I’m saying this right now: this is my LAST TIME falling for a cartoon cover and a cute blurb (it’s not). It will never get me again (it will). The next time I see one, I’m ignoring it (putting it on my TBR). As long as I shall live, I will not be reading a cartoon cover (I’m already reading one).
MAIN CHARACTER NAMES AND AGES
Star Shine Meadows (28) | Rafferty “Rafe” Whitman (33)
FEATURES
∘ fake dating
∘ grumpy / sunshine
∘ sixth month agreement
∘ commitment-phobe fmc
∘ serious, workaholic mmc
REVIEW
You know, I never thought I’d say this about conflict in a romance novel, but there was too much communication.
It seemed like at least once a chapter Star or Rafe (mainly the former) would have an issue and then need to communicate through it or put the other in their place. Despite this, there were many instances where both of them kept their worries and/or feelings to themselves, so they communicated too much, while also not communicating enough
Both of them would say things that purposely hurt the other (not in a malicious or rude way), they would apologize, and then there’d be another unspoken feeling they’d have to address. I love an opposites attract romance, but Star and Rafe were too opposite to work. One of them had to change, meaning Star was the one to make the most sacrifices (without being asked). It was disappointing to watch someone so self-assured become so insecure.
I did appreciate how quickly the fake dating turned real. Even though they stumbled a bit in the middle, they eventually came to voice their feelings and insecurities, and we got to see them as an actual couple.
The blurb and cover name it seem like this would be a cute and fun read. Initially, it held onto its promise, but it quickly became slogged by the constant shallow angst and characters justifying their actions. At times, it was frustrating, exhausting, and (worst of all) boring. The moments of enjoyment I got just weren’t enough to make me forget about the times I was left without.
OW/OM DRAMA minor OW — Rafe’s family still tries to set him up with other women when Star and him first start “dating” | past OW Rafe’s cheating and selfish ex makes an appearance or two | minor OM — one of Star’s ex-flings comes while they’re on a fake date and briefly kisses her (on the corner of the lips), which sparks a discussion about how she doesn’t “believe” in monogamy
CHEATING none
THIRD ACT BREAKUP sort of — they do have some “breaks” and/or distance before they officially start dating; things get dicey at the end, and Star gets overwhelmed, but Rafe clears it up
ENDING HEA
POV singular (Star) / first person
SPICE LEVEL 3 / 5
RATING 2.5 / 5