Just a few days after she gives birth alone in the Northwoods, a recently widowed young Chippewa woman stumbles into a nearby lumber camp in search of refuge and sustenance. Come summer, the camp owner sends Skypilot, his most trusted friend, to accompany Moon Song and her baby on the long and treacherous journey back to her people. But when tragedy strikes off the shore of Michigan's Upper Peninsula wilderness, Moon Song and Skypilot must depend on each other for survival. With every step they take into the forbidding woods, they are drawn closer together, until the tough questions must be asked. Will she leave her culture to enter his? Will he leave his world to enter hers? Or will they walk away from a love that seems too complicated to last?
With evocative descriptions of a breathtaking landscape, Under a Blackberry Moon will sweep readers into a wild realm where beauty masks danger and only the truly courageous survive, even as the sweet love story along the way tightly grips their hearts.
I live only a few miles from a flourishing Amish community and am blessed to count many Old Order Amish as friends. Love Finds You In Sugarcreek, Ohio is a natural outgrowth of my on-going fascination with these valiant, flawed people who struggle to live their lives according to their interpretation of the Bible. Once, when I apologized for asking so many questions while researching this book, an Amish father told me that I could ask anything I wanted. “Nothing is forbidden,” he said. He told me that he wanted my book to be accurate. I was thrilled when his family read it and gave me their enthusiastic nod of approval.
Our family, however, also lived for many years in Michigan. My father, a sawyer, told me stories he had heard from old timber men who had cut the fabled giant pine in the Saginaw Valley. Visiting museums and reading about the years directly after the Civil War, when Michigan became the lumber capitol of the world, became a hobby. I was delighted when Revell Publishing allowed me to revisit that era by writing The Measure Of Katie Calloway.
There are many other books on their way—both Amish and historical. Please know that each one is a labor of love from me to you.
I liked the first book, The Measure of Katie Calloway, but it didn't make me want to continue the series right away. However, my friend on Goodreads (Staci), said she enjoyed this book way more than book 1 so I figured I will give it a go. Then, thanks to a book challenge, it gave me the final motivation to get to this book.
In Book 1, I found Moon Song strange, especially because she couldn't really speak English. She was this weird silent Indian character which just happened to be there. But from page 1, Moon Song found her voice in this book. From the start where she gave a horrible man a well deserving kick, right up till the end, she had my vote. She was a strong, courageous young woman which I grew to admire as her story unfolded. I loved to read her thoughts and see what she is made off.
Skypilot, ah, what a precious sigh-worthy character he was. Especially how he pursued Moon Song and how he met the white man and Indian worlds half way.
The historical facts were well researched and I found myself having long discussions with my husband about what I've read (he loves history). It saddens me to think what the "white men" took away from the Indians by forcing their ways and traditions on them and "stealing" their land. I wonder how different today would be if everyone acted like Skypilot did.
The twists and surprises throughout this book made it a very fast read. The secondary characters were rounded off nicely with their own little story which just added to the enjoyment of the book in total.
According to goodreads and the publication years, this is the third book of the series, however, this book started in 1868, and A Promise to Love in 1871, so I read Under a Blackberry Moon first.
As soon as I started, I realised this is actually a sequel and I hadn't read the first in the series. It didn't matter. The beautiful cover first drew my attention to this novel. I love to think that the main character, Moon Song, looked just like this. I think the story achieves everything a historical novel should.
It did take me a little while to warm up to either of the main characters. I found Skypilot a bit quick to cast judgments at first. Just before the explosion, while he'd been chatting with Isabella's husband, Hatchette's revelations disgusted him. Skypilot couldn't even imagine how he and that man could be from the same species. Yes, the guy was seriously misguided, but hey, isn't that still a bit harsh coming from a preacher?
I was intrigued by Moon Song's parts of the story. Such a lot of research had been done into the mindset of her people. This was fantastic, but made it a bit hard to relate to her point of view at first. Who knew what the girl would come out with next? (Swimming around in the floating aftermath of the explosion without being squeamish, for example. The idea makes me shudder.)She was so aloof and almost gruff for so much of the story, but I got used to her ways and found her growing on me.
What made me object to both of them was the casual way they behaved when Isabella lost her baby. Instead of thinking how traumatic this would be for a young mother, they both seemed to consider her a nuisance, distracting them from the more serious question of survival. Neither of them made a single move to try to comfort her at the outset. I'm glad to say this changed as the story went on, and they acted with more compassion.
The sad, shameful history of the white settlers' dealings with the native American Indians has so many parallels with the way Australian settlers treated our native Aboriginals. I never realised it was quite so similar. It's disturbing and amazing that this is the history of both countries. The forced boarding schools reminds me of my country's Stolen Generation shame. Also, it seems that in both cases, the proud native people were reduced to ending up dependent on white folk's handouts.
The second part of the book was my favourite. Who can resist a good love story when the guy is challenged to prove his love to the girl? I admired the way Skypilot went about it. There was a lovely surprise twist or two. I'm so glad Isabella's story ended happily too, as she was one of my favourite characters. On the whole, I think Serena B. Miller did a wonderful job and couldn't have asked for a better ending than this epilogue.
I received a copy of this book from NetGalley and Revell in return for an honest review.
What an utter disappointment. I was enchanted by "The Measure of Katie Calloway" and really liked "A Promise to Love."
The underlying racism of this book bothered me deeply. While the author intended to make a point about the value of Native American culture and the great harm done by the government in systematically destroying that culture, she did the *exact same thing* by insulting Native spiritual beliefs. To the author, Native beliefs are far lesser than Christianity and should be cast aside - how is that any different than the viewpoint that Native children should cut their hair and switch to English? It's not.
I get that this is a Christian series. In the first two books, Christianity was a source of strength for the main characters. That's great. I have no problem with that at all. In this book, Christianity is set up as the superior religion and used as a comparison, and how a non-Christian woman is simply inadequate until she converts. So, so disappointing.
Moon Song is a young Chippewa widow who days after giving birth finds her way into a lumber camp. She spends the winter there and makes friends with Isaac Ross, known as Skypilot. When the summer arrives, the owner of the camp understands that for her own protection, Moon Song and her baby son need to be sent back to her people. Skypilot is asked to accompany her. While on the journey North, tragedy strikes and what was supposed to be a simple journey is now wrought with peril. As they travel together, both realize they have come to love the other. But there are obstacles in their way. Will she be forced to give up her world to live in his? Or will he give up his world to live in hers? Will they ever share the same faith?
Wow! That's really all I can say about this book. It started off rather slow, but things picked up when the tragedy struck Moon Song and Skypilot. The scenery in this book is truly breathtaking. And the way that the author has captured both of their struggles had me hoping that some way some how, the two would end up together.
Skypilot showed a strength in character that I've not seen a lot in the heroes of the books. He was determined to live his faith out. And to do all he could to obtain the trust of Moon Song's people. Moon Song for her part showed me a way of life I'm really not familiar with. The way that she went out of her way to ensure that her companions were able to survive showed the depth of her character as well.
There were many times while reading this book that I was reminded of a classic from my childhood, Island of the Blue Dolphins. I also was reminded at times of Jeanette Oke's book Drums of Change. It's been a long time since I've read either of those, but I was able to remember the struggles for survival that occurred in both books.
I really wasn't expecting to like this book the way that I did. Typically when a book starts off slow, I find myself having a hard time getting into it.
I received this book for free from Revell Books for the purpose of reviewing. My thoughts and opinions are my own.
Recommended to fans of Laura Frantz, Joanne Bischof, Jody Hedlund, historical fiction
Rating - 5 stars - It truly wowed me. Available in October, 2013 from Revell Books a division of Baker Publishing Group.
SUMMARY: Just a few days after she gave birth alone in the northwoods, a recently widowed young Chippewa woman stumbled into a nearby lumber camp in search of refuge from the winter snows. Come summer, it is clear that Moon Song cannot stay among the rough-and-tumble world of white lumbermen, and so the camp owner sends Skypilot, his most trusted friend, to accompany her on the long and treacherous journey back to her people.
But when tragedy strikes off the shore of Lake Superior, Moon Song and Skypilot must depend on each other for survival. With every step they take into the forbidding woods, they are drawn closer together, until it seems the unanswerable questions must be asked. Can she leave her culture to enter his? Can he leave his world to enter hers? Or will they simply walk away from a love that seems too complicated to last?
REVIEW: This continuation from the story The Measure of Katie Calloway focusing on Moon Song and Skypilot was a wonderful read. The descriptions throughout the story of the settings were detailed and made the reader feel they were right there in the midst of the Michigan Upper Peninsula. The storyline with the development of the relationship between Moon Song and Skypilot was intriguing with all the twists and turns that occurred in their lives. The historical research into the white-Indian relationships was well done and introduced me to new facts regarding the treatment of the Native American during that time period in history. I enjoyed how Moon Song made Skypilot realize that so many of the his concepts of Indian life were incorrect or skewed. She was a strong woman who knew and accepted who she was. The ending definitely had some surprise moments which were very enjoyable.
FAVORITE QUOTES: "One thing they had all grown to realize was that hatred could do terrible things to the person who did the hating."
"They had all learned a great deal. The best lesson of all was that gold, real gold, true gold, was found only within the hearts of those who loved."
Under a Blackberry Moon is the fourth book by Serena B. Miller I've read and it was another book I ended up loving! For most of the first half, I felt like it was a four-star read, but once I got further into the story, wow, I had a hard time putting it down and absolutely loved the ending -- SO good!
The characters were good. It took a little bit for me to get connected to Skypilot and Moon Song, but in the end they are both my favorite characters from Under a Blackberry Moon. I loved how real their actions and thoughts felt. I also thought the romance story was very sweet and the way Skypilot pursued Moon Song was wonderful.
The history in Under a Blackberry Moon was fantastic and I learned some things I hadn't known. I also thought the Author's Note at the end was great. Another thing that I enjoyed was that Katie and her family (from The Measure of Katie Calloway) were mentioned and in this book quite a lot. I kind of wish Ingrid (from A Promise to Love) would have made an appearance, or at least been mentioned, but I understand why that didn't happen.
Overall, Under a Blackberry Moon was a unique and wonderful read. I enjoyed it more than I had initially thought I would. I recommend it to fans of historical fiction with some action and romance.
*I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher for my review. I was not required to give a positive review, only my honest opinion - which I've done. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own.*
Available October 2013 at your favorite bookseller from Revell, a division of Baker Publishing Group
The kind of read that makes your blood boil and your heart thrill. Miller does an exceptional job of delivering historical accuracy...and she doesn't pull any punches. The treatment of native people throughout history has been abysmal. It's a good thing I wasn't actually there because I would have done a few individuals bodily harm. How so-called Christians could treat an entire race with such callousness and cruelty...well it boggles the mind.
Skypilot (Isaac Ross) is larger than life -- the stuff tall tales are made of. A kind and decent man with his feet firmly planted in the white man's world. Moon Song is just as immersed in her Chippewa culture and yet an unlikely friendship has developed between the two. A friendship that deepens into something much more during their treacherous journey. Talk about an impossible romance!
Miller has drawn on historical figures to flesh out her fictional characters and their stories leave me in awe. The details are spectacular -- everything from the bawdy logging town to the plight of women in the mid 1800s. Lots for a reader to sink her teeth into. Like this:
"Ladies are supposed to strive to be competent, never excel." A secondary character, Isabella, makes this comment to Skypilot. Of course, she's speaking from a white woman's perspective so the contrast between Moon Song and her white counterparts is riveting -- both for the reader and Skypilot himself. Because Moon Song excels at a lot of things.
Complicated relationships, life and death struggles and always the thrill of the unexpected -- Under a Blackberry Moon is the kind of story that sweeps you away and holds you captive until the very last page.
I wish this had been book 2 in the series so I could remember Moon Song a little better. It had been a while since I read book 1. That being said, I enjoyed the history in this book. It is obvious the author did a lot of research regarding the lifestyles of the Native Americans and the way the government treated them in the 1800s. It was crappy treatment to say the least. Skypilot was such a good man and Moon Song was bada$$. Not as much romance as I had hoped, but the respect they had for each other and the trials they endured together kept me throughly engrossed.
I found The Measure of Katie Calloway to be an ok novel. Under a Blackberry Moon was so much better.
One difference between the two is that I found The Measure of Katie Calloway to be a bit predictable. Under a Blackberry Moon had many twists and turns. I also enjoyed the history woven into the novel.
Well….I completed this series in 2025…the same year….not the norm for me. I must say I enjoyed each and every 5-star read but believe this beautiful story of Moon Song was my favorite of the three. I’m looking forward to reading more of Ms Miller’s works in 2026.
Absolutely amazing!!! When I read the book description I thought that I'd give it a shot. It sounded pretty interesting. I WAS blown away with how amazing this story turned out to be, and I'm not sure the description really does it justice!!! I laughed SO hard at some of the dialogue and the pages are filled with surprise after surprise. This story is SO great that I can read it again and again. I enjoyed it so much I didn't want it to end! The pace is excellent, blending one great scene after another, and I absolutely love the scenes where the characters must survive in the wilderness! Serena made it all so realistic with the way Moon Song had to find food and shelter. I love when an author has to come up with ways for their characters to survive with little to no tools and Serena knocks it out of the ball park. The messages of strength in body, mind, and faith are expressed beautifully in this rugged background. From "civilization", to Lake Superior, to the deep forest, Under a Blackberry Moon takes you through it all! Serena has also captured the sad devastation the Indian tribes faced through history. From losing the old ways to having everything stolen from them, to the prejudices against them; these characters must find a way to survive not just the harshness of the wilderness but also from the changing times. After reading this book I would LOVE to go back and read where Moon Song was first introduced in The Measure of Katie Calloway. This is a MUST READ!!! Entertaining, beautiful, humorous, lovable, surprising, and heartwarming!
And a shout out to Koechel Peterson & Associates and Bryan Hansel! They out did themselves on this beautiful cover!!!
Songs: "Loon - Bird Call Song" by Sound Affection, "For The Beauty Of The Earth (Album Version)" by BarlowGirl, "Believer" by Kutless, "How Can I Not Love You (Anna and the King) [Karaoke Instrumental Track] [In the Style of Joy Enriquez]" by ProSound Karaoke Band, "A Mighty Fortress Is Our God, Rock Of Ages, Victory In Jesus, Because He Lives (Medley) (LP Version)" by Sandi Patty, and when I found what I think is the strange French lullaby from the book I couldn't resist adding it's instrumental: "La petite poule grise" by The Kiboomers
Joshua 1:5
~ASC
*I received this book free from Revell in exchange for my honest review. This in no way affected my opinion and the above is what I truly think about Under a Blackberry Moon. ~ASC
Under a Blackberry Moon is the latest in a line of terrific historicals from author Serena B. Miller. As in her previous book, A Promise to Love, it took a few chapters to warm up to the hero, Isaac "Skypilot" Ross, but in the end Moon Song and Skypilot's story is a treasure. Under a Blackberry Moon isn't so much a romance but a story of survival and strength.
Moon Song, was blessed to escape with her life and that of her newborn son's during the midst of one of the harshest Michigan winters. After a season of tender care and friendship at the hands of the local lumber camp owner and his wife, she's ready to head back to her own family on the Chippewa Indian reservation. Skypilot accompanies her on the journey -- but trips aboard steamships aren't always the safest route. When their plans go tragically awry, they must fend for themselves in the unforgiving wilderness and fight the feelings that grow between them.
From the first few chapters of this book, I didn't think this was going to be a romance. I loved the sort of camaraderie and friendship that both had towards each other. The friendship between Moon Song and Skypilot worked well, but then the romantic aspects jumped out from nowhere and seemed a bit forced. Skypilot seemed very reluctant to acknowledge her as woman at first and then it jumped straight to wanting a serious relationship with her. It didn't work for me, however, I still enjoyed the journey and spiritual growth of both Moon Song and Skypilot. Anytime you can see the evolution of the character on the page and feel yourself become a part of that character's story, it's a book worth reading. Moon Song's gradual acceptance of the Christian faith and Skypilot's gentle teaching saved this book for me. A lot of times the spiritual messages can be forceful and unnatural but it worked great in this story. If you enjoy Christian romances I might not recommend starting out with this one, try A Promise to Love (MY REVIEW HERE), but I definitely recommend that you read this one if you like a little adventure and history.
*I receive complimentary books for review from the publisher. I am not required to write positive reviews. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255.*
Title: UNDER A BLACKBERRY MOON Author: Selena Miller Publisher: Revell October 2013 ISBN: 978-0800721183 Genre: Historical
Which wilderness is more treacherous--the one she must cross to find her home . . . or the one she must traverse to find love?
Just a few days after she gave birth alone in the north woods, a recently widowed young Chippewa woman stumbled into a nearby lumber camp in search of refuge from the winter snows. Come summer, it is clear that Moon Song cannot stay among the rough-and-tumble world of white lumbermen, and so the camp owner sends Skypilot, his most trusted friend, to accompany her on the long and treacherous journey back to her people.
But when tragedy strikes off the shore of Lake Superior, Moon Song and Skypilot must depend on each other for survival. With every step they take into the forbidding woods, they are drawn closer together, until it seems the unanswerable questions must be asked. Can she leave her culture to enter his? Can he leave his world to enter hers? Or will they simply walk away from a love that seems too complicated to last?
Get swept into a wild realm where beauty masks danger and only the truly courageous survive in a story that will grip your heart and your imagination.
UNDER A BLACKBERRY MOON is the sequel to The Measure of Katie Halloway, but it easily stands alone. I enjoyed getting reacquainted with Skypilot, the preacher-turned-logger, and Moon Song. At first, Moon Song is out of place in Bay City, Michigan, but when she and Skylark ended up stranded in the wilderness she was the strong one with the skills to survive.
I enjoyed seeing Moon Song find herself, and appreciated that Skypilot was able to remain strong and courageous while clearly out of his league. I wondered how these two would work everything out.
The storytelling is not as good in this book as it was in Ms. Miller’s previous books set in Michigan. It is stiff, and doesn’t allow us to get into Skypilot’s head as much as I would’ve liked. Moon Song was very well developed. However, it is still a book I enjoyed, full of Michigan history, and vivid descriptions. Recommended. 4.5 stars, rounded up to 5. $14.99. 341 pages.
UNDER A BLACKBERRY MOON by Serena B. Miller, is a unique novel filled with tenderness, grace, determination, and the story of love conquering all.
Moon Song has come a long way from the day she stumbled into a Lumber camp seeking refuge from the harshness of winter, after giving birth alone and on her own. But now it is time for her to go back to her people. And, because of the fondness the camp owners have for Moon Song, they have asked their trusted friend Skypilot to see her safely home.
After a major disaster, Moon Song and Skypilot must make their way several miles by foot to civilization. Along this journey their feelings for each other begin to grow into something more than fondness. Skypilot is convinced he’s in love with Moon Song and tries to convince her of the same. But, because of the betrayal of white men to both her and her mother, Moon Song is convinced Skypilot will one day leave her and because of that she refuses to give him her heart, even though he already possess it. After delivering Moon Song safely to her people, Skypilot tries once more to convince her he wants to stay with her and prove his love. She refuses. Realizing there is only one way to prove his love, Skypilot sets out on a life altering journey, praying that his path will cross Moon Song’s once again.
I really enjoyed UNDER A BLACKBERRY MOON. The story felt fresh and unique but my heart ached as the story read as a review of American history and the mistreatment of the Native American people. The secondary characters added depth and color to an already rich story. And as previously stated it was the epitome of love conquering all.
Available October 2013 at your favorite bookseller from Revell, a division of Baker Publishing Group.
Let me just say that I really,really,really enjoyed reading this book from the the very first page! I had been looking forward to this book ever since it came out and I was not disappointed! I actually finished this book in a day or two because I was very captivated by this story. I highly recommend this book!!!
To me, the story was a breath of fresh air. I had been looking forward to a book where it'd capture my attention with an unpredictable story. I thought it was very original. I learned a lot about the tribe that Moon Song came from in this book which was AWESOME. I love learning about different cultures. The story surrounding Moon Sing and Skypilot was very adventurous and fun to read about! I loved the book cover as well.
This story had me turning page after page until I was done. With some books I have very low patience because all throughout the story I'm wondering,"When is it going to end!" That wasn't the case with this book! I think this might be the best book by this author yet! She has written some very good ones and I can't wait to read her next book! I totally recommend this very intriguing story. You won't regret it! (5 stars)
Under a Blackberry Moon is a very moving and touching tale. The story is rich in detail, which made it very easy to picture everything.
Moon Song was such a complex character. I wasn't sure at first if I was going to like her, but very quickly I did. Then as the story progressed, and I came to understand her, I loved her. I've come to learn that she was a minor character in one of this author's previous books, The Measure of Katie Calloway, and understand why people have said they wanted to see a book about her - She is such a great character!
Under a Blackberry Moon is the first book I've read by this author, but I hope to read her other books soon. Highly recommended!
***I received a complimentary copy of this book to review. I was asked to give my honest opinion of the book - which I have done.***
Honestly I was not expecting much out of this book, I just figured it would be like many of the other books I have read. Much to my delight this turned out to be a fantastic read! Definitely one of the best books I have read this year. The author took me on a historical journey and right when I thought how the book would end she changed it's direction. The history of the Native American culture in this book is incredible, the details, and the characters are full of depth and intrigued me. I loved Moon Song and Skypilot and how they worked together when they ended up in the wilderness. This is a great historical fiction read, I highly recommend!!
Learn more about the book over here.
"I received this book from Revell for free in exchange for an honest review."
“Available October 2013 at your favorite bookseller from Revell, a division of Baker Publishing Group.”
This story was okay but I certainly enjoyed the 1st two books in this series better. This is the story of Moon Song and Sky Pilot from The Measure of Katie Calloway, the first book in the series. This was hard for me to enjoy because it was very one-sided. Sky Pilot had to give up everything, which he didn't mind, but Moon Song was stubborn, and to me came across as childish by always having to have her way.
What a great story about Moon Song, the lady who shows up at the timber camp with her starving baby, and Skypilot, who used to be a preacher. Skypilot takes Moon Song back to her grandmother. They have quite the adventure there. Then Skypilot decides to learn the way of the Chippewa and convince Moon Song to be his bride. Quite a few surprises along the way.
What a great book there's no words to even describe how much I loved this book no wonder its nominated for a Christy award. I love moon song how strong and brave she is . This is defiantly one of my favorites . this is the third book in the Michigan Northwood's series by Serena miller the series is just remarkable this book and the series is a must read.
I really enjoyed this well written historical novel. The characters were well drawn and were interesting. The plot was both sweet and intense. It's definitely a new favorite.
I truly enjoyed this story & loved it being set in my state of MI. This book continues the story of Skypilot & Moon Song. It starts as he is well & she is ready to return to her Native family. While helping her Grandmother get well, she finds a bible with a letter & another paper left to her by her real Father. She then learns he did not have any hand in the murder of her Mother & that he has in fact left her land north of where they are now, & the deed to it as he is expected to die in the near future. He escorts her to them but of course, they run into many challenges & she can not overcome the fact that "white" men who marry Native women, end up leaving them. Skypilot does everything he can to make he feel he will not, but she is hesitant & lives with her people. Skypilot teaches school not far away until he can get her to take him seriously & become his wife. Then the government people show up & her family are forced to leave their home so the children are not taken to "white man" schools. She sends for Skypilot who joins her family. They travel in harsh UP winter weather & when they get to her land, they are greeted with a man with a shotgun. After they find out who he is, the Native people are given shelter in the cabin & barn. Once it gets even colder, they all move into the cabin. They find out that the man with the shotgun is Moon Song's real Father. He did not die as he was told he would so he came to the land he left for her to build a cabin & barn so when she arrived, she would have a home that was safe. Of course, the government people find them & with Skypilot there, teaching the children, they leave them alone. It takes a little while until Moon Song agrees to marry Skypilot so there is the Happily Ever After.
DNF at 60% This wasn't a bad book... I just could not bring myself to finish it. After reading (& loving) the first two books in this series, which were actually hard to put down, I thought I would love this one. Alas, that was not meant to be. With over-the-top descriptions of Moon Song, Skypilot and Moon Song consistently having no chemistry and then having chemistry (for awhile I thought the author was going to allow Skypilot and Isabella fall in love, but then she goes nuts, etc.). After surviving the wilderness, aka Moon Song is so perfect here, she is beautiful, and Skypilot made her feel safe, etc, I sort of lost interest. Look, survival is important. And I don't necessarily like survival type plots... in fact, I barely do, but all the lovey dovey input drove me insane, and I LOVE CHRISTIAN HISTORICAL ROMANCES. Look I do not need every other page detailing how beautiful and graceful Moon Song is... I needed more chemistry or something. All in all, this book's saving grace is the attention to historical detail Serena B. Miller put in this series. The history buff in me is doing a happy dance because of all the author's notes explaining the history and inspiration behind each of the books in this series.
Note: I have a flatrate policy, if I don't finish a book, it gets one star. I was really tempted to give this book two stars because of how much I like the author's historical detail, but I just couldn't.
I deeply appreciate the effort that authors put forth who write Historical Fiction. It is clear that Miller has done her homework concerning the Michigan Indians and white man's intrusion. There are several changes that had they been in place would have improved my rating of this book. First, the dialog was too modern. Skypilot says things in conversation such as "Good Question". That is a modern day expression that is overused in today's world and detracts from the authenticity of this novel. Some plot items that bothered me a great deal was the art work of Isabelle. It would have been fine to depict her as an artist but turning her into a world renown artist in the scope of this novel in the manner in which it came about was silly and out of place and not believable.
There were so many predictable cliche incidents that occurred that kept the book from feeling authentic; everything that could happen did happen especially along the walk after the shipwreck. I appreciate the depiction of the Indian girl as being totally at home in nature but it was just too much. Some things that felt very forced and too contrived were the finding of the barrel with the muslin after the shipwreck, the wolf attacks. It was too convenient that the only evidence of the entire shipwreck was one barrel that was intact, not a drop of water in it and it just happened to have enough muslin in it to construct a rope to climb the cliff. And then they just happen to find a canoe; groan.
This book was more than your average story of a white man meeting a Native American girl and falling in love. Although that is the just of most of the plot there are other parts of the story that are more complex and involved. I love the way that the author brings attention to the many challenges in the lives of native American tribes and people during this time. Looking back it’s hard to believe that people treated one another this way. But in an imperfect world there are obviously going to be imperfect people. The story was very well told and it was not one of those glossing over stories that you read about where everything turns out great in the end… It does turn out well of course but the road is not easy and there are a lot of challenges on the way. And that’s OK because that it’s what makes a good story. I like to moon thongs independence and courageousness and tenacity. She knew who she was and she demanded to be treated in a specific way without compromising. Of course Skypilot was A strong male character but I really feel like moonshine was her own strong and courageous character And in some ways was stronger than Skypilot was. In the end though they both had their own set of strengths and weaknesses that bolstered them and helped solve the many issues faced by the Cherokee