What do you think?
Rate this book
The Tower and the Hive #2
Damia: a compelling, captivating and epic fantasy from one of the most influential fantasy and SF novelists of her generation
Of all the Rowan's children, Damia was the most brilliant, the most difficult, the loneliest, and the one who had inherited the greatest Talent. It was obvious from childhood that she was going to be a Prime, with all the honours, burdens and strains of that elite class. Her one friend was Afra -- older, wiser, Talented in his own way, but 'belonging' almost exclusively to the Rowan and the workings of Callisto Station.
As Damia grew up, her Talent became almost too strong to control, and the solution was separation -- from her parents, from Callisto, from her beloved Afra. Sent to the distant planet of Deneb, to her strange and gifted grandmother, Damia began the training necessary to turn her into a Prime of extraordinary gifts -- a Prime who could contact the minds of approaching aliens through space, some of whom threatened to totally destroy the worlds of the Nine Star League.
386 pages, Kindle Edition
First published January 1, 1991
About the author
Anne McCaffrey
500 books7,907 followersAnne Inez McCaffrey was an American writer known for the Dragonriders of Pern science fiction series. She was the first woman to win a Hugo Award for fiction (Best Novella, Weyr Search, 1968) and the first to win a Nebula Award (Best Novella, Dragonrider, 1969). Her 1978 novel The White Dragon became one of the first science-fiction books to appear on the New York Times Best Seller list.
In 2005 the Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America named McCaffrey its 22nd Grand Master, an annual award to living writers of fantasy and science fiction. She was inducted by the Science Fiction Hall of Fame on 17 June 2006. She also received the Robert A. Heinlein Award for her work in 2007.
In 2005 the Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America named McCaffrey its 22nd Grand Master, an annual award to living writers of fantasy and science fiction. She was inducted by the Science Fiction Hall of Fame on 17 June 2006. She also received the Robert A. Heinlein Award for her work in 2007.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 267 reviews
March 20, 2011
This is silly, this book isn't about Damia, it's about Afra. Which is probably the right choice as he's more interesting than she is, given he's 24 years older than she is and by the end of the book she's only 19. (Which has its own set of problems right there.)
It's a middling book. But you know, I think I've realized why this series wears on me; it's quite boring to read about hyper-privileged aristocrats who are spoilt, moody, confident of their skills and power and who never interact with the riff-raff. It's palace intrigue without the actual intrigue, because no one's ever trying to kill each other off and there's no political opposition to (or check on) the FT&T monopoly. There's no struggle in their lives, only small flare-ups of drama between siblings. So the only things they expend effort on are flirting, pouting, and having children. It's maddening.
The first half of the book's all Afra, the second half of the book's largely Damia, the Rowan lurks around being moody and pregnant and fussy, Raven flits in and out like the high school quarterback, adored by all. Boring! Boring boring boring.
Romance novels in spaaaaaaaaace.
It's a middling book. But you know, I think I've realized why this series wears on me; it's quite boring to read about hyper-privileged aristocrats who are spoilt, moody, confident of their skills and power and who never interact with the riff-raff. It's palace intrigue without the actual intrigue, because no one's ever trying to kill each other off and there's no political opposition to (or check on) the FT&T monopoly. There's no struggle in their lives, only small flare-ups of drama between siblings. So the only things they expend effort on are flirting, pouting, and having children. It's maddening.
The first half of the book's all Afra, the second half of the book's largely Damia, the Rowan lurks around being moody and pregnant and fussy, Raven flits in and out like the high school quarterback, adored by all. Boring! Boring boring boring.
Romance novels in spaaaaaaaaace.
August 9, 2013
Guilty-pleasure reading. You know it is when you open the book and the inside of the cover is coated in unicorn stickers that you put there when you were eleven.
If I were reading it for the first time now, at the age of *coughcough*, I probably wouldn't have enjoyed it. As it is, I've always skimmed this book more than read it from cover-to-cover. It's not the kind of book I read for the writing itself, it's the book I read for the ideas of the characters. I've just always loved Afra and the completely romanticized and unrealistic love he has for Damia.
The alien sub-plots I could do without, as they were basically only put in there to traumatize Damia.
If I were reading it for the first time now, at the age of *coughcough*, I probably wouldn't have enjoyed it. As it is, I've always skimmed this book more than read it from cover-to-cover. It's not the kind of book I read for the writing itself, it's the book I read for the ideas of the characters. I've just always loved Afra and the completely romanticized and unrealistic love he has for Damia.
The alien sub-plots I could do without, as they were basically only put in there to traumatize Damia.
May 22, 2012
So. Continuing with the re-read of this series ... after choosing to re-read The Rowan as the story of some highly dysfunctional people rather than as a grand romance, I read the first sequel as the story of how their children — particularly their second daughter/third child — had to learn how to deal with the world and their own psionic talents. In the case of the third child ... not very well, at first. Her two older siblings had this weird sibling bond and they tended to leave her out of their games. So her mother had the bright idea of having another baby, except she'd been pregnant too much in too short a time, and developed gestational diabetes, and they had to pack the kids off to a different planet to live with extended family.
To sum up: really weird relationship dynamics. The first part of the book is a reverse angle story - it's many of the events of The Rowan from the point of view of Afra, one of the supporting characters. Eventually, the title character gets older and we get more of her viewpoint. And we learn that Afra (who has been her parents' colleague since forever, changed her diapers, etc.) was just waiting for her to grow up. Which is this weird mix of sane and creepy, you know? It ends with him feeling renewed and able to "manage a third generation of Rowan women." Yes, that's a quote. Gag me!
To sum up: really weird relationship dynamics. The first part of the book is a reverse angle story - it's many of the events of The Rowan from the point of view of Afra, one of the supporting characters. Eventually, the title character gets older and we get more of her viewpoint. And we learn that Afra (who has been her parents' colleague since forever, changed her diapers, etc.) was just waiting for her to grow up. Which is this weird mix of sane and creepy, you know? It ends with him feeling renewed and able to "manage a third generation of Rowan women." Yes, that's a quote. Gag me!
September 29, 2017
I started this series last year and am so happy to have finally read the 2nd installment! McCaffrey has created a deeply imaginative world that has all the best bits of a good sci-fi: telekinesis, telepathy, CATS, aliens, teleportation, CATS, and just enough romance and sex to mature what could have turned out to be childish, into an edgy, emotion-filled, chronicle of a Talented family's adventures.
June 20, 2020
Yikes. Holy internalised misogyny, batman. From women needing a man to 'manage' them to the fact that no one seems to care that a man nearly twenty five years older and her parents best friend wants to bang a teenager. YIKES.
May 15, 2020
This book is told through the POV of the man who babysits, befriends and eventually has babies with Damia, the Rowan's psychic daughter. Boring as only McCaffrey can manage.
April 4, 2019
That rating is for the love I had for this book as a teenager. I read and reread this series. I’d come home on vacation from university or Edinburgh or Seoul and reread those same old copies. They are all falling apart. Pern was my favourite, but these were a close second.
As an adult with children, it’s considerably harder to believe the romances. Rowan’s insta-love, Damia’s insta-father figure to lover. And like, I’m married to a man ten years my senior, but it’s still weird that she’s 19 and he’s 25 years older and he changed her diapers. That’s weird. It’s as weird as the Jacob thing in Twilight and how messed up is our culture that it took me this long to really look at how weird this romance is.
I do find the whole FT&T thing fascinating and as an older reader I wish there was more about the politics and power structures of all these worlds and such.
As an adult with children, it’s considerably harder to believe the romances. Rowan’s insta-love, Damia’s insta-father figure to lover. And like, I’m married to a man ten years my senior, but it’s still weird that she’s 19 and he’s 25 years older and he changed her diapers. That’s weird. It’s as weird as the Jacob thing in Twilight and how messed up is our culture that it took me this long to really look at how weird this romance is.
I do find the whole FT&T thing fascinating and as an older reader I wish there was more about the politics and power structures of all these worlds and such.
July 29, 2020
When you hear the name Anne McCaffrey, what comes to your mind?
For many of you, it's probably dragons; Ms. McCaffrey was "The Dragonlady," after all. Readers of her non-Pern writings may also think of fictional planets, characters with magical abilities, and maybe even cats.
What probably wouldn't come to your mind is sex...but unfortunately, that's what this book was all about. The title character hops in bed with multiple guys; so much so, I felt like I was reading a trashy romance instead of a sci-fi/fantasy novel. While romance has its place in science fiction--hey, even Star Trek and Star Wars had such themes!--this was over the top. I mentioned on here before that I had to special order The Rowan so I could complete the entire Tower and Hive series this month; maybe the fact that iBooks and the Kindle Store didn't have the first volume was a divine hindrance from reading this series.
I give it two stars because, while the story was rather trashy, at least the writing was great. Ms. McCaffrey had a wonderful way with words; it's a shame she couldn't have used them in a better way.
For many of you, it's probably dragons; Ms. McCaffrey was "The Dragonlady," after all. Readers of her non-Pern writings may also think of fictional planets, characters with magical abilities, and maybe even cats.
What probably wouldn't come to your mind is sex...but unfortunately, that's what this book was all about. The title character hops in bed with multiple guys; so much so, I felt like I was reading a trashy romance instead of a sci-fi/fantasy novel. While romance has its place in science fiction--hey, even Star Trek and Star Wars had such themes!--this was over the top. I mentioned on here before that I had to special order The Rowan so I could complete the entire Tower and Hive series this month; maybe the fact that iBooks and the Kindle Store didn't have the first volume was a divine hindrance from reading this series.
I give it two stars because, while the story was rather trashy, at least the writing was great. Ms. McCaffrey had a wonderful way with words; it's a shame she couldn't have used them in a better way.
November 13, 2015
One word? Logical. Words like 'can't' were replaced with 'cannot' and the like. It was filled with curiosities and possibilities, and it was certainly entertaining. It's logical scientific almost way of writing, meant you couldn't get emotionally involved but you could be painfully curious in the world that exists in the future.
It's incredibly well laced for a series of generations to pass, and the texts ties up perfectly. It isn't boring but because it doesn't grab at your emotions there's no excitement of exhilaration either.
If you haven't read the first (like me) then don't worry about this one yet. I felt like I was missing most things to fill in the gaps and was winging a fair bit to try and piece the story together. I think if I'd read the previous text first, this one would have flowed better but that's more my fault. The author chose not to enable readers like me and instead insists on a complete picture to really appreciate it. So I think I will certainly go back and fill the gap.
I have marked the rest as to read. I'm not sure if that will stick but they aren't a priority. I haven't been left dying to know what happens next.
It's incredibly well laced for a series of generations to pass, and the texts ties up perfectly. It isn't boring but because it doesn't grab at your emotions there's no excitement of exhilaration either.
If you haven't read the first (like me) then don't worry about this one yet. I felt like I was missing most things to fill in the gaps and was winging a fair bit to try and piece the story together. I think if I'd read the previous text first, this one would have flowed better but that's more my fault. The author chose not to enable readers like me and instead insists on a complete picture to really appreciate it. So I think I will certainly go back and fill the gap.
I have marked the rest as to read. I'm not sure if that will stick but they aren't a priority. I haven't been left dying to know what happens next.
January 6, 2017
3.5 stars
This is my least favorite of all the Tower & Hive books, but I can't quite put my finger on the issue. (It should probably be called "Afra" too, but that's something else!) I do love the problems of dealing with Talented and gifted children!
This is my least favorite of all the Tower & Hive books, but I can't quite put my finger on the issue. (It should probably be called "Afra" too, but that's something else!) I do love the problems of dealing with Talented and gifted children!
June 5, 2019
This is the second book of the Tower and the Hive series that introduced the character Rowan to us. This book focuses on her daughter Damia. I've read this book many times since I was a teen, and I still love it. I still find new things and new perspectives each time.
Certain parts of this book has not aged well, and I think that some of the modern readers are a bit thrown off at the romance aspect of this. Afra, who is significantly older than Damia (24 years older) helps to raise her and a lot of the book focuses on their relationship at different points. First as a babysitter, honorary uncle to her. Then as a supervisor type, and then finally as a lover.
In this day and age it can come off as grooming her as a child to become his later, but I think you really need to step out of your own universe and into theirs. Afra never groomed her and he treated her appropriately at each age. When she was a child he loved her as the dear child of his friends. When she was a teenager and had a crush on him he ignored it completely, because he's an honorable man.
Only years later when she was adult, had lived off world controlling her own tower, do they finally turn to each other in romantic love. The age difference is weird to us, but to Primes who live significantly longer, and to telepaths who share emotions on a deeper level it's not really a factor. It is a bit cringy when they tell her parents and neither of them are at all concerned about the fact that he used to change her diapers--I would have expected at least some upset about that even when this book was written almost 30 years ago.
I gave this book only 3 -stars more because the Damia character just irritated me a lot. She is whiny and spoiled, treats people badly and always comes off entitled. She doesn't seem to grow up until tragedy strikes and then she immediately matures. For an overall great series this one book fails for me.
Certain parts of this book has not aged well, and I think that some of the modern readers are a bit thrown off at the romance aspect of this. Afra, who is significantly older than Damia (24 years older) helps to raise her and a lot of the book focuses on their relationship at different points. First as a babysitter, honorary uncle to her. Then as a supervisor type, and then finally as a lover.
In this day and age it can come off as grooming her as a child to become his later, but I think you really need to step out of your own universe and into theirs. Afra never groomed her and he treated her appropriately at each age. When she was a child he loved her as the dear child of his friends. When she was a teenager and had a crush on him he ignored it completely, because he's an honorable man.
Only years later when she was adult, had lived off world controlling her own tower, do they finally turn to each other in romantic love. The age difference is weird to us, but to Primes who live significantly longer, and to telepaths who share emotions on a deeper level it's not really a factor. It is a bit cringy when they tell her parents and neither of them are at all concerned about the fact that he used to change her diapers--I would have expected at least some upset about that even when this book was written almost 30 years ago.
I gave this book only 3 -stars more because the Damia character just irritated me a lot. She is whiny and spoiled, treats people badly and always comes off entitled. She doesn't seem to grow up until tragedy strikes and then she immediately matures. For an overall great series this one book fails for me.
January 6, 2009
Not sure I'm going to be able to finish a rereading of this one. I last read this in jr high or high school, and remember quite liking the character of Afra. I still do, but there's a whole lot else about this book I don't like. The Rowan, who was a pretty good character in the last book of the series, is the stereotypical overworked mother. If the book wasn't written by a woman I'd honestly have a tough time not thinking this were some sort of criticism of working mothers. Maybe it is anyhow? Also, McCaffrey seems to be contradicting things she wrote in the last book. In any case, I know how the book is going to end up and just keep wishing it had been done better, because I quite like the premise of this universe. I'm just worried it's going to get worse.
And yeah... I ended up skimming the last 100 pages, and we're going to be downgrading from two stars to one, for this line alone "Afra now looked forward to managing a third generation of Rowan women." Slightly paraphrased as I don't have the book in front of me. It made me barf in my mouth a little bit. Thus, one star.
And yeah... I ended up skimming the last 100 pages, and we're going to be downgrading from two stars to one, for this line alone "Afra now looked forward to managing a third generation of Rowan women." Slightly paraphrased as I don't have the book in front of me. It made me barf in my mouth a little bit. Thus, one star.
July 26, 2022
This review is for the audiobook. I have been reading McCaffrey series including The Tower and Hive since a teenager so I have read them a number of times. Having the audiobook narration has been excellent. Listening instead of reading made for a refreshing telling.
25/7/22 Have listened to this again and I love this story of Afra, I've come to realise he's one of my favourite characters in this series. This time around listening to Damia, I found adolescent Damia a bit irritating and obnoxious, but that was just minor thing, that hasn't really occurred before. What do you know, I'm in my mid 50s now so maybe her adolescent behaviour is just getting to me now where as it didn't before. But as an adult and child 'Damia' I liked her.
I have to say that I also have the book and have read it numerous time since I was a teenage. But I do listen to a lot of audiobooks these days, while I'm working or just doing things around the house. Because I work on a pc all day at work, I like to rest my eyes a bit so audiobooks are excellent for that.
25/7/22 Have listened to this again and I love this story of Afra, I've come to realise he's one of my favourite characters in this series. This time around listening to Damia, I found adolescent Damia a bit irritating and obnoxious, but that was just minor thing, that hasn't really occurred before. What do you know, I'm in my mid 50s now so maybe her adolescent behaviour is just getting to me now where as it didn't before. But as an adult and child 'Damia' I liked her.
I have to say that I also have the book and have read it numerous time since I was a teenage. But I do listen to a lot of audiobooks these days, while I'm working or just doing things around the house. Because I work on a pc all day at work, I like to rest my eyes a bit so audiobooks are excellent for that.
April 1, 2022
I'm not sure why I keep on with this series. Somehow they start off good but jump the shark halfway through. This story is about Afra, Damia is a side character. I think it's weird/uncomfortable whenever Damia is called a minx when shes a child. Creepy.
June 25, 2023
Romanzo poco interessante, per la maggior parte tratta della fanciullezza di zio Afra e poi di quella da Damia, che, diventata donna, si innamora di Afra. Tre arrivi di alieni risolti al max in una o due pagine ciascuno. Tutta la tecnologia si riduce alla potenza di alcuni individue telepatici che trasportano merci e persone (compresi se stessi) istantaneamente nei più punti più lontani dell'Universo, bah!
June 17, 2021
2.5 rounded up
May 5, 2017
Damia (1992) by Anne McCaffey is the sequel that nobody asked for starring characters that nobody found interesting. Then, McCaffrey expanded the story, providing us with a novel full of filler.
Inside those bound, Damia continues the family story begun in The Rowan. We meet several characters, follow the development of both their personal and professional lives, culminating in a rehashing of the original short story, "Damia." The novel is almost entirely devoid of tension, anxiety, excitement, or charm. It just is. This is sorta the SF equivalent of an Epic Fantasy where you read about what every character does on making camp, day after day. What's there is all well written, but not engaging, possessing no momentum of its own. Damia doesn't even show until past page 100, over 1/3 of the way through the book. The characters themselves feel rather dull to the touch, like dough where the yeast has died off.
I'd love to say that expanding the story added something, deepened the setting, or increased our attachment to the characters, but it didn't. The whole thing takes place in the well run future, and the problem with the well run future is that there's really very little to sort out. The problems with this setting just overwhelm McCaffey's good intentions. I found little in the world that charmed me. Combine this with no knack for writing a family drama, and you get a novel that's pretty much dead in the water. Even so, the book is a marked improvement over The Rowan.
If you liked The Rowan, this book will continue to satisfy, possibly even more so. Otherwise, you're likely to get bored before the story gets anywhere, because the story really doesn't get anywhere.
Inside those bound, Damia continues the family story begun in The Rowan. We meet several characters, follow the development of both their personal and professional lives, culminating in a rehashing of the original short story, "Damia." The novel is almost entirely devoid of tension, anxiety, excitement, or charm. It just is. This is sorta the SF equivalent of an Epic Fantasy where you read about what every character does on making camp, day after day. What's there is all well written, but not engaging, possessing no momentum of its own. Damia doesn't even show until past page 100, over 1/3 of the way through the book. The characters themselves feel rather dull to the touch, like dough where the yeast has died off.
I'd love to say that expanding the story added something, deepened the setting, or increased our attachment to the characters, but it didn't. The whole thing takes place in the well run future, and the problem with the well run future is that there's really very little to sort out. The problems with this setting just overwhelm McCaffey's good intentions. I found little in the world that charmed me. Combine this with no knack for writing a family drama, and you get a novel that's pretty much dead in the water. Even so, the book is a marked improvement over The Rowan.
If you liked The Rowan, this book will continue to satisfy, possibly even more so. Otherwise, you're likely to get bored before the story gets anywhere, because the story really doesn't get anywhere.
June 22, 2007
Having just read Get Off the Unicorn, Rowan's back story was pretty fresh in my head. It was probably too fresh in my mind as I found myself going from feeling bored to feeling a little icky.
The first 100 pages are basically a recap of the previous versions of the story. It's a long and drawn-out "previously on Young and the Telepathic" and a complete waste of time.
The remainder of the novel shows the Rowan as a conflicted and possibly post partum depressed mother who is overworked and trying to be a super mom. First she pawns off her kids on her coworkers and later when pregnancy number four is causing her health issues and emotional problems, Damia and her siblings are shipped off to grandma and grandpa's house! This book devolves into a melodrama in space.
But it gets better! Damia finds romance (while growing into the family business as her talents are as strong as her mother's) with Afra, her old baby sitter and now mentor. No one thinks this relationship is a good idea and yet no one tries to stop it. Somehow uniting Damia with a man old enough to be her father is happy ending.
The first 100 pages are basically a recap of the previous versions of the story. It's a long and drawn-out "previously on Young and the Telepathic" and a complete waste of time.
The remainder of the novel shows the Rowan as a conflicted and possibly post partum depressed mother who is overworked and trying to be a super mom. First she pawns off her kids on her coworkers and later when pregnancy number four is causing her health issues and emotional problems, Damia and her siblings are shipped off to grandma and grandpa's house! This book devolves into a melodrama in space.
But it gets better! Damia finds romance (while growing into the family business as her talents are as strong as her mother's) with Afra, her old baby sitter and now mentor. No one thinks this relationship is a good idea and yet no one tries to stop it. Somehow uniting Damia with a man old enough to be her father is happy ending.
August 30, 2023
This was one of my favorite books as a teenager. I had a huge crush on Afra, from his green skin to his love for cats to his skills with origami. I wanted to be Damia and find my own Afra.
As an adult in the year 2023, I'm struggling to get through the reread. I still love Afra's green skin, his love for cats, and his skills with origami. But I just can't get over my revulsion and disgust at a 43 year old man getting matched up with a 19 year old teenager, especially when he was BFFs with her mom before she was born, helped raise her as a toddler, and has been an involved surrogate uncle her entire life. Ew ew ew ew ew. 100% grooming.
Her brother, looking at her with the "eyes of a man", and saying that he's surprised she'd fall for a cerebral type because she is so physically attractive? Ew ew ew ew ew.
The fact that, the day after they got together he was able to sing a lullaby to make her fall asleep due to the brainwashing trigger put in her mind when she was a child? Fucking horrifying. Just one of many moments the patriarchal condescension makes me wanna throw up.
As an adult in the year 2023, I'm struggling to get through the reread. I still love Afra's green skin, his love for cats, and his skills with origami. But I just can't get over my revulsion and disgust at a 43 year old man getting matched up with a 19 year old teenager, especially when he was BFFs with her mom before she was born, helped raise her as a toddler, and has been an involved surrogate uncle her entire life. Ew ew ew ew ew. 100% grooming.
Her brother, looking at her with the "eyes of a man", and saying that he's surprised she'd fall for a cerebral type because she is so physically attractive? Ew ew ew ew ew.
The fact that, the day after they got together he was able to sing a lullaby to make her fall asleep due to the brainwashing trigger put in her mind when she was a child? Fucking horrifying. Just one of many moments the patriarchal condescension makes me wanna throw up.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
February 13, 2025
I've always been curiously enraptured by this book, and I think I've finally figured out why -- because it holds back certain things I would have like answered. What does it mean that mercurial Damia didn't shield when she was with her first lover, Amer? McCaffery isn't going to tell us explicitly. Want to know what Damia's birth was like? Her first few years at Augeraie, her eventual Prime tower posting? Nah, you'll get a quick sketch of an update, and LIKE IT. Thank goodness after a book of very noble, lonely characters, McCaffery gives us The Chapter of Love and Quiet Moments Fishing, a single note of reflection in an otherwise very busy book spanning twenty eight years of the life of the male protagonist (another question, what does Capella's 'methody' ethic entail, really?)
Whatever. There are mental powers, precociously smart and adorable kittens, (and kids), and Epic True Love ("a meeting of the minds") and really, are you reading this for the educational value? Come on.
Whatever. There are mental powers, precociously smart and adorable kittens, (and kids), and Epic True Love ("a meeting of the minds") and really, are you reading this for the educational value? Come on.
October 15, 2021
These books are comfort food for me. I've been rereading them for years.
That being said, I don't think they've held up as well as some of McCaffrey's other works.
Damia especially is a bit of a twit. And the weird father-daughter vibe of this romance is pretty weird. Like I don't care if nudity is normal if a teenage girl with the hots for you asks you to rub oil on her naked boobs...and crotch...you can say no! You can walk the heck off. It's ok!
Afra comes off as highly condescending and not at all a respectful even match of minds. He still treats her like a little stubborn girl, that's not a foundation for a relationship. Frankly she SHOULD feel bad for what happens to her brother, they brush that off so fast the guy doesn't even get a funeral!
Sorry McCaffrey, but this one just might not stand the test of time.
That being said, I don't think they've held up as well as some of McCaffrey's other works.
Damia especially is a bit of a twit. And the weird father-daughter vibe of this romance is pretty weird. Like I don't care if nudity is normal if a teenage girl with the hots for you asks you to rub oil on her naked boobs...and crotch...you can say no! You can walk the heck off. It's ok!
Afra comes off as highly condescending and not at all a respectful even match of minds. He still treats her like a little stubborn girl, that's not a foundation for a relationship. Frankly she SHOULD feel bad for what happens to her brother, they brush that off so fast the guy doesn't even get a funeral!
Sorry McCaffrey, but this one just might not stand the test of time.
March 11, 2018
Like the first book, I did enjoy reading it.... but to a much lesser degree.
However, when Damia does something so reprehensible to another minor Talented person, that his whole career goes down the drain... and she is never punished for it... I realised that Primes are the 'Mary Sue' of Anne's mind.
I'm pretty sure mentally diminishing someone else's own Talent so that they will never work in a Tower again should have resulted in Damia having mental walls placed in her own mind so that she can't use her own Talent for a number of months... so that she can feel exactly what she had done to her victim. Damia just gets a bit of a stern word from Afra... not even getting sent to bed without dinner!!
I did like the book but honestly, Damia is a bit of a twat.
However, when Damia does something so reprehensible to another minor Talented person, that his whole career goes down the drain... and she is never punished for it... I realised that Primes are the 'Mary Sue' of Anne's mind.
I'm pretty sure mentally diminishing someone else's own Talent so that they will never work in a Tower again should have resulted in Damia having mental walls placed in her own mind so that she can't use her own Talent for a number of months... so that she can feel exactly what she had done to her victim. Damia just gets a bit of a stern word from Afra... not even getting sent to bed without dinner!!
I did like the book but honestly, Damia is a bit of a twat.
August 22, 2018
Picked this up for a couple of quid at a second-hand bookshop on Charing Cross Road. I’m a fan of McCaffrey’s ‘Dragonriders’ series, so thought I’d give it a whirl.
It’s... well, let’s be honest - it’s proper, old-fashioned sci-fi pulp. Pretty dubious prose, weirdly meandering story, stock characters, and some awkward sex with a surprisingly male gaze.
Aside from that...I quite enjoyed it! Certainly I had no trouble getting to the end of the book. And, actually, the worldbuilding was good. I understand this is actually the sequel to another book, but I didn’t feel unable to follow it for that, or like I was missing a huge amount.
TL;DR - If you enjoy pulp SF, you’ll probably enjoy this. Otherwise, probably not.
It’s... well, let’s be honest - it’s proper, old-fashioned sci-fi pulp. Pretty dubious prose, weirdly meandering story, stock characters, and some awkward sex with a surprisingly male gaze.
Aside from that...I quite enjoyed it! Certainly I had no trouble getting to the end of the book. And, actually, the worldbuilding was good. I understand this is actually the sequel to another book, but I didn’t feel unable to follow it for that, or like I was missing a huge amount.
TL;DR - If you enjoy pulp SF, you’ll probably enjoy this. Otherwise, probably not.
September 3, 2021
A Little Too Pedo For My Adult ReRead
This book came out in 1992, and I read it then at the age of 17. I blithely fell for the characters, the romance and the sweetness of the series.
Yet now as an adult I have to say I can not get over the nauseating grooming and pedophilic nature of the love story between Damia and Afra. While I was already alarmed by a minor live story found in Pegasus in Flight, here we have a character who as an adult decades older than the infant he cared for precedes to fall in love with and pursue a romantic relationship with the same child. In one scene he even runs oil on her naked body. And though yes he waits for "her to see him as a man" he should not be seeing her as anything but a child. Just disturbing.
This book came out in 1992, and I read it then at the age of 17. I blithely fell for the characters, the romance and the sweetness of the series.
Yet now as an adult I have to say I can not get over the nauseating grooming and pedophilic nature of the love story between Damia and Afra. While I was already alarmed by a minor live story found in Pegasus in Flight, here we have a character who as an adult decades older than the infant he cared for precedes to fall in love with and pursue a romantic relationship with the same child. In one scene he even runs oil on her naked body. And though yes he waits for "her to see him as a man" he should not be seeing her as anything but a child. Just disturbing.
December 14, 2012
I did not love this book as much as the first time I read it some 15 years ago for a two reasons:
The first 1/3 of the book is a recap of the previous book, but from Afra's point of view. If I had read the other one some time ago, the recap might have been helpful, but because I moved straight on from the first one it was a little pointless.
The relationship between Afra and Damia was just plain weird. I tried to keep an open mind about it, but Afra had taken care of Damia like a father in the beginning and then they became lovers... a little strange for me.
The first 1/3 of the book is a recap of the previous book, but from Afra's point of view. If I had read the other one some time ago, the recap might have been helpful, but because I moved straight on from the first one it was a little pointless.
The relationship between Afra and Damia was just plain weird. I tried to keep an open mind about it, but Afra had taken care of Damia like a father in the beginning and then they became lovers... a little strange for me.
February 26, 2017
I agree with most that this book isn't so much about Damia as it is about Afra. that being said I adore Afra and thus love this book as I have loved almost all of Anne McCaffreys books. The immense worldbuilding she accomplishes is incredible and lends itself so well to character development.
June 6, 2023
Not my favorite of the Pegasus, and Tower and the Hive series but still very enjoyable and comfortable. Still loving my reread of these series!
December 9, 2025
Still love this book and this series after all these years. ❤️
September 5, 2020
I knew it was gonna happen but it really disappointed me when it did.
June 14, 2021
Geez Anne Mccaffrey got a bit pervy later on didn't she, with the whole lotion at the pool thing. Unnecessary, and pervy.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 267 reviews