Note: I read the Revised Edition published in 2015. I don't know what the differences are.
As always, I love Schwartz's writing style. I liked the weaving of historical and other interesting information into what could have been a simple list of how-to steps. I learned so much from the introductory chapters, but I also enjoyed all the great explanations and asides within the bench chapters. Besides, he likes cats. I was surprised, however, at the numerous small editing misses (Schwartz being an editor, as well as this being a 2nd edition). It didn't really bother me, but there were enough of them to notice it.
On a practical level, I can't wait to get started on a workbench of my own. I found the chapters about workbench features and how to choose those that would benefit my work (now and in the future) most helpful and informative. I now feel much more confident that I can select the lumber and build a bench that will last me a lifetime. I also appreciated the appendix, as I learned about bench accessories and the portable bench, which can be used on any solid surface that can take a clamp. As I am currently an apartment-dweller with little extra room, I'm going to try this out. I know it won't have the heft of a real bench, but maybe it'll allow me to perfect my dovetailing and learn other smaller-scale skills. Overall, this book was a wise purchase.