2.6 unresolved stars.
As the last book in the Lost Book series I am disappointed, and well, lost. I spent a lot of time on six books just to be let down by the ending. I don’t understand why nothing was culminated. Like, for example, how Johnis of all people is the “chosen one”. I really thought I would finally understand, but alas.
The last installment in the series is a continuation of the same plot as the previous book. Darsal is on a mission to save Marak, the Horde, the albinos, and Johnis and Silvie by convincing those close to her to drown in the red lakes. Meanwhile, Johnis is still possessed by the Leedhan and is leading a troop to control all the shataiki with a magical medallion that can defeat the Horde and albinos once and for all.
I had a hard time following this book. I didn’t know where we were or what to imagine in my head, and I don’t think the plot was explained well enough. What was this great sacrifice they were trying to make at Ba’al Bek? And why? Maybe I missed something in the text, but there were so many places I would ask myself, why? It was virtually constant action with no understanding of where the narrative was going. It felt unnecessarily heavy.
And then there’s the lost books of history. The whole series is named after these books, and yet they become nothing. What was the purpose of these books? The last two books took a turn that went downhill for me. The first five books were really interesting and I loved the ending. But then the entire purpose of these lost books was lost when they arrived back in Middle.
And nothing frustrates me more than Johnis’s entire arc. Darsal is the one who saves everyone. It was her who brought everyone to all seven of the lost books where they all vanished to the other world. It was her who spent ten long grueling years on earth. It was her who spent that decade with the vilest of evil creatures and who actually found the greater good in the end. It was her actions and morals that saved everyone from evil on earth. It was her with the famous hero arc. Not Johnis. Never Johnis. He was always there to make rash decisions because he was “following his heart”. He treated Silvie like she was beneath him (and everyone else for that matter), and he never got over his big “you must follow me to Hell and back because me big hero” ego. AND THEN, when all three of them return to Middle, it was Darsal who drowned first. Darsal who got the message from Elyon, “love the Horde for me, for Johnis.” And she did! It was her the whole time, in all six of these books, it was Darsal who saved everyone. Not Johnis. Johnis got himself possessed by a vampire. Where did this heart of his go now? Silvie was the only one with any sense to question the hallucinations of a mysterious hypnotic woman. Ugh. I’m sorry, but this final book really frustrates me. Nothing was resolved.
We never got to meet another circle member like Thomas or any of their family, we don’t even know where they were hiding this whole time. What happened to Thomas? What happens to the Leedhans? And how many of these vampires are there anyway?
And don’t get me started on Darsal and Marak’s romance. It was similar to Johnis and Silvie where there was no lead up to the romance or even reason besides the fact that Dekker is telling us that they are romantically invested now. This is where show don’t tell is so important. People don’t just fall in love with people they find repulsive and can’t stand the smell of. Marak had no redeeming qualities. He was a mean old man who killed his family including his supposed love of his life, Rona. There needed to be more character development here.
At least Darsal was cool.
I can’t really recommend this book when I’m so frustrated by it, but at the same time, it is the final book in a decent series. Read at your own risk and don’t expect a grand ending.
3 stars for entertainment
3 stars for impact
3 stars for writing
2 stars for pace/organization
2 stars recommendation
=2.6 stars.