I'd like to believe that readers recognize greatness, so that all the best books have been preserved and no masterpieces have been lost to the sands of time. But then I look over and see that Michael Cisco, an endlessly inventive writer with an absolute mastery of prose, is so obscure that even most well-read people have never even heard of him. While I've yet to find one of his works that fully clicked with me, the books of his I've read make it obvious that Cisco is so talented that he should be orders of magnitude more popular than he is. The Tyrant is another showcase of that talent.
In a way, Cisco has chosen obscurity. His writing tends to have lots of descriptive prose such that some readers probably find it prolix. Furthermore, and more importantly, his books are incredibly, fascinatingly weird, so weird that some of his strangest works become hard to follow. The Tyrant shows that, if he wanted to, Cisco could write amazing realistic fiction as well. In its opening pages The Tyrant depicts Ella, a teenage prodigy crippled by polio so that she has to use crutches and leg braces, trying to navigate the New York subway system. If you've ever had to use that system, you can imagine the risks someone with braces and crutches faced in the days before things were handicap accessible, and the determination and assertiveness someone would have to have to make it work. It's just a great piece of writing, completely tethered to the real world.
Having proven himself capable of writing realistic situations so well, Cisco wastes no time in revealing the supernatural elements of The Tyrant's setting. The world of this story is a strange one filled with gothic horror, but its most peculiar eccentricities like ectoplasm, alchemy, and other worlds filled with the dead are just another thing to be scientifically analyzed. To its inhabitants it is no more than humdrum reality. This is only the world as it stands at The Tyrant's opening pages, however. As we get deeper into the book the setting gets more and more surreal and over-the-top until by its ending the setting makes Halloween Town from The Nightmare Before Christmas seem tame by comparison.
We explore this world at the side of our protagonist Ella. In the first, more grounded half of the book, wunderkind Ella is conducting research. In the second half she travels the globe, and other places too, in search of the titular Tyrant. As the back of the book blurb reveals, The Tyrant is a love story. While I wish that the book had spent a little more time developing the early stages of the romance, otherwise this love story works well in giving the story structure even as things gets stranger and stranger. I was continually impressed by how Cisco subtly reminded you that Ella, though she seems older because of how she has hardened herself against the world, is still a teenager experiencing her first love. Despite the story's implications I was actually rooting for her by the end, and that’s something that not many books make me do.
I found the setting wonderfully bizarre, the protagonist was a satisfyingly complex character, and the plot actually made me give a damn, and thus The Tyrant is one of my favorite works by Cisco. But it’s only a 3.5 for me for a number of reasons. Primarily, it’s because the book is more than a bit of a slog to get through. I know I said I like Cisco’s prose, and I do, but The Tyrant piles on a huge number of intricately constructed descriptions. Furthermore, developments are often subtle, requiring you to really engage with the text. There are also certain sections that just seem endless. Together these things make the book so dense that it feels more like reading 500 pages rather than the actual page count of 250. Every page read felt like an accomplishment.
Cisco doesn’t make it easy for you either, what with his disregard for common comma usage. He intentionally does not use commas a large portion of the time, which I think is intended to simulate those rushed moments where it feels like you notice ten things all at once instead of grasping a string of distinct observations in an orderly fashion. To make up an example, compare the sentence “I was at the grocery store and saw fresh apples, pears, and oranges” to the sentence “suddenly the fruit truck flipped over and an avalanche of apples pears oranges bore down on me.” Cisco uses the latter type of sentence throughout The Tyrant. Though he obviously did it for effect, and though it’s intellectually interesting, it makes an already slow book even harder to read and so I wish he hadn’t.
I always feel like Cisco writes exactly how & what he intends to write, and that’s not a feeling I often get from an author. This is not the most accessible of the books I’ve read by Cisco (The Traitor) and it’s not the best example of his unique style (probably The Divinity Student), but overall I think The Tyrant was my favorite of his works so far. I give it a 3.5, and just barely decided against rounding up. I’m going to keep reading Cisco, and once I find the work of his that I really click with I know I’m going to love it.
Edit, four years later: Since finishing The Tyrant I haven't read as much Cisco as I expected to because, as this review touched on, his works aren't exactly the easiest to get through. A silver lining to this, though, is that once you've finished a Cisco book the difficulty of getting from one page to the next fades, while the strength of the work as a whole stays sharper. Thus, while I know intellectually that The Tyrant was a bit of a slog, in my heart I remember it as a well-written and absolutely batshit crazy love story, as well as my favorite of the Cisco books I've read so far. Accordingly, I'm bumping this one up to a 4/5. It's not an easy book (basically none of Cisco's works are), but to me it's worth it.