I read the Guardians of Ga'Hoole series when I was in school, and since then they've been my favorite book series of all time. Even as an adult, something about the world of Ga'Hoole captures my imagination more than any other series that I've read. I love the characters, I love the story, and I love the detail Mrs. Lasky goes into when describing the different environments. Although I think the series went on for a little too long, I'm glad we got more, and the ending of "The War of the Ember" felt so satisfying. Bittersweet, yes, but satisfying. So when I heard that Mrs. Lasky was writing a prequel on one of Ga'Hoole's most beloved characters, I admit I was a little apprehensive. Ezylryb was the mentor figure of the books, someone whose backstory remained mostly anonymous. To give him a prequel novel would be like giving Obi-Wan Kenobi or Albus Dumbledore a prequel.
Still, as a die-hard fan of the series, I couldn't avoid this story forever. After some coaxing from my friends, I decided to buy the book and read it shortly after finishing "The Lost Tales of Ga'Hoole", and what did I think? Well, it was certainly good, but I wouldn't call it my favorite out of all the Ga'Hoole books.
The story was well executed and detailed, and Ezylryb's (or rather Lyze of Kiel's) personality as a hatchling was very amusing considering how he turns out in time, but at the same time I thought the story itself was extremely problematic. A majority of the characters weren't fleshed out, and because of that they get little to no development. Lyze's relationship with Ifghar went nowhere. The story tries to explain this with the fact that Lyze never connected to Ifghar when they were hatchlings, but I still feel like it could have been developed more. Speaking of which, Ifghar and Gragg's intentions were never explained, so their rise to villainy and corruption feels forced (on that note, I feel their characters had no purpose in the original series either. You could have cut them out and nothing would've changed). The main villain of the story, Bylyric, felt like a nobody. He had no personal connection to Lyze or his friends, even though he is the source of their misery, and the reason the War of the Ice Talons continued for longer than it should, and he doesn't appear until the very end of the story where he is killed rather quickly. I know this story is written from Ezylryb's first-person view, but The First Collier was written in a similar manner, and that story was perfectly rounded with great characters and relationships.
Oh, if you're not a fan of the consequences of war, and the endless violence, depression, and death that it brings about, then you're in for a treat. Whenever something happy happens in Lyze's life, whenever something comes along to bring joy and love to his heart, it is immediately taken away from him by the tragedy of war. Every. Single. Time. It is heartbreaking to read about what Lyze goes through, to the point where the book becomes unpleasant to read. I understand that this is what war is like, and how it affects regular people, but it becomes a bit too much for me. Maybe I'm just that type of person.
There is also one part that I found very odd, and a little out of place in the Ga'Hoolian world. At one point in the story, Lyze and his friends discover the frozen body of a human mountain climber. Now, humans existed in Ga'Hoole, but they've all vanished at this point. It is fascinating to see the characters examine the human, and the modern tools he used to climb the mountain before his un-timely death, but then they find his still working flare gun...It's so weird imagining owls taking a gun, shooting it, and re-loading it in battle, it felt so out of place. This does lead into an important lesson everyone learns later on, and has Lyze pondering on how the humans became extinct, but the build up to it is beyond weird.
Overall, despite the negativity I heaved all over the place, I don't hate "The Rise of a Legend", or "The Book of Ezylryb" as the alternate title is called. Although there was room for lots of improvement, I feel it was still well told for the most part, and who knows, maybe it will grow on me over time.