My reviews contain spoilers.
This probably isn’t normally the kind of book I would pick up, but it was at the dollar store and I find it exciting anytime I stumble across a YA book there. And the premise did sound interesting initially.
I think it was kind of clear in reading it that this story was written by a guy. A lot of times it makes no difference, but sometimes you can just tell whether the author was a girl or a boy. The main character was a high schooler, but everything came across as much older. Normally people seem pretty young to me in writing, yet far more mature (in a negative way) in TV shows, and when books are turned into shows, there is a contrast in the feeling of their ages from my perspective. This was a rare book where I felt like the characters were older than they were supposed to be.
The main character, Leon, is a slacker. He was in the gifted program in middle school, but it sort of fell apart and he stopped trying. He’s content to live his life never trying. Then his middle school girlfriend who moved away reveals she might return, and he becomes worried that she’ll be disappointed. He wants to turn his life around, so his friend/mentor of evil starts giving him random little tasks that ultimately change him.
The first task leads him to sitting in a little empty restaurant on Valentines Day. It didn’t really lead him there, he chose to be there, but whatever. He ends up giving a ride home to a classmate, who later shows up at his house asking to date. He doesn’t agree until his friend tells him to.
At first this was interesting to me. Sometimes I read a story where it’s kind of obvious who the main love interest is, and I’m immediately like, “No! I don’t like them! Pick someone else! Pick someone else! Ahhh!” For no particular reason, it’s just how I feel. And then another random character will walk by (sometimes an actual character, sometimes just a background character), and I’ll say, “Them! Them! I choose them! Love them!” It rarely works out.
When the girl showed up in the restaurant needing a ride, I liked the idea of her much better than the middle school girlfriend. I didn’t expect the story to actually play out that way, so I was pleasantly surprised when she returned. But the way it was handled made my excitement fizzle. I shrugged it off, figuring it was a questionable start but it could still be good.
If it wasn’t her (Paige), then it would be the middle school girlfriend (MSG), and that was unappealing to me. The MSG was Leon’s dream girl, and he viewed her as this perfect, intellectual, artistic person. It also often referenced the trouble and pranks she liked to pull, but it was hard for me to accept that into the image I had created of her. Leon adored her, to me she seemed lame. Not because anything about her was actually lame, but just because her qualities were put up on a pedestal and I didn’t feel those things should be on a pedestal. They can be liked and appreciated and be great, but acting like they’re things that make her so much more impressive than everyone else so no one can compare just bothers me and makes me turn against that. It’s not the book’s fault, it’s my own personal response I guess.
Leon starts dating Paige and it goes back and forth over whether I like it or not. My main issue was that it didn’t really delve into their conversations or emotions toward each other. It did give them attention, but not in a way I was able to connect with. I think it’s because it’s a coming-of-age story, and that quick, kinda distant writing method tends to be how they come across to me, and I didn’t realize is was coming-of-age until I finished it and read it on the back cover, and I was like, “Dang, I wish I’d known! I hate those stories.”
One of the tasks Leon is given is to find a specific slushie flavor somewhere among all the gas stations because hunting for it will give him and Paige something to do together, since they run in different circles and don’t have much in common. They seemed to enjoy this activity together – I know because the story told me. There were only tiny pieces that actually indicated this without directly telling me.
Paige liked him and thought they had a good conversation from the time he drove her home on Valentines Day, and he understandably doesn’t know what she’s talking about. But she likes him and doesn’t think he’s a loser and waves away all his beliefs that she wouldn’t want her friends to knowing she’s dating him. She is actually invested in the relationship, where as he spends most of the book supposedly liking her while also not referring to her in the most positive way. He says she’s on the least attractive end of the popular crowd, “puts up” with her girl drama from the Yearbook Club he requests she help get him invited into. Those were the main ones that stuck out to me.
He just found a lot of her interests to be a nuisance and things he had to put up with and couldn't understand, while he viewed MSG's interests as inspiring things that he was a lesser person for not already being interested in himself.
Page's family sucked. Leon's family was fun, and Paige seemed interested in them, but after her first exposure she wasn’t so sure. That bothered me, but she changed her mind. They both hung out a few times with each other’s friends to keep things fair. It makes sense that Leon wouldn’t like her immediately since he only went out with her because he was told to and not because he had any real interest. It would’ve been cool that she was adamant about pursuing him at first if it had been done differently.
He grew to really care about and like her and he was pretty sure he was in love. They both were. But there was a lot that all these characters were involved in that I just did not find relatable, especially if they’re in high school. Like the big concern about jobs. Paige really wanted him to have a better job than he had, it was very important to her, because she needed to know he was a competent person. Neither of their family’s needed extra money, they were both fine. He only worked his job because it was easy and he enjoyed it. It didn’t make sense for them to be so stressed about that.
Then they had a pregnancy scare. Paige suspected she was pregnant, he took that as incentive to finally get his act together and grow up. She didn’t want to take a test yet because it would be too definitive, so without being sure, they just carried on as if it was a fact. I’ve seen shows where characters come to the conclusion they’re pregnant on very little evidence, and I know the entire time they’re not because it’s too laughable. I never understand how they can act this way when they don’t know for sure and have zero proof. Like, they keep talking about the baby and what they need to do and planning things out and buying things. This book had them referencing the baby and their future plans, but they didn’t go beyond that like the shows do. For that reason, I thought it was possible she was really pregnant, but I had doubts. I figured if it wasn’t true, they would learn from this experience and break up, which would be typical and a let down.
I was expecting it to be like a reverse “How I Met Your Mother”, where instead of waiting to meet this mystery girl only for the guy to end up with the girl that’s been there the entire story, it would instead ditch the girl who’s been there the entire story in favor of the mystery girl we meet at the end. Luckily by the end he wasn’t so infatuated with MSG and could view her visit as just seeing an old friend, or even saying goodbye to her, rather than hoping they would get back together.
There was also one part in a scene, and the way it was described, and then re-described, has stuck with me, disturbed me, disgusted me. I didn’t need that info in the first place, and then explaining it again in a worse way … why? I hope to one day forget it.
There were lot of times during reading this that I was looking forward to reading more, and I got through it quickly because much of it was enjoyable at the time, even if ultimately I wasn’t satisfied. But I didn’t really expect to be. I might’ve been disappointed if I’d spent more money on it, but since I got it for a dollar, there was no loss.