3.5 stars.
This small book by a French Jesuit theologian, out 1883 and here with three appendixes added in 1989, concentrates on showing how much avoiding Hell is worth it. I don’t think it will convince any non-believer or unsure to change their minds, so thatwise it’s not a successful tool, but it still has some interesting stories of various ways people have been visited by the dead-in-Hell, have become convinced to change their ways by thoughts of Hell or being temporarily dead, and so on.
Stories are told: saints and ordinary people (some sinners, some not) have been visited by the dead, or have witnessed a recently-dead person come briefly alive to deliver a message, or witness those who have been believed to be dead come back alive to tell about it, or a dying person experiences hell-pains while dying. Or people see or are shown visions of Hell. Sometimes it is the story of a person themselves briefly dying (coma?), or being buried-as-dead but saved from the grave by their knockings.
The ones who have died can be sinners, or delayers of baptism or confession (sometimes have given insincere confessions), atheists, and those who outwardly seemed pious but hid a sin or two.
There’s stories of sights of Hell, the ‘always, always’’never, never’ shouts, the shouting of regrets of having so easily given up a road to salvation. Sometimes just contemplation of a fireplace, or intense thoughts of Hell have inspired seeking of goodness, penance, and austerities trying to avoid it (here the story of Christina The Astonishing is given, and all her crazy ways of penance and austerities, and living in trees etc. The Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds song about her is pretty good, too.). There were also a few stories of destruction by fire of buildings and some train accidents from the 19th century – so many charred bodies piled up, of bodies perishing in water (ships, trains, crumbling buildings), and the most heartbreaking one was of a circus fire with animals trapped in cages, nowhere to go… the suffering of animals-stories always give me the ‘want to unread’ moment, and a reason to drop half a star from my rating, at *least*.
The main part of the book ends quite suddenly, which also can be seen as a small weakness; I guess the author thought a smooth ending wasn’t necessary, so I’m a bit glad that the appendixes were added. Of the appendixes, Sr Josefa Menendez’ Hell-description were quite spooky, the Fatima story was familiar to me (but poor kids must’ve been so terrified after what they saw), and the rich man and Lazarus story and someone’s reflections on it was probably the weakest appendix of the three, but a little meditation on the story might be worth it for the reader.
So: the book may have its weaknesses, but most of the time I felt there were few dull spots in the stories.