3.5 Stars.
I found this when out and about after cat-sitting my best friends little fur-balls. It wasn't in the YA section, so when I gave the back a quick read-thru, I thought it was about something else.
As I have read some other reviews of this book, I have discovered that the author is very anti-bullying. It is obvious. This book reminds me so much of a cross between "Little Darlings," "Mean Girls," and, the original "The Parent Trap."
Amy is sent against her wishes to summer camp, run by her uncle. She is hesitant to leave her disabled little brother, but goes. Before they even get to the camp, Amy becomes the target of a camp bully named Rory. Even worse, her cousin, Robin, is in with Rory. Amy does her best to ignore the camp bully, but isn't entirely successful, leading to embarrassing hazing and other instances of horrendous behavior. What is worse, is Robin joins in. Her uncle, reading her letters home, encourages her to write about how much she is enjoying herself when she isn't. She embellishes enough in her letters home.
Apparently, home life isn't much better for Amy. She loves her little brother--disabled and all, but her mother is apparently an empty soul of a woman. A woman who becomes the little "devil" on Amy's shoulder about how much to eat, what to wear, her posture, etc. This apparently "lack of any human emotion" woman also had an affair with Amy's uncle, and had a life before her father, in Germany, where her first daughter, Anna and husband were killed during WWII. So it seems Sonia only had enough love for her first daughter.
Amy gets through summer camp, only to have her brother die in a tragic accident while she is snooping/looking for the goods on her mother. Sonia fights cancer and finally admits this previous life to Amy. They end up with a someone resolved relationship. The End.
*sigh*
If only it was that easy.
I am all for anti-bullying. I was bullied relentlessly by this b****h relentlessly in my school days. I cringed any time I had a class with her. In stories like "Little Darlings" and "Mean Girls" the bullies pretty much get handled by her peers. In "Little Darlings," when the campers shenanigans get one of the counselors into trouble, the instigator of the whole plan finally get slapped upside her smug little face (go Cinder!). In Mean Girls, while the antagonist tries to get some revenge via trying to blame her friends for everything, she gets hit by a bus, still gets recognized in a neck brace and learns to get out her aggressive behavior by joining the Lacrosse team.
Too bad this didn't happen here. I wanted to see Rory get some kind of comeuppance for her actions. Sure, there are rumors that she was being molested at home by her father, but even with the absence of any visitors during visitors day, or waiting for her upon return, it isn't really known if Rory is being abused. I know, most people today will say that the bullies are facing trouble of their own. However, while I believe this to a point, I also know that there are some bullies that are just plain mean and evil--nothing going on behind the scenes to provoke. They are just assholes who get off on being mean.
And lets look at the mother, Sonia. Because she purportedly gave "all her love" to her first daughter, Anna, there was nothing left for Amy or Charlie. That is sad. This woman made her daughter stay in her room while she screwed her brother in law, to the point Amy would mess herself because she wasn't supposed to leave her room. The woman also comes across as mean. I mean, seriously, you just meet the camp bully and your daughter is telling you that she isn't what she seems...do you believe your daughter or this virtual stranger sucking up to you? Doesn't that come across as a bit shitty behavior for a parent? You write to your folks, asking to send certain clothes for a dance and bring cookies and such treats to share with her bunkmates, but gets a party dress (out of place) and a bag of fruit (laughable and out of place).
Even worse, and this gets a bit irritating. The father continues to try and placate Sonia. So he is always saying "Sonia, please, Sonia." It is one phrase that I just would have cut in half.
Look, I like the idea of this book. But there does not seem to be a pay out in regards to what happens to the bullies: Rory gets to skip off on her merry little way? No repercussions for Robin's hideous behavior toward her cousin? Yes, Sonia gets cancer, then she survives it...but she mellows only slightly. I think it needed something more.