What do you think?
Rate this book
Lost Boys #1
The Skeptic
From USA Today Bestselling Author Kelly Fox comes a new series set in one of Central Texas's fastest-growing river towns.
You've heard of those romances where the priest is seduced by the worldly outsider? Yeah, this isn't that.
I'm a gay preacher with more tattoos than sense and more notches on my bedpost than years in the ministry. I'm also not totally settled on the existence of God. Call me a skeptic, but when you work with abandoned and abused teenagers, you tend to have a few questions for anyone calling themselves divine .
Having lived in Seguin most of my life, I've always been the troublemaker. Most of my queer friends fled this place just after high school, but we all know that the only reason any of us made it out alive was our shop teacher, Mr. Paige. He lovingly called us his Lost Boys. Now that his health is failing, the Lost Boys are coming together to support him and his family.
To be honest, I may have been more supportive of Mr. Paige's son than was totally appropriate for a guy in a collar. Turns out, just like the Lost Boys, Holden had good reason to leave Seguin all those years ago.
Despite his history, I'm hoping he's willing to find a reason to stay.
You've heard of those romances where the priest is seduced by the worldly outsider? Yeah, this isn't that.
I'm a gay preacher with more tattoos than sense and more notches on my bedpost than years in the ministry. I'm also not totally settled on the existence of God. Call me a skeptic, but when you work with abandoned and abused teenagers, you tend to have a few questions for anyone calling themselves divine .
Having lived in Seguin most of my life, I've always been the troublemaker. Most of my queer friends fled this place just after high school, but we all know that the only reason any of us made it out alive was our shop teacher, Mr. Paige. He lovingly called us his Lost Boys. Now that his health is failing, the Lost Boys are coming together to support him and his family.
To be honest, I may have been more supportive of Mr. Paige's son than was totally appropriate for a guy in a collar. Turns out, just like the Lost Boys, Holden had good reason to leave Seguin all those years ago.
Despite his history, I'm hoping he's willing to find a reason to stay.
316 pages, Kindle Edition
Published November 15, 2023
280 people are currently reading
483 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 137 reviews
July 27, 2024
4.25**** stars
This was… just plain wonderful. I loved how freaking wholesome this first installment was. Ofc hot, also super heartfelt, with a lot of Kelly’s trademark humor and an absolute great introduction into her new series and the Lost Boys with all the found-family love you can ever want.
As for Beckett, the hot and heavily tattooed (kinda) priest and the shop-class teacher’s son, Holden… their romance was sweet, caring and so supporting.
All the Lost Boys gathering together in their hometown Seguin, Texas to honor a man who gave them strength and a safe space. I can’t wait to meet all of them in person in their own book and I already have an inkling as to which lost souls will be the epic finally of the series. Again, I can’t wait.
Declan Winters is a great choice as a new go-to narrator and I’m looking forward to all the audios to come for this series.
side note: I’m pretty curious to learn what Kelly has planned for this Chase guy. If she just painted a homophobic, abusive and terrorizing villain for the series or if she intends on giving us a redemption story similar (although he’s worse) to the one we got for Justin in Sworn Enemy.
***************
Lost Boys Series
Prequel - The Thief - 3.5 stars
Book 1 - The Sceptic - 4.25 stars
Book 2 - The Crush - 4.25 stars
Book 3 - The Punk - 3.5 stars
Book 4 - The Steady - 4.5 stars
“Forgive me, Father, for I have sinned.”
This was… just plain wonderful. I loved how freaking wholesome this first installment was. Ofc hot, also super heartfelt, with a lot of Kelly’s trademark humor and an absolute great introduction into her new series and the Lost Boys with all the found-family love you can ever want.
As for Beckett, the hot and heavily tattooed (kinda) priest and the shop-class teacher’s son, Holden… their romance was sweet, caring and so supporting.
“So you want to sin and yet receive praise?” I asked, squeezing his junk until he whined. “Yes, Father.”
After carefully, deliberately removing every stitch of clothing, he stood in front of me. His demand was silent, but so fucking loud.
All the Lost Boys gathering together in their hometown Seguin, Texas to honor a man who gave them strength and a safe space. I can’t wait to meet all of them in person in their own book and I already have an inkling as to which lost souls will be the epic finally of the series. Again, I can’t wait.
Declan Winters is a great choice as a new go-to narrator and I’m looking forward to all the audios to come for this series.
side note: I’m pretty curious to learn what Kelly has planned for this Chase guy. If she just painted a homophobic, abusive and terrorizing villain for the series or if she intends on giving us a redemption story similar (although he’s worse) to the one we got for Justin in Sworn Enemy.
***************
Lost Boys Series
Prequel - The Thief - 3.5 stars
Book 1 - The Sceptic - 4.25 stars
Book 2 - The Crush - 4.25 stars
Book 3 - The Punk - 3.5 stars
Book 4 - The Steady - 4.5 stars
February 8, 2024
Wholesome romance with a dash of priest-kink.
Before we start - what the heck is this cover? I almost didn’t pick it up because of it. What convinced me were Kati’s review and the fact that Declan Winters is narrating.
And because you kind of know what you get when you read a book by Kelly Fox: usually there’s some kind of a queer group, usually with one older couple (where one of them might or might not die at some point), a mostly queer friendly small town, low drama and a lot of wholesomeness despite a loosely interwoven crime/human trafficking plot and the occasional homophobic prick.
I’m happy to report that we got all of that - even the darker themes are treated in a way that don’t drag you down as a reader, even if I bawled my eyes out when that one older character died.
As for the romance: it was… ok. “Priest-kink” isn’t really “my” jam, usually everything religion-related leaves me uneasy because of the underlying bigotry that (usually) goes along with it. At least Beckett (the “Skeptic”) didn’t continue on his Catholic path that had been pre-picked for him, and I loved the kind of community he created for himself, and the way he talked to his congregation. But that priest-kink stuff where he left his collar on and had his partners call him “Father”- uh. No. Leaves me with an uneasy feeling.
In the other corner we have Holden, who left his hometown before college after a homophobic attack that almost killed him. He returns to the side of his dying father, and he looks for… idk… a break? repentance?… in Beckets arms right after Beckett picks him up at the airport. For a while, he keeps showing up at Becket’s doorstep claiming that he “needs to be put back together”.
I kind of loved it, and kind of didn’t. Tbh I’ve been more invested in the side characters that are being set up for upcoming books than in the main couple. Declan Winters still made it worth my while, but the romance itself fell a bit short for me.
Still: good start in a new series, I’ll definitely continue listening to the audio books!
Before we start - what the heck is this cover? I almost didn’t pick it up because of it. What convinced me were Kati’s review and the fact that Declan Winters is narrating.
And because you kind of know what you get when you read a book by Kelly Fox: usually there’s some kind of a queer group, usually with one older couple (where one of them might or might not die at some point), a mostly queer friendly small town, low drama and a lot of wholesomeness despite a loosely interwoven crime/human trafficking plot and the occasional homophobic prick.
I’m happy to report that we got all of that - even the darker themes are treated in a way that don’t drag you down as a reader, even if I bawled my eyes out when that one older character died.
As for the romance: it was… ok. “Priest-kink” isn’t really “my” jam, usually everything religion-related leaves me uneasy because of the underlying bigotry that (usually) goes along with it. At least Beckett (the “Skeptic”) didn’t continue on his Catholic path that had been pre-picked for him, and I loved the kind of community he created for himself, and the way he talked to his congregation. But that priest-kink stuff where he left his collar on and had his partners call him “Father”- uh. No. Leaves me with an uneasy feeling.
In the other corner we have Holden, who left his hometown before college after a homophobic attack that almost killed him. He returns to the side of his dying father, and he looks for… idk… a break? repentance?… in Beckets arms right after Beckett picks him up at the airport. For a while, he keeps showing up at Becket’s doorstep claiming that he “needs to be put back together”.
I kind of loved it, and kind of didn’t. Tbh I’ve been more invested in the side characters that are being set up for upcoming books than in the main couple. Declan Winters still made it worth my while, but the romance itself fell a bit short for me.
Still: good start in a new series, I’ll definitely continue listening to the audio books!
August 25, 2025
Bad boy priest? SIGN ME UP. I picked this up on a whim because I noticed the series was included on Hoopla, and a bad boy priest is hard to pass up 😂 I'd also never tried anything by Kelly Fox before, so why not, you know? I was pleasantly surprised how much I enjoyed this! I vibed well with Fox's writing style, and I'm already looking forward to the rest of the series.
I went back and forth on my rating for this one, but I think I'm going to settle on 4* rounded up from 3.5*. Beckett and Holden were great together, and I loved their journey, but there were a couple of things that didn't work for me that are keeping me from rating it higher. I don't have time to go into detail, but I found Beckett's entire priest situation unusual, and the things I typically enjoy about the trope didn't work for me here. Also, the pacing toward the end was weird. There was a lot tossed in all of a sudden, and I'm not sure it worked very well.
This was also my first time listening to a book narrated by Declan Winters, and I was NOT disappointed 😌 His voice is very soothing, and I appreciated how well he did with the variety of characters. I'm usually pretty particular when it comes to accents because some narrators do a really cringe job, but I was pleasantly surprised with his Texas drawl. It's been a while since I discovered a new narrator that I've really enjoyed, so I'm excited to listen to him in the rest of the series and to check out more of his audiobook catalog 🎧
I went back and forth on my rating for this one, but I think I'm going to settle on 4* rounded up from 3.5*. Beckett and Holden were great together, and I loved their journey, but there were a couple of things that didn't work for me that are keeping me from rating it higher. I don't have time to go into detail, but I found Beckett's entire priest situation unusual, and the things I typically enjoy about the trope didn't work for me here. Also, the pacing toward the end was weird. There was a lot tossed in all of a sudden, and I'm not sure it worked very well.
This was also my first time listening to a book narrated by Declan Winters, and I was NOT disappointed 😌 His voice is very soothing, and I appreciated how well he did with the variety of characters. I'm usually pretty particular when it comes to accents because some narrators do a really cringe job, but I was pleasantly surprised with his Texas drawl. It's been a while since I discovered a new narrator that I've really enjoyed, so I'm excited to listen to him in the rest of the series and to check out more of his audiobook catalog 🎧
October 29, 2024
As soon as I had time to finish the first chapter, I full on devoured this book. It was so much fun. As someone who was raised in faith and by Christian parents, I loved Becketts views on his ministry. The spice was reallyyy good, all the characters and lost boys were great and I can’t wait to get to know all the lost boys a bit more. I bawled my eyes out at some parts. Overall such a great read!
🩷🩷 shout out to Bree for the recommendation!
🩷🩷 shout out to Bree for the recommendation!
February 2, 2024
3.5 stars rounded up
This was cute. The sex was 👌👌 Priest kink ftw. As for the rest, I am intrigued to see all the "Lost Boys" find their HEA.
This was cute. The sex was 👌👌 Priest kink ftw. As for the rest, I am intrigued to see all the "Lost Boys" find their HEA.
July 5, 2024
3.25 stars
November 15, 2023
Once again, Kelly Fox made me cry... big fat tears... not because Holden has a priest kink and Beckett is a non-denominational minister, but because she tore me up and put me back together more than once in this story.
Not only do we get steamy scenes, great world building and a sweet HEA, we get cameos from so many of the characters from previous worlds AND a little foreshadowing of what's to come with future "Lost Boys". If you are a fan of Kelly's previous worlds, you'll find great rep in the pop up side characters visiting Texas... make sure you have tissues handy and get ready for a roller coaster of emotions as you start this next chapter with The Skeptic!
Not only do we get steamy scenes, great world building and a sweet HEA, we get cameos from so many of the characters from previous worlds AND a little foreshadowing of what's to come with future "Lost Boys". If you are a fan of Kelly's previous worlds, you'll find great rep in the pop up side characters visiting Texas... make sure you have tissues handy and get ready for a roller coaster of emotions as you start this next chapter with The Skeptic!
December 19, 2023
4.5 rounded to 5
After enjoying the introduction novella to this new Kelly Fox series I was excited to get to know the Lost Boys more and I was not disappointed. An abundance of found family , queer support & love, hurt /comfort , high steam , priest / sinner role play , loss of a parent, ALL the feels ( y'all I shed more than a few years ) , a sprinkle of cameos from past Kelly Fox series ( but not enough for someone to feel left out , just a treat for fans) , a happy ending to put a smile on your face . I honestly don't know which Lost Boys
I'm most excited to get a HEA because I'm so excited for them all .
Favorite Quotes :
After enjoying the introduction novella to this new Kelly Fox series I was excited to get to know the Lost Boys more and I was not disappointed. An abundance of found family , queer support & love, hurt /comfort , high steam , priest / sinner role play , loss of a parent, ALL the feels ( y'all I shed more than a few years ) , a sprinkle of cameos from past Kelly Fox series ( but not enough for someone to feel left out , just a treat for fans) , a happy ending to put a smile on your face . I honestly don't know which Lost Boys
I'm most excited to get a HEA because I'm so excited for them all .
Favorite Quotes :
December 14, 2024
I did not expect this book to be so emotional???
Beckett is a skeptical priest. He’s tattooed and gay but still preaches and uses his influence to do so much good in a small Texas town. He’s happy hooking up occasionally and lives a simple life.
Holden was assaulted by a bully as a kid and left the town he calls home. When his Pop’s health deteriorates, he comes back so he can be with both his dads!
I did not see the pain coming. And ouch. Mr. Paige (Holden’s dad) helped so many queer kids in need, including Beckett. He was such a father figure to all of them and I adored him.
The lost boys are such a cute found family. Absolutely can’t wait to read more!
I am obsessed with Father Beckett and his wicked ways! He was such a caretaker and the way he loved Holden and was there for him was so damn lovely. It was beautiful seeing their relationship slowly build!
The religious aspect of the book combined with all the queer rep healed something in me!
Beckett is a skeptical priest. He’s tattooed and gay but still preaches and uses his influence to do so much good in a small Texas town. He’s happy hooking up occasionally and lives a simple life.
Holden was assaulted by a bully as a kid and left the town he calls home. When his Pop’s health deteriorates, he comes back so he can be with both his dads!
I did not see the pain coming. And ouch. Mr. Paige (Holden’s dad) helped so many queer kids in need, including Beckett. He was such a father figure to all of them and I adored him.
The lost boys are such a cute found family. Absolutely can’t wait to read more!
I am obsessed with Father Beckett and his wicked ways! He was such a caretaker and the way he loved Holden and was there for him was so damn lovely. It was beautiful seeing their relationship slowly build!
The religious aspect of the book combined with all the queer rep healed something in me!
September 9, 2024
From the foreword:
"A Catholic seminary dropout who's questioning the divine and willing to leave the collar on if a lover asks nicely"
That's my kind of book 😂
I loved the found family and lost boys theme. Being accepted and loved no matter what, finding your person and falling for them. Giving back.
I was a little confused by all those side characters, and the villain seemed to pop up at the most convenient times, but I'm excited to read the next book.
"A Catholic seminary dropout who's questioning the divine and willing to leave the collar on if a lover asks nicely"
That's my kind of book 😂
I loved the found family and lost boys theme. Being accepted and loved no matter what, finding your person and falling for them. Giving back.
I was a little confused by all those side characters, and the villain seemed to pop up at the most convenient times, but I'm excited to read the next book.
April 12, 2024
Smut was fun and sweet but basically everything else? Somehow both overwhelming and kinda boring. There were a million side characters and subplots and not nearly enough about the actual *romance*. Some good messaging and the writing itself was good, but the story as a whole was not executed well imo. And the pacing was truly wild tbh. Overall meh, but I’ll probably give this author another try in the future.
October 21, 2025
Enjoyable listen I must say! Beckett and Holden were so funny and hot together 🥰 I may have listen to this just for Declan Winters voice, but hey - I loved it 🤗
Will see if I continue with this series!
Will see if I continue with this series!
June 13, 2024
4.25 ⭐️ - it’s just so precious.
December 11, 2023
All the feels
4.5 stars! I read only one book by Kelly Fox before and it wasn’t my favorite so I put her in the ‘probably won’t read again’ category in my mind. But give me a priest on the cover and I might just show up. And I’m glad I did because I really enjoyed The Skeptic! Very interesting discussions about religion and sexuality. The light priest k!nk and praise k!nk was sexy and well done. It also made me tear up, so it’s got all the feels. :) Will be checking out more in this series.
4.5 stars! I read only one book by Kelly Fox before and it wasn’t my favorite so I put her in the ‘probably won’t read again’ category in my mind. But give me a priest on the cover and I might just show up. And I’m glad I did because I really enjoyed The Skeptic! Very interesting discussions about religion and sexuality. The light priest k!nk and praise k!nk was sexy and well done. It also made me tear up, so it’s got all the feels. :) Will be checking out more in this series.
December 18, 2023
Absolutely fantastic!
There was never any question as to if the books in this universe were good because the stories have never disappointed. The issues always came down to poor editing. The books were inconsistent, lacked continuity, and were a grammatical mess. It made me sad and angry and annoyed to sit there and give them such low ratings, and I’m beyond excited to say that I don’t have to do that this time. It’s not even a thing on my radar.
The editing was solid, even if a few issues cropped up in the last ~20%. I still want clarification on the whole Leo and Lyle thing, but I’m honestly willing to let it go and overlook it. One or two things here and there are such a massive step up from before and I can definitely give credit where it’s due.
The main characters, this new town and bubble of space in this universe, the new cast of satellite characters, the story…all of it was amazing. I love Beckett and Holden so much. I want to be their friend so bad. The spice was E X T R E M E L Y nice, and I will not feel sorry for thinking the opening lines of the book were perfection.
We’re also not talking about the ugly crying and hysterical laughter I had going on throughout because we’re nice and respectful like that.
And the quotes…😗🤌🏽
I cannot tell you how much I love this new series. I can’t wait for the next book. My patience is thin because I’m overeager to hear all of the Lost Boys tell their stories. The game has changed and even though I will still never forgive The Wimberly Chronicles for existing, I’m happy that I stuck it out and made it this far. This is The Best of the Best.
4.5/5. I’m gonna need to readjust my views on religion (not really) because I’m pretty sure Beckett created one that actually works. And seeing Jules again gives me hope that another book as good as Scout’s is coming🥺🙏🏽
There was never any question as to if the books in this universe were good because the stories have never disappointed. The issues always came down to poor editing. The books were inconsistent, lacked continuity, and were a grammatical mess. It made me sad and angry and annoyed to sit there and give them such low ratings, and I’m beyond excited to say that I don’t have to do that this time. It’s not even a thing on my radar.
The editing was solid, even if a few issues cropped up in the last ~20%. I still want clarification on the whole Leo and Lyle thing, but I’m honestly willing to let it go and overlook it. One or two things here and there are such a massive step up from before and I can definitely give credit where it’s due.
The main characters, this new town and bubble of space in this universe, the new cast of satellite characters, the story…all of it was amazing. I love Beckett and Holden so much. I want to be their friend so bad. The spice was E X T R E M E L Y nice, and I will not feel sorry for thinking the opening lines of the book were perfection.
We’re also not talking about the ugly crying and hysterical laughter I had going on throughout because we’re nice and respectful like that.
And the quotes…😗🤌🏽
I cannot tell you how much I love this new series. I can’t wait for the next book. My patience is thin because I’m overeager to hear all of the Lost Boys tell their stories. The game has changed and even though I will still never forgive The Wimberly Chronicles for existing, I’m happy that I stuck it out and made it this far. This is The Best of the Best.
4.5/5. I’m gonna need to readjust my views on religion (not really) because I’m pretty sure Beckett created one that actually works. And seeing Jules again gives me hope that another book as good as Scout’s is coming🥺🙏🏽
November 15, 2023
Father Beckett!
I adore Kelly Fox and have absolutely loved everything she’s written and haven’t been disappointed yet. The Skeptic has a different feel too it from her other series. This story has a softer feel to it and I absolutely adored that. Beckett’s view on being a preacher and whether or not God exists was actually very enlightening and I completely understood where he was coming from. Holden came into the story needing something soft and loving and his and Beckett’s spicy scenes were just that, granted, they were also HOT with Holden calling Beckett “Father” and wanting him to leave his collar on!
The main story revolves around Beckett and Holden but there is a second important arc that just broke me! Mr. Paige’s health and eventually decline was devastating. I cried so hard at the initial scene and several times throughout the rest of the story, though those later tears were mixes of sad and happy tears. Thru the tears though, there was laughter and joy and growth. I adored meeting this crew of Lost Boys and seeing how Mr. Paige brought them into his fold and they all came together no matter what for one another.
Needless to say, I truly loved this story and the softer feel of it. I loved seeing all the connections to Wild Heart Ranch and seeing Jules again ( I really hope we get a story from her. She seems truly amazing!!)
One thing I do NOT want to see in future Lost Boys books is a redemptive arc for Chase Dewitt. Not everyone needs to be redeemed. Chase needs to go crawl into a hole and disappear from Seguin from now into eternity.
I adore Kelly Fox and have absolutely loved everything she’s written and haven’t been disappointed yet. The Skeptic has a different feel too it from her other series. This story has a softer feel to it and I absolutely adored that. Beckett’s view on being a preacher and whether or not God exists was actually very enlightening and I completely understood where he was coming from. Holden came into the story needing something soft and loving and his and Beckett’s spicy scenes were just that, granted, they were also HOT with Holden calling Beckett “Father” and wanting him to leave his collar on!
The main story revolves around Beckett and Holden but there is a second important arc that just broke me! Mr. Paige’s health and eventually decline was devastating. I cried so hard at the initial scene and several times throughout the rest of the story, though those later tears were mixes of sad and happy tears. Thru the tears though, there was laughter and joy and growth. I adored meeting this crew of Lost Boys and seeing how Mr. Paige brought them into his fold and they all came together no matter what for one another.
Needless to say, I truly loved this story and the softer feel of it. I loved seeing all the connections to Wild Heart Ranch and seeing Jules again ( I really hope we get a story from her. She seems truly amazing!!)
One thing I do NOT want to see in future Lost Boys books is a redemptive arc for Chase Dewitt. Not everyone needs to be redeemed. Chase needs to go crawl into a hole and disappear from Seguin from now into eternity.
November 13, 2023
Anything Kelly Fox writes is an auto-read for me. I just love how interwoven all her stories are. It’s filled with love, sadness, pain, hope, basically all the feelings. As one would come to expect from a KF book. Holden and Beckett are very sweet together and come into each other’s lives at the right time. I’m not sure anything I say can do it justice - be prepared to laugh and cry out loud. I am so excited to read more in this new series!
December 20, 2023
This is a wonderful start to a new series! In this story, Beckett is a tattooed, skeptical non-denominational minister who wonders about the existence of God while he's also very committed to serving his community, especially at-risk LGBT+ youth. He exists on occasional hook-ups, only connecting with men fairly far from his own home in Seguin, Texas. He's one of the Lost Boys, a group of queer friends who became close in high school while mentored and protected by gay shop teacher, Mr. Paige. They are now coming back to Seguin to help support Mr. Paige and his husband while Mr. Paige deals with two severe, damaging bouts of pneumonia.
Holden is Mr. Paige's adopted son, who has stayed away from Seguin for years, although his fathers came to visit him periodically. Holden was badly beaten in a homophobic attack while in high school and returning to the place where his attacker still live has been too triggering. Now, however, with his father seriously ill, Holden braves his fears to return while also breaking up with his cheating boyfriend.
Holden and Beckett meet and spend time together. Holden needs some comforting in these difficult times and turns to Beckett for affection and passion. It doesn't hurt that he has a priest kink that Beckett fills perfectly. What begins as a one-time hook-up becomes more. Can these two men overcome the obstacles, danger, and grief they must encounter?
The book lightly introduces members of the Lost Boys who will likely star in upcoming books in the series. There is also a nice tie-in to a few characters from the Wild Heart Ranch and Rebel Sky Ranch series, as they are located in the same general vicinity. The writing has just the right blend of kink, kindness, friendship, passion, danger, and delight. I look forward to reading every book in this series.
Holden is Mr. Paige's adopted son, who has stayed away from Seguin for years, although his fathers came to visit him periodically. Holden was badly beaten in a homophobic attack while in high school and returning to the place where his attacker still live has been too triggering. Now, however, with his father seriously ill, Holden braves his fears to return while also breaking up with his cheating boyfriend.
Holden and Beckett meet and spend time together. Holden needs some comforting in these difficult times and turns to Beckett for affection and passion. It doesn't hurt that he has a priest kink that Beckett fills perfectly. What begins as a one-time hook-up becomes more. Can these two men overcome the obstacles, danger, and grief they must encounter?
The book lightly introduces members of the Lost Boys who will likely star in upcoming books in the series. There is also a nice tie-in to a few characters from the Wild Heart Ranch and Rebel Sky Ranch series, as they are located in the same general vicinity. The writing has just the right blend of kink, kindness, friendship, passion, danger, and delight. I look forward to reading every book in this series.
Read
January 22, 2024I was not a fan of the first book in this series, but I was so intrigued by the concept of this book that I couldn't resist giving it a try. Unfortunately, this was an immediate dnf.
No rating, because this is my own fault for not thinking through the trigger warnings. Please absolutely definitely heed the content warnings, as the story begins with a sexual encounter between a priest and a seminary student (which is presented as consensual, but there is a power dynamic there that some would take issue with and it is presented as the student 'seducing' the priest).
No rating, because this is my own fault for not thinking through the trigger warnings. Please absolutely definitely heed the content warnings, as the story begins with a sexual encounter between a priest and a seminary student (which is presented as consensual, but there is a power dynamic there that some would take issue with and it is presented as the student 'seducing' the priest).
December 11, 2025
4.5 ⭐️ a seriously good read. Low angst, but quite a few tears. This was my first Kelly Fox book, but certainly won’t be my last, I’m starting book 2 today. I loved the skeptic and all the lost boys.
April 26, 2024
so this started amazing... and that's it.
January 29, 2024
Way too many characters
So, I went into this book thinking it was a standalone (in this series) and nope. Peoples names kept being dropped left and right and I was so completely confused on who the heck everyone was.
Apparently this author likes to have characters from other series make lots of guest appearances in all the other ones she writes too. Mentioning that the reader should perhaps read the other series (and list which ones to read), would have been better.
There’s also so many Lost Boys, random side characters, and teens in this book that I still have no idea who is who. I get having to know about a group of people for a new series, but this was like an absolute info dump of random people and how they fit in with who, what and where.
So, I went into this book thinking it was a standalone (in this series) and nope. Peoples names kept being dropped left and right and I was so completely confused on who the heck everyone was.
Apparently this author likes to have characters from other series make lots of guest appearances in all the other ones she writes too. Mentioning that the reader should perhaps read the other series (and list which ones to read), would have been better.
There’s also so many Lost Boys, random side characters, and teens in this book that I still have no idea who is who. I get having to know about a group of people for a new series, but this was like an absolute info dump of random people and how they fit in with who, what and where.
January 3, 2024
I used to really love Kelly Fox’s books, but it seems that lately her stories just aren’t grabbing me.
I didn’t feel much chemistry between Holden and Beckett. They jumped into bed together too quickly for any chemistry/tension to build, so for me the story was quite boring. I like the idea of this story but it’s just lacking something for me.
I didn’t feel much chemistry between Holden and Beckett. They jumped into bed together too quickly for any chemistry/tension to build, so for me the story was quite boring. I like the idea of this story but it’s just lacking something for me.
November 14, 2023
This book easily works as a stand-alone, but I’ve now seen Beckett in two previous works by Fox (the finale of her Wild Heart Ranch series and the prequel to this series) and already knew I was intrigued by this character. I’m generally not keen on religious characters, but Fox has turned into an author I trust to handle all issues with care, so I was willing to make the leap here. It turns out that Beckett is the literal opposite of everything generally hate about religious characters, and therefore I absolutely adore him. He is truly the skeptic the title indicates, and that makes his care and dedication to his friends and community all the more genuine and valuable.
Holden is a bit more “stereotypical” as a character (which actually makes him an anomaly in Fox’s books), but sometimes that’s exactly what the story calls for. We didn’t meet him in the prequel, for good reason, and his return to his hometown may be unplanned but comes at the right time nonetheless. I knew immediately that he would be quietly badass in his own way, and that was with only hints of his backstory and before he turned up the heat with his seduction game.
At first, I thought Fox had just figured out a fun way to give us some early spice before the traditional romance arc unfolded between these characters. Instead, she upends everything I expected about this book, making me cry harder than I did in any of her series that involved heavier issues like human trafficking. Though she may have broken my heart for real this time, it’s clear that Fox doesn’t hurt her readers lightly. The pain in this book is necessary for the main characters to bloom, and it may be the first in the series, but the theme of legacy is sure to reverberate through each of the books that come after.
Thus, we don’t necessarily get a traditional romance arc for what develops between Beckett and Holden, but it’s still an important and lovely story that highlights the difficulty of loving someone during and through a time of personal and emotional upheaval. Along the way, Becket and Holden also undergo excellent individual character development. Both may have fraught moments that involve confronting their pasts, but the results secure a better future for everyone.
I have the feeling that Beckett and Holden have been passed the mantle of caretaker for this lovely community of Lost Boys, and I look forward to seeing them in truly supportive roles through the rest of this series.
Disclaimer: I received a digital review copy of this book from the author.
Holden is a bit more “stereotypical” as a character (which actually makes him an anomaly in Fox’s books), but sometimes that’s exactly what the story calls for. We didn’t meet him in the prequel, for good reason, and his return to his hometown may be unplanned but comes at the right time nonetheless. I knew immediately that he would be quietly badass in his own way, and that was with only hints of his backstory and before he turned up the heat with his seduction game.
At first, I thought Fox had just figured out a fun way to give us some early spice before the traditional romance arc unfolded between these characters. Instead, she upends everything I expected about this book, making me cry harder than I did in any of her series that involved heavier issues like human trafficking. Though she may have broken my heart for real this time, it’s clear that Fox doesn’t hurt her readers lightly. The pain in this book is necessary for the main characters to bloom, and it may be the first in the series, but the theme of legacy is sure to reverberate through each of the books that come after.
Thus, we don’t necessarily get a traditional romance arc for what develops between Beckett and Holden, but it’s still an important and lovely story that highlights the difficulty of loving someone during and through a time of personal and emotional upheaval. Along the way, Becket and Holden also undergo excellent individual character development. Both may have fraught moments that involve confronting their pasts, but the results secure a better future for everyone.
I have the feeling that Beckett and Holden have been passed the mantle of caretaker for this lovely community of Lost Boys, and I look forward to seeing them in truly supportive roles through the rest of this series.
Disclaimer: I received a digital review copy of this book from the author.
February 5, 2024
This book is LONG. Probably far longer than it needed to be. There was a ton of fluff and unnecessary environment plotting, BUUUUUUT, it was still good. This book follows rouge priest/minister Beckett and the son of Mr. Paige (founder of the Lost Boys), Holden. Holden is finally informed that his father was in the hospital and flees a failed relationship and a draining job to be closer to his father. Beckett is sent to pick him up when he arrives and the chemistry is off the charts. They stick together through some really tough things and live their life with their friends and family once the dust settles.
I am going to find a nice soapbox now:
Like I mentioned earlier, this book is long. So long. It is a very easy read and the pacing is great, but I found myself wondering why certain information was included. Maybe it's just me because I am from Texas and near the area that this book takes place in, but I cannot see a single reason why every highway/toll road in the area needs to be named. Or the specific art installations at the airport. I know the author is from Texas and visited Seguin but this, at times, felt like more of a brochure of Seguin/Austin/SA, than a romance telling.
As someone that lives near the town and has a husband that lived in Seguin, I am aware that the times are changing. However, this is still Texas and while there was some conflict, it did not seem at all realistic to the actual environment. Even in Austin, arguably one of the most (if not THE most) liberal/accepting cities in Texas, it is still not as openly inviting as the author portrays it to be. Again, this is still Texas.
Anywho, I did enjoy the book for the most part. It just required me to live in a state of semi-suspended reality while I read it. There is conflict in the story, but it just seemed... unrealistic? Off? I don't know. I just can NOT envision a man being able to wear the cloth/collar while not being actually ordained and no one batting an eye.
This review probably makes the book sound less than great, but it really is good for those looking for a low angst, cozy read. It just apparently summoned both my opinions on small town Texas and the Church in one fell swoop. 🤣
I am going to find a nice soapbox now:
Like I mentioned earlier, this book is long. So long. It is a very easy read and the pacing is great, but I found myself wondering why certain information was included. Maybe it's just me because I am from Texas and near the area that this book takes place in, but I cannot see a single reason why every highway/toll road in the area needs to be named. Or the specific art installations at the airport. I know the author is from Texas and visited Seguin but this, at times, felt like more of a brochure of Seguin/Austin/SA, than a romance telling.
As someone that lives near the town and has a husband that lived in Seguin, I am aware that the times are changing. However, this is still Texas and while there was some conflict, it did not seem at all realistic to the actual environment. Even in Austin, arguably one of the most (if not THE most) liberal/accepting cities in Texas, it is still not as openly inviting as the author portrays it to be. Again, this is still Texas.
Anywho, I did enjoy the book for the most part. It just required me to live in a state of semi-suspended reality while I read it. There is conflict in the story, but it just seemed... unrealistic? Off? I don't know. I just can NOT envision a man being able to wear the cloth/collar while not being actually ordained and no one batting an eye.
This review probably makes the book sound less than great, but it really is good for those looking for a low angst, cozy read. It just apparently summoned both my opinions on small town Texas and the Church in one fell swoop. 🤣
June 20, 2025
4.5 stars (not perfect, but important for me)!
I absolutely did not see this one coming. Every readathon, I gamble on one wild card—something that’s been lurking in my queue, quietly waiting to knock the wind out of me. The Skeptic wasn’t just a pleasant surprise; it was a full-on emotional ambush, disguised as a taboo romance audiobook.
Let’s start with Father Beckett. Tattooed. Weathered. A walking contradiction. He’s a priest who cusses just enough, and wrestles with his own unravelling faith like it’s a living thing. He’s no saviour, but he tries to be a shepherd to the Lost Boys—a found family of bruised and beautiful souls clinging to each other through grief and shame. And Holden? My precious boy. He comes home after a trauma so brutal it reshaped him. He’s grieving a father who's fading and a version of himself that never got the chance to exist.
What unfolds between them isn’t insta-love—it’s slower, messier. It's grief meeting purpose, loss meeting longing, faith meeting flesh. Yes, it is insta-LUST, but the emotional bond felt really authentic. Their bond doesn't bloom—it scars, it cracks open, it hurts. And it heals.
Yes, the story dips into familiar beats. You might call parts of it surface-level, but that would miss the point. It’s smart without being pretentious, tender without losing bite. The theology isn’t weaponised—it’s worn-in, lived-through, still questioning. It doesn’t ask you to believe—it asks you to witness. And that alone makes it special.
Let’s talk about the smut because *holy* hell. It’s not there to titillate—it’s there to reveal. The scenes are soulful and sharp, reverent and raw. It's not about shame, which is new for a priest/taboo romance. Because this one does not treat sex as taboo, (unusual but not taboo) but it wants and tries to reclaim something sacred in the ruin. It’s not about a priest screwing for shock value—it’s about two broken bodies and misunderstood souls meeting like a prayer.
In short: The Skeptic is a devastatingly beautiful book that threads theology, trauma, grief and desire into something both irreverent and holy.
I absolutely did not see this one coming. Every readathon, I gamble on one wild card—something that’s been lurking in my queue, quietly waiting to knock the wind out of me. The Skeptic wasn’t just a pleasant surprise; it was a full-on emotional ambush, disguised as a taboo romance audiobook.
Let’s start with Father Beckett. Tattooed. Weathered. A walking contradiction. He’s a priest who cusses just enough, and wrestles with his own unravelling faith like it’s a living thing. He’s no saviour, but he tries to be a shepherd to the Lost Boys—a found family of bruised and beautiful souls clinging to each other through grief and shame. And Holden? My precious boy. He comes home after a trauma so brutal it reshaped him. He’s grieving a father who's fading and a version of himself that never got the chance to exist.
What unfolds between them isn’t insta-love—it’s slower, messier. It's grief meeting purpose, loss meeting longing, faith meeting flesh. Yes, it is insta-LUST, but the emotional bond felt really authentic. Their bond doesn't bloom—it scars, it cracks open, it hurts. And it heals.
Yes, the story dips into familiar beats. You might call parts of it surface-level, but that would miss the point. It’s smart without being pretentious, tender without losing bite. The theology isn’t weaponised—it’s worn-in, lived-through, still questioning. It doesn’t ask you to believe—it asks you to witness. And that alone makes it special.
Let’s talk about the smut because *holy* hell. It’s not there to titillate—it’s there to reveal. The scenes are soulful and sharp, reverent and raw. It's not about shame, which is new for a priest/taboo romance. Because this one does not treat sex as taboo, (unusual but not taboo) but it wants and tries to reclaim something sacred in the ruin. It’s not about a priest screwing for shock value—it’s about two broken bodies and misunderstood souls meeting like a prayer.
In short: The Skeptic is a devastatingly beautiful book that threads theology, trauma, grief and desire into something both irreverent and holy.
November 15, 2023
Review - The skeptic by Kelly Fox
5 🌈
Kelly is a one click author for me, half the time i don't read the blurb fully i’ll just jump right in. The Skeptic reminded me of why this is. This gave me the feels similar to when I read Kelly’s Wrecked and rebel sky series. There’s something about grief, comedy and spice in a book that only Kelly can seem to master (for me anyway). I knew the hurt and tears would be kissed better along the way. Having seen a little of Beckett in previous books I was really looking forward to getting to know him better. Beckett isn't like any man of the cloth that i've met and i'm totally here for it.
Holden and Beckett meet again when Beckett picks him up from the airport as a favour for Mr paige. They instantly have chemistry that is on fire. And this leads to the first of many spicey encounters. Seeing these two fall for each other around their grief and events that could test a couple really felt like something special. Mr paige (pops) really made something amazing when he found his lost boy’s. They are more than just a group of friends, they are a found family. There for each other and the Paiges no matter what.
I can't wait to learn more about all Mr Paiges lost boys, I can already tell that Kelly has started another series that will be special to me in its own little way. I loved the little cameo’s throughout this book and it wouldn't be a book by Mrs Fox if Anders wasn't mentioned. I may have had a happy dance when Jules popped up. I'm now left wondering how much English breakfast tea I need to ship to Kelly to get Jules and Ginger's story 😂 .
I received a copy in return for my honest review
5 🌈
Kelly is a one click author for me, half the time i don't read the blurb fully i’ll just jump right in. The Skeptic reminded me of why this is. This gave me the feels similar to when I read Kelly’s Wrecked and rebel sky series. There’s something about grief, comedy and spice in a book that only Kelly can seem to master (for me anyway). I knew the hurt and tears would be kissed better along the way. Having seen a little of Beckett in previous books I was really looking forward to getting to know him better. Beckett isn't like any man of the cloth that i've met and i'm totally here for it.
Holden and Beckett meet again when Beckett picks him up from the airport as a favour for Mr paige. They instantly have chemistry that is on fire. And this leads to the first of many spicey encounters. Seeing these two fall for each other around their grief and events that could test a couple really felt like something special. Mr paige (pops) really made something amazing when he found his lost boy’s. They are more than just a group of friends, they are a found family. There for each other and the Paiges no matter what.
I can't wait to learn more about all Mr Paiges lost boys, I can already tell that Kelly has started another series that will be special to me in its own little way. I loved the little cameo’s throughout this book and it wouldn't be a book by Mrs Fox if Anders wasn't mentioned. I may have had a happy dance when Jules popped up. I'm now left wondering how much English breakfast tea I need to ship to Kelly to get Jules and Ginger's story 😂 .
I received a copy in return for my honest review
February 22, 2024
Here I am, just trying to live, and Kelly Fox delivers a book that gave me EVERY FEELING simultaneously with what may amount to a bucket of tears.
I LOVED this book.
Every single star.
The Skeptic is set in Seguin, a small town in Texas with a budding queer community. The series is set around the "Lost Boys," a group of queer adults who were mentored as teens by their beloved shop teacher, Mr. PAIGE. The adults either stayed or are in the process of moving back to reclaim their town and be a part of the growing changes.
The Skeptic is Beckett and Holden's story. Beckett, the tattooed preacher who questions the existence of God and believes in ministering and helping his community. Holden, Mr. Paige's son, who [redacted] but moves back to Seguin to be with his parents.
I can't recommend this book enough. It's set in Kelly's Texas universe. So you see familiar faces, but this new group really captures the heart.
💚 Beckett's care and kindness
🩵 sweet Holden with his religion k!nk
💜 Ren! And Pops. But REN, and their love 😭😭
💚 the found family vibes are immaculate
💜 the Chase story is hard to read, but important
🩵 the way the community shows up
💚 Carl!
🩵 the epilouge, oh my god
To say I loved this book is an understatement. This was the hug I needed with the community vibes that make me excited to read the next book. Which I will start immediately when I'm home.
Kelly is a real artist.
I loved Beckett and Holden.
I can't wait to see them in the next book.
" I imagined scooping out handfuls of that black tar from my insides and letting the wind take it. By the time we hit the Idaho border, I felt free."
I LOVED this book.
Every single star.
The Skeptic is set in Seguin, a small town in Texas with a budding queer community. The series is set around the "Lost Boys," a group of queer adults who were mentored as teens by their beloved shop teacher, Mr. PAIGE. The adults either stayed or are in the process of moving back to reclaim their town and be a part of the growing changes.
The Skeptic is Beckett and Holden's story. Beckett, the tattooed preacher who questions the existence of God and believes in ministering and helping his community. Holden, Mr. Paige's son, who [redacted] but moves back to Seguin to be with his parents.
I can't recommend this book enough. It's set in Kelly's Texas universe. So you see familiar faces, but this new group really captures the heart.
💚 Beckett's care and kindness
🩵 sweet Holden with his religion k!nk
💜 Ren! And Pops. But REN, and their love 😭😭
💚 the found family vibes are immaculate
💜 the Chase story is hard to read, but important
🩵 the way the community shows up
💚 Carl!
🩵 the epilouge, oh my god
To say I loved this book is an understatement. This was the hug I needed with the community vibes that make me excited to read the next book. Which I will start immediately when I'm home.
Kelly is a real artist.
I loved Beckett and Holden.
I can't wait to see them in the next book.
" I imagined scooping out handfuls of that black tar from my insides and letting the wind take it. By the time we hit the Idaho border, I felt free."
Displaying 1 - 30 of 137 reviews