Really? I can't believe this got so many good reviews, because I couldn't find a single redeeming quality in it. Ugh. Terrible protagonist, flat characters, and boring storyline (wait, a storyline? where?!). I guess a pretty cover isn't everything.
--
Full Review:
There have been some great entries into the YA fantasy world lately with angel lore, and after reading many positive reviews for this one, I thought I'd give it a shot. (It also didn't hurt that the cover is so gorgeous.)
Within the first 50 pages, I was pretty certain I wasn't a fan of this story. By the end, I actively despised it. Why? Let's start with the narrator, Violet. We've all heard this story before--teenage girl discovers she has some great, world-altering destiny, and life as she knows it is over. I agree that there needs to be some sort of adjustment period, because for anyone, that would be hard to swallow. But Violet Eden (yes, that's really her name) wins the prize for the whiniest, brattiest protagonist in the genre, in my opinion. The whole book is a constant stream of her angsting over everything, and being annoyed at everyone.
There's also her relationships with other characters. Her best friend acts ditzy at best (although she's apparently smart when no one else is around...?), and her main function in the story seems to be showing just how absolutely gorgeous Violet is and cooing over the guys in her life. At one point early on, the friend is saying how jealous she is of Violet's body, and Violet thinks about how she'd rather emphasize her beautiful face instead. Basically the only interactions between these two outside of the 'omg-you're-so-hot-Violet' scenarios are bizarre phone conversations to, I guess, keep the friend from fading into the background of the story. When Violet finally tells her the big secret no one else is supposed to know, it's in a *mall foodcourt*. Because nothing can be overheard there, obviously. A lot of these q&a scenes between Violet and some other characters occur around food, which makes me wonder if the author was hungry while writing them.
And then there are the guys, Lincoln and Phoenix. Honestly, I disliked them both, but Phoenix hands down is one of the creepiest, most obsessive love interests I've ever had the displeasure to read about. He manipulates, stalks, and is borderline controlling throughout the book. And yet, somehow, Violet thinks he's the safe option. I won't get into spoilers, but there is one scene between the two of them that made her characterization completely unbelievable and made me dislike her even more--she violates the one thing she said in the beginning of the story she was all about. Not okay. Lincoln has some serious anger and possession issues too, but at least he maintains some semi-normal qualities. And hey, at least he's less annoying than Violet.
Now, I know this is the first of a series, and that there needs to be a lot of setup and worldbuilding, but another main problem I had with this book is that nothing really happens. If I had to sum up the main events, it would be: Violet uncovers destiny, Violet asks questions, Violet is pissed, Violet asks more questions--and maybe does one or two things towards the end. But the "action", if you want to call it that, is paced very oddly, which could be because of the simplistic writing style. None of the tension holds--for example, there's a scene in which one of the main characters is in seeming mortal peril, and the bad guys are standing over him; Violet arrives, and said bad guys agree to leave if she'll listen to a story. No fight to the death, no mental battle of wills, just...a story.
My advice: there are a lot of good entries into the YA fantasy genre lately. Do yourself a favor and pass on this one.