How I Came To Read This Book: I got a review copy from the publisher. I picked it because I liked the idea of a nonfiction fashion memoir from a young & buzzy writer – great pick for your sartorial-addicted best friend.
The Plot: Truth be told I wasn’t really familiar with Leandra Medine or her blog, Man Repeller, prior to reading this book. I only obliquely knew who she was through an appearance on Project Runway / checking out her blog once shortly after that. But as it turns out, based on the fact she WAS on PR and has a book, she’s obviously ‘kind of a big deal.’ The gist of the book takes pieces from Leandra’s wardrobe – from her childhood to adulthood – and ties them into specific personal and sartorial memories, many of which are cringe-worthy but humanizing. The essays are very chronological and while they often spend the first half delving deep into a fashion moment, by the second half of each essay we are propelled into a dissection of Leandra’s friends, family and love life.
The Good & The Bad: Another book I struggle with rating. I feel like if I was already a diehard Man Repeller fan I would have been a lot more involved and interested. As it was, I polished off the book in pretty short order – in part because it’s fluffy, but also because it is pretty digestible, fun, and thoughtful. I was a little frustrated that each essay meandered so far from the source topic – to the point where I kept on flipping to the front of the chapter to remind myself what we were discussing – but she ultimately (usually) brought the topic back by the end of the essay. Beyond that, I liked that the story was chronological, and the essays were ultimately linked, tying in repeated elements that made for an almost novel-like read.
While I was pleasantly amused for the first three quarters of the book, I didn’t entirely know where the story was going until we got to the Canadian Tuxedo chapter, which highlights how Man Repeller came to be – the idea being that Leandra’s love for fashion (and off-kilter sense of style) was ultimately conflicting with her love life and ability to ‘attract a man’. From there, the book takes a sort of serious turn. In general, I was surprised how much the book focused – quite candidly – on her love life. I thought she was kind of psychotic for spending so much time focused on her ex Abie, although by the end of the story, it all made sense (spoiler alert: they get married). While I personally quite enjoyed the Hermes clutch story, I thought the final chapters were some of the most insightful, as Leandra explores what marriage means to a young, modern woman that also holds traditional Jewish beliefs quite dearly. The chapter she wrote where she reveals what it was like to reveal her big engagement was also interesting – although rang a little false or irritated at the same time. There’s no problem with that though. As Leandra points out in a memorable passage, the internet is a voyeuristic place, and giving people some insight to your life can make you a star – while I get she was sorta apologetic about the engagement running converse to her blog’s ‘fashion over dudes’ persona, I actually kind of appreciated that I personally felt like I could see through it and that she really (understandably) feels like it ain’t no thang to get all worked up about.
So while there were a lot of enjoyable things to the book, as someone that doesn’t regularly read Man Repeller, I have to say there were some other things I didn’t like. Leandra strikes me as sort of a fashion blogger version of Lena Dunham; someone that grew up in a rather privileged, wealthy home and was able to use that as a springboard to make waves in the fashion industry. She honestly seems to take for granted how lucky she is (particularly in her flippant breakdown of her wedding in the final chapter). Not too many people get hand-me-down Chanel, or interview for a Valentino internship at eighteen, nor do they have Rebecca Minkoff custom-designing a leather moto jacket for a grand New York wedding. It seriously made my eyes roll that she was so glib about her wedding yet bought a friggin’ Marchesa gown. I mean really? I definitely don’t want to discredit her as I respect she made a name for herself in the industry with nary a fashion design credit to her name – but something about her persona just felt entitled and pretentious, and the anecdotes bordered this strange line between being really showy (some of the hipper-than-thou writing was a little icky, although in line with her blog’s voice) and really humanizing.
I’m not sure where I land on it. Do I think Leandra is the most relatable person on the planet? No, not by a mile. She is not the free spirited girl she likes to paint herself as - not with the upper crusty background and support network she's got. But I’d hesitate to call her a snob either: it takes quite a woman to speak about three deadly period experiences to the intimate degree she does here. And yet...I wonder. Why write the book at all, aside from money to buy more fabulous clothes? To present yourself as an everygirl? To give fans some bonus content? To justify your marriage? It’s a weird thing to be an outsider reading this book, and I wonder whether this is what Man Repeller fans will really be looking for. I liked the book, but I’m not so sure about what Leandra was trying to accomplish for herself.
The Bottom Line: Witty and fluffy, yet grounded with some genuine (at times pretentious) insights, the book charms more than the author.
Anything Memorable?: Truthfully, this book made me want to go shopping. Or at the very least, play around in my wardrobe a bit more. I have a new obsession with purchasing some booties.
60-Book Challenge?: Book #53 in 2013