I won this book in a Goodreads First Reads giveaway (thank you!), but it was not a term of the contest that I review the book as a condition of winning.
I find 5 star rating systems wholly inadequate to address what I really thought of this book. It definitely doesn't belong in the 4 star and above category with other books I have absolutely loved, however it also doesn't deserve to be in the three star and below category where books for which I have only lukewarm feelings live. Is it a 3.5? Maybe, possibly. Truth is, I am still not entirely sure how I felt about this book.
I liked the concept. As far as urban fantasy goes, this was a unique concept for me, so I liked that it was different than the standard genre staples. The world building wasn't bad, but the fragmented and drawn out way Katie MacAlister explained certain aspects of her world and those in it was a bit off-putting to me. Maybe that's just my impatience, but there were definitely moments when I was distracted from the story and found myself paging back (like a time thief, natch) because I assumed I had simply missed an explanation of something important due to unanswered questions. this is often a great way to develop a story, but with this book, this world, I found it unnecessary and distracting at times.
I have never read anything else from this author, but I found her development of Kiya, the main female lead, quite refreshing. She was a bit different from the norm. She spoke her mind, in humorous and ridiculous ways at times (calling attractive men "male models" to their face), but her lack of a filter was actually a bit endearing, charming and silly. I actually enjoyed the silliness (though I can definitely see it being a con for some). I did, however, have a hard time believing that Kiya was 32 - she struck me as much younger, like late teens/early 20s. I disliked the lack of back story for Kiya - why she lacked employment at 32 and what led her to that place in her life. While this should not matter, in this case it seems it was necessary for an understanding of her personality.
Another thing that irked me about Kiya were the constant references to her id, ego, and superego, and how "in tune" she was with those elements of her psyche. It really felt redundant, forced, and a bit jarring. We get it - your foster mother is a psychiatrist.
Peter is interesting, but again a little more backstory might have made him feel more believable. He was written to be conservative and old world, kind of wooden, yet much of his dialogue really wasn't and felt a little too modern to be believable. I think his character simply needs a bit of refining.
The love story - oh, what a let down that was. On the one hand, MacAlister goes out of her way to ridicule the "love at first sight" and "quick to fall in love" scenarios that proliferate in books these days (particularly in the YA genre), yet this love story is probably the fastest progressing, and therefore most unbelievable, love story I have read in the recent past (and I read a ton of YA, so that's saying something). I have a much easier time digesting and going with the flow when the characters are meant to me young, and therefore susceptible to such a quick fall, but in this case it didn't work for me. The characters were too old, too "wise" for that; moreover, nothing in the story suggested to me anything beyond the lust of a new relationship, much less love.
The story itself was actually fun, albeit pretty predictable, but as far as establishing this new world and the characters in it, this was a pretty solid introduction to a new series. Will I be buying the second in the series when it eventually comes out? I really am not sure yet. There are a lot of elements I liked, but a lot that I didn't. I will probably give it another shot if only because with the world and its characters already established I expect a more fulfilling story and more development of the characters.