上帝掷骰子吗:量子物理史话

by 曹天元

董光璧、江晓原、刘兵、武夷山、刘华杰等学者鼎力推荐！
　　本书适合任何有中学基本物理概念的读者。只要您对科学和历史有一点兴趣，我们都诚邀您同行。或许，您将收获一次人生中难得的奇妙体验。

　　本书将带你做一次量子之旅。读者将从神话时代出发，沿着量子发展的道路，亲身去经历科学史上的乌云和暴雨，追逐流星的辉光，穿越重重迷雾和险滩，和最伟大的物理学家们并肩作战。除了回顾基本的历史背景，我们还将向着未来探险，去逐一摸索量子论面前的不同道路，闯入人迹罕至的未知境地，和先行者们一起开疆扩土。让你惊叹的，不仅仅是沿途那令人眼花缭乱的绚可风景，更来自于你内心深处的思索和启示一那是科学深植在每个人心中不可抗拒的魅力。
　　本书是关于量子论的故事。量子论是一个极为奇妙的理论：从物理角度来说，它在科学家中间引起了最为激烈的争议和关注：从现实角度来说，它给我们的社会带来了无与伦比的变化和进步；从科学史角度来说，也几乎没有哪段历史比量子论的创立得到了更为彻底的研究。然而不可思议的是，它的基本观点和假说至今没有渗透到大众的意识中去，这无疑又给它增添了一道神秘的光环。
　　本书适合任何有中学基本物理概念的෿

Genres: Science, Nonfiction, Physics, Popular Science, History, China

479 pages, Kindle Edition

First published January 1, 2006

Reviews

[WANG Zong-Kai · Rating 4 out of 5]

废寝忘食3天读完, 文风颇似评书演义. 量子物理可以很严肃深奥, 但史话就可以娓娓道来. 量子物理发展快100年了, 也有诸如激光\核磁共振\超导\芯片等现代科技普遍应用的技术成果, 太需要扫盲了.

站上巨人肩膀的重要性
人对这个世界的认识, 要么来自直接体验, 要么来自间接经验. 但限于时间\脑力\财力等诸多因素, 一个人的直接体验总是非常有限. 相比之下, 间接经验却可以广阔得多. 生活在现代社会, 有一部联网手机, 在家就可品味最先进天文望远镜发回的宇宙高清大图, 而不会自大得以为中华就是天下, 也许我们一辈子都不曾肉眼见过几颗行星, 但我们从小就知道太阳系深处有天王星和海王星; 翻阅资料就知道双缝干涉\电磁感应, 知道电与磁可以转化, 也知道光的本质是电磁波. 正如一句老话所说, 我们现代人之所以看得比较远, 是因为站在一代代巨人的肩膀上. 也正因如此, 间接经验在我们的知识结构中占据压倒性的优势, 而书是对间接经验很有系统\效率的总结. 因此, 我们对世界认识的深度与广度, 基本取决于读了多少本好书.

读书门槛
闻道有先后, 学术有专攻. 在这个知识越来越庞杂\专精的时代, 圈内人最有效率的沟通方式是用定义精准的术语, 但术语却对外行人竖起了门槛. 比如我对所生活的世界充满好奇, 渴望了解现象背后的规律, 我如果直接去看物理学专著, 就会遇见精准描述物理规律的数学公式, 我在缺少高等数学和量子力学系统训练的情况下, 很难迈过这道门槛. 如果从头补起高数和物理, 则显得没有必要, 就好像本想学习开车代步, 却非要从亲手造车开始. 因此, 低门槛的科普读物就成了很好的选择.

评书科普
知识呈网状结构, 要想把一个陌生遥远的知识纳入进来, 就要让其与现有知识网产生联系. 换句话说, 要通过熟悉去了解陌生, 把生僻的量子力学用类比的方式\形象的语言揭示出来. 本书作者就是讲评书, 虽然主题是介绍量子力学发展史, 却也时不时聊一聊这些物理学家的私人感情\私人恩怨. 不过, 科普的信息转化是有损失的, 枯燥的内容变得有趣了, 却也失真了, 严肃的论证变得活泼了, 却也失焦了. 通过科普了解科学, 终究还是隔着一层纱, 貌似看到了, 却又没法看得很清楚.

思辨与知识
学而不思则罔, 思而不学则殆. 勤思考, 也要勤读书. 回顾物理学发展史, 人一次次以为掌握了宇宙一切真理, 又一次次重新踏上征程, 知识越积累, 问题越丰富, 只能慨叹学海无涯. 牛顿时代, 人以为该知道的都知道了, 结果又有了相对论, 后来又有了量子力学, 后来又追求把三种力(强力\弱力\电磁力)的大一统理论, 后来又追求四力统一(强\弱\电磁\引)的万物理论. 每个时代的大神级人物, 都被后浪拍在沙滩山, 包括牛顿\爱因斯坦\霍金. 科学就在一次次的颠覆\证伪中破浪前行.

九牛二鼠
2022年10月31日

[4lchan · Rating 5 out of 5]

Before this book, I thought that the all the classic history of physics was about Newton, and all the modern history of it was about Einstein....sorry...

[Barack Liu · Rating 5 out of 5]

238-History of Quantum Physics-Cao Tianyuan-Nature-2006
Barack
2019/09/25
2020/06/26


—— "If anyone is not confused about quantum theory, then he does not understand quantum theory."

"The History of Quantum Physics" was first published in China in 2006. It explores the history of quantum physics. Quantum theory is an extremely wonderful theory: from a physical point of view, it has caused the most intense controversy and attention among scientists; from a practical point of view, it has brought unparalleled changes and progress to our society; from a scientific perspective From a historical perspective, there is almost no history that has been studied more thoroughly than the creation of quantum theory. However, it is incredible that its basic views and hypotheses have not penetrated into the consciousness of the public so far, which undoubtedly adds a mysterious halo to it.

Cao Tianyuan was born in Shanghai in 1981. He studied in the United States and Hong Kong, China, majoring in biochemistry and electronic engineering. Representative works: "History of Quantum Physics" etc.

Part of the catalog
1. The golden age
2. Dark clouds
3. Bolide
4. Where the white clouds grow
5. Dawn
6. Different routes to the same goal
7 uncertainty
8. Decisive battle
9. Astray
10. Back to the classics

The first verse of "Old Testament Genesis" states, "In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth. And the earth was without form, and void; and darkness was upon the face of the deep. And the Spirit of God moved upon the face of the waters. And God said, Let there be light: and th ere was light."

The story of quantum physics also started from the study of light. In the early 19th century, the great French scientist Laplace used Newton's equation to calculate the orbit of the planet and showed it to Napoleon. Napoleon asked: "Where is God in your theory?" Laplace replied calmly: "Your Majesty, my theory does not require this assumption."

Now that the hypothesis of "God" is abandoned, physicists must use observable phenomena to explain the nature of light. In history, two views have fought each other for hundreds of years. They are wave theory and particle theory. Both parties have a large number of experimental observations as a basis, but neither party can explain all natural phenomena. In history, the controversy between wave theory and particle theory has triggered several physical crises, and after each crisis, mankind seems to have a deeper understanding of the material world in which we live. As a difficult brother of physics, so does the development of mathematics.

In order to explain the phenomenon of the photoelectric effect, Planck boldly proposed the concept of light quantum, thus introducing the discontinuity, which is "apostate" and "shocking the world" into the physical world. Later, the wave-particle debate on the nature of light that lasted for hundreds of years seemed to come to an end with the conclusion of wave-particle duality.

But why can particles freely switch between wave dynamics and particle states? The Copenhagen School led by Bohr gave Copenhagen interpretation to explain phenomena in quantum physics. But the problem is that such an explanation is too dependent on the observer, because before the observer makes the observation, the quantum exists in the probability state of the wave function, which is a random superposition state; and when the observer makes the observation, it It suddenly collapsed into a specific and measurable quantum state.

But its biggest problem is that it takes "consciousness" as an important hypothesis, and we still lack consensus on the definition of "consciousness", let alone a thorough understanding of what "consciousness" is. It took hundreds of years for scientists to pull mankind from the center of the universe, but now they seem to be facing the embarrassing situation of sending mankind back to such a special position.

Therefore, in order to pursue the deterministic beauty of classical physics, physicists have also proposed many other theories, and many-worlds interpretation is one of the very attractive ideas. This theory assumes that there is a certain real, unique, and objective universe, but its dimensionality is too high. The actual universe we observe is just a low-dimensional projection of it; it also has almost countless A low-dimensional projected universe. These projected universes are orthogonal to each other, so they are often interpreted as parallel universes. It can also explain the difference between the micro world and the macro world through "decoherence". In a sense, it is an "ultimate anthropological theory." It also brings some strange inferences, such as: once a "consciousness" begins to exist, from its own perspective, it must live forever.

In addition to discussing the origin of the universe, which has nothing to do with most people, quantum mechanics also has applications that are closely related to everyone's daily life, such as quantum computers. 2 019 Nian out of a big news, Google is known to achieve a "quantum hegemony." We have not yet clearly realized what it means, but it is likely that this event is another milestone in the history of quantum physics and even human history in the eyes of future generations .

Science and religion have many similarities, but I think the biggest difference between them is that science welcomes challenges and is always being challenged. And some challenges seem to have brought the end of the world, but humans have built new high-rise buildings from the ruins again and again.

Scientists are not gods, and they make mistakes. Euclid made mistakes on the fifth hypothesis, and von Neumann also planted on the fifth hypothesis, thus drawing some wrong conclusions. But the abandoned old theories are not worthless, because they also enable us to have a deeper knowledge and understanding of the material world in which we live and live. On the other hand, the new theory is probably only temporary. It is ready to be challenged or even completely destroyed at any time, but at the same time it is full of confidence and will never surrender without a fight.

" Now, Heinrich Rudolf Hertz is standing in a laboratory at the University of Karlsruhe, concentrating on playing with his equipment. At that time, Hertz was just 30 years old and was newly married. Perhaps he would not have thought that he would become as famous as his teacher Hermann von Helmholtz in the history of science, nor would he have thought that he would become this small town together with the car king Carl Benz. Pride. Now his mind is just completely devoted to his device. "

I have noticed , many great men when they were 30 years old , often has been made on the cause of the initial representation of achievement, or at least has to go in the future and bring the greatest glory of a brilliant career for them on the way .

" Hertz keeps repeating the discharge process. Every time, sparks are excited from the receiver obediently. In Hertz's view, there is nothing more beautiful in the world. After a long time, Hertz finally rubbed her eyes. Straighten up: Now everything is clear. Electromagnetic waves really exist in space, and it is it that stimulates the electric spark on the receiver. He succeeded and successfully solved the reward proposed by the Prussian Academy of Sciences in Berlin 8 years ago. At the same time, Maxwell’s theory also triumphed. A new peak in physics—electromagnetic theory was finally established. The great Faraday (Michael Faraday) laid the foundation for it, and the great Maxwell built its main body. Today, he-the great Hertz-capped the building. "

For some people. Discovering the truth is also a great pleasure. This kind of spiritual happiness is unparalleled. It may give people more spiritual rewards than wealth itself . However, the number of people who get great satisfaction from the search for the truth is really small.

" In October 1887, Gustav Robert Kirchhoff (Gustav Robert Kirchhoff) died in Berlin. Helmholtz strongly recommended Hertz as his successor to the professorship, but Hertz refused. Perhaps in Hertz's eyes, the hustle and bustle of Berlin It's not for him. Helmholtz understood his student's thinking and wrote to encourage him: "A person who wants to fight with many scientific issues is best to stay away from the metropolis. "It's just that Hertz did not expect that his decision suddenly changed many things.

He didn't know that he had planted the seed of a ghost in the electromagnetic wave experiment, and the person who replaced him to teach in Berlin would wake the ghost from his sleep at a destined moment. After that, everything changed. In the next 30 years, some very wonderful things will continue to happen, completely reshaping the face of physics. The prelude to a revolution has been unknowingly opened, and our universe is about to undergo a stormy baptism, which will become even more mysterious, bizarre and shocking. "

Every event that occurs now must have the results planted before. And we are doing every thing, because in the future will also become something of. Between cause and effect out there secretly intertwined. When the descendants of unraveling the time to look back from the perspective of God, would probably find life more wonderful than the drama itself.

" When people are well aware of the various behaviors of light, our most basic problem has not been solved yet, that is: "What is light in essence?" "This question does not seem to be that difficult to answer. No one would have imagined that the exploration of this question would be so protracted, and the process of this exploration would have such a profound and significant impact on physics. The significance is beyond anyone's imagination at the time. "

Many basic questions seem the answer is quite simple , or self-evident of. But when we think increasingly in-depth, we will more hair it reads like a puddle like a bottomless pit. But even if we do not think these fundamental questions in life , too , like to live on the matter very satisfied with life. But for some people, merely pursuing material life is not enough. They are also willing to spend a lot of energy to explore the spiritual world and the natural world. Some of them are willing to pay all their youth, even the price of their lives , to explore the truth that fascinates him deeply .

"The wave theory believes that light is not a material particle, but a wave generated by the vibration of the medium. Let's imagine the "wave of people" caused by spectators on a football field: although each spectator simply stands up and sits Down, there is no running around, but the "wave" is actually moving around the audience. This "wave" is a kind of wave. The same is true for the water wave in the pond. It is not an actual transmission. It is the result of the vibration of the water surface along the way. If the light is also fluctuating, we can easily explain the light and dark stripes in the projection, and it is also easy to explain that the light beams can pass through each other without interfering with each other.

Regarding the problem of straight-line propagation and reflection, people later realized that the wavelength of light is extremely short. In most cases, light behaves just like a classical particle, and diffraction experiments further prove this. But the wave theory has a basic problem: since the wave itself is the vibration of the medium, it must be transmitted in a certain medium. For example, sound can travel along air, water or even solids, but it cannot propagate in a vacuum. In order to understand this easily, everyone just needs to think like this: If there is no one in the stadium, then there is no way to talk about "people waves". "

In the world of philosophy and theology , invisible and intangible concepts are almost inevitable . But in the world of natural science , such assumptions have no place. Scientists try to remove such unprovable and unfalsifiable assumptions from the temple of science.

" " Ether "origin of the word as early as in ancient Greece: Aristotle (Aristotle)" On the day, "a book described his knowledge of celestial bodies he believed the moon and stars circles the earth, but its. The composition is different from the four elements on the earth: water, fire, air, and earth. The things in the sky should be perfect and they can only be composed of a purer element. This is what Aristotle called " The fifth element "ether" (αηθηρ in Greek). Since this concept was borrowed into science, the status of ether in history can be said to be quite subtle. On the one hand, it has played such an important role that become the basis for the whole of physics; on the other hand, when it is no longer glory, though it also suffered ridicule not willing to struggle over and over again, a face-lift, giving new meaning to their own, but still. However, can not escape the ultimate fate of being abandoned, For a while, it almost became a special term for pseudoscience.

But no matter what, the concept of ether still holds its place in the history of science. Although the optical media and absolute reference system it once represented, although it has withdrawn from the center of the stage, it has taken on a historical mission after all. To this day, whenever we mention this name, it still seems to be able to evoke our nostalgia for that golden years. It is like a yellowed photo, recording the glorious past of a nobleman. Today, as another concept, Ethernet is used to name a network protocol (Ethernet Ethernet). When we live in the e-era, every time we see this word, do we sigh? "

Man is not the designer of the universe. We just try to explain the world from our own perspective. But our explanation is not always correct. And in the process of explanation, we may need a lot of auxiliary tools. Even the old theories are replaced by stronger and more explanatory theories in the future . But this does not mean that it is meaningless. On the contrary, not a theory but a gradual one after another , in order to build the Yi Tiao road leading to the truth of the universe. Humanity is now probably still groping in the darkness of ignorance in more.

" Young people in early 1672, a fellow named Isaac Newton (Isaac Newton) because manufactured a prominent telescope and was elected to the Royal Society will be members. Newton was only 29 years old, young, is preparing to Optics and instruments are showing great feats. We know that Newton had already made deep thinking in the field of optics when his hometown in the country escaped the plague. In a letter to the secretary of the society, Henry Oldenburg, Newton once again introduced his theory of light and color, the content of which was about the dispersion experiment of light.

On February 8, this letter was read out at the Royal Society.

[Cheng · Rating 5 out of 5]

- 已经不知道什么时候听过这本书了，也许是书名这句话太过出名？即使在看这本书的过程中，还是一度以为作者是外国人，这本书是翻译过来的。当然，很快便发现了自己的误解。亚马逊的电子书服务实在是太方便，居然只要1元便能看到这么有意思的书。利用假期的空闲时间看完了此书。
- 尽管是一名理工科学生，还是应该承认在看此书之前我对于量子力学所知甚少，也许仅仅比其他人多知道一些名词而已，即使现在看完这本书，也只能说对于量子理论所知甚少，仅仅比之前多知道了一些名词，更多的大概只能算量子理论发展史了，而与量子理论本身无关。
- 作者的语言浅显易懂，前半部分内容比较了解，看的我心潮澎湃，有不忍释卷如同看情节巧妙的小说一般。牛顿，爱因斯坦，玻尔等人的伟大成就，19世纪末期到20世纪初期这段量子理论崭露头角的年代，令人疯狂、激动。后半部分比较接近现代的发展由于理论众多且名家辈出，相较于前期井喷式的个人成就显得不是那么令人激动，作者也说，1905年是物理史上少见的奇迹年，爱因斯坦的六篇论文在整个历史长河中都是那么耀眼。但是现代物理学注定不会再有那么灿烂的个人成就了。
- 超弦理论，M理论等最新理论的发展远远没有达到尽头，理论物理最前沿的科学家们此时应该正在奋战吧？但是量子论的应用确确实实给这个世界带来了巨大的变革。哲学思想的不清晰并不能否定量子理论改变了这个世界的事实，期待物理理论的发展，希望现在的迷茫与矛盾不是智子的恶作剧。：）科学史一方面可以给人们以基本科学素养的提高，另一方面这些科学家的行事也能给普通人以启示。这一群智力上碾压同时代绝大多数人的人啊。
- 另外，关于科学史上的一些“神话传说”辟谣很有意思，看来无论中外都喜欢神话伟人呢。“这在科学史研究中是非常需要避免的辉格式解释（Whig Interpretation）倾向”
- > 辉格史（Whig history）是一个历史学派，该学派认为人类文明不可逆转地从落后向先进，从愚昧到开蒙。这个学派得名源自辉格党派（辉格党, Whig），是目前英国自由党的前身。辉格党得益于1688年光荣革命带来的政治变化。它于1714年之后长期支配英国政治，他也通过捍卫包括有限君主制和议会重要性在内的“1688年原则”而获得不少支援。这个党派的历史学家们对历史的解释往往从今天的角度出发，来评判历史事件的价值。——http://zh.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E8%BE%8...
- 还搜到了下面这本书： [1]赫伯特·巴特菲尔德. 历史的辉格解释[M]. 张岳明, 刘北成, 译. 商务印书馆, 2012.
- 看一本书很有趣，写书评其实挺累的，暂时就写这么多了，以后再补充或者再也不补充了。不给自己压力。：）

[Mao · Rating 5 out of 5]

Its history of quantum physics, writing an interesting and exagarating of history. No history is complete without wars. Instead, it shows the conflicts and major events in the past. Of course, there is little maths. It doesn't affect the reading even if you ignore them. The author also tries to explain physics phenomenon and theories with an example, using anology in our tangible world.

[Sheldonliu · Rating 5 out of 5]

作为科普读物，远离了繁杂的公式，趣味性很强，引人入胜的文字，令人流连往返。
这本书让我认识了海森堡、玻尔、薛定谔，也看到了爱因斯坦的另一面。力荐！

As a popular science book, it is far from complicated formulas, interesting and fascinating text, which makes people linger.
This book introduced me to Heisenberg, Bohr, Schrödinger, and also to another side of Einstein. Highly recommended!

[Shuyuan Xu · Rating 5 out of 5]

通俗而流畅，一气呵成，佩服。
其中一个极度浪漫的观念：
E和t满足不确定规则，所以在某一个刹那—每一个刹那—我们的空间中汹涌着超乎想象的能量起伏；而这种刹那间的涨落在超长的时间里归于无可捉摸和感知的守恒量。这种近乎耀眼的湮灭和终结以达成“曾经存在”的证明，是我理想中的浪漫主义。
诸如此类的感受，重新点燃了高中时代狂热而执着的对物理的热爱，仿佛这几年的现实生活丝毫没有消磨去我的理想；只要努力与付出，依然能有立竿见影的满意的结果，还没学会妥协，还没接受失望，一切都还是最年轻、最灿烂的模样。把这次完美的阅读体验送给那义无反顾的三年，也试图换回那个意气风发的少年时代。

[Deerhound · Rating 5 out of 5]

This book opened my mind. The world is still the same, but how I see it is different now. While reading this book, I, a macroscopic creature, was amazed by the chaotic microscopic world. I want thank the author for giving me a glimpse of the beauty of quantum mechanics.

[d0zingcat · Rating 4 out of 5]

因为没有 3.5 星所以我给 4 星
整体来讲读起来还是比较顺畅的，很多物理史/八卦还是非常有趣的，能和中学课本对应，但也能补充很多额外的细节。
对于具体的理论细节没有钻牛角尖写的非常深入，但有粗浅的介绍和有趣的类比（作为科普读物已经足够）。
整体语言风格非常夸张（作者自己也有谈到是故意为之以此来增加书籍的趣味性）但看到会觉得啰唆和厌倦 跳过即可
对整体了解近300年来的物理学的发展还是有很大的启发的 开始理解了数学和物理的浪漫 也多了对大自然 上帝的敬畏

[Mia · Rating 5 out of 5]

meaningful and make me felt interested in the relationship between science and philosophy.

[Soppy · Rating 5 out of 5]

非常好的科普读物。

[Feng Zihan · Rating 3 out of 5]

实际上没有看完，尝试了两回也没能看完

[JX Sun · Rating 4 out of 5]

这本书可以算是量子力学的发展历史百科了，关于量子力学的重大事件都有描绘。不可否认的是很多物理理论对门外汉来说晦涩难懂，但并不妨碍对量子有一个更深入的了解和思考。伴随着各个科学巨头的battle，不知不觉也会产生好奇和思考，非常有趣～

[Fred · Rating 4 out of 5]

地铁上读过，好长的一本书。作者用了大量的比喻，努力向普通读者讲述量子物理的发展。读完我对历史上的一些科学大师多了一些理解，量子物理果然很难理解。

[Yan · Rating 4 out of 5]

物理不断刷新人们对世界的认识 聪明如爱因斯坦 也无法接受啊……

[Catbaron · Rating 5 out of 5]

理学的罗曼蒂克

[Junyi Yang · Rating 4 out of 5]

It took me forever to read, but it is captivating. I would put more effort into physics if only I knew then how interesting it was.

[CheeseMoon]

三体完后读

[Lok Guan Lim · Rating 5 out of 5]

作为科普性质的书籍，以比较通俗的故事描写了量子物理的历史及相关公式，只要上过大学物理的，应该都能很好的明白这些历史故事及部分公式。但若想更深入的了解，那还是得去烦翻阅教材吧。（虽然我不太可能这样做，太难了）

[666DHG · Rating 5 out of 5]

很牛的一本量子物理科普，有趣有深度

[Hong Wu · Rating 3 out of 5]

过程虽然确实比较曲折，但额外的废话太多了，感觉就是边查维基百科边写的。。。读了一半弃了

[吴思源 · Rating 5 out of 5]

5/5 systematical and with audience awareness
the most engaging book i've ever read

[Raynald Chung · Rating 4 out of 5]

读了一半

[Sevenlock · Rating 4 out of 5]

11.22
半年过去我已经忘了这本书的大部分内容了………………等我复习完笔记再来写

前几天看到自己的摘抄，贴过来：
虽然我们有时候还会偶尔怀念经典时代，怀念那些因果关系一丝不苟，宇宙的本质简单易懂的日子，但这也已经更多的是一种怀旧情绪而已。正如电影《乱世佳人》的开头不无深情地说：“曾经有一片属于骑士和棉花园的土地叫作老南方。在这个美丽的世界里，绅士们最后一次风度翩翩地行礼，骑士们最后一次和漂亮的女伴们同行，人们最后一次见到主人和他们的奴隶。而如今这已经是一个只能从书本中去寻找的旧梦，一个随风飘逝的文明。”虽然有这样的伤感，但人们依然还是会歌颂北方扬基们最后的胜利，因为我们从他们那里得到更大的力量、更多的热情，还有对于未来更执着的信心。

这段写得挺好的，但是是从奴隶主角度出发的，奴隶只会觉得那是一段黑暗且痛苦的被压迫的历史。
换个视角，把奴隶主改成日本人，奴隶改成东三省，你还觉得是旧梦吗

[Kevin · Rating 5 out of 5]

最好的量子物理入门书，与The music of primes一样，轻松易懂讲述了最为复杂的理论和他们所带来的影响。

[Kevin Chen · Rating 5 out of 5]

满足你对量子物理的兴趣，又不至于让你看不懂，其中还有很多物理学家的鲜为人知的轶事，不错的书。

[Tina · Rating 4 out of 5]

完全看不懂……好吧我是来看八卦的

[Kevindreamfly · Rating 4 out of 5]

还行吧。量子纠缠和超距作用，要是被证实就妙了，岂不是那些科幻中的超距传递信息都有希望了。另外，量子的概率波坍缩和多世界理论，以及退相干，这块还是蛮有趣的