What do you think?
Rate this book
魔法科高校の優等生 (Comic) #1
魔法科高校の優等生 1
電撃文庫の人気作 『魔法科高校の劣等生』 から、主人公・達也の妹で最強可憐な魔法師・深雪の目線で描くスピンオフシリーズが登場！ 深雪たち優等生の日常風景や、深雪が胸に秘めた達也への想いなど、見どころ満載。
178 pages, Kindle Edition
First published June 8, 2012
25 people are currently reading
665 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 25 of 25 reviews
July 22, 2021
This is the same story as The Irregular at Magic High School, but ostensibly from the point of view of Miyuki, Tatsuya's sister from the main series. Ostensibly, because Miyuki isn't the only honor student in this series, it includes her classmates, particularly Honoka and Shizuku as well.
If you enjoyed The Irregular at Magic High School, this is a good alternative instead of rereading the main series, and experience it from a different angle.
If you enjoyed The Irregular at Magic High School, this is a good alternative instead of rereading the main series, and experience it from a different angle.
August 10, 2022
The story was okay and Tatsuya was hot but the incesty vibes this gave was not it. Miyuki was just a bit weird with her brother, it was just weird. I made a little counter of everything time there was an incesty bit and the final count was 41 so.... Everyone just loved her cause she was pretty which rubbed me the wrong way.
I don’t know. I probably wont read the rest of the series but this was an interesting read.
I don’t know. I probably wont read the rest of the series but this was an interesting read.
October 1, 2025
Unfortunately quite incesty
July 12, 2021
Not a big fan of the little sister trope -- and while I'm afraid that will infect the rest of the series, depending on the degree of it, I might be okay. I am liking the world set up, and the conflict between the Bloom/Weed, the magic system... and the hints of a lot more. A solid first volume. If my library ever gets back the first volume of the light novels The Irregular at Magic High School, Vol. 1: Enrollment Arc, Part I I am likely to pick that up to read too!
March 7, 2018
It definitely appeals to fans of the core series, but I think it can be read separately and enjoyed on its own, especially if you've heard bad talk about the series marty stue protagonist and would like a story more focused on its female players. Not that it isn't there, but the focus is very much on the female protagonist and her world, her friends, rather than his engineering and accomplishments.
Also, you have to accept the incest undertones... overtones... subtext doesn't quite cut it..... but if you can do that it's a good story to read when you feel like protagonists kicking ass and being too awesome for the world.
Also, you have to accept the incest undertones... overtones... subtext doesn't quite cut it..... but if you can do that it's a good story to read when you feel like protagonists kicking ass and being too awesome for the world.
March 13, 2019
This could be a good series if the fan service was dialed down from an 8 to a 2... so many unnecessary gratuity frames.
I have seen a lot of this in anime format several years ago but didn't recall the underwear frames being so prevalent, perhaps it wasn't as noticeable in a different medium. The whole concept is good though, the return of magic enhanced by technology in the future. It's trope is rather black and white, fairly standard non magic users hating magic users and magic users being discriminatory thinking everyone else is lesser than them... but the magic system makes the read worthwhile.
I have seen a lot of this in anime format several years ago but didn't recall the underwear frames being so prevalent, perhaps it wasn't as noticeable in a different medium. The whole concept is good though, the return of magic enhanced by technology in the future. It's trope is rather black and white, fairly standard non magic users hating magic users and magic users being discriminatory thinking everyone else is lesser than them... but the magic system makes the read worthwhile.
October 28, 2020
This is a new Fine Arts Library. I wanted to start a new manga and this one caught my eye, which I was interested to is just a continuation of another series. I now wish to read the other novels as well as the manga series. I feel that it is an interesting concept, and I'm quite pleased that, though it is a English translation it still has some Japanese characters, which is helping me continue my learning of the Japanese language.
May 26, 2025
This was a pleasant surprise. First, because there is a real bad guy in this story. Second, because there are real good guys of each sex in the story. I can relate to one of the protagonists without shame and enjoy the drama.
October 27, 2017
Onto book #2.
December 18, 2018
Some what confusing on the story and not a big fan of the brother/ sister relationship going on. Might try the anime to see how it is.
November 10, 2021
This was kind of terrible.
February 22, 2023
⭐️⭐️⭐️ I spent a lot of this confused, but I like the characters and the idea behind the story so I might continue or try the anime. Not sure how I’m feeling about the light incest though 😂
January 3, 2016
A lovey-dovey story of a sister crushing hard on her brother, who's not quite a year older! They would be in the same class at school, but - sadness! - he is much less magically powerful than her, and gets put into Class 2, while she joins Class 1. There's some bullying by Class 1 students who feel superior to the Class 2s, but friends on both sides support them in their efforts to remain together.
I liked the look of the magic system in this book! It's very obviously science-based, tied to more modern equipment than staves or wands, and is similar to the way hacking or logging in to a virtual reality are often portrayed. The art is very cute, with sparse backgrounds and large figures in most panels. A heartwarming school story, with the sibling romance front and center!
I liked the look of the magic system in this book! It's very obviously science-based, tied to more modern equipment than staves or wands, and is similar to the way hacking or logging in to a virtual reality are often portrayed. The art is very cute, with sparse backgrounds and large figures in most panels. A heartwarming school story, with the sibling romance front and center!
March 26, 2016
This book was easier to handle than The Irregular at Magic High School, which I stopped watching about 5 minutes into the first episode when the main character walked into a girl bending over a desk with her panties all up on our business. This is more shojo, with the main girl SUPER into her brother. It follows the students in the school who have the best magical abilities. It was cute, but nothing mindblowing.
February 10, 2016
I did not realize that this was a spin off of another manga. That would explain why the world-building was seriously lacking. The art was really beautiful, but the writing was a bit awkward. I feel like you have to be familiar with the original series to really enjoy this manga.
**I received a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.**
**I received a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.**
March 19, 2016
The characters are pretty and cute, the anime was drawn pretty good. It has a fascinating storyline and its about magic. There is not too much writing so you don't get bored.
I can't wait for volume 2!
I can't wait for volume 2!
February 5, 2017
Great mangA
Loved seeing the stuff happen from the sister's point of view. Can't wait to see what next happens in the series!
Loved seeing the stuff happen from the sister's point of view. Can't wait to see what next happens in the series!
March 30, 2020
Nice extension of the major story lines
The art work is very good, and the story line complements and expands the base story in “Irregular”. I enjoyed it, but you need a large tablet of monitor to view it on to fully appreciate it.
The art work is very good, and the story line complements and expands the base story in “Irregular”. I enjoyed it, but you need a large tablet of monitor to view it on to fully appreciate it.
November 27, 2015
This was much better than I expected it to be - Miyuki is an easier character to get behind than her brother.
Full review will eventually appear on The Anime News Network.
Full review will eventually appear on The Anime News Network.
December 6, 2015
I really enjoyed the story and thought that the characters were likable
January 22, 2016
A little too much world building, but I don't know the other series, so i can't judge. Good storyline.
April 10, 2016
Liked it
I liked the anime and the light novels. The manga is pretty good as well. I can't wait till I read the next one.
I liked the anime and the light novels. The manga is pretty good as well. I can't wait till I read the next one.
July 17, 2016
Yikes why spoil a decent storyline with hints of incest? I am so very uncomfortable.
Displaying 1 - 25 of 25 reviews