refreshing. Even though, at times, it seem to keep me from completely connecting with the characters.
I was a little nervousness to begin this book knowing it was the first in a trilogy. I usually wait until all the books are available so I don't have to wait for the next installment. But this book is strong enough to stand on it's own. Although, I have to say . . . I cant wait for the next book!!!
January 1, 2014
Seldom Come By. Book 1 of The Iceberg Trilogy. Sherryl Caulfield
Review from Jeannie Zelos Book reviews.
Well, hooked by the connection to two series I love, the Diana Gabaldon and Sarah Donati ones I thought I’d try this and ...Wow! I really don't know where to start. It was everything promised and more, had me glued to the kindle for hours, smiling, laughing and crying. Its packed with emotion, really deep dark scenes, and high bright ones which made for a perfect read for me. The people felt real, the story so believable. I was pulled into it along with Rebecca and Samuel and the rest of the families. What I loved too is that though this is a trilogy this book is complete in itself, with a proper ending. No horrible, awful, hateful cliffhangers, though I can see – and am hungry for – where the story is going next.
The descriptions of the land and icebergs were incredible- I’ve never seen one, but I felt as if I was there with them in the boat that day under the iceberg arch. The great contrasts in life stories between Rebecca's home life and Samuel's was typical of the time period, and I like Samuel I love Rebecca's enthusiasm for life. I can see too why both her and her sister were so attracted to him. At no time was I able to predict what was gong to happen, it really was a story that kept me on the edge of my seat, and when THAT scene happened – oh the tears I shed – so emotive and such deep dark sadness from it. I feel sad even now just thinking about it.
Then there's Samuel joining his brother in WW1 – I skim read much of the battle scenes, not because they weren't realistic but because they were, and I have a personal antipathy to war. My grandfather served for Britain in both WW1 and WW2, and would never speak of his experiences, threw his medals in the back of a drawer, and never joined the many reunions held by others. I learned from mum and gran how distraught and shadowed he was by the experiences, it never really left him I think, and that's affected my attitudes to war so was why I skipped this part. Samuel's experiences after the war were sadly very, very common, but often misunderstood – he was lucky to have a loving family to let him recover in his own time. My granddad had to come home to a wife and child he's not seen for years after WW2, having dreaded it because of his experiences of WW1, and I suspect he was just pushed back into the workforce and the need to support his family, and that's perhaps why he was so reticent about what happened to him. Shut it into the back of his mind, locked away from everyday life. Anyway, its a section that shaped Samuel and Rebecca, was integral to the events that followed, and added yet more to the sadness and happiness balances.
Well, not much more I can say except if you love deep, epic, romantic stories this is one for you. Its definitely one to re read too – has so much content that I know I must have missed some, and look forward to discovering even more on second and subsequent readings. I've found this before in the very best books, they have details that I find after the first read, bits that add to the story because I know what's coming, those little hints that are sometimes missed when we don't know what's about to occur, or may develop much later in the novel.
At £3.14 for 514 pages its a real bargain especially taking into account the re read factor. I'm really looking forward to the next in the series.
Stars: After having several four and four and a half star reads recently, I’ve been wondering if maybe I’m too strict about the five star criteria I have, but reading this I know its necessary that there's something held back for those books that are really, really special. Its a five star read – I just wish I could give more.
ARC supplied by Netgalley
Review from Jeannie Zelos Book reviews.
Well, hooked by the connection to two series I love, the Diana Gabaldon and Sarah Donati ones I thought I’d try this and ...Wow! I really don't know where to start. It was everything promised and more, had me glued to the kindle for hours, smiling, laughing and crying. Its packed with emotion, really deep dark scenes, and high bright ones which made for a perfect read for me. The people felt real, the story so believable. I was pulled into it along with Rebecca and Samuel and the rest of the families. What I loved too is that though this is a trilogy this book is complete in itself, with a proper ending. No horrible, awful, hateful cliffhangers, though I can see – and am hungry for – where the story is going next.
The descriptions of the land and icebergs were incredible- I’ve never seen one, but I felt as if I was there with them in the boat that day under the iceberg arch. The great contrasts in life stories between Rebecca's home life and Samuel's was typical of the time period, and I like Samuel I love Rebecca's enthusiasm for life. I can see too why both her and her sister were so attracted to him. At no time was I able to predict what was gong to happen, it really was a story that kept me on the edge of my seat, and when THAT scene happened – oh the tears I shed – so emotive and such deep dark sadness from it. I feel sad even now just thinking about it.
Then there's Samuel joining his brother in WW1 – I skim read much of the battle scenes, not because they weren't realistic but because they were, and I have a personal antipathy to war. My grandfather served for Britain in both WW1 and WW2, and would never speak of his experiences, threw his medals in the back of a drawer, and never joined the many reunions held by others. I learned from mum and gran how distraught and shadowed he was by the experiences, it never really left him I think, and that's affected my attitudes to war so was why I skipped this part. Samuel's experiences after the war were sadly very, very common, but often misunderstood – he was lucky to have a loving family to let him recover in his own time. My granddad had to come home to a wife and child he's not seen for years after WW2, having dreaded it because of his experiences of WW1, and I suspect he was just pushed back into the workforce and the need to support his family, and that's perhaps why he was so reticent about what happened to him. Shut it into the back of his mind, locked away from everyday life. Anyway, its a section that shaped Samuel and Rebecca, was integral to the events that followed, and added yet more to the sadness and happiness balances.
Well, not much more I can say except if you love deep, epic, romantic stories this is one for you. Its definitely one to re read too – has so much content that I know I must have missed some, and look forward to discovering even more on second and subsequent readings. I've found this before in the very best books, they have details that I find after the first read, bits that add to the story because I know what's coming, those little hints that are sometimes missed when we don't know what's about to occur, or may develop much later in the novel.
At £3.14 for 514 pages its a real bargain especially taking into account the re read factor. I'm really looking forward to the next in the series.
Stars: After having several four and four and a half star reads recently, I’ve been wondering if maybe I’m too strict about the five star criteria I have, but reading this I know its necessary that there's something held back for those books that are really, really special. Its a five star read – I just wish I could give more.
ARC supplied by Netgalley
March 20, 2014
Thank you to Hildy for receiving an extra copy of this book and the author Sherryl Caulfield for sharing it with me. Historical fiction is by far my favorite genre and this book captures the elements perfectly. An engaging, strong heroine, a dashing, honorable stranger, a brutal daily life existence in Newfoundland set during WWI. The story and characters are made more rich by the superb writing. I look forward to reading more from this author.
March 29, 2014
4.5 stars
One more reason to ALWAYS trust my Book Boss. Thanks again, Hildy!
One more reason to ALWAYS trust my Book Boss. Thanks again, Hildy!
February 1, 2014
First of all, I need to thank the person on our Facebook page who recommended this to me a couple of weeks ago. I was looking for epic WOW recommendations and someone threw this out there. I waited for a review copy via Netgalley and was happy to give this a go for an honest review. I was looking for some historical fiction/romance and was happy to hear that this was set during World War 1, mostly in Newfoundland and Ontario. I haven't read a lot of Canadian historical fiction, other than The Bride of New France and The Book of Negroes, so I was curious. I thought it was time.
My one regret with this book was that I didn't start it when I had more time to read. It took me a good 4 or 5 days to get very far along and it may have been because I just didn't have a large chunk of time. Whenever I do that, I never feel a great attachment to the characters and story. It didn't mean that I didn't like this story, I just often compare all historical fiction novels to how I felt when I read Outlander and The Bronze Horseman and Into the Wilderness and it wasn't quite there. At about 30%, I decided that I was quite possibly doing this book a disservice and decided to set aside some time and immerse myself for awhile. Well, I was right! I fell in deep with the main characters and really cared about what was happening with them, but also the people around them. It sucked me in, gave me heart palpitations and made me think about them and how to get back to them when I wasn't reading. THAT was what I was looking for. The last half of the book was beautiful and heartbreaking and romantic. I almost skipped ahead to see how it was all going to end. I didn't, thank goodness.
As I was reading, I did wonder what other people would think of the Canadian history. As a Canadian, a lot of the places, battles, historical figures, were familiar to me and it served as a little refresher course to see how much I remembered. It made me think about the movie Passchendaele, but I mostly just thought about how hot Paul Gross was. :) I guess though, that most of the historical fiction that I read about centres around new-to-me events and places and it doesn't fail to pull me in. Hopefully others will feel the same.
The story was beautifully descriptive. There were some editing errors that I noticed a lot at first but once I became fully engaged in the story, I didn't notice any more. I found myself Googling icebergs, and old pictures of Toronto and Muskoka and wished I could be transported back in time.
I'd definitely recommend this book if you like historical romance. I will definitely be reading the next two books in the series although this one stands well on its own. Please leave a comment if you've read it and let me know what you think.
For my FULL review, check out our blog.
http://thebookbosses.blogspot.ca/2014...
My one regret with this book was that I didn't start it when I had more time to read. It took me a good 4 or 5 days to get very far along and it may have been because I just didn't have a large chunk of time. Whenever I do that, I never feel a great attachment to the characters and story. It didn't mean that I didn't like this story, I just often compare all historical fiction novels to how I felt when I read Outlander and The Bronze Horseman and Into the Wilderness and it wasn't quite there. At about 30%, I decided that I was quite possibly doing this book a disservice and decided to set aside some time and immerse myself for awhile. Well, I was right! I fell in deep with the main characters and really cared about what was happening with them, but also the people around them. It sucked me in, gave me heart palpitations and made me think about them and how to get back to them when I wasn't reading. THAT was what I was looking for. The last half of the book was beautiful and heartbreaking and romantic. I almost skipped ahead to see how it was all going to end. I didn't, thank goodness.
As I was reading, I did wonder what other people would think of the Canadian history. As a Canadian, a lot of the places, battles, historical figures, were familiar to me and it served as a little refresher course to see how much I remembered. It made me think about the movie Passchendaele, but I mostly just thought about how hot Paul Gross was. :) I guess though, that most of the historical fiction that I read about centres around new-to-me events and places and it doesn't fail to pull me in. Hopefully others will feel the same.
The story was beautifully descriptive. There were some editing errors that I noticed a lot at first but once I became fully engaged in the story, I didn't notice any more. I found myself Googling icebergs, and old pictures of Toronto and Muskoka and wished I could be transported back in time.
I'd definitely recommend this book if you like historical romance. I will definitely be reading the next two books in the series although this one stands well on its own. Please leave a comment if you've read it and let me know what you think.
For my FULL review, check out our blog.
http://thebookbosses.blogspot.ca/2014...
September 19, 2014
Oh wow! The setting, the characters, the history, the dialogue, the love, loss, heartache, joy, forgiveness, compassion.....it was all so beautifully woven together in this fabulously written epic story. I couldn't help but become attached to the lives of Rebecca and Samuel and all those who surround them. The details of the setting and history was fascinating, intriguing and horrifying. It all felt so real. It was as if the reader (me) was on a journey with Rebecca and Samuel and witnessed the many layers of their story unfolded. I cried and laughed and hoped with them every step of the way. I love it when I read a story and feel apart of the characters' journey in life. Love it. I also love the epic-ness of this story. And, I love that there is a book two so that I can rejoin Rebecca and Samuel's family again. There was great depth. Truly, Seldom Come By is richly written. I am very glad to have read this gem.
{And those area my very quick "just finished reading the book" thoughts. }
{And those area my very quick "just finished reading the book" thoughts. }
November 29, 2013
I was fortunate enough to receive an Advance Readers Edition of Seldom Come By, the first novel in the Iceberg Trilogy.
Set on the edge of Newfoundland, Seldom Come By tells the love story of shipwreck survivor Samuel Dalton and his rescuer, teenage Rebecca Crowe.
The author's breathtaking descriptions of sea and landscapes and the historical setting drew me into the first few pages of the book but the relationships between the characters kept me reading. A shocking event that occurred about halfway through the book compelled me to finish the book in only two more sittings.
I feel that the book's themes of love, loss, forgiveness and healing would make it a terrific book club pick and lead to great discussions. I look forward to reading the author's next two books in this series.
Set on the edge of Newfoundland, Seldom Come By tells the love story of shipwreck survivor Samuel Dalton and his rescuer, teenage Rebecca Crowe.
The author's breathtaking descriptions of sea and landscapes and the historical setting drew me into the first few pages of the book but the relationships between the characters kept me reading. A shocking event that occurred about halfway through the book compelled me to finish the book in only two more sittings.
I feel that the book's themes of love, loss, forgiveness and healing would make it a terrific book club pick and lead to great discussions. I look forward to reading the author's next two books in this series.
March 21, 2014
Well I really enjoyed Seldom Come By. I enjoyed the story and loved the characters. Sherryl Caulfield has a beautiful descriptive style of writing. I enjoy History and this is a story from the early 1900's and about a place I knew little about. Looking forward to reading the next book in this series.
January 9, 2014
I'm not an easy five star person, but theres no denying it, I loved the characters and the settings and the drama in this book. The dialogue is immediately engaging and goes on being so. I am currently on my second read and loving it just as much!
November 26, 2013
I elected to read an Advance Readers Edition of Seldom Come By as I enjoy reading books set in Newfoundland and that part of the world. The Shipping News, and The Colony of Unrequited Dreams are two that come to mind.
Seldom Come By tells the story of a restless teenage girl who has been raised in a very religious and superstitious family who through the act of rescuing a shipwrecked sailor, brings into their home a young man who is worldly and educated and thinks quite differently to them - the basis for conflict in this story.
However this story is much bigger than that, and while it starts off slowly it is a story that builds in pace and intensity to epic proportions. Two sisters vie for the attention of one man. Two brothers, both doctors go off to the bloody battlefields of WWI and like every person involved in that war they do not come out of it unscathed. What happens to the Crowe and Dalton families during 1918 is particularly harrowing and moving and the trials that the hero and heroine go through during that period are gripping indeed. Being a story that focused on the Canadian war experience was novel – to this reader – and the inclusion of John McCrae, Canadian physician and author of the famous poem, In Flanders Field, was delightful.
The author has a fine eye for scenes that are visuallly spectacular and no doubt has an affinity with nature – the icebergs of Newfoundland, the endless Canadian forests, even the claustrophobic trenches of the Western Front, make this a very memorable book in the way that they are combined with significant elements in the story. But more that that, all the locations in this book are well depicted, as too are the characters, placing you right in the midst of the story and the emotional pulse running through the book keeps you there.
A thoroughly enjoyable read – even to this male reader. I suspect it will be very popular with women of all ages despite its historical setting. The story itself is quite timeless, exploring universal themes of coming of age, action and consequences, forgiveness, redemption and family. It has a lot going for it.
Seldom Come By tells the story of a restless teenage girl who has been raised in a very religious and superstitious family who through the act of rescuing a shipwrecked sailor, brings into their home a young man who is worldly and educated and thinks quite differently to them - the basis for conflict in this story.
However this story is much bigger than that, and while it starts off slowly it is a story that builds in pace and intensity to epic proportions. Two sisters vie for the attention of one man. Two brothers, both doctors go off to the bloody battlefields of WWI and like every person involved in that war they do not come out of it unscathed. What happens to the Crowe and Dalton families during 1918 is particularly harrowing and moving and the trials that the hero and heroine go through during that period are gripping indeed. Being a story that focused on the Canadian war experience was novel – to this reader – and the inclusion of John McCrae, Canadian physician and author of the famous poem, In Flanders Field, was delightful.
The author has a fine eye for scenes that are visuallly spectacular and no doubt has an affinity with nature – the icebergs of Newfoundland, the endless Canadian forests, even the claustrophobic trenches of the Western Front, make this a very memorable book in the way that they are combined with significant elements in the story. But more that that, all the locations in this book are well depicted, as too are the characters, placing you right in the midst of the story and the emotional pulse running through the book keeps you there.
A thoroughly enjoyable read – even to this male reader. I suspect it will be very popular with women of all ages despite its historical setting. The story itself is quite timeless, exploring universal themes of coming of age, action and consequences, forgiveness, redemption and family. It has a lot going for it.
September 14, 2014
I'm so happy I said yes to reading this beautiful story, it was everything promised and more, and the lovely Sherryl Caulfield is a local Brisbane author. Three of Sherryl's favourite authors are also mine, Diana Gabaldon, Sarah Donati and Paullina Simons ... big shoes to fill but Sherryl Caulfield proved more than up to the task and Seldom Come By stands very much on its own merit. It also reminded me of Gabriele Wills' Muskoka Trilogy, which I adored, set in the same era.
Following the Crowe family of Second Chance Island, Newfoundland and the Dalton family of Toronto, Rebecca and Samuel's love story spans continents, the Great War, triumph and adversity ... it's a love that endures.
There's so much to love; the scenery and icebergs of Newfoundland ... harsh, unforgiving, stark beauty. The severity of the Crowe family's life in sharp contrast to Rebecca's thirst for knowledge and enthusiasm for life. A wonderful blending of historical fact and mesmerising tale, lyrical prose, characters to love and loathe, with a tangible sense of hope throughout.
Halfway through there is an event so shocking, so devastating I was completely overwhelmed with emotion and nausea, yes nausea, it felt that real.
To be so completely transported and immersed in characters' lives is testament to an author's care and skill, and despite the heartache I loved every minute.
Seldom Come By is an exquisite tale of love and loss, forgiveness and healing.
Iwant need the next book NOW!
Following the Crowe family of Second Chance Island, Newfoundland and the Dalton family of Toronto, Rebecca and Samuel's love story spans continents, the Great War, triumph and adversity ... it's a love that endures.
There's so much to love; the scenery and icebergs of Newfoundland ... harsh, unforgiving, stark beauty. The severity of the Crowe family's life in sharp contrast to Rebecca's thirst for knowledge and enthusiasm for life. A wonderful blending of historical fact and mesmerising tale, lyrical prose, characters to love and loathe, with a tangible sense of hope throughout.
Halfway through there is an event so shocking, so devastating I was completely overwhelmed with emotion and nausea, yes nausea, it felt that real.
To be so completely transported and immersed in characters' lives is testament to an author's care and skill, and despite the heartache I loved every minute.
Seldom Come By is an exquisite tale of love and loss, forgiveness and healing.
I
January 25, 2014
This is the fantastic story of the love between Rebecca and Samuel. Rebecca is fascinated by icebergs, and meets Samuel when he survives his ship wreck. Their great love follows them through Samuel’s war experiences during WWI and the ups and downs of a fairly well-to-do family wanting the very best for their children and of a not so well-to-do fisherman’s daughter. As the war drags on and Samuel knows that his Rebecca is home safe in Newfoundland, Canada the couple experiences a life filled with surprises and fears that make them stronger in their love and own selves. This book is an epic story of how love grown, matures and survives the ups and downs of life. The descriptions of the life they lead, in war and back home in Newfoundland are superb. My only complaint was that the book was a bit long, but I figured the author needed the space to get in those great descriptions. The intensity of and chemistry between the two main characters was very well done. This book is no cliff-hanger at the end, but will so suck the reader in that he/she will be looking for the next book in the series as soon as this one is finished. This is a book for the reader who revels in love stories and enjoys being totally involved in the story and its characters as well as a good romance. I received this from Library Thing to read and review.
January 7, 2014
What an epic read - let me start by saying my reading of this book was almost as epic as the book itself. I downloaded Seldom Come By on my Kobo to read on a business trip to China. I was hooked from the first page and then stupidly left my Kobo in the seat pocket on a plane to Dalian in northern China agh! It was so unputdownable that I tried to get another eReader before Christmas so I could finish BUT they were all sold out! I finally got my hands on a new one this week only to leave it at home when I left on my next business trip (at least it will be there when I get back). So with the help of technology and my iPad I finally got to finish this great read in the early hours of this morning. I particularly love a fiction book that teaches me a little more about another place or time and SCB didnt disappoint - the Newfoundland location, the era and connection of WWI interwoven around a great love story with a few unexpected twists and turns was great. I am also the mother of a Newfoundland dog and very pleased to see they got a few mentions as well (Byron couldn't have described them better). Can't wait to read the next installment in this trilogy....
February 3, 2014
I enjoyed the setting of this book. I've never been to Newfoundland so found it interesting to learn about. I loved getting to know the characters. I found it took me a while to connect with the main character but once I did I really felt what she felt. I loved the unexpected events, they really made me wonder what was going to happen next. I enjoyed the description of peoples relationships with one another. The story is often what matters to me so I found it a little slow at first but I couldn't put it down by half way!
I enjoy a bit of historic fiction so liked reading about life in those days, particularly in Newfoundland and war time.
I'd call it a romantic adventure with a bit of historic fiction. I know that it is the first of a trilogy so I was very pleased that the book 'finished.' I would have been annoyed if I'd been held in suspense for the next one, but no. I'm excited to read the next one now having a good background of the characters and life they've experienced. If you like a romance with a bit of adventure and a wee bit of action I'd recommend it. I've really enjoyed Paullina Simons books, so if you've read and enjoyed any of hers you'll like this too.
I enjoy a bit of historic fiction so liked reading about life in those days, particularly in Newfoundland and war time.
I'd call it a romantic adventure with a bit of historic fiction. I know that it is the first of a trilogy so I was very pleased that the book 'finished.' I would have been annoyed if I'd been held in suspense for the next one, but no. I'm excited to read the next one now having a good background of the characters and life they've experienced. If you like a romance with a bit of adventure and a wee bit of action I'd recommend it. I've really enjoyed Paullina Simons books, so if you've read and enjoyed any of hers you'll like this too.
December 1, 2013
If you want to read this book, make sure you have a decent chunk of time set aside because there are many times throughout when you will not be able to put it down. You may also want a few tissues as this book made me laugh and cry - often unexpectedly.
I was absolutely absorbed in Rebecca and Samuel's story, and in the Canadian setting. I've never been to Newfoundland but could clearly picture its bleak landscapes thanks to the vivid and descriptive language used.
The ending left me wanting more, so I was very pleased to hear this is book 1 of a trilogy. I hope to read much more from Sherryl Caulfield - and not just the Iceberg Trilogy.
If you are looking for a Christmas gift for a lover of family dramas or historical fiction with well written characters who make you feel their joy and their sorrow, you won't go wrong with Seldom Come By.
Disclaimer: I was given an Advanced Reader's Edition of this book.
I was absolutely absorbed in Rebecca and Samuel's story, and in the Canadian setting. I've never been to Newfoundland but could clearly picture its bleak landscapes thanks to the vivid and descriptive language used.
The ending left me wanting more, so I was very pleased to hear this is book 1 of a trilogy. I hope to read much more from Sherryl Caulfield - and not just the Iceberg Trilogy.
If you are looking for a Christmas gift for a lover of family dramas or historical fiction with well written characters who make you feel their joy and their sorrow, you won't go wrong with Seldom Come By.
Disclaimer: I was given an Advanced Reader's Edition of this book.
December 1, 2013
I was given an Advanced Reader's Copy of "Seldom Come By", written by Sherryl Caulfield, to read. I very rarely come across a book that has me wanting to spend every minute of my day sitting and reading but this book was certainly one of those books!
The story is set in Newfoundland and it is predominantly based on two main characters Samuel and Rebecca. I loved the depth of all the characters in the book and how each character , even those I really despised, added so much to the story. The setting and surroundings of the story are described in intricate and stunning detail. It is the sort of story that you can easily picture the setting, and characters, in your mind as you read the book.
There is no doubt that this book is a page turner and it has twists and turns that leave you breathless and full of emotion at times. I cannot wait for the release of the other two books in this trilogy to see how the story unfolds!!
The story is set in Newfoundland and it is predominantly based on two main characters Samuel and Rebecca. I loved the depth of all the characters in the book and how each character , even those I really despised, added so much to the story. The setting and surroundings of the story are described in intricate and stunning detail. It is the sort of story that you can easily picture the setting, and characters, in your mind as you read the book.
There is no doubt that this book is a page turner and it has twists and turns that leave you breathless and full of emotion at times. I cannot wait for the release of the other two books in this trilogy to see how the story unfolds!!
December 3, 2013
I was given an Advanced Readers Edition of Seldom Come By, the first novel in a trilogy by Sherryl Caulfield.
I love being taken to faraway places by a story and this book certainly did that with the authors breathtaking descriptions of coastal Newfoundland and eastern Canada. I was reminded of my own travels to Toronto and Quebec city and am now yearning to return there to enjoy this beautiful part of the world once again.
The compelling and haunting love story of the central characters, Samuel and Rebecca, is a heartfelt read, and set during the Great War, takes you on an emotionally charged journey of the love and loss in their lives. The author has researched meticulously to ensure the accuracy of events and timelines within the context of the war.
This story made me laugh and made me cry and has a message for us all about forgiveness. It would be a fantastic choice for a book club.
I eagerly await the release of her second book in the Iceberg Trilogy.
I love being taken to faraway places by a story and this book certainly did that with the authors breathtaking descriptions of coastal Newfoundland and eastern Canada. I was reminded of my own travels to Toronto and Quebec city and am now yearning to return there to enjoy this beautiful part of the world once again.
The compelling and haunting love story of the central characters, Samuel and Rebecca, is a heartfelt read, and set during the Great War, takes you on an emotionally charged journey of the love and loss in their lives. The author has researched meticulously to ensure the accuracy of events and timelines within the context of the war.
This story made me laugh and made me cry and has a message for us all about forgiveness. It would be a fantastic choice for a book club.
I eagerly await the release of her second book in the Iceberg Trilogy.
November 18, 2013
I read an Advanced Reader Copy of this book and found it a real page-turner. I was swept up in the story of the central characters - Rebecca and Samuel - and found their journey reminiscent of Tatiana and Alexander's in The Bronze Horseman by Paullina Simons. I loved the way this book painted such illustrative pictures in my head and I also loved the supporting cast - whether you liked them or not, they were well written. I am a big fan of history and enjoyed hearing about Canada's efforts in the Great War and just love that poem - In Flander's Fields. There were many moments of happiness in this book but parts that made me weep - a truly rewarding emotional read on so many levels. I'm looking forward to the rest of the series with baited breath. This is up there as one of my all time favourite books already. I can see it has movie potential as well!
December 8, 2013
https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/1...#
I was hooked immediately and drawn into the story. I like the fact that Rebecca saved Samuel but in many ways Samuel saved her as well. If a doctor from a fairly wealthy family got lost at sea, turned up at my doorstep, became the the love of my life and promised me a brighter future, he’d be my hero too :-) After Revelations I was in a state of shock and grief. I just had to keep reading to find out what happened next. Seldom Come By really is a great big, satisfying read - the tragedies are balanced by enough happiness and the characters are solid – they overcome so much adversity and their love stays strong. It makes you feel a bit stronger too.
I was hooked immediately and drawn into the story. I like the fact that Rebecca saved Samuel but in many ways Samuel saved her as well. If a doctor from a fairly wealthy family got lost at sea, turned up at my doorstep, became the the love of my life and promised me a brighter future, he’d be my hero too :-) After Revelations I was in a state of shock and grief. I just had to keep reading to find out what happened next. Seldom Come By really is a great big, satisfying read - the tragedies are balanced by enough happiness and the characters are solid – they overcome so much adversity and their love stays strong. It makes you feel a bit stronger too.
December 16, 2013
This is such a wonderful book!I was hooked by the story-line and characters almost immediately and found myself lost in Newfoundland and Canada in no time. This book is evocative and beautifully written, and you simply don't want to put it down.
It provides insights into life just prior to, and during the first World War, but mostly it is a captivating story of emotions and love, with some surprising twists and turns along the way.
'Seldom Come By' is perfect as a holiday read, a commuting read, an escapist read, a book club read or just a good read.
I really cannot wait to read the other two parts of the trilogy.
A novel like 'Seldom Come By" really does seldom come by!
It provides insights into life just prior to, and during the first World War, but mostly it is a captivating story of emotions and love, with some surprising twists and turns along the way.
'Seldom Come By' is perfect as a holiday read, a commuting read, an escapist read, a book club read or just a good read.
I really cannot wait to read the other two parts of the trilogy.
A novel like 'Seldom Come By" really does seldom come by!
January 2, 2014
Seldom Come By . . . . I loved this book! The story had me hooked from the start. I love characters that imbed themselves into your consciousness and draw you back to the book each day. Seldom Come By is one of those books that I found hard to put down. It has a nice balance of history, a compelling landscape that the author brings life so well and romance. There are characters I disliked and many I loved and they make me smile and they made me cry (mostly the ones I disliked!). From the wonders of Newfoundland to the trenches of the Western Front I was drawn along on this story of human endurance and love. I can’t wait for the next book.
April 14, 2014
Very interesting read of the history of Newfoundland and Canada's involvement in World War I. The writing was so engrossing that at times I felt I was beside the characters, in the boat with them, experiencing the iceberg and their life through their eyes and all their personal struggles, which at times were daunting.
It highlighted how challenging life was back then yet at other times the story did not feel like history at all. Parts of it were absolutely confronting and sad, though lightened by heartfelt moments of warmth and family. Very much looking forward to the next in the series to see what's in store for the characters.
It highlighted how challenging life was back then yet at other times the story did not feel like history at all. Parts of it were absolutely confronting and sad, though lightened by heartfelt moments of warmth and family. Very much looking forward to the next in the series to see what's in store for the characters.
February 4, 2014
Fantastic book, I really enjoyed this one. It did take me a little while to get into the story at first, but Sherryl does a terrific job of really endearing you to her fascinating characters and their intriguing lives. Once I was hooked, I just couldn't put the book down. Fantastic story that just keeps you wanting more and I'm really excited to see that it's just the first in a trilogy - can't wait for the next two books! I highly recommend Seldom Come By - well done on a great book Sherryl Caulfield!
February 15, 2014
Rebecca is growing up in an isolated environment dreaming of more. It's a time in history just prior to the great war which will change everything for Rebecca and those she loves. This is a love story about what lies concealed, and how the unspoken can cause pain and stifle love. As much a story about a time in history as Rebecca's own story, Seldom Come By follows Rebecca's journey to reveal more than the tip of the iceberg. This is a moving and beautifully woven love story with characters who I cared about.
November 26, 2013
I have just finished an Advance Readers Edition of Seldom Come By, Book 1 of The Iceberg Trilogy.
Seldom Come By is a haunting love story set against the windswept coast of Newfoundland. The story draws you in from the opening lines and takes you on a compelling journey across time and continents, through love, loss, heartache and healing. It is a beautiful and memorable story - a great accomplishment and a wonderful read.
January 7, 2014
Seldom Come By is the kind debut novel that any author would be proud of. I really hope that this gets the attention it deserves. The writing moves along at a great pace and the story, the characters and their journey had me completely drawn in. Rebecca and Samuel's story will keep you entranced and wanting more. The scenes, places and times in history that Sherryl brings to life are quite simply amazing.
January 9, 2014
Wonderful book, I was so impressed by this author.
I found myself transported into the Crowes lives, feeling Rebecca's and Rachel's every moment of their journey through life.
I found myself gasping at moments, a few tears and always a feeling of being connected to their lives.
A great read!, can't wait for the next book!
I found myself transported into the Crowes lives, feeling Rebecca's and Rachel's every moment of their journey through life.
I found myself gasping at moments, a few tears and always a feeling of being connected to their lives.
A great read!, can't wait for the next book!
February 11, 2014
Seldom Come By by Sherryl Caulfield
This is a thoroughly absorbing 'can't put down' novel! A wonderful interwoven story that had me entranced from beginning to end. I loved the characters in the book and their individual personalities were beautifully crafted - as was the description of landscapes and other settings in the book.
A MUST READ!
This is a thoroughly absorbing 'can't put down' novel! A wonderful interwoven story that had me entranced from beginning to end. I loved the characters in the book and their individual personalities were beautifully crafted - as was the description of landscapes and other settings in the book.
A MUST READ!
July 23, 2016
I loved this book! It is a truly satisfying page turner based in beautiful & rugged Newfoundland..my home. A young girl coming of age on the edge of the atlantic and at the edge of a world war!!! If you do not mind staying up late into the night reading then this one is a definite must!!!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 58 reviews