An absolute beast of a book, weighing in at over 1,000 pages. Don't let the title fool you; a better title would be something like, "The Nineteenth Century Naval Arms Race That Helped Set the Stage for a World War, With Biographic Sketches of a Full Range of Supporting Characters of Many Nations, Giving Particular Emphasis to British and German Politicians, Diplomats, and Naval Personages." If you're looking for a book about ships, you'll find them here and in abundance, but they're not Massie's focus. If you're looking for a detailed account of the diplomatic and military history of the period preceding WWI, that's what you'll find, with the sort of detail that allows chapter-length accounts of the Agadir Crisis, for example, or the political storm that cost the House of Lords their veto over Commons legislation.
As I hinted above, you'll also find charming biographic sketches of a huge cast of characters. I say characters intentionally, because this reads like a gripping novel more often than not -- includes: Queen Victoria, Otto von Bismarck, Winston Churchill, Admiral Jackie Fisher, Admiral von Tirpitz, Gladstone, Balfour, Bulow, Cambon, Chamberlain, NIcholas II, Grey, Lloyd George, etc.
Random impressions:
* Wilhelmine Germany wasn't quite the modern state we're familiar with. Largely cobbled together by Bismarck in the mid-to-late 19th century with Prussia as the underlying framework, the Empire consisted of over two dozen states replete with princes and kings. Many of these states actually exchanged ambassadors with one another.
* Bismarck had a prodigious appetite for alcohol and tobacco, as well as food. He "[s]moked fourteen cigars a day, drank beer in the afternooons, kept two large goblets - one for champagne, the other for port - at hand during meals, and tried to find sleep at night by drinking a bottle of champagne... When [Bismarck] complained of an upset stomach, [his wife] calmed him with foie gras."
* Despite his reliance on military force as the means to create an Empire at the expense of the Danes, the French, and the Austro-Hungarian Hapsburgs, once the new German state was a reality, Bismarck strove to maintain a peaceful status quo in Europe. He also expressed no interest in German overseas colonies, and in fact encouraged French colonialism as a means of distracting them from the loss of Alsace and Lorraine in 1871.
* "In a country like ours, governed by discussion, a great man is never hanged. He hangs himself." Jackie Fisher's friend Esher, counseling him during a stressful period to remain calm. Jackie Fisher, by the way, is an absolutely fascinating character. Untried at sea, but a masterful commander of military bureaucracy, and an obsessive dancer.
* Many of Massie's portraits are quite nice. For instance, I find Lord Grey remarkable and very sympathetic. He spent as much free time as he possibly could at his small country cottage with his wife, and waxed poetic about communing with nature while he fished the streams by his home. On Sundays, he would often spend the day reading with his wife: "He was a serious reader and quoted with approval the story of a man happy in his country home when unexpected visitors were announced. The man greeted his visitors, declared that he was delighted to see them, and then said, "And now what would you like to do? We are reading." An unlikely Prime Minister.
* Churchill on the political wrangling that accompanied the budgeting process for ship construction: "In the end a curious and characteristic solution was reached. The Admiralty had demanded six ships; the economists offered four; and we finally compromised on eight."
* The book summarized in a few lines: "Great Britain had decided not ot tolerate German hegemony on the Continent. From this vague but powerful instinct flowed the entente with France, the rebuilding of the Royal Navy, and the entente with Russia. The result was a restoration of the balance of power in Europe. Theobald von Bethmann-Hollweg, the future German Chancellor, understood: "You may call it 'encirclement,' 'Balance of Power' or what you will, but the object aimed at and eventually obtained was no other than the welding of a serried and supreme combination of states for obstructing Germany, by diplomatic means at least, in the full development of her growing power." " Of course, Bethmann's take is colored by his allegiances, but that's about right.
* Diplomacy can be amusing. When King Edward visited Germany in 1909, "[t]he visit was plagued by mishaps. The first occurred as the King's train reached [the frontier], where a military band and a regiment of hussars were drawn up. When the royal train pulled into the station, the King was unready; the train had crossed into a different time zone and his value, having failed to adjust his watch, had not laid out His Majesty's uniform. When the King's suite in full uniform descended from the train, the band, expecting the monarch to follow, struck up "God Save the King." For ten minutes, while King Edward struggled into the uniform of a German field marshal, the band played "God Save the King" over and over, "till we all nearly screamed," said a member of the British suite. Eventually, King Edward appeared and, walking so briskly that he lost his breath, inspected the hussars." Also, note that Edward was wearing a German uniform. Since the European monarchies were closely related, they were fond of bestowing upon their relations honorary military rank. Wilhelm II was an honorary British admiral, and maintained a great affection and admiration for the British navy.
* Grey, on the eve of war: "Thus, the efforts of a lifetime go for nothing. I feel like a man who has wasted his life." Later that same evening: "The lamps are going out all over Europe," he said. "We shall not see them lit again in our lifetime."
There's a good deal more, obviously, not least of which is the discussion of naval planning, technology, logistics, etc.
Wonderful stuff, and highly recommended.