What do you think?
Rate this book
Stalin’s Nose: Across the Face of Europe
Winston the pig fell into Aunt Zita's life when he dropped onto her husband's head and killed him dead. It was a distressing end to a distinguished life of spying for the U.S.S.R. After the funeral Zita, a faded Austrian aristocrat and vivacious eccentric, refuses to remain at home in East Germany. Instead she hijacks her nephew Rory and, with Winston in tow, sets out on one last ride. Austrians have extended families, their lineage is Europe's history and Zita has decided to rediscover hers. In a rattling Trabant the threesome puff and wheeze across the continent, following the threads of memory Zita's remarkable east European relations - the angel of Prague, the Hungarian grave digger who had buried Stalin's nose, a dying Romanian propagandist - help tie together the loose ends of her life. The travelers picnic at Auschwitz. They meet Lenin's embalmer. They visit the impoverished Czech town where the sewers run with jewels. Everywhere they learn what life had truly been like under totalitarian rule. They hear a torrent of life tales, some heartbreaking, some hilarious, all enriched with the joy of telling after decades of enforced silence. Humorous and black, touched with the surreal and the farcical, Stalin's Nose is a true and exceptionally vivid story of a journey from the Baltic to the Black Sea, between Berlin and Moscow, through an eastern Europe divested of fear and free to face the past.
236 pages, Kindle Edition
First published January 1, 1992
18 people are currently reading
233 people want to read
About the author
Rory MacLean
29 books66 followersCanadian Rory MacLean is one of Britain's most expressive and adventurous travel writers. His twelve books include the UK top tens Stalin's Nose and Under the Dragon as well as Berlin: Imagine a City, a book of the year and 'the most extraordinary work of history I've ever read' according to the Washington Post. He has won awards from the Canada Council and Arts Council of England and was nominated for the International IMPAC Dublin Literary prize. His works – according to the late John Fowles – are among those that 'marvellously explain why literature still lives'. A Fellow of the Royal Society of Literature, he divides his time between the UK, Berlin and Toronto.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 38 reviews
March 7, 2013
I am informed that this is "travel writing" and in his preface Colin Thubron tells me that this an innovative piece of travel literature breaking new ground by being a blend of fiction and fact.... Excuse me.... am I missing something here? This is a work of fiction in which the hero, his aunt and her pig travel through Eastern Europe at the time of the great changes that took place when the Berlin Wall came down. So it's fiction set in a real time and real places... Doesn't a lot of literature fall into this category?
So it's a story and once you realise that this isn't really a piece of travel writing, since there are very few bits where we get a description of the place, then what you find you have is a very amusing story with a fascinating cast of dysfunctional and woe-begotten characters. Our hero (we never learn his name but it sure as hell ISN'T Rory) gets a call from his rather domineering Aunt Zita to inform him that his Uncle Peter (a former key player in the Soviet takeover of the Eastern Block) has been killed by his pet pig, Winston, who fell on him. Apparently this wouldn't have happened if they hadn't taken the wall down in the first place. Winston has run off with Zita's dentures and mislaid them but you can, apparently get good replacements in Budapest! Zita then railroads her nephew into a road trip visiting friends and relatives on the way. Many of these friends and relatives turn out to be former Communists or collaborators - or just plain dysfunctional individuals, beginning to adjust to a post-Communist world itself adjusting to new, as yet undetermined, circumstances.
The whole is a genuinely amusing but also thought-provoking story. Whist MacLean doesn't spend a great deal of time describing places he does give us a sort of superficial snapshot of the great changes taking place by concentrating on his characters. In Czechoslovakia the remains of dead heroes, secretly buried, are being disinterred, as is the real history of the Communist era. In Hungary adjustments are also taking place in an atmosphere of revelation. Poland is seen as heavy with history and the spirit of resistance, whilst Romania is just the same old story but with different labels. Russia is entering the era of the great disillusion. Poverty abounds, alcohol flows. Somewhere in there one can hear the greasing of palms.
MacLean does a super job of helping us see that process of change, coming to terms with the truth, expressing resentment or relief and, of course, survival. Reading this is like entering the dark ages of Modern History and there are very few books that I know of that bring this brief period to life (I'm thinking here of that other great bit of writing, Anne Applebaum's "Between East and West: Across the Borderlands of Europe").
...And it's amusing as well as serious. My hero is Winston, the pig. He sleeps his way across this era of change sleeping in the back of the Trabant, drinking beer and occasionally causing mayhem - I bet he's a Polish pig! Good old Winston.
So it's a story and once you realise that this isn't really a piece of travel writing, since there are very few bits where we get a description of the place, then what you find you have is a very amusing story with a fascinating cast of dysfunctional and woe-begotten characters. Our hero (we never learn his name but it sure as hell ISN'T Rory) gets a call from his rather domineering Aunt Zita to inform him that his Uncle Peter (a former key player in the Soviet takeover of the Eastern Block) has been killed by his pet pig, Winston, who fell on him. Apparently this wouldn't have happened if they hadn't taken the wall down in the first place. Winston has run off with Zita's dentures and mislaid them but you can, apparently get good replacements in Budapest! Zita then railroads her nephew into a road trip visiting friends and relatives on the way. Many of these friends and relatives turn out to be former Communists or collaborators - or just plain dysfunctional individuals, beginning to adjust to a post-Communist world itself adjusting to new, as yet undetermined, circumstances.
The whole is a genuinely amusing but also thought-provoking story. Whist MacLean doesn't spend a great deal of time describing places he does give us a sort of superficial snapshot of the great changes taking place by concentrating on his characters. In Czechoslovakia the remains of dead heroes, secretly buried, are being disinterred, as is the real history of the Communist era. In Hungary adjustments are also taking place in an atmosphere of revelation. Poland is seen as heavy with history and the spirit of resistance, whilst Romania is just the same old story but with different labels. Russia is entering the era of the great disillusion. Poverty abounds, alcohol flows. Somewhere in there one can hear the greasing of palms.
MacLean does a super job of helping us see that process of change, coming to terms with the truth, expressing resentment or relief and, of course, survival. Reading this is like entering the dark ages of Modern History and there are very few books that I know of that bring this brief period to life (I'm thinking here of that other great bit of writing, Anne Applebaum's "Between East and West: Across the Borderlands of Europe").
...And it's amusing as well as serious. My hero is Winston, the pig. He sleeps his way across this era of change sleeping in the back of the Trabant, drinking beer and occasionally causing mayhem - I bet he's a Polish pig! Good old Winston.
October 12, 2014
With the big praise on the cover (John Le Carre, William Dalrymple, Jan Morris, The Times etc) I guess I expected more. Fictionalised travel - ie a story woven into characters in the cities and towns along the route of travel - rather than actual travel.
Not sure it was for me.
Not sure it was for me.
June 10, 2020
A wonderful time capsule of life in Eastern Europe in 1990, shortly after the Wall came down. I enjoyed how the author focused on ordinary people with interesting pasts. Not too heavy though the prose on occasion was a bit pretentious for me. I am intrigued to read his other books though.
November 10, 2016
I have had this book on my bookshelf for sometime and have been looking forward to getting started on it. It should have been really good, It is the story of the author and his aunt from West Berlin. In the aftermath of the fall of the wall they set off on a road trip in an old Trabant. En route they meet lots of long lost relatives a friends who tell their stories. A perfect recipe. I expected to find this informative, funny and very readable, However I found the writing style very cumbersome and a little irritating. I gave up afte 3 chapters.
September 10, 2012
loving this so far. Loved it.
Here is the author. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PvjMAD...
Here is the author. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PvjMAD...
January 16, 2025
This book tells the story of a man who travels through Eastern Europe with his aunt and their pig during the dramatic and historic fall of the Berlin Wall. The narrative is set against real historical events, but there’s no clear indication that the story is based on true events. Despite its cultural focus, the book is surprisingly thought-provoking and offers much more than I expected. It’s not just a historical retelling; it’s a deep dive into the human side of history and the personal impact of political change.
As someone who didn’t know much about communism before reading this, the book gave me a completely new perspective on the history surrounding the fall of the Iron Curtain. It explores how different Eastern European countries dealt with the pressures and impacts of Stalin’s rule and the aftermath of that era. The way it describes the lasting effects on people’s lives—like the alcoholism in Hungary and the cultural trauma in various parts of Eastern Europe—was eye-opening and sometimes pretty shocking. I was particularly moved by one quote: “In Asia it’s tigers, in America monsters, but in Eastern Europe children fear bears under their beds. ‘I’d lie between the sheets knowing they were there. Knowing that I couldn’t sleep until I looked. Knowing that the moment I did they would take me,’ as they had taken her parents in 1968 when they came in tanks.” That quote stuck with me, especially when it’s told from the perspective of a child who fears these "bears" in a very real way. The idea of a child lying awake, knowing that fear could turn into reality, made the story much more personal and frightening than I expected.
What I enjoyed most about this book, though, was the way it was written. The journey is told like a personal journal, which made it feel so much more intimate and real. Instead of just reading a story about a man and his aunt, I felt like I was experiencing it with them, almost like I was getting a glimpse into their actual lives. This kind of storytelling always hooks me, and it was easy to get lost in the narrative because it felt like a real, lived experience rather than a traditional novel. It made the emotional moments hit harder and the historical context feel more alive.
I think this book would really appeal to people interested in learning more about the social and cultural history of Eastern Europe during and after Stalin’s reign. It’s not just a history book; it’s a look at how people were affected by political forces, how they lived under communism, and how those experiences shaped their lives long after the fall of the Iron Curtain. Even though it’s about a specific period in history, the book’s themes about fear, survival, and the impact of totalitarianism feel universal.
If you're someone who wants to sound more informed in conversations about the fall of the Iron Curtain—or just want to understand it from a more personal, human perspective—this book is a great way to start. It’s one thing to learn the facts and events, but this book helps you see it through the eyes of people who lived through it. It’s not just a way to sound smart in discussions, but a way to truly understand and empathize with the experiences of those who lived through such a monumental moment in history.
As someone who didn’t know much about communism before reading this, the book gave me a completely new perspective on the history surrounding the fall of the Iron Curtain. It explores how different Eastern European countries dealt with the pressures and impacts of Stalin’s rule and the aftermath of that era. The way it describes the lasting effects on people’s lives—like the alcoholism in Hungary and the cultural trauma in various parts of Eastern Europe—was eye-opening and sometimes pretty shocking. I was particularly moved by one quote: “In Asia it’s tigers, in America monsters, but in Eastern Europe children fear bears under their beds. ‘I’d lie between the sheets knowing they were there. Knowing that I couldn’t sleep until I looked. Knowing that the moment I did they would take me,’ as they had taken her parents in 1968 when they came in tanks.” That quote stuck with me, especially when it’s told from the perspective of a child who fears these "bears" in a very real way. The idea of a child lying awake, knowing that fear could turn into reality, made the story much more personal and frightening than I expected.
What I enjoyed most about this book, though, was the way it was written. The journey is told like a personal journal, which made it feel so much more intimate and real. Instead of just reading a story about a man and his aunt, I felt like I was experiencing it with them, almost like I was getting a glimpse into their actual lives. This kind of storytelling always hooks me, and it was easy to get lost in the narrative because it felt like a real, lived experience rather than a traditional novel. It made the emotional moments hit harder and the historical context feel more alive.
I think this book would really appeal to people interested in learning more about the social and cultural history of Eastern Europe during and after Stalin’s reign. It’s not just a history book; it’s a look at how people were affected by political forces, how they lived under communism, and how those experiences shaped their lives long after the fall of the Iron Curtain. Even though it’s about a specific period in history, the book’s themes about fear, survival, and the impact of totalitarianism feel universal.
If you're someone who wants to sound more informed in conversations about the fall of the Iron Curtain—or just want to understand it from a more personal, human perspective—this book is a great way to start. It’s one thing to learn the facts and events, but this book helps you see it through the eyes of people who lived through it. It’s not just a way to sound smart in discussions, but a way to truly understand and empathize with the experiences of those who lived through such a monumental moment in history.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
June 15, 2024
Travelogue or novel? I think the latter but, for all that, this is a really enjoyable yarn that recounts a journey from the Baltic to the Black Sea by an English writer and his eccentric Aunt, her pig - which just happened to have fallen out of a tree and killed her husband - and a few characters that they meet along the way.
Set shortly after the break up of the Soviet Union, the story successfully intertwines vignettes of historical and political interest that provide a sometimes chilling reminder of the way in which countries and their people were subjected to horrendous treatment at the hands of, in turn, the Nazis and the Soviets, and often their own political leaders, none more so than the Poles.
Whether fact of fiction, this is an entertaining vehicle for some really fascinating and entertaining tales, which I thoroughly enjoyed.
Set shortly after the break up of the Soviet Union, the story successfully intertwines vignettes of historical and political interest that provide a sometimes chilling reminder of the way in which countries and their people were subjected to horrendous treatment at the hands of, in turn, the Nazis and the Soviets, and often their own political leaders, none more so than the Poles.
Whether fact of fiction, this is an entertaining vehicle for some really fascinating and entertaining tales, which I thoroughly enjoyed.
January 1, 2021
I read this after having read Pravda Ha Ha, which was written as a sort of sequel 30 years later. Like Pravda Haha he travels around Eastern Europe, only this time in an old Trabant just after the fall of the Berlin Wall accompanied by his elderly aunt Zita, Winston the pig and an assortment of others.
It paints an intriguing picture of post-communist Eastern Europe with the added twist that his family were once Habsburg royalty and sat on both sides of the fence during the totalitarian C20th. His uncle Oto signed up to be a Nazi SS guard at Auschwitz and his aunt married a Russian KGB agent. Not the sort of family one typically fesses up to!
It’s difficult to know how much of what he writes can be believed but it makes for a good read
It paints an intriguing picture of post-communist Eastern Europe with the added twist that his family were once Habsburg royalty and sat on both sides of the fence during the totalitarian C20th. His uncle Oto signed up to be a Nazi SS guard at Auschwitz and his aunt married a Russian KGB agent. Not the sort of family one typically fesses up to!
It’s difficult to know how much of what he writes can be believed but it makes for a good read
March 23, 2022
Canadian author Rory Maclean travels Eastern Europe in 1990 - as the Soviet control and Iron Curtain have recently fallen - with his aunt, who by any calculation I can make, cannot be his aunt. The family of the aunt are discussed throughout the book, but never the connection to the author himself, who is referred to as her nephew, nor his parents, who were a Scottish-Canadian newspaper man and publisher and an English secretary (per Wikipedia and genealogy sites). I really wonder how much of this is complete fiction and the sketchy relationship kind of ruined it for me. If it was presented as fiction, great, but since it was not, I feel deceived.
There were some lovely sections describing the former Soviet Bloc countries, their people, and history.
There were some lovely sections describing the former Soviet Bloc countries, their people, and history.
July 19, 2025
This book manages to be both hysterically funny & tragic all at once. I imagine a lot of people might be put off by the fact that it's more of a series of "sketches" than a straightforward story. I think if you accept that early on, it's very enjoyable. I certainly learned a lot about Eastern Europe. More importantly this book teaches a ton of history while also making the reader ponder the nature of societal evil - as the book asks many times "Who is responsible for all the deaths? All the evil that is perpetuated out of fear?" I do wish there had been a character index bc sometimes it was hard to keep track of who was who, but again, with this being more of a series of sketches, frankly it doesn't matter that much. That's really my only criticism.
January 9, 2020
A strange but generally enjoyable read. There is some terrible grammar, which to me detracts from the pleasure of reading a book and makes me wonder what the editors were doing. The story is, frankly, often baffling though usually very amusing. I did find that I frequently lost track of what was happening, and there are definitely a lot of rather random sentences scattered through the text of which it's hard to make sense. But overall I thought it was mostly good fun, though it has a pronounced dark side too.
February 14, 2022
Such a good read! This short book manages to pack in so much about the history of 20th century Central Europe all through the prism of the author's family. It is fascinating, funny and absolutely heartbreaking. It deals with the themes of family, guilt culpability and expediency and has a most excellent pig as one of the protagonists. My only quibble is that we don't get to know what happened to Winston. You could never play family histoty Top Trumps with Rory MacLean, he would win every time in all categories!
October 10, 2020
A brilliant travel guide, a chilling history, a collection of heartfelt memoirs, a dire political warning, and an epitaph to a socialist world - told by those who lived it, believed it, were ground to dust by it, and came to regret it. This is by far one of the best books of recent memory. Eastern Europe comes alive, too frighteningly well, in the pages of this most lovely travel diary. People flirting with today’s version of socialism would be wise to hear the thoughts of those who lived it.
May 7, 2018
Amusing journey around a revival Eastern Europe
Witty, wry and slightly wonderful, this tale captures the essence of a Europe liberated from a decomposed Communism but haunted by its past. Well-known written, sometimes funny but sometimes sad, this novel is an enchanting look at the beginning of change.
Witty, wry and slightly wonderful, this tale captures the essence of a Europe liberated from a decomposed Communism but haunted by its past. Well-known written, sometimes funny but sometimes sad, this novel is an enchanting look at the beginning of change.
August 14, 2020
Clever, informative and black-humored account of a journey across central and eastern Europe. A detailed exploration of the impact of the historical upheavals of the twentieth century on the countries and their people. Cleverly and wittily presented through the eyes of the author's relatives encountered en route, Oh and Winston, the pig...
December 10, 2024
For me, this book fell into an unappealing place where it wasn't plausible or concrete enough to satisfy me as a nonfiction travel narrative, but also wasn't sufficiently expressive or subtle to succeed as a novel. The prose was admirable, but after a while I just wanted the journey to end.
July 30, 2017
After about 20 boring pages, I've given up. It sounds very interesting, but it just isn't compelling enough. It was not enjoyable to read...so I put it down. Which is hard for me.
November 9, 2020
Lost its momentum towards the end.
December 18, 2024
I enjoyed this crazy drive round eastern europe.
October 22, 2025
A weirdly entertaining book, but not a great story. Love the travel part and the map at the back showing the full journey.
January 8, 2025
This is a weird book. The topic is interesting, the treatment dubious, the characters remain without much character.
March 21, 2013
Rory MacLean's 1992 travels around the Eastern Bloc,hot on the tailwind of the momentous events of 1989 & the 'fall of the wall' & 'the drawing-back of the iron curtain' make an engrossing,entertaining & often black-humourous tour of the darkest areas of the horrific Communist(whatever that meant!) Eastern Bloc.
From its opening chapter,where the ex-KGB agent,Peter,is killed(off-screen,as it were)by a falling pig,Winston (he was in a tree!) the tone of black satire is set.Rory MacLean,the narrator,& his Aunt Zita (Peter's lovelorn widow) & her pet pig are bundled-up in a state-of-the-art Trabant on a journey,ostensibly, to Budapest for quality dental treatment.But as we follow them through Germany,Czechoslovakia,Hungary & on to Romania,we are in for a potent rough-ride mix of history,ancient & modern; of politics,communist & fascist; of culture,medieval & pseudo-modern (artificially created by state apparatchiks); and of real human tragedies,dealt with in a truly memorable way.(The Jewish cemetery-keeper who is the only Jew still remaining in his town to bury,as all the other Jews were murdered or driven-away during the Holocaust). Each of the countries travered,(now nominally 'free'), bleed their tragic histories all over MacLean's deadpan(but often morbidly amusing) recitation of cruelty,intolerance & mass-murder,under the malign influence of Lenin & Stalin,(whose nose appears briefly!)& the Soviet Union.Many of the characters that MacLean delineates in a few dozen words will remain in your memory,I assure you!
I would recommend this book to any reader with more than a passing interest in Eastern Europe.I learned more about the history of geographically ill-favoured Poland,the tragic fate of brave Hungarians in 1956,& the abject state of hopeless Romania than I had previously garnered from any number of BBC documentaries & reports in the apologist left-wing press.The whole Communist Bloc was a monstrsity,an inhumane experiment in political cynicism,a blot on European history....I could go on!
Read this book,& learn; There but for the grace...
From its opening chapter,where the ex-KGB agent,Peter,is killed(off-screen,as it were)by a falling pig,Winston (he was in a tree!) the tone of black satire is set.Rory MacLean,the narrator,& his Aunt Zita (Peter's lovelorn widow) & her pet pig are bundled-up in a state-of-the-art Trabant on a journey,ostensibly, to Budapest for quality dental treatment.But as we follow them through Germany,Czechoslovakia,Hungary & on to Romania,we are in for a potent rough-ride mix of history,ancient & modern; of politics,communist & fascist; of culture,medieval & pseudo-modern (artificially created by state apparatchiks); and of real human tragedies,dealt with in a truly memorable way.(The Jewish cemetery-keeper who is the only Jew still remaining in his town to bury,as all the other Jews were murdered or driven-away during the Holocaust). Each of the countries travered,(now nominally 'free'), bleed their tragic histories all over MacLean's deadpan(but often morbidly amusing) recitation of cruelty,intolerance & mass-murder,under the malign influence of Lenin & Stalin,(whose nose appears briefly!)& the Soviet Union.Many of the characters that MacLean delineates in a few dozen words will remain in your memory,I assure you!
I would recommend this book to any reader with more than a passing interest in Eastern Europe.I learned more about the history of geographically ill-favoured Poland,the tragic fate of brave Hungarians in 1956,& the abject state of hopeless Romania than I had previously garnered from any number of BBC documentaries & reports in the apologist left-wing press.The whole Communist Bloc was a monstrsity,an inhumane experiment in political cynicism,a blot on European history....I could go on!
Read this book,& learn; There but for the grace...
February 24, 2013
In his preface to the 2009 edition Colin Thubron suggests that Rory Maclean may have strayed from the factual into the realms of the surreal and fantastic in his journal of a road/rail trip through the Central/Eastern Europe of the early 90s. As someone who personallyt spent as much of the 90s as I could travelling in the same region I can only assume That Mr Thubron never travelled there during that period or if he did he did so in a cocoon or with his eyes closed. There was something unique in the quirkiness and bizzareness of the region at that time emerging as it was from one social system into one under unrelenting attack of a neo-colonial, neo-liberal system which the fresh born peoples of the region had no time to prepare themselves fior and which ensured that no experimenting with alternative possible social systems could possibly derail the return of the region to the fold of the west. Maclean captures perfectly a period of upheaval, tradgedy, misery and joy. He shows almost by accident how populations are generally little more than flotsam tossed about on a political sea in which they sinply try to survivie, reproduce and die happy as "isms" pull and push peoples and families together and apart. The only creature to emerge clean from the book is Winston the pig and that is with a minor charge of accidental manslaughter against him. I for one have no trouble accepting every word as gospel. I read this book following some of Macleans journey and even now some twenty years on it is nice to see the surrealism that makes this part of Europe so special is clinging on in the face of the gloablisation of blandness.
October 27, 2013
This was the first piece of travel writing I've read, and it took me quite a while to adjust to its style, especially in how it played with fact and fiction. I was not expecting it and quite a few times I would forget that I wasn't reading a novel, because, for me, it really did read like fiction.
I really liked the idea behind the book- taking a journey 'of memory' across Eastern Europe, and it's very telling of the immediate post-communist moment in Europe, however, while I was actually reading it I found it hard to get in to and quite hard to follow.
I particularly enjoyed reading about Zita, especially in how she tries to (or fails to) come to terms with her past, which becomes more difficult for her as the book progresses and it is frequently brought to bear on her present. However, the final 'conclusion' of the book of collective guilt, I'm not entirely sure how I feel about. I definitely think there is a responsibility to memory of the past (and particularly of difficult moments in history). There is a responsibility to remember, and also to be critical about how we remember such moments, but whether you can say someone born (after world war ii, for example) can be said to be 'collectively responsible' for what happened in that time, I'm more unsure about. I mean these questions don't have simple answers, and I'm not sure they're even answerable questions anyway, but I suppose this book was good in putting these ideas forward for reflection.
Overall then, I really liked the concept of this book, and the issues and questions it bought up are useful to reflect upon, however, as an actual reading experience, I enjoyed it much less.
I really liked the idea behind the book- taking a journey 'of memory' across Eastern Europe, and it's very telling of the immediate post-communist moment in Europe, however, while I was actually reading it I found it hard to get in to and quite hard to follow.
I particularly enjoyed reading about Zita, especially in how she tries to (or fails to) come to terms with her past, which becomes more difficult for her as the book progresses and it is frequently brought to bear on her present. However, the final 'conclusion' of the book of collective guilt, I'm not entirely sure how I feel about. I definitely think there is a responsibility to memory of the past (and particularly of difficult moments in history). There is a responsibility to remember, and also to be critical about how we remember such moments, but whether you can say someone born (after world war ii, for example) can be said to be 'collectively responsible' for what happened in that time, I'm more unsure about. I mean these questions don't have simple answers, and I'm not sure they're even answerable questions anyway, but I suppose this book was good in putting these ideas forward for reflection.
Overall then, I really liked the concept of this book, and the issues and questions it bought up are useful to reflect upon, however, as an actual reading experience, I enjoyed it much less.
March 26, 2015
How do you confront learning a loved ones you knew as a gentle gardener was a bigwig in the KGB? You travel across Eastern Europe with your Aunt Zita, his wife, and her pig dubbed Winston whose fall from a tree broke your uncle's neck. That description of circumstances sets up what becomes a series of surreal encounters with distant family, starting with strapping Zita's estranged sister's husband's coffin to the top of your faulty Trabant and taking it to be buried. The endpapers show their route on a map, a device for which I am a sucker. I enjoyed this book and MacLean's sometimes obscure historical digressions. (Are we talking about a historical figure from 5 centuries ago or the current cousin? You'd only be sure a few pages later.) Some of his metaphors seem heavy-handed when described out of context (for example the fish taken to the shore who sees only what he always saw, his own reflect in a bowl--this as we approached Russia, see page 206) but worked well in his narrative. You learn why it's called Stalin's Nose on page 116, and the fate of said nose on page 164. I'm glad I read this. MacLean has written a new book about Berlin. I'm not sure this helps me decide whether to buy it for myself, which is why I first grabbed. It helps me manage my expectations, but he wrote this 25 years ago. His abrupt ending left me wondering, I'll have to see if I can find out what happened to Zita.
I started this and then set it aside for three weeks.
I started this and then set it aside for three weeks.
August 16, 2014
A very peculiar book indeed. This attempted to combine fiction and fact in order to portray the condition of post-Communism Eastern Europe. The obviously fictional elements such as travelling with a pig seemed to be an attempt to portray the societies as farcical but this didn't really work for me. It would have been better to describe actual experience to illustrate the bizarre and frustrating aspects of life met by the traveller. The result was that MacLean comes across as a poor man's PG Wodehouse.
On the positive side the author did come across as being clued up on Eastern European History so if you are unfamiliar with the region you will learn a fair amount about 20th century events. There were some great moments such as an observation that Austrians have 'perfected the great deception: that Beethoven was an Austrian and Hitler a German. In fact the reverse is true,'
On the whole, however, this wasn't very satisfying. Although in places, such as the section on Dresden the account rang true there was often a lack of telling detail which left me wondering whether the author had visited half of the places he wrote about. If you want to read a good travelogue on the former Eastern Bloc then Vitali Vitaliev's 'Borders Up' is vastly superior, being both wittier and benefiting from an insider's knowledge and understanding.
On the positive side the author did come across as being clued up on Eastern European History so if you are unfamiliar with the region you will learn a fair amount about 20th century events. There were some great moments such as an observation that Austrians have 'perfected the great deception: that Beethoven was an Austrian and Hitler a German. In fact the reverse is true,'
On the whole, however, this wasn't very satisfying. Although in places, such as the section on Dresden the account rang true there was often a lack of telling detail which left me wondering whether the author had visited half of the places he wrote about. If you want to read a good travelogue on the former Eastern Bloc then Vitali Vitaliev's 'Borders Up' is vastly superior, being both wittier and benefiting from an insider's knowledge and understanding.
February 27, 2024
Unique.
I've never read anything quite as singular in a series of connected real-life anecdotes. Rory MacLean must be one of the most underrated writers of nonfiction in the UK.
A masterpiece of dark comedy, this rolling tale also gives the reader deep insights into the European continent, taken at its widest cultural identity. As a study in dialogue alone it's a gem.
There is something of the historical document about this book too.
Written during the fall of Communism, it reflects so much of the messy daily life and suffocating bureaucracy which surely ruled at the time.
(This review was written without the use of AI: more correctly called "plagiarism software.")
I've never read anything quite as singular in a series of connected real-life anecdotes. Rory MacLean must be one of the most underrated writers of nonfiction in the UK.
A masterpiece of dark comedy, this rolling tale also gives the reader deep insights into the European continent, taken at its widest cultural identity. As a study in dialogue alone it's a gem.
There is something of the historical document about this book too.
Written during the fall of Communism, it reflects so much of the messy daily life and suffocating bureaucracy which surely ruled at the time.
(This review was written without the use of AI: more correctly called "plagiarism software.")
March 27, 2010
This book describes a trip taken by the author, his aunt and her pig a few months after the fall of the Berlin Wall. They drive through some of the countries that have just been freed from Communism in her old Trabant.
What started off as a funny book is in fact informative and interesting in the descriptions of life under Soviet influence, and the people who suffered through it, as well as the point of view of his aunt, who had been married to a Communist agent.
Although it has been only 20 years, it seems far away already. This book is a good reminder of our recent history.
What started off as a funny book is in fact informative and interesting in the descriptions of life under Soviet influence, and the people who suffered through it, as well as the point of view of his aunt, who had been married to a Communist agent.
Although it has been only 20 years, it seems far away already. This book is a good reminder of our recent history.
August 1, 2010
This book is a bit dated since the travels in it occur in the 1990s, but it is interesting nevertheless. The author gives the reader some very good insights into how people who lived under the Communist regimes were beginning to make the transition to other forms of government rule. This may sound like a dull book, but it is not dull at all. The asuthor tends to see both the humor in people's thoughts, attitudes and practices as well as the poignant.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 38 reviews