I’m not really sure where to start… I don’t want to be the most horrible party pooper here (considering aaaaall the positive reviews), but I definitely have to start by saying that this book is not that great as everyone made me expect it to be.
Let’s start with the negative stuff then. The characters (referring here mostly to the two main ones, Shay and Avalon) are probably the most annoying people I’ve ever, EVER read about. Okay no, Bella Swan was worse, but that’s another story. These two are just so immature and in general so dumb that they made it extremely difficult for me to keep reading because I was starting to get really freaked out after like their fifth stupid argument, all of them which usually consisted of nothing but throwing blaming and words back and forth at each other, at ourselves, etc. (“I really don’t want you to read my stuff, they’re so bad” “No, no, I think they’re great!” “That’s only because you haven’t read them all” “No, I really do think they’re awesome!” “No, no, just wait until I get to the end” […] “But the end was awesome!” “No, no, it was horrible, trust me!” — these kind of arguments. Tons of them. I liked the one when Shay asked Avalon out by screaming “DO YOU WANT TO BE MY FUCKING GIRLFRIEND” into the air. That was nice.) Then there was Nixon, Shay’s “best friend” but to be honest, what kind of a best friend is that who ignores the shit out of you when her boyfriend is around or bitches you out and gets mad at you when you nicely ask them to give you their car because your girlfriend is really, really sick? (Obviously later it turned out what was exactly between Nixon and Shay so I forgave her and by the end of the book she became my favorite character.) I just really didn’t get most of the characters, not to mention the stupid way how the relationship between Dylan and Forever (with infinity symbol) starts out. Then there was Shay's dad... the character of who I didn't quite understand. He's aggressive, I get it. His top priority is that Shay is the best in school, I get that too. But why is he so aggressive? What's his reason? And if he's like that, how come that sometimes he actually could be quite nice to Shay? I'm guessing the guy drank a lot (although it was never exactly mentioned in the book as far as I'm concerned...?), but I just don't understand what his dad's motive was to be like that with his own son, not to mention why the mother hadn't divorced yet.
Anyway, as the plot blossomed, so did the relationship between Shay and Avalon get just so much worse it annoyed the hell out of me and I'm sorry, but I just couldn't get myself to like neither of them. They were horrible, both of them. To me, there was nothing romantic in any single thing they did together/for each other/whatever.
Besides all this, I have to say I loved the general idea of the plot. The witch-thing and the others with the main characters and I also kinda liked the end although I think the bad guy was finished off quite quickly. But yeah, the last 30-40 pages of the book or so was the best part to me, definitely.
I hope to come back 5 years later and see Forever's latest book and give it a try because I believe she has potential and as a beginner writer myself of the same age as hers, I can't say any more but to encourage her to write more, improve, and publish books in the near future that people will just admire. Even if this book now didn't really work out for me, let's hope the next one will.