A raw, smart, and darkly funny memoir, My Heart Is An Autumn Garage unapologetically chronicles a lifelong struggle with clinical depression. Anne Thériault neatly lays bare her heart, unsparingly detailing the naked self-loathing and self-destructive behaviors that led to her breakdown and subsequent hospitalization at the age of twenty one. Both an examination of the frightening and deeply dehumanizing treatment of psychiatric patients and a wry coming-of-age story, this book deftly explores the knife's edge between despair and hope.
I can see how people are comparing this book with the Bell jar but I don't think that Anne Theriault is trying to be a modern version of Sylvia Plath. Depression has many faces, and the fact that these faces might be somewhat similar should not be surprising. I can relate to both these books, and I'm sure I can relate to many more depression stories, and it's good to know you're not the only one, and it's sad anyway.
Anne takes you on an imagery-filled journey through depression in "My Heart is an Autumn Garage". It is a brave and personal book about a journey too many people go through and not enough people discuss. Particularly poignant is Anne's illustration of how one perceives people with mental illness - she is clearly a funny, intelligent, young woman, confident enough in her voice and in her own skin to share her story; and yet she speaks of feeling as much less than those things, due to the crippling effects of depression - teachers, romantic partners, even doctors and therapists ostensibly there to help, with a stubborn lack of understanding of the effects of mental illness, and how it can affect all facets of someone's life. If it can happen to someone as capable as Anne, it can happen to anyone.
She speaks of her depressed self and her healthy self as almost two different people at times, personifying her depression - and in so doing, provides perhaps the most comprehensible, relatable and concrete insight into mental illness I've seen, and in that sense, this is an excellent memoir in which I guarantee we will all see either someone we know ... or perhaps even ourselves.
It is a quick read, and an easy one in terms of Anne's relatable writing style, although obviously the subject matter can be difficult (but important, and all the more reason it is worth the read). The only complaint I have, honestly, is in its own way a compliment - the book was so readable and fascinating, and gave such an insight into the author's life it left me wanting more! And really, while selfishly that was a little unsatisfying, isn't that the ultimate sign of a good book? :)
To me, this book read like a very long denial of mental illness. There's a certain tactic that many brighter folks with mental illness use in which they come clean about or resolve one issue to distract themselves, the psychiatrist/psychologist, or both from seeing there's another problem there. I say this not only as a mental health professional, but as someone who has experienced many of the same things the author has. This book read very defensively, and I'm wondering why. I feel like the entire time, the author is trying to pit us against all of the mental health workers she encounters while checking over her shoulder to make sure we've still got her back. Many employees of psych hospitals or wards are unsympathetic and power-hungry, but not all of them. The black and white, us vs. them mentality isn't quite right. We've read memoirs before; we know we're only getting half a story here.
And not to be harsh, but the whole thing sounded like it desperately wanted to be a 21st century Bell Jar. If I can see that from the first chapter and roll my eyes so hard it hurts my head, you're trying way too hard.
Overall, I feel like I wasted a few dollars and a few hours. I do think the author has potential and a great command of language. Perhaps she should try her hand at fiction?
This is raw and powerful and hard to read and also a damn great look at how screwed up depression and anxiety can make you as an individual. I've always loved Theriault's writing, and her book is no different. I downed this in a single sitting -- they just rereleased it, with a new cover, and I hope it finds an even bigger audience. This is for readers who want a thoughtful look at mental illness and how the system both works for and against those who struggle with them.
I loved the author's geographical metaphor of depression. And I was appalled by the way they treated her at the psychiatric hospital. You'd think the system has changed since One flew over the cuckoo's nest, especially in Canada, but you'd be mistaken. What a way to treat someone who is at the lowest point of their life!
Theriault descriptive writing is great, she created a perfect picture of sadness. She has done a brilliant job of describing her struggle with depression, the feeling of hopelessness and anxiety. Its all believable and very sad to read.
Her hospitalization and diagnosis made me really angry. Why doesn't the hospital staff, the psychiatrists and doctors realise that people with any kind of mental illness can still see, feel and hear their reactions? in fact, they are more sensitive to these things than a normal person. What happened to treating people with dignity and respect? It just made me so angry. How can people who are meant to take care of the most vulnerable in our communities can be so thoughtless and unprofessional? what happened to sympathy?
Reads like a Reddit post but I hate psychiatry enough to give it three stars. Felt the vacation home metaphor was not properly formed and it felt vestigal. Penultimate chapter was out of step with the rest of the book without needing to be. Also, how was a bottle of perfume allowed in a psych ward? But I like her point.
Raw and emotional. A personal journey of dealing with depression. I was particularly sad at the stigma experienced at the hands of mental health practitioners the ones who are supposed to be the caregivers
Eloquently told story about what it’s like to struggle through a major depressive episode but all the typos were a distraction. Compelling enough to read in one sitting.
"The end of August is when the light begins to change; it's still strong and bright during the day, but becomes melancholy, even a little desolate in the waning afternoon and long, dreamy evenings. Late summer light, from the days when the works teeters on the divide between the hot, green summer and the slow descent into the cold heart of winter, is what nostalgia is made from. Autumn is the season of endings, of barren fields and bonfires and celebrations for the dead. Autumn is the season of packing up, storing away, battening down. Autumn is always, still, the sweetest ache I've ever known."
This short book is the account of Anne's battle with depression. It should be hard to read, depressing even, and yet somehow it's not. It's so well written that you can get carried along with the story without getting bogged down in the depression yourself. And somehow, even in the hardest parts, she seems to have a ray of hope that shines through.
I knew Anne a little during the time she is writing about but not well enough to know her struggles, so I would like to thank her for bravely sharing with the world. I think it's an important read both for people who struggle with depression and also for people who live with someone who does - which, given the stats, is probably everyone. Pick this one up - it's an ebook and not very expensive, and worth every penny.
“I didn’t understand why I couldn’t get my life together and I bought in to the old lie that it was somehow the result of laziness or lack of will power. See, this is the tricky thing about depression and the lies that it tells you. It masquerades itself so brilliantly as your own clear undiseased thoughts that you can very rarely if ever catch it in the act of lying. It’s only later, once you’re healthier and finally able to sift through all of the sweet nothings your sadness has been whispering to you these many weeks and months that you can begin to separate the truths from the untruths. When you’re in the thick of it though, your mind turns traitor and offers you the worst advice possible the main result of which is you feel worse and worse and worse. It’s like you’re inhabited by one of those weird parasites that forces you to do things that you wouldn’t normally do in order to ensure its own survival. Because your depression wants to badly to survive.”
Anne's stunning command of language and evocative storytelling made reading this memoir a joy, regardless of it being about depression and anxiety. Her struggles and experiences and realizations have mirrored mine in so many ways that reading this was comforting, even as it had me confront unsettling details and memories of my own reality. This was a lovely read and I'm grateful to have found it.
"The truth was that all of those events and objects and feelings, even when taken together, did not make up an especially good list of reasons to live. But they were a start, weren't they? A place that I could jump off from, a place that I could come back to if I was ever unsure of how or where to go."
Anne Theriault has written a book that anyone suffering from, or who has suffered from, depression will relate to. Even if you have never suffered from depression but love someone who has, this book will resonate. She paints such a clear picture of what it's like to slip into darkness, but her story never reeks of self-pity. It is reflective yet haunting, and reminiscent to me of Sylvia Plath's "The Bell Jar" in the way that she so beautifully articulates what it's like to be profoundly sad. It's a quick read-- I read it in one afternoon-- but one that stays with you for a while after you're done.
I loved this so much. The author's description of her descent into a deep depression and her subsequent one night stay in a psychiatric ward was at times heartbreaking and very relatable. My only wish would be that it would be expanded into a full length book. I would have liked to have seen the after-effects of her overnight stay.
I really wish there was a star between "really liked it" and "it was amazing" because I'm reluctant to give it five stars, but I didn't just really like it. I loved this book in a way that makes me not want to share it with anyone else.
Honest, sometimes brutally so, and often fiercely funny, this is a personal story of depression and breakdown. Not a 'how to' book, not a guidebook, but a simple, eloquent account of a young woman struggling. Far too short, though!
I always want more from a memoir. And this one falls into the creative non-fiction category. So I expected a lot. Something really raw and messy. It has some wonderful bits and pieces. And the honesty is everywhere.
This book is incredibly short, and I don't think I would have kept up with it had it been longer. There were some interesting passages, but for the most part, it is forgettable.