DNF. Did not finish. Part of kindle UL, so free to me.
I could not finish this book. It is unreadable. Having spent more than half of my 40+ year career working with abused, neglected, traumatized, and savagely parented (IF that word even fits here) children, I found this book totally unreadable. It isn't the depictions or descriptions of the physical trauma that drove my decision because when you have seen it in real life, there is a sense of knowledge aforehand about the subject. However, this "story" is simply not likely to have continued past the age of perhaps 9, because if public and private schools, churches, counselors, teachers, school bus drivers, and even neighbors have learned anything, it is that once might be a mistake, but repeatedly seeing these same types of bruises, fractures, burns, scars, in other words, physical testimonials of abuse or any other type of even suspected or supposed adult involvement with a minor child, it will NOT go unreported, uninvestigated, or dismissed by any faction. There are of course millions of children who suffer at the hands of horrendous adults, but let one child appear out of kilter for even a day and someone is going to say something.
I think this tale has some issues with continuity and clarity. How is it possible for a child to have both arms dislocated and no one notices? Please.
There really isn't a story in place here. Events continue on a daily basis, she supposedly attends school, no absences, how is this possible with 2 displaced shoulders? A live stove burn, that would have to be a full thickness (3rd degree) trauma-and no one sees it?
Each page describes situations that begin, "The next day, when Emma came home from school"-yeah, no. With both shoulders dislocated, burns over a more than 25% body surface, a broken nose, two blackened eyes, a palm-sized chunk of hair/scalp missing? In one day?
There just isn't a story. It's shock fiction. Unreadable. Thoroughly disgusting.
Now, to be fair, I have seen horrendous traumas perpetrated on children. They will break your heart, trying to treat/repair/restore some of these conditions, all while trying to protect the child, and determine causation. Education and training always, always, focuses on believing the child, "AS IF". That's "AS IF" they are truthful. "AS IS" this XYZ did in fact, happen. But NOT ONE CPS worker shows up, not ONE neighbor or neighbor's adult son (supposedly "big and mean" men drag this father into the middle of the night and teach him a lesson? Are all the teachers blind, deaf, and dumb? This is totally illogical, again I think it is shock fiction without very much substance to it. This lacks a narrative other than "abuse du jour".
IF (a BIG IF) IF there were any truth-telling moments in this miserable story this child and her sister would have been yanked out of that home in a split second. Both parents would be arrested, and held without bond. SATC task force detectives, nurses, physicians, counselors, would be crawling up these parent's hindquarters, dancing tap shoes on their heads until the trial phase ended.
The pages run into each other, the writing is mediocre, and to top it all off, the adult (or at least older) Emma falls back into that same kind of dumb-as-a-post thinking? Yes, cycles of abuse are quite often repetitive, but seriously? NO.
I put this down after about 2 chapters. It wasn't going anywhere I felt like heading.
I think we can read about stories that have some point, regardless of the violence or the atrocities in them. But in order for them to be believed, there has to be a lesson taught and learned, and consequences for horrific actions that feel just, they feel as if, though the "victims" are made to suffer, they are, at some point, allowed to grow and get past the nightmares.
This was a strained point of view, in the loosest definition of the term.
I cannot recommend this book.