I feel really conflicted about this rating, so let's just say; it was a good idea but there were some problems with the execution. Since it's a debut novel and the beginning of a series, I'm not willing to make too hard a judgement on the author. I will have to read the second book before I decide to commit to this series.
There were some really good things: The idea was very interesting and the research on torture was very well done.
Aislinn Cain is a genius and an expert in the field of medieval torture. She is also a sociopath who has survived two serial killers. So, when a serial killer uses torture devices from the middle ages to kill people, she gets approached by the US Marshals as a consultant. And, of course, a personal connection to her will draw her into the investigation.
That's all I'm going to give you about the story.
Unfortunately, there were some problems. The first of which was the believability of some things about some characters. If I discuss them, I will have to put a spoiler alert on this review - something I very rarely do. You can decide for yourself. This book was a free download (and probably still is, so it might be worth checking out.) It is something I can forgive to an extent.
The thing that really bothered me was the writing style - no, not the short, clipped sentences. I thought that fit very well with the emotionless, logical main character. The first third of the book was written really well - the pace was great. But all of a sudden, everything slowed down to a crawl when the story became mainly dialogue. And there was so much repetition when they recapped what they had figured out up until that point. This didn't work for me. It was dull, it was boring and, most of all, it was difficult to get through. And then the pace pics up again toward the end of the book.
Okay, I said my peace, but it is worth mentioning that I was really impressed by the research into torture. I also have an interest in the subject and, some years ago, did some research of my own on the subject. She still managed to tell me some things I didn't know.
It doesn't matter why people are interested in the subject - it's an entire debate on its own. What I have found out is that there are only three reasons why people torture other people:
Information, punishment and (sexual) sadism*.
* I will call it sadism from now on, because this is also a debate without any definitive answers. An argument can be made that any type of pleasure has a sexual nature to it, whether the deed is actually done or not. The feeling of being "god" when you can take away someone's life (as described by many a serial killer), can also be included in this. No, it doesn't matter what I believe, but I'm not willing to argue about it either.
These days, if you asked anybody about torture, most will reference serial killers (real or imaginary), without giving it much thought. Thanks to Hollywood, we know just how bad serial killers can be. Hell, I'm no different. The first movie that made me wonder if I would ever be able to handle any kind of torture was a 70's movie with Dustin Hoffman in the lead, called MARATHON MAN. In one scene, this dentist drills a hole in his tooth, then works the nerves underneath until they start dying, and then he moves on to the next tooth. FUCK, man! I wanted to piss myself just thinking about it. But, in that case, it was to get information.
Want to know about punishment? SAW was probably the best example I can think of, simply because the people had to do some severe shit to themselves in order to survive. Remember, Jigsaw never killed anybody.
What about the movie PRISONERS with Hugh Jackman and Jake Gyllenhaal? A father was willing to torture someone for information in order to get back his abducted daughter. I personally loved that movie, I thought it was absolutely brilliant.
And, of course, the ultimate punishment movie has to be SE7EN - don't get me started on that one.
Sorry, I'm going off subject here.
The thing about torture - the truly horrible thing - is that it has happened since the beginning of time. And it is still happening to this day. Not only by killers, but there will always be a certain amount of torture during war - of which there is always one somewhere in the world. Sometimes it can be very simple - there is a water torture where they hang someone upside down and make water drip on his head, in the same spot, for hours. It may not sound like much, but can you imagine having a migraine and somebody keeps poking your head in the same spot?
There is sleep deprivation, which causes hallucinations and maybe even insanity. The examples are endless. And you don't even have to think about armies when I say war. There are gangs and cartels who goes so far beyond anything a normal human being would be willing to do.
At the end of the day, this subject is wide and (to me) very interesting. The story line of this book was good enough to make me willing to give this author another go. I do hope I will enjoy the second one more.
** Thanks for the recommend, Pat, I'm glad I read it!