Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book
Rate this book
Athanasia ist noch immer auf der Flucht vor ihrem Vater, der seit seinem Gedächtnisverlust versucht sie zu finden. Zum Glück hat sie Jeanette, die sich freut, Athanasia Gesellschaft leisten zu dürfen. Als die beiden inkognito einen Ausflug machen, begegnen sie einem mysteriösen Mann, der in seiner Art sehr Kaiser Claude ähnelt. Athanasia hat ein ungutes Gefühl, während Jeanette ihm direkt zugetan ist. Doch auch Jeanette kommt ins Grübeln, als er plötzlich auf dem Anwesen ihres Onkels auftaucht …

288 pages, Paperback

First published July 20, 2021

8 people are currently reading
311 people want to read

About the author

Spoon

210 books46 followers
Associated Names:
* SPOON
* 스푼 (Korean Profile)

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
1,108 (58%)
4 stars
553 (29%)
3 stars
196 (10%)
2 stars
22 (1%)
1 star
5 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 71 reviews
Profile Image for Rebecca.
4,324 reviews69 followers
November 6, 2024
The shift in perspective to Jeannette makes for an interesting change in the way the story is unfolding. It's a much more tragic tale from her perspective, and I think Athy doesn't always understand that, even as she's realizing that this is more than just a book she once read.
Profile Image for Mika.
596 reviews91 followers
July 22, 2025
This one was rather medium paced and I was hoping all the time for an happy end for Athansia and it kinda happened only at the end of the 5th book which was rather disappointing. I also say kinda as the problem is still not solved and that makes me feel a bit uneased.

But except that the relationships with the characters were quite lovely again. Especially the difference between how Felix treats an intruder and Athanasia. He even made himself smaller so she feels more comfortable and not threatened which was so considerate of Felix!

The ‘sister's’ relationship was cute and I totally felt the nervousness of telling your sister that you are her actual sister. Jennette was so worried about Athansia and in the end was worried if Athanasia even liked her and her ‘father’ as they both never asked her any questions regarding her and that made Jennette feel like she is uninteresting.

And lastly, unfortunately the plot twists wasn't that shocking as I already predicted it while I read (I mean we got more than enough hints).

This book showed us mainly Jennette and how she feels about certain things and perceives the world. Felt really more out of her POV then from Athanasia what we usually get. Very interesting. Would like to see more of Jeanette!
Profile Image for ༄ ℛary ✨.
219 reviews
March 25, 2023
⭐3.4⭐

Ho divorato l'intera serie in pochissime ore!
È stata un incredibile esperienza e ringrazio infitamente la mia migliore amica S per avermi fatto conoscere la famiglia reale di Obelia. 🥰

Devo ammettere che considero questa storia molto ben strutturata rispetto agli altri manga letti nel corso della mia vita. Probabilmente, uno dei motivi principali per cui mi è piaciuto di più, è il fatto che il genere Romance in questo caso riguarda la famiglia.

Infatti è un'opera che tratta dei rapporti padre-figlia, di traumi, del ritrovamento di sé, dei problemi politici e molto altro.

𓆞𓆝 𓆟 𓆞𓆝 𓆟 𓆞𓆝 𓆟 𓆞𓆝 𓆟
Profile Image for Sarah Jabr.
120 reviews
April 17, 2024
Guys, if the author went missing, don't blame me.
I mean, how could she do this ?!!! How could the author not adding a FUCKING KISS ??!!!!
I was excited from the beginning for the sex scene between Athanasia and whatever the black-haired guy name is, but there's nothing 💀.
Not even a FUCKING KISS!!! 💀💀🔪🔪🔪🔪🔪
Anyways, thank goodness Claude is here.
Who needs a male lead when u have a female lead hot father🔥🔥🔥
The way he was jealous on her that he even had her first dance 😭😭, while the male leads were standing speechless 😭💀💀.
Profile Image for Maia Soria.
550 reviews
June 14, 2025
CLAUDE ME ASUSTANTE PENDEJO [15/02/22]

AAAAHHHH MI POBRE ATHY, ME DIO MUCHO Y ME DA MUCHO MIEDO TODO, pero no puedo odiar a Claude aaaahhh
Profile Image for belle ☆ミ (thisbellereadstoo).
2,587 reviews176 followers
December 6, 2023
september 2023

completed: chapter 125

i absolutely loved this. athanasia was executed by her father in her previous life and now that she's back, she's trying to find a way to survive. somehow, in this life, athanasia got closer to her coldblooded father and they actually develop a father-daughter relationship. it's heartwarming to see how protective he became.
Profile Image for aradhya.
135 reviews
January 13, 2024
i don't hate Jeannette but i don't like her. I know she always wanted father's love but girl, he isn't your father. and you are also disturbing athy and claude's relationship. the f-cking claude, why you needed to use black magic huh??? your doings are now reflecting over athy, i hate you.
WHERE'S THIS LUCAS????? he disappeared when he was needed the most!!!
Profile Image for Carmen.
453 reviews32 followers
April 9, 2025
Copy/paste review for all the volumes:

I read this series online and now need to collect the physical copies. I’m curious if the epilogue/side stories will ever come to be as the creator notes stated that they would but I haven’t seen anything.

As a review of the completed series and not just the one volume I think this sits as a 4.5 ⭐️ if I could give halves.

I enjoy the twists/explanations of reincarnation into a novel verses regression plot that’s more similar to something like Dr Elise.

This one was tagged as romance along with the childcare isekai trope but honestly any romantic storyline for the female protagonist is very secondary to the plot and I personally don’t feel is concretely settled at the end of the main story. As the main plot is that of the FL and her relationship with her father I don’t think we need a solid romance. In something like Father I don’t want this Marriage that is a very good balance between her romance arc and her father daughter relationship arc. While there are a lot of similarities in the father/daughter arc between the two stories, this one doesn’t put as much weight on the romance but then the majority of this story is told while she is in the body of her childhood self. It would be icky if there was more weight on the romance.

I’m not sure why there couldn’t have been a more concrete conclusion to the love triangle as the story definitely favours the one ML as the end game but alas we are left with a “who knows what the future will bring” scenario.

As for the father/daughter relationship I think the backstory/explanation for his cold behaviour that resulted in her death in the novel is well explained and a justifiable one as me the reader to accept why I forgive him in the current life as redeemable. I think others I’ve read have the FL forgiving the father (or other family member) too easily because it wasn’t “them” that was mistreated in the previous “life” when I’m left unsatisfied because it looks like the only reason they are liked and survive in this life is because of luck or they made theirselves interesting or useful when really the father is trash and should just live the kid regardless. Thankfully we get more in this one.

I do wish that we did get a bit more in character development from the father when the plot switches him from cold to caring. We get the why and even some of his awkwardness as he adjusts and while HE doesn’t know that his actions led to her death in the novel he could be a bit more remorseful about the first 5 years of her life in this life where he was nonexistent. Its still good though and worth the read
Profile Image for Zeynep.
65 reviews1 follower
Read
July 12, 2025
Seriyi yarılamışken bir yorum girmek istedim. Orta şeker spoilerlar içerecektir dikkat!

Öncelikle seri aslında en sevmediğim klişe olan "öldüm ve okuduğum romanın karakteri (özellikle trajik ölümü olan) oldum" serisi imiş ancak bebeklikten itibaren olduğu için benim bu tropeda en nefret ettiğim kişilik değişimi/başka kişi olması yok. Bebeklikten itibaren aynı kişi. bu yüzden zihnimde oluşan bu eksi hemen nötrlendi.

Ardından Lucas meselesi... Bir yerde gördüğüm bir spoilera göre Lucas isimli yüzyıllardır yaşayan karakterden bahsediliyordu. Hatta romantik ilişki potansiyeli taşıyor olarak. (Bu kısımdan emin değilim, eski bir spoiler ve henüz öyle bir şey olmadı) Ve yaş farkı beni bu konuda rahatsız etmişti lakin kız aslında ikinci bir ömür yaşıyor ve Lucas da bunun farkında gibi. Romantik bir şeyler olacaksa da sorun yok o yüzden. Bu olumsuz düşünce de nötrlendi.

Kısaca her şey harika gidiyordu. 2.cilt bittiğinde çok iyiydim. Seriye başlamadan spoiler almış olduğum ClaudexDiana dinamiklerinden de ufak ufak parçalar alıyorduk.

DERKEN HER ŞEY MAHVOLDU!!

Claude hafızasını kaybetti, Lucas yok oldu ve 5.ciltte hala hiçbir şey düzelmedi!!

Yani en çok ne hayal kırıklığı oldu bilmiyorum. İlk 3 cilt harikaydı ama 4 ve 5 beni delirtti. 5'te Diana ile ilgili bir sürü şey öğrenmeyi bekliyordum kapak sebepli ama resmen hiçbir şey görmedik. Ayrıca bu adamın hafızası yerine gelse bile kızında ve kızının itibarında oluşturduğu hasar nasıl düzelecek?? Anladık olay lazım da cidden bu gerekli miydi??

Bakalım Lucas geldi nihayet. Neler olacak görelim.

Yine de seri beklentimin altında kalacak gibi. Çünkü yıllardır okumayı bekliyordum ben bunu ya. 2.kez webtoon okumaya başladıktan kısa bir süre sonra bir şekilde bahsini hep gördüm ama hep erteledim. Yıllar geçtikçe de gerçekten sağlam bir beklenti oluşturmuştum. Üzücü...
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for R..
2,095 reviews
April 28, 2024
Seems like one step forward and three steps back. At least Claude no longer wants Athy dead, but his memories haven't resurfaced either and now it seems it may be far more serious than just amnesia and migraines. Then there's this other stranger they keep running into that reminds them of Claude and seems to have it out for Athy and Claude while encouraging Jeanette. Seems his Jeanette's true father, though no one is telling her or anyone else that, so she still is convinced Claude is her father and Athy her half-sister to complete the family she longs for. So how does that all work when Claude wants Jeanette around to relieve the pain from the migraines but can't stand being around Athy. Yet Athy is the acknowledges princess who resides at the palace and has now returned home and just wants her Daddy back, even if she keeps trying to remind herself the original goal was just to survive. Hopefully Lucas can help unravel things before they get even worse. As much as Claude definitely has always had a temper, he was also far more personable when he actually cared.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Anne .
773 reviews4 followers
February 10, 2025
Dieser Band war minimal schwächer als die letzten, aber einfach nur, weil nichts großes passiert ist. Jedoch war gleichzeitig viel los, Athanasia versteht sich sehr gut mit Jeanette (auch wenn immer noch etwas Abstand besteht) und sie hat ihr auch geholfen. Genauso wie Izekiel. Dieser Typ, der anscheinend seine Identität verbirgt (auch wenn diese angeteasert wurde) und nur Böses im Schilde führt, scheint hinter dem Zustand von Claude zustecken, der eigentlich Athanasia treffen sollte - zumindest so meine These. Lukas, der Schuft, hat durch seine Reise einfach alles verpasst. Gott sei Dank ist Athanasia wieder zurück im Palast, nur ich kann auch verstehen, dass sie es unschön findet, dass nur Jeanette Claude helfen kann (was natürlich der Typ Schuld ist). Ganz schön viele Intrigen und noch einige ungelöste Rätsel. Bin super gespannt, wie es nach der Offenbarung am Ende jetzt weitergeht.
Profile Image for Elle.
110 reviews
November 8, 2024
Loved this volume! There's just so much going on with all the characters however, I just absolutely do not like Jeanette at all. I just find her too naive and needy all the time and I understand that she just wanted her supposed family to acknowledge her but every single time she appears in this (which is a lot) I just find myself super annoyed. Athy could've just asked Ezekiel for help in the first place (because that's definitely what I would do haha) instead she goes to Jeanette who is so self absorbed that she only does things because it benefits her too. Hopefully they just give Jeanette's screentime to Ezekiel or Lucas haha.
Profile Image for Natali.
140 reviews1 follower
May 3, 2025
Mi volumen menos favorito.
Es que Arti mija cómo puedes actuar tan normal?? de verdad que pareciera que estabas dispuesta a servirle todo a Zenith en bandeja de oro 🫤.
sí pareciera que tomarás esa decisión pues bueno, vete al campo y cómprate una pequeña casa, porqué aceptar alojo en casa de los Alfierce??

•Yo no odio a Zenith, ella solo es una pieza en este juego. Pero es que Artie también la pone difícil.
No lo sé, no logro expresarme como quiero jajajaja, pero estoy algo decepcionada de que esto esté empeorando y que no haya movimiento.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Dul × Cronopio en Jaque.
241 reviews7 followers
June 9, 2022
Salgo de un dolor en el alma y entro a otro 😖 Ahora no soy capaz de desearle el mal a la quimera porque me encariñe y hasta empatizo con ella. De todas formas se está poniendo difícil para Athanasia y los paneles de su carita entristecida me duelen, me queman, me lastiman 💔

La creadora de esta joyita sin saberlo está manipulando mi corazón, si este manhwa no tiene final feliz voy a proceder a llorar mil años.
1,795 reviews
Read
April 26, 2024
Poor Athanasia has been forgotten by her beloved father, and is sneaking around with magic, hanging out with Jeannette, and generally at loose ends waiting for Lucas to return.

It was hilarious that she assumed Felix wouldn’t notice her invisibly following him - he may act bumbling and dense around her, but he IS the main guard of the emperor, so it stands to reason he is capable. They startled each other 🤭
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
83 reviews
December 31, 2024
Hier wird es noch mal richtig spannend.
Echt empfehlenswert!


Spoiler!

Nach dem ihr Vater unter Gedächtnisverlust leidet, muss Athanasia fliehen. Claude versucht seine eigene Tochter zu töten, da er sich nicht mehr an sie erinnert. Der Kaiser leidet unter furchtbaren Kopfschmerzen und aus irgendeinem Grund scheint nur die Anwesenheit von Jeanette diese etwas zu lindern. Können sich Athanasia und Claude wieder annähern?
35 reviews
October 12, 2022
4.5
Me encantó un poco más q los anteriores, aquí vemos la relación de claude y diana, muy triste la verdad (mientras leía los capítulos la cancion "The one that got away" se me venía a la mente). Sigo un poco triste ya que yo quería que Diana y claude tuvieran otro final pero no me quejo..... La historia si que se puso buena.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
3,187 reviews
June 13, 2025
Princess Athanasia continues to hide from the King who still has amnesia and wants to kill her.

This volume felt like filler to kill time so it dragged a bit. Very little has changed at the end of this 280 page book though the last few pages do show that things will be moving along in volume 6. The art was its usual beautiful colorful self.
Profile Image for Alejandra Zavala.
127 reviews3 followers
May 6, 2023
Creí que terminaría odiando a la señorita Magrita, pero todo lo contrario, la termine amando, es un gran apoyo para Athy en un momento tan crucial, es sin duda un amor de persona. Al igual que Athanasia yo espero que la quimera también tenga su final feliz. ❤️
Profile Image for Cami Piriz.
67 reviews2 followers
January 19, 2025
El personaje de Zenith me agrada, no siento que sea una mala chica, solo que es inocente e ingenua, pero sé que muchos quieren aprovecharse de sus cualidades para manipularla, y eso me molesta. Ojalá no caiga en la trampa. No quiero que se convierta en la villana.
Profile Image for Yan.
467 reviews
February 20, 2025
This is such a cute story. There is a romance but I like that the story line is focused on the relationship between Athy and Claude. I love how cute the relationship is between the father and child. Athy is also smart, especially on how she use her knowledge about the story to her advantage.
Profile Image for Christina Mastoraki.
273 reviews
July 29, 2025
Πρέπει να συμφωνήσω με τον ψιλό. Από ποιον πήρε η Jeanette? Είναι τόσο γλυκιά και οι γονείς της ήταν θεός φυλάξει. Και το δράμα συνεχίζεται με περισσότερα σκαμπανεβάσματα και δολοπλοκίες. Θέλω πολύ να δω τι θα φέρει στο τραπέζι ο Lukas.
Profile Image for Mara Carvajal.
103 reviews2 followers
July 18, 2022
Este es de las primeras novelas gráficas digitales que lei. Athanasia es un personaje muy interesante.
Profile Image for &#x1f9f8;♡뀨♡&#x1f423;.
1,240 reviews
August 21, 2022
55-68 必須一直跟自己說這不是珍妮特的錯,不然真的無法喜歡她欸⋯⋯然後皇帝哥哥感覺超邪惡的,應該就是有黑魔法吧⋯⋯拜託爸爸趕快恢復記憶把娜西接回去啦,我想看追女兒火葬場😂
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for marmarmar.
176 reviews27 followers
webcomic
July 13, 2023
(55-68)
LA PORTADA-
ATHY REGRESA A CASA. Claude está todo medio muerto, se muere él, me muero yo. Otro tomo lleno de dolor.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 71 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.