What do you think?
Rate this book
The Pursuit of Victory: The Life and Achievement of Horatio Nelson
The starting point of Roger Knight's magnificent new biography is to explain how Nelson achieved such extraordinary success. Knight places him firmly in the context of the Royal Navy at the time. He analyses Nelson's more obvious qualities, his leadership strengths and his coolness and certainty in battle, and also explores his strategic grasp, the condition of his ships, the skill of his seamen and his relationships with the officers around him - including those who could hardly be called friendly.
This biography takes a cool look at Nelson's status as a hero and demolishes many of the myths that were so carefully established by the early authors, and repeated by their modern successors. Nelson was a shrewd political operator who charmed and impressed political leaders and whose advancement was helped by the relatively weak generation of admirals above him. He was a difficult subordinate, only happy when completely in command, and capable of great ruthlessness. He was flawed, but brilliant - and not to be crossed.
1004 pages, Kindle Edition
First published January 1, 2005
47 people are currently reading
1062 people want to read
About the author
R.J.B. Knight
8 books9 followersRoger John Beckett Knight is one of the leading scholars in the field of 18th century and Napoleonic era British naval history. A former Deputy Director of the National Maritime Museum at Greenwich, he is a Fellow of the Royal Historical Society and has served as a member of the council of both the Society for Nautical Research and the Navy Records Society.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 42 reviews
June 14, 2018
List of Illustrations
List of Charts and Text Illustrations
Note on the Text
Acknowledgements
Introduction
Prologue
--The Pursuit of Victory: The Life and Achievement of Horatio Nelson
Chronology of Nelson's Life
General Chronology: Naval, Military and Political Events
Nelson's Ships: Size, Armament, Complements and a Full Listing of Officers
Biographical Sketches
Glossary
Text and Illustration Permissions
Index
List of Charts and Text Illustrations
Note on the Text
Acknowledgements
Introduction
Prologue
--The Pursuit of Victory: The Life and Achievement of Horatio Nelson
Chronology of Nelson's Life
General Chronology: Naval, Military and Political Events
Nelson's Ships: Size, Armament, Complements and a Full Listing of Officers
Biographical Sketches
Glossary
Text and Illustration Permissions
Index
July 27, 2010
The book is 559 pages with another 180 or so pages of chronology, ship descriptions, glossary, biographical sketches and index. It is crammed to the gills with a very straightforward telling of Nelson’s life based on a massive amount of original material. It is a most admirable and honest biography as the author states his intentions before speculating and only does so when the record implies some ambiguity in interpretation. There is no discernible literary embellishment – all to the good – and the author scrupulously lets Nelson and his contemporaries speak for themselves. What emerges is a picture that few of us would like to see of ourselves and one that few would ever measure up to. Though gullible, vain, grasping and naive, Nelson’s extraordinary focus on victory and glory along with his courage, empathy and compassion made him the hero of his and following ages. Heroic status can be conferred by the luck of the historic draw or of artful tending of the heroic memory and Nelson has been helped by both of these. Knight strips him bare of legend, adulation and idealogical interests and gives us the man, full of contradictions and still worthy of our study.
June 16, 2020
It’s hard to assess a biography like this. It is exceptionally accurate and would undoubtedly serve as a fine source for someone doing research on the Napoleanic Era. On the other hand, it’s plodding and uninspiring and reveals nothing of its subject’s character. And on the other other hand, it was clearly never trying to be anything but the former. So is it fair to judge it based on not doing what it clearly wasn’t trying to do?
A part of why this book is so dry is that it’s mainly based on logs and such, and as a result we get few emotive insights or keen descriptions of events. This is intentional as Knight distrusts most earlier biographies for repeating all sorts of whitewashed and legendary details as facts. This also accounts for why the book often comes across as rather technical.
I would not recommend this to anybody as their first book on naval history. I saw a few reviewers comment on this, but I’m quite confident in my ability to work out new concepts through context and I still found myself lost at times. Naval English is basically a different language and the book makes few concessions to the reader apart from including a glossary in back. But really, I don’t think you can understand this book completely unless you’re familiar with the basics of 18th century naval practices. I often found myself perplexed at why something Knight described was such a revolutionary idea. And I’ve no idea why the Battle of the Nile was such a stunning success, apart from the surprise of it.
As far as its role as a biography, I can’t say I ever really understood Nelson the man. Quotes from towards the end of the book surprised me since Nelson’s character is such a blank. For example:
Wilberforce was England’s key antislavery campaigner (not that Knight tells us that), so what this reveals is that Nelson was quite the militant proslavery racist. No hint of that before. No hint of much of anything before except for three things:
As for the last point there I have no idea what made him so accessible since we’re given no context for what the norm was. I gather inviting junior captains to meals was not common in the Royal Navy? Or was it that he invited more junior officers? Or was he just good company? I dunno.
So while I’d say this book would work well as a reference, I can’t recommend it as a biography or an introduction to a very complex subject. It certainly could have done better than it did, even given its technical focus. Context is what’s lacking. Sometimes I actually felt that I was expected to know the key details of Nelson’s life already so I could understand what he was contradicting and ignoring. As a source it’s likely to impress. It covers his career in detail and has an array of appendices that cover everything from biographical sketches of key players, to a glossary of key terms, to a detailed rundown of his ships and the chronology of his life. If that’s all you want then this book is for you. But it’s not for me.
A part of why this book is so dry is that it’s mainly based on logs and such, and as a result we get few emotive insights or keen descriptions of events. This is intentional as Knight distrusts most earlier biographies for repeating all sorts of whitewashed and legendary details as facts. This also accounts for why the book often comes across as rather technical.
I would not recommend this to anybody as their first book on naval history. I saw a few reviewers comment on this, but I’m quite confident in my ability to work out new concepts through context and I still found myself lost at times. Naval English is basically a different language and the book makes few concessions to the reader apart from including a glossary in back. But really, I don’t think you can understand this book completely unless you’re familiar with the basics of 18th century naval practices. I often found myself perplexed at why something Knight described was such a revolutionary idea. And I’ve no idea why the Battle of the Nile was such a stunning success, apart from the surprise of it.
As far as its role as a biography, I can’t say I ever really understood Nelson the man. Quotes from towards the end of the book surprised me since Nelson’s character is such a blank. For example:
“The damnable and cursed doctrine of Wilberforce and his hypocritical allies; I hope my berth in heaven will be exalted as his, who would certainly cause the murder of all our friends and fellow-subjects in the colonies.”
Wilberforce was England’s key antislavery campaigner (not that Knight tells us that), so what this reveals is that Nelson was quite the militant proslavery racist. No hint of that before. No hint of much of anything before except for three things:
1. He was socially insecure and in awe of royalty.
2. He was extremely confident and aggressive professionally.
3. He was very popular with his men and considered exceptionally accessible.
As for the last point there I have no idea what made him so accessible since we’re given no context for what the norm was. I gather inviting junior captains to meals was not common in the Royal Navy? Or was it that he invited more junior officers? Or was he just good company? I dunno.
So while I’d say this book would work well as a reference, I can’t recommend it as a biography or an introduction to a very complex subject. It certainly could have done better than it did, even given its technical focus. Context is what’s lacking. Sometimes I actually felt that I was expected to know the key details of Nelson’s life already so I could understand what he was contradicting and ignoring. As a source it’s likely to impress. It covers his career in detail and has an array of appendices that cover everything from biographical sketches of key players, to a glossary of key terms, to a detailed rundown of his ships and the chronology of his life. If that’s all you want then this book is for you. But it’s not for me.
June 7, 2013
the book reveals Nelson as a flawed but brilliant individual who, despite, several mistakes and misjudgements gradually rises to become the best leader the Naval forces has ever had. As his career matures and his brilliant victories stack up the story gets more compelling and simultaneously overlaid by his unconventional private life which causes it's own stresses. It would be worth reading for the compelling battle accounts alone as any Englishman/Brit should understand the role that Nelson played in keeping Napoleons European expansion from progressing to our own island and thence to take all our colonies. Destroying the French fleet twice kept Napoleons ambitions in check despite his increasing pan european success. Initially I found it a little too scholarly but then realised the importance of the references as he became a more and more controversial and political figure. I raised my review score from a 4 to a 5 when reading the last third of the book. It greatly helped my broad understanding of the history of the period and would do that for any person whether they come at the book from the sailing-maritime or history-hero-figure angle.
November 30, 2020
I think I must have been like a sailor in Nelson's navy in a past life or something as the amount of love I have for Nelson is weeeeeird, man. No matter what was said of him in this in this book, I finished it like:
(with all that frustrated, simmering disappointment in myself haha)
ANYWAY. This book is a real hefty chonker (the footnotes, biographies and chronology took up about 300 pages on their own at the end) but it felt like a breeze. The author's style isn't the most exciting or brisk, but I loved his use of primary logs and letters. I really like the way it gave the figures a way to talk for themselves. Others have called it 'dry', and yeah, I guess you could say that, but the subject is Nelson, soooo... Saying that though, an interesting subject doesn't always make for an interesting book. The last one I read on Trafalgar was very dry - so it was good to read a real in-depth and engaging one.
I LOVED that this looked at Nelson's legendary image, but was essentially about the real man. He was a brilliant leader, but also the biggest drama queen, often short-tempered, vain, and could be pretty nasty. That's not mentioning the imperialist, colonial overtones of this entire era, which has been discussed and re-discussed over and over (and rightly so). I'm not going to get into that snake pit here as it would take a much longer review, but it's safe to say that Nelson was much more than his pretty portraits (and god, they are pretty) .
To look at some of the more 'glorious' parts of his career, I have to mention the boarding of the Spanish ships at the Battle of St. Vincent, the Battle of the Nile and also, of course, Trafalgar. What an absolute mad lad Nelson was. The sheer audacity of some of his actions - if it was in a fictional novel, it would sound insane; like taking the San Josef and San Nicolas in one crazy manouevre. Clambering up the side of a ship after being shot in the arm (and this is after losing the sight in one eye). His fleet blowing the L'Orient sky high at the Nile. Ploughing straight through the Franco-Spanish line in two divisions, and fighting literally hull to hull.
Plus, he KNEW how to court this popularity. Nelson was like his own walking propaganda. His whole vibe was essentially:
I am utterly fascinated by things like this - people built up as legends and icons by the public, which usually says more about the time period of those building them up than the actual person (in this case, the Victorian era and its values were massive in creating the idea of Nelson). But beneath that icon, there is always more, usually a shaky kind of confidence in theirselves. I loved this quote from Lord St Vincent in the book, even if it doesn't paint Nelson in the best light:
'Poor man! he is devoured with vanity, weakness, and folly; was strung with ribbons, medals etc and yet pretended that he wished to avoid the honours and ceremonies he everywhere met with upon the Road.'
It shows Nelson the icon, Nelson the man, and also how much the public actually did love him. He was such a complex figure, and this book only made me more fascinated in him. So that brings me on to the more negative side of things. I felt so sad for Lady Nelson, Frances. She was really treated badly. Imagine being taken to the theatre by your husband, while the woman he is having an affair with sits the other side of him. Ouch. I do find Lady Hamilton very fascinating though - that was a woman who knew exactly what she was doing, and very cleverly navigated the society of her time, under the restrictions of her gender.
I got the impression that Nelson could also be pretty selfish and hard to reason with sometimes - the epitome of a stubborn, hard-headed man. I cringed sometimes with some of his actions. But that was why this book was good - it didn't gloss over that, and not even Nelson could hide that in his letters. 'But why WHY aren't people paying attention to me? I, I, did that, not them! Did you hear about the time when I...'
(to be fair, they're not all like that, but that's a strong vibe with a lot)
So it's kind of weird that I still came away from this book with a fierce adoration with Nelson. But, like, with a critical eye too, I have to stress that. He might not have been as handsome as his portraits, he was viciously mean sometimes, but there is a certain aura around Nelson that my British heart can't quite tear out of itself. Every history student/historian has a figure that they feel a particularly deep interest in, and Nelson is mine, take it or leave it.
And can we just all appreciate my favourite portrait of Nelson...
(Guy Head really went off with that one)
closely followed by...
and the classic shiny shiny Nelson
Anyway, I loved this book for its subject and its unbiased look at Nelson. I can't wait to go back to the Portsmouth Dockyards now, and see the Victory again.
(with all that frustrated, simmering disappointment in myself haha)
ANYWAY. This book is a real hefty chonker (the footnotes, biographies and chronology took up about 300 pages on their own at the end) but it felt like a breeze. The author's style isn't the most exciting or brisk, but I loved his use of primary logs and letters. I really like the way it gave the figures a way to talk for themselves. Others have called it 'dry', and yeah, I guess you could say that, but the subject is Nelson, soooo... Saying that though, an interesting subject doesn't always make for an interesting book. The last one I read on Trafalgar was very dry - so it was good to read a real in-depth and engaging one.
I LOVED that this looked at Nelson's legendary image, but was essentially about the real man. He was a brilliant leader, but also the biggest drama queen, often short-tempered, vain, and could be pretty nasty. That's not mentioning the imperialist, colonial overtones of this entire era, which has been discussed and re-discussed over and over (and rightly so). I'm not going to get into that snake pit here as it would take a much longer review, but it's safe to say that Nelson was much more than his pretty portraits
To look at some of the more 'glorious' parts of his career, I have to mention the boarding of the Spanish ships at the Battle of St. Vincent, the Battle of the Nile and also, of course, Trafalgar. What an absolute mad lad Nelson was. The sheer audacity of some of his actions - if it was in a fictional novel, it would sound insane; like taking the San Josef and San Nicolas in one crazy manouevre. Clambering up the side of a ship after being shot in the arm (and this is after losing the sight in one eye). His fleet blowing the L'Orient sky high at the Nile. Ploughing straight through the Franco-Spanish line in two divisions, and fighting literally hull to hull.
Plus, he KNEW how to court this popularity. Nelson was like his own walking propaganda. His whole vibe was essentially:
I am utterly fascinated by things like this - people built up as legends and icons by the public, which usually says more about the time period of those building them up than the actual person (in this case, the Victorian era and its values were massive in creating the idea of Nelson). But beneath that icon, there is always more, usually a shaky kind of confidence in theirselves. I loved this quote from Lord St Vincent in the book, even if it doesn't paint Nelson in the best light:
'Poor man! he is devoured with vanity, weakness, and folly; was strung with ribbons, medals etc and yet pretended that he wished to avoid the honours and ceremonies he everywhere met with upon the Road.'
It shows Nelson the icon, Nelson the man, and also how much the public actually did love him. He was such a complex figure, and this book only made me more fascinated in him. So that brings me on to the more negative side of things. I felt so sad for Lady Nelson, Frances. She was really treated badly. Imagine being taken to the theatre by your husband, while the woman he is having an affair with sits the other side of him. Ouch. I do find Lady Hamilton very fascinating though - that was a woman who knew exactly what she was doing, and very cleverly navigated the society of her time, under the restrictions of her gender.
I got the impression that Nelson could also be pretty selfish and hard to reason with sometimes - the epitome of a stubborn, hard-headed man. I cringed sometimes with some of his actions. But that was why this book was good - it didn't gloss over that, and not even Nelson could hide that in his letters. 'But why WHY aren't people paying attention to me? I, I, did that, not them! Did you hear about the time when I...'
(to be fair, they're not all like that, but that's a strong vibe with a lot)
So it's kind of weird that I still came away from this book with a fierce adoration with Nelson. But, like, with a critical eye too, I have to stress that. He might not have been as handsome as his portraits, he was viciously mean sometimes, but there is a certain aura around Nelson that my British heart can't quite tear out of itself. Every history student/historian has a figure that they feel a particularly deep interest in, and Nelson is mine, take it or leave it.
And can we just all appreciate my favourite portrait of Nelson...
closely followed by...
and the classic shiny shiny Nelson
Anyway, I loved this book for its subject and its unbiased look at Nelson. I can't wait to go back to the Portsmouth Dockyards now, and see the Victory again.
April 23, 2018
Extremely well written and researched. Great balance between Nelson's naval and personal life - and how they interact. Very enjoyable and interesting, and the extra information (details of Nelson's ships, biographical sketches, etc.) were definitely appreciated.
January 4, 2022
This is a dry biography that could have done a better job of explaining strategic context for certain victories/losses etc. However, there are points in the book though that will really hook the reader, and it provides a lot of context and background into what naval war was like in this period. The allure of Nelson is explained well in one of the final chapters ("The Summing Up"). He was popular because he was seen by the subsequent generations as an officer who achieved his station on his own merit rather than being a part of the aristocracy. Having also died in battle, he was before Churchill the embodiment of the British fighting spirit ("England expects that every man will do his duty", pg 514). He was remarkable (for his time) in the sense that he dealt with his subordinates on easier terms than his peer cohort, and while not a lax disciplinarian his subordinates felt attached to him. However, his dealings with them were primarily to make his point of view and order of battle intentions clear so when battle came, the captains and midshipmen knew what the admiral wanted. This allowed his subordinates to feel trusted in operations because they understood what the boss wanted and could do it with minimum direction. My final thought is that most great officers are a product of luck and timing, in addition to their own qualities. Nelson was a product of a strong British navy and weak continental navies. Additionally, the British naval institutions became more aristocratic in the Victorian era, but at in Nelson's time it allowed for commoners to rise through the ranks as a means to improve their station.
What makes this biography remarkable is all the reference material in the back of the book - biographical sketches, timelines, index, terms, etc. I do not think I've read a biography with so much additional content to help the reader keep track of what is going on.
What makes this biography remarkable is all the reference material in the back of the book - biographical sketches, timelines, index, terms, etc. I do not think I've read a biography with so much additional content to help the reader keep track of what is going on.
November 17, 2020
With the recent BLM protests in London, Nelson's legacy is under renewed scrutiny due to his alleged support for the trans-Atlantic slave trade. As it turns out these dubious allegations are based on a single letter in Nelson's name, published after his death by anti-abolitionists and now revealed to be forgery, and Nelson's reputation remains intact. While we're waiting for Afua Hirsch to admit her mistake (yeah right), I figured it was time to learn a little more about this pivotal figure in British history.
Knight's biography weighs in at over 550 pages, not including notes, and it paints a thorough picture of Nelson's life, from his modest beginnings in Norfolk to his rise through the ranks, his heroic victories at the Nile and Cape St Vincent, his disastrous raid on Tenerife, his scandalous affair with Emma Hamilton and his ultimate death in victory at Trafalgar. There's clearly some deep scholarship that went into this work; the broad sweeps of Nelson's life are interspersed with flourishes of detail about naval life in the late 18th/early 19th century and that era's political intrigues, and I learned a lot.
The flipside is that this level of detail at times makes for a dry reading experience; I'll admit I skimmed a few sections because I just wasn't interested enough. Also, while The Pursuit of Victory gave me a thorough understanding of what Nelson did, I don't feel like I learned very much about what Nelson was like as a person. Maybe it's because the book draws so heavily from ships' logs and other matter-of-fact records, but the real-life personalities behind the events don't often shine through.
All in all though, this is a great book if you want to learn more about the eventful life of the man who did more than anyone in his era to make Britannia rule the waves. It's not the lightest of reads, but as a work of scholarship it's hard to find flaws.
Knight's biography weighs in at over 550 pages, not including notes, and it paints a thorough picture of Nelson's life, from his modest beginnings in Norfolk to his rise through the ranks, his heroic victories at the Nile and Cape St Vincent, his disastrous raid on Tenerife, his scandalous affair with Emma Hamilton and his ultimate death in victory at Trafalgar. There's clearly some deep scholarship that went into this work; the broad sweeps of Nelson's life are interspersed with flourishes of detail about naval life in the late 18th/early 19th century and that era's political intrigues, and I learned a lot.
The flipside is that this level of detail at times makes for a dry reading experience; I'll admit I skimmed a few sections because I just wasn't interested enough. Also, while The Pursuit of Victory gave me a thorough understanding of what Nelson did, I don't feel like I learned very much about what Nelson was like as a person. Maybe it's because the book draws so heavily from ships' logs and other matter-of-fact records, but the real-life personalities behind the events don't often shine through.
All in all though, this is a great book if you want to learn more about the eventful life of the man who did more than anyone in his era to make Britannia rule the waves. It's not the lightest of reads, but as a work of scholarship it's hard to find flaws.
July 8, 2013
At first I was tempted to give this book 4 instead of 5 stars. It drags at parts and the conclusion of Trafalgar is a little iffy for me. When I thought about it, however, Knight is an expert in this field and it shows in his writing. The reader can tell he loves what he writes and goes into (sometimes excruciating) detail about every facet of Nelson's career. The part I love the most about this book, however, is Knight's ability to make Nelson a flawed character. He makes Nelson human in a way I never thought possible. I enjoyed reading this book immensely and would recommend it for any lover of British history or Nelson.
October 26, 2017
Both literally and figuratively, this is a weighty tome. It is a deeply detailed biography of Lord Nelson buried in an excellent history of the 18th century British Navy. The quality of the scholarship and research is obvious. It may be a bit much for the casual reader of history, but if you are interested in these subjects, it is a must for your bookshelf.
On a side note:
One of my favorite series of books is Patrick O'Brian's Captain Jack Aubrey novels. Pursuit of Victory is an excellent companion piece for fans of those books. It fleshes out the historical context.
On a side note:
One of my favorite series of books is Patrick O'Brian's Captain Jack Aubrey novels. Pursuit of Victory is an excellent companion piece for fans of those books. It fleshes out the historical context.
January 6, 2019
Extreme spoiler alert!
Horatian Nelson is the legend of the British navy. He is known for his great commanding ability, his leadership, his strategy, and his bravery. Knight’s biography about Nelson provides us with a clear view of his lifetime achievements, using the events in his life as the plot.
Being born in a commoner family alongside with three siblings in a small house at Norfolk, England. Nelson’s uncle Maurice Suckling was a high-ranked officer at the royal navy. As written in Nelson’s diary and in this book, Nelson described his uncle as the main reason of joining the navy. Nelson joined the royal navy at the age of 14, serving under his uncle’s battleship as assistant lieutenant (a common position for will-be-officers, usually requires some sort of background in their family to gain this position). Due to Nelson’s love of the sea and everything in the navy, he gained ranks fast, and soon he became the Navy’s youngest captain at the time, thus beginning his legendary career.
Due to Nelson’s clear mind, logical thinking, bravery, calmness, and natural leadership, he, and his fleet added (first his own vessel to his own fleet) countless amount of victories under her majesty’s name. At the time, it seems like nothing can get in the way from victory and the proud commander.
However, his pride is eventually the cause of his death. At the Battle of Trafalgar, he was shot and later after killed by a French marksman on the enemy ship. The marksman spotted Nelson wearing clothing full of medals and pins (due to his earlier date with the royal family, he was described as “wearing a Christmas tree”), which he earlier refused to take of due to thinking that he doesn’t have anything to fear and the shortage of time.
What made him such a great men is his courage and his beliefs in the "Pursuit of Victory". With those two factors by hand, he became the best commander that the Royal Navy've ever had. Overall, the language in the book are clean, clear, and very precise when it comes to facts. The book doesn’t contain many strong personal opinions, but the only flaw are the parts where the author spends too much time or too much detail on not useful events. I would rank this book a 4 out of 5.
Horatian Nelson is the legend of the British navy. He is known for his great commanding ability, his leadership, his strategy, and his bravery. Knight’s biography about Nelson provides us with a clear view of his lifetime achievements, using the events in his life as the plot.
Being born in a commoner family alongside with three siblings in a small house at Norfolk, England. Nelson’s uncle Maurice Suckling was a high-ranked officer at the royal navy. As written in Nelson’s diary and in this book, Nelson described his uncle as the main reason of joining the navy. Nelson joined the royal navy at the age of 14, serving under his uncle’s battleship as assistant lieutenant (a common position for will-be-officers, usually requires some sort of background in their family to gain this position). Due to Nelson’s love of the sea and everything in the navy, he gained ranks fast, and soon he became the Navy’s youngest captain at the time, thus beginning his legendary career.
Due to Nelson’s clear mind, logical thinking, bravery, calmness, and natural leadership, he, and his fleet added (first his own vessel to his own fleet) countless amount of victories under her majesty’s name. At the time, it seems like nothing can get in the way from victory and the proud commander.
However, his pride is eventually the cause of his death. At the Battle of Trafalgar, he was shot and later after killed by a French marksman on the enemy ship. The marksman spotted Nelson wearing clothing full of medals and pins (due to his earlier date with the royal family, he was described as “wearing a Christmas tree”), which he earlier refused to take of due to thinking that he doesn’t have anything to fear and the shortage of time.
What made him such a great men is his courage and his beliefs in the "Pursuit of Victory". With those two factors by hand, he became the best commander that the Royal Navy've ever had. Overall, the language in the book are clean, clear, and very precise when it comes to facts. The book doesn’t contain many strong personal opinions, but the only flaw are the parts where the author spends too much time or too much detail on not useful events. I would rank this book a 4 out of 5.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
May 14, 2023
A highly readable, deeply researched, and fair-minded biography, Roger Knight’s “The Pursuit of Victory” convincingly shows how Nelson’s confidence in British naval superiority—especially its trained seamen who could fire and reload cannons much faster than their French and Spanish opponents—facilitated Nelson’s aggressive tactics. For example, in the Battle of the Nile and Trafalgar, Nelson confidently and decisively attacked head-on formations of French and Spanish (in the case of Trafalgar) to get in close next to them, where British rapid-firing cannons and carronades could prove decisive. Nelson’s confidence extended to his subordinates, to whom he delegated much authority in battle, entrusting them to break formation when they spotted an opportunity so long as they erred on the side of aggressiveness.
Moreover, Knight does not overlook Nelson’s more controversial features, including his conduct in Naples (where he allowed British ships to be used to facilitate the execution of Republican opponents of the king), his love of medals and honors, and his affair with Emma Hamilton. And yet, Knight’s biography makes clear that while imperfect and likely unsuited to peacetime life, Nelson was perfectly suited to this moment in history, when British naval power was at its greatest and when Britain was most threatened by invasion.
Moreover, Knight does not overlook Nelson’s more controversial features, including his conduct in Naples (where he allowed British ships to be used to facilitate the execution of Republican opponents of the king), his love of medals and honors, and his affair with Emma Hamilton. And yet, Knight’s biography makes clear that while imperfect and likely unsuited to peacetime life, Nelson was perfectly suited to this moment in history, when British naval power was at its greatest and when Britain was most threatened by invasion.
July 26, 2019
An incredible book. The author gets into Nelson's life quickly, while still providing important background. The book gets a little tedious when Nelson gets his first command as the author shares a lot of technical information about naval rules of the time but that knowledge pays off later on. The author does a great job illuminating Nelson's strengths and flaws in terms of his personal life and military career. He isn't afraid to share his own view of things, yet always backs up his opinions with relevant contemporary quotes. This is a very humanizing portrait of a legendary, and sometimes controversial, figure.
May 30, 2019
"Dry History". An in-depth, well-researched biography of Horatio Nelson. The thing I loved most about it (aside from the standard tales of Nelson's brilliance and bravado) was the delving into the prize money system and the politics surrounding it. When you think of the strong incentives the system provided, both to the captains, and the Admiralty in general, and then think of the implications to treasury and prestige of the nation, wow, the last 400 years are pretty interesting to think about.
August 26, 2025
My inspiration for reading this book was a visit to Nelson’s final resting place in St. Paul’s Cathedral about 3 weeks ago, preceded by reading ALL OF Patrick O’Brian’s books featuring Jack Aubrey and Steven Maturin. This book filled in a lot of the gaps in my knowledge of Nelson’s life. A bit dry in places, but then a hero’s life can’t be all drama and excitement. A great synopsis of Nelson as a man and a leader is at the very end of the book.
August 21, 2023
For a first time reader of this period of history let alone naval history, it took me a while to get used to some of the nautical terms. But aside from that, I loved it!
I honestly think as British citizen Nelson should be studied more. He was our Napoleon at sea! and his feats can't help but make you feel proud.
I honestly think as British citizen Nelson should be studied more. He was our Napoleon at sea! and his feats can't help but make you feel proud.
September 26, 2023
I just could not plow through this. The author’s research, knowledge and accuracy remains beyond my question but who would read this?
Certainly not a beginner in naval history. The amount of detail and footnotes made for dry reading. Maybe it’s meant for a truly devoted fan of British naval lore. Not me.
Certainly not a beginner in naval history. The amount of detail and footnotes made for dry reading. Maybe it’s meant for a truly devoted fan of British naval lore. Not me.
August 14, 2024
Will admire Nelson's Column more next time i pass by it... Great read, especially how the Royal Navy operated in the 1700's (cough cough nepotism), superior ship building, advanced cannons and better trained sailors. I feel my specialist subject on Mastermind right now could be Vice Admiral, Baron, Lord Horatio Nelson!!!
June 17, 2025
Outstanding biography to be sure! It takes a long time to read, and I read a couple other books while putting this one aside. But I always came back to it and was fascinated chapter by chapter. A word of caution, one should be extremely interested in the British Navy, and 19 century methods of fighting. Fortunately I am so I found this to be a fascinating book.
February 20, 2025
Incredibly insightful from start to finish, the book also makes a good attempt to explain in some detail the surrounding geopolitical landscape and the microcosm of day to day life in an 18th century Royal Navy.
August 25, 2018
Good look at British Naval history and 9ne of its key figures.
July 16, 2020
An excellent study of Admiral Horatio Nelson and his times. Thoroughly researched and well written. Highly recommended for those interested in the topic.
January 18, 2023
Great story & detail. Maybe a little too long for my liking though.
July 26, 2023
This was a great read. The two people I want to sit down with from history are Jesus and Lord Nelson.
March 12, 2024
i enjoyed this a surprising amount. 5 stars for grandad but rly a 4.5
December 5, 2024
A quite notable account of the life of Britain’s greatest hero (apologies to Thomas Lawrence).
November 27, 2012
Lovely biography, but HANDS OFF THE PAPERBACK EDITION!
The Penguin paperback edition is published without a bibliography, which is pretty shitty publishing policy for a work that claims to be scholarly and repeatedly gets praised for being one of the top works on the subject.
This is the first Nelson-biography I've read, so take my opinion with a grain of salt, but I thought Knight treated his subject fairly. The book never loses itself in sentimentalism, nor does it gloss over Nelson's flaws, like the cruel treatment of his wife, and dedicates a chapter to the violent suppression of the Neapolitan revolution. Which is the least one could expect from a modern Nelson-biography.
The book mainly puts its focus on the last decade of Nelson's life, which arguably is the most eventful. The writing is a bit dry at times, but the interesting and exciting content sure makes up for it.
However, not being from the UK myself, I'm still at a loss about what Nelson meant to the British. It's not a question a biography should answer, but it would have been nice, had the last chapter, dealing with the impact of Nelson's fame on later generations, been a bit longer. But I guess that's a subject matter for a different book, that I have yet to find.
I did, however, really enjoy having the biographical sketches at the end of the book. Very useful.
The Penguin paperback edition is published without a bibliography, which is pretty shitty publishing policy for a work that claims to be scholarly and repeatedly gets praised for being one of the top works on the subject.
This is the first Nelson-biography I've read, so take my opinion with a grain of salt, but I thought Knight treated his subject fairly. The book never loses itself in sentimentalism, nor does it gloss over Nelson's flaws, like the cruel treatment of his wife, and dedicates a chapter to the violent suppression of the Neapolitan revolution. Which is the least one could expect from a modern Nelson-biography.
The book mainly puts its focus on the last decade of Nelson's life, which arguably is the most eventful. The writing is a bit dry at times, but the interesting and exciting content sure makes up for it.
However, not being from the UK myself, I'm still at a loss about what Nelson meant to the British. It's not a question a biography should answer, but it would have been nice, had the last chapter, dealing with the impact of Nelson's fame on later generations, been a bit longer. But I guess that's a subject matter for a different book, that I have yet to find.
I did, however, really enjoy having the biographical sketches at the end of the book. Very useful.
February 16, 2016
Lengthy, thorough, but fairly readable biography of the famed Admiral Nelson. It's not quite as imposing as it seems as the last 300 pages are filled with footnotes, bibliography, biographies of prominent individuals mentioned in the book, a glossary, etc. As an aside, there is a printing error at least in this edition which scrambles up the biographies; some are out of order, some omitted entirely. Unfortunate, since among the omitted are Keats and Jervis.
The biography does a very nice job of placing Nelson within the period in which he lived. Nothing more annoying that a biographer who tries to judge his subject by the standards of his own time, decades or centuries removed.
If you want to know what Nelson was doing at any particular time and where he was doing it, this is the book for you. For anyone trying to learn what it was made that made Nelson special, the book is somewhat lacking. Yes, he was kind to his men. Yes, he had dinner with them, but the narrative is thin on details or even speculation.
The biography does a very nice job of placing Nelson within the period in which he lived. Nothing more annoying that a biographer who tries to judge his subject by the standards of his own time, decades or centuries removed.
If you want to know what Nelson was doing at any particular time and where he was doing it, this is the book for you. For anyone trying to learn what it was made that made Nelson special, the book is somewhat lacking. Yes, he was kind to his men. Yes, he had dinner with them, but the narrative is thin on details or even speculation.
April 26, 2015
This is a dense read, but probably one of the best biographies I Ever read. It has 400 pages at the end of footnotes, ship descriptions, mini bios of all the protagonists and is amazingly researched. Nelson is fascinating, both brilliant (jibing HMS Captain and crossing the line of battle to attack the spanish flagship at Cape St Vincent took huevos as did entering aboukir bay at dusk with no chart data and annihilating the french) and completely stupid (his attacks in west indies and santa cruz where he lost his eye and arm, and dumping his wife for a harlot who was married to a senile nobleman and allowing lawless slaughter on his ships due to blind love). If you love naval history, you have to read this, it also gives a strong background for the Patrick Obrien novels. A great read about a great officer and true hero.
February 10, 2017
A bit dense for me, especially since I know nothing about sailing.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 42 reviews