Overall a good read. Perhaps not for me as I never felt particularly invested in the characters. But the book itself was well thought out, very detailed and you can see a lot of hard work went into its construction. Though it often felt like dry reading and was too wordy at times.
The male lead was irritatingly dismissive and judgmental of the female spy at the start. Without due cause. They both acted rather immature in their first reactions to each other. Yet neither had done anything to warrant the other putting his back up.
You would think no one could take offense within mere minutes of a first time meeting, especially when introduced through a trusted friend, but it was set up in that "Let's hate each other passionately for no discernible reason!" way, perhaps to have conflict.
The lead female, Sophie was also trying a little too hard to seem"cool" I guess we would say in modern parlance. She didn't really seem very comfortable in her own skin. And the emphasis the author placed on her not being a lady by birth meant we spent a lot of time with her hang-ups about this fact.
A lot of effort was put into describing surroundings unnecessarily. It's kind of hard for me to pinpoint exactly what I mean when I talk about too much focus on triviality but I suppose this passage below shows it a little with all the rigamarole around some hot water.
Did water really have to feature that prominently that it's mentioned three or so times in a passage? It's water. Move on, a one sentence mention would do.
Excerpt-
“In her most ladylike way, she ordered the best room, and insisted the hot water be brought up as soon as possible. Bruce had stayed with Jem to see that the coach was indeed fit to travel the next day.
Sophie was shown to a large, bright room. The water was heated and brought up with remarkable efficiency by the innkeeper’s children. Sophie hoped it wouldn’t cool too quickly.
Fortunately, Bruce came in then, worn down by the effort of final repairs to the carriage. “Good news,” he said. “There’s only minor damage. Jem will handle the rest of it, and we can continue on in the morning as scheduled.”
“I ordered you some hot water,” Sophie said, pointing to the pitcher and basin.”
This is a really minor quibble and it was probably only noticeable in conjunction with other things but I kind of almost wanted to throw the water in someone's face. Lol
I guess it also has to do with how used to the genre you are. For someone reading a historical romance for the first time these details are perhaps interesting and helpful in constructing an accurate impression of the norms and culture of the time period.
But if you are familiar with it already it becomes a case of too many factoids thrown in randomly and it merely distracts you as a reader. It draws you out of the story.
It's as if the author did a lot of research and wants to include every interesting thing learnt along the way. For example, the fact that society marriages were often cold by virtue of being arranged for dynastic purposes is so generally known that the titbit about wives included below merely causes the scene to lose momentum...
Excerpt-
“Bruce stripped to the waist without so much as a warning. Sophie, a little stunned, watched him as a wife might…though in a society marriage, it was entirely possible that a woman might never see her husband half-naked save for in the darkness of a bedroom. And many proper ladies would never dare look more than they absolutely had to.”
Or even just the fact that upper servants go by their last names which can be shown not told to the reader-
Excerpt-
“My name’s Maggie.”
“And your family name?” Sophie asked. Ladies’ maids were customarily referred to by their surname only.
“Sawyer, ma’am. But I’m not a proper lady’s maid, so Maggie it is.”
------
And sometimes we would leave one character, move over to the POV of the other and have him/her rehash everything that had just happened between them, which can get dull.
Bruce and Sophie took too long to finally like each other, I thought. Quarter of the way through the book they still disliked and distrusted each other and since they had no improved opinions of each other I really didn't like them any more that I had at the start when all I felt was indifference.
It was still an interesting read, with some very insightful dialogue at times. I particularly liked the line about how women move through the world versus the security inherent in being a male. Things men do unthinkingly, such as walking around late at night, going to an unknown party location with a casual male acquaintance, getting into a cab, are things women can't always feel safe doing for practical reasons. Life as a woman might not be as extreme as in the author's example but it's a poignant point Sophie makes.
Excerpt-
“I said I would tell you the very first thing a woman thinks on seeing a man.”
“I give up. Tell me what a woman thinks on seeing a man.”
Sophie said, with deliberate calm, “She thinks, How can he hurt me?”
Bruce stopped what he was doing, the washcloth falling into the basin with a splash. “That’s not true,” he said instantly.
“I promise you it is,” Sophie said. “It is the first thought to cross a woman’s mind, no matter how young or old, rich or poor, powerful or desperate. Maybe not all women even realize they think it—but they do.”
“Honestly?”
Sophie nodded. “She thinks: Can this man hurt me? How much could he hurt me? In what ways could he hurt me? How can I escape? How do I fend him off? How do I survive this?”
Bruce stared at her, his previous task completely forgotten. “Is that what you thought when you first met me in the club?”
She nodded again.
“But Julian vouched for me, did he not?”
“What does that matter?” Sophie asked. “Believe me, all women share the same fear. Only after she asks that question and makes those dozen small decisions can she move on to what you think of as normal thoughts.”
“That’s mad.”
“That’s life for a woman. Understand this, and how can you go about treating half the world in the same way?”
He frowned. “You make me sound like a monster.”
“Not at all. I merely acknowledge you’re a man, and as such have never had to ask yourself the same questions."
*Received a review copy