This is my second reading of this book, and it only confirms my initial opinion from 2 years ago:
Expected more. Disappointed.
Let me first say that I've been a photo hobbyist for a little over ten years now, and most of my experience during that time was with digital SLRs. I was looking to make the switch to shooting film, and was hoping for something that would highlight the differences involved in working with the two mediums. The subtitle of the book seemed to indicate that the book was exactly what I was looking for: a guide to shooting film for photographers accustomed to shooting digital. In this, I was disappointed.
The book would've been more accurately subtitled: "How The Author Chooses to Shoot Film."
While I learned a few things, it certainly wasn't worth the cost of the book. It felt like I was just reading the author's setup, and while that's fine, it was not what was suggested by the book's title. To say there are photos peppered throughout the book would be an understatement. There were pages and pages of them, sometimes without a bit of text aside from the camera & film used. 95% of the photos in the book have little or nothing to do with the text. The book feels more like an essay or extended blog post padded by mostly random photos and printed on nice paper with a nice hardcover.
The author begins the book with the statement, [paraphrased]: "If you still have questions after reading this book, Google them." Now I know why. I find myself using Google for topics that I feel should have been covered more extensively in the book, such as light metering (which had a section, but it felt weak), and "pushing" (which was briefly mentioned).
I bought this book because I HAD been using Google to learn about using film, and I wanted something more structured that was all in one place. Unfortunately, this fell short of my expectations, and while it looks nice, it lacks the very substance declared in the title.
PROS: Nice photography, nice printing, nice cover, great title.
CONS: Doesn't fulfill the promise made in the subtitle.
I decided to revisit this book having had 2 years experience since returning to film. I thought maybe I'd find reason to improve my review (because honestly, I wanted to love this book, and I do love the fact that there is a market for the book described on the cover). If anything, I was even more frustrated the second time around. The book may be useful if you happen to shoot the exact same gear as the author, but otherwise it's like reading instruction manuals for cameras you don't own.
While the title seems to imply the book is about film, it's quite misleading. The book is about shooting MEDIUM FORMAT FILM, and specifically, shooting with a CONTAX 645. If you're interested in shooting anything other than this combination, you won't find much in this book. For this reason, I've decreased my initial rating from 3 stars to 2. This book is simply not worth reading for the majority of film shooters, and I'm sorry I decided to hang onto it.