In the third instalment of Sheryl and her daughter Carrie Berk's The Cupcake Club series, in Winner Bakes All (published in 2013 and with Kylie Carson, Lexi Poole, Jenna Medina and Sadie Harris like in the second novel, like in Recipe for Trouble being in grade five), the featured story takes place in the winter (hence a destructive snowstorm) and specifically focuses on Sadie, who is tall, really good at basketball but is also dyslexic (and who in Winner Bakes All is suddenly severely struggling with mathematics as well and that there is equally much tension between Sadie's parents because of financial issues, due to Sadie's father not getting enough clients for his contracting business). And yes, I do very much appreciate that while Peace, Love and Cupcakes (which is what Kylie, Lexi, Jenna and Sadie call their baking club and cupcake catering business) and the four friends making and selling cupcakes from scratch are always front and centre in what the Berks are textually presenting in their series (at least thus far I should say), there are also other issues covered and presented in the Cupcake Club novels (such as for Winner Bakes All, Sadie Harris' struggles with math and her parents' finances based marital problems, that Sadie and her older brothers are worried that their parents are arguing a lot and might therefore be getting divorced).
Now with regard to the four girls' cupcake baking business, while I still think that for a bunch of grade fives, that for a group of elementary school girls, the sheer amount of cupcakes Kylie Carson, Lexi Poole, Jenna Medina and Sadie Harris are constantly baking and selling is a trifle unrealistic, I am glad that in Winner Bakes All, there are also now some financial concerns etc. cropping up (that of course and naturally, if Mr. Ludwig's shop is closed because its roof caved in during that snowstorm, he thus not being able to buy and sell the girls' cupcakes will of course also negatively be affecting them, and yes, that sometimes one has to deal with nasty, entitled and downright impossible clients). But just to say that I also find it quite cheering and refreshing that when Kylie, Lexi, Jenna and Sadie have the chance to be on a TV show for a cupcake baking competition against some big names in the business, they do not automatically get shown by Sheryl and Carrie Berk as winning the top prize (but receive honourable mention and as such a five-hundred dollar consolation prize), although I must admit that the baking competition scenes in Winner Bakes All are a bit over the top and almost inadvertently parodistic for me, and that the fake and exaggerated accent for Fiero kind of makes me personally cringe a bit (although just a bit and I do wonder if I might be overreacting a trifle here).
Three stars in general for Winner Bakes All, recommended and likely fun for young middle grade readers (and in particular girls) from about the age of eight to eleven or so (and of course that I do continue to appreciate how in The Cupcake Club series, the recipes for the featured cupcakes are always included), but that yes, neither the story nor the characters for Winner Bakes All are all that developed (and that this will likely continue with the rest of the The Cupcake Club series). However, because I indeed totally and hugely struggled with mathematics at school, I personally speaking have not only found reading about Sadie Harris' math issues totally relatable, I also really textually adore that Sheryl and Carrie Berk have both Sadie's cupcake baking friends and also her math teacher be nicely helpful and supportive (and not to mention that Sadie's family is for the most part also not negative but positive and encouraging), and that therefore, I am going to up my rating for Winner Bakes All from three to four stars (and that Winner Bakes All is to date also my favourite of The Cupcake Club series).