Pambo, Evagrius, Macarius of Egypt and Macarius of Alexandria, the four fathers presented in this volume, were well-known in Alexandria and Lower Egypt some 1600 years ago. Their lives, brought to fame by Palladius' Lausiac History, provide valuable insight into the Egyptian monastic communities of the fourth century and into the saintly tradition of the Coptic Church. This volume serves as a companion volume to St Macarius the Spiritbearer, also published by SVS Press, which features further insight into Macarius of Egypt.
A few months ago my priest charged us with reading the Desert Fathers. This was a good selection to read - four lives of Desert Saints. While the main thrust of the book is less interesting to me (the difference between received texts) the material is very edifying. On a side note, the cover is beautiful.
Unlike other volumes in these SVS series, this is not a collection of these fathers’ teachings. It is rather 4 mini-biographies which includes their teachings. The translator/editor’s introductions are patristic gold mines. While these fathers, for example, cannot simply be tagged with Origen’s teachings, they are understood in something of an Origenist framework, a framework which would have major repercussions on St John Chrysostom.
The sections on Evagrius and Macarius of Egypt were particularly good in explaining knowledge and spiritual warfare as it regards demons. And while these fathers were great ascetics, they did acknowledge they made mistakes and sometimes took it too far.
Another strength is the footnotes. Tim Vivian (the editor) connects the Desert Fathers’ teachings with key passages from The Life of Antony and Cassian’s Conferences. That’s where the real gold lies.
In conclusion I highly recommend this volume. It is a manual on spiritual warfare and many of the footnotes are correlated with other key monastic texts.
This is an interesting, if odd book. It is the lives of four Desert Fathers-Pambo, Evagrius, Macarius of Egypt and Macarius of Alexandria, first of all. All four of these are prominent desert fathers of the late fourth century, at the height of the desert monastic movement. However, what is odd about it is the sources for these lives. They are, first and foremost, lives taken from Palladius' Lausic History- a monastic history of the late fourth and fifth century. However, the author also mixes in the Coptic Lives of these figures, which offer more information and a more generous treatment. The reason for this is the contention that the Lausic History as we have it in its Greek text, is heavily edited to remove the odium of heresy which hung on the more Origenist monks. This affects, especially, Evagrius, who was one of the most prominent followers of the 3rd century theologian, Origen, whose works were beloved by some theologians and monks and condemned by others- a condemnation which has stuck until recently. So, in some ways, this is an attempt to restore something like the original text of the work.
The result is a bit of a strange hybrid. The two texts are put together and marked off using italics, so we can know the sourcing. However, the effect is occasionally confusing, although, I think, helpful for those concerned with issues of sources.
That said, these are interesting lives, especially for those of us interested in the Desert Fathers and Mothers. They give that store of odd and enlightening stories which is what we expect of Desert Fathers- quite odd to modern ears, but oddly wise. The Life of Evagrius is particularly interesting because his writings give a foundation to that tradition of monastic spiritual psychology which has been experiencing a small revival in the last few decades.
Even with the format oddities, this book is still very much worth reading.
The morning I finished this, the canticle antiphon from morning prayer was: "Let everything within you watch and wait, for the Lord our God draws near." This sums up well the lives of the desert fathers told in this Coptic text. It's easy to think of the desert fathers living in isolation as hermits. However, these texts make evident that they regularly engaged with others, whether it be by assembly (i.e. Mass and the Hours), welcoming visitors, and giving counsel and mutual support to one another. One also sees from these texts that in leaving the world they in turn penetrated and sanctified it.
This book seems to be a companion to another text that I have not read, the Lausiac History of Palladius. The editors have published another text to go along with this, but it, too, I think is a coptic version of a more mainstream greek version. Thus, a lot of the commentary in the book focused on how this compared to the other work - this version retains the apparently Origenist qualities while they were carelessly removed from the other. Still, the fragments about these four desert father were quite interesting. The primary text is not very lengthy for the first two fathers - Pambo and Evagrius, but there is more substance about the Macarii. For me this was useful as another picture of early monasticism along with the Life of Antony, and I'm gaining a clearer picture of what was important to these ascetics and defenders of the faith, and I plan to quickly return to the primary texts within to get a greater understanding and because they are so short. Were I a more erudite scholar, I think I could have gained much more.
I love reading the wisdom of long-forgotten Desert Fathers. Many of the writings contained here have been translated for the first time in English.
This is not really a perfect fit for spiritual reading like others in the Popular Patristics Series, and clearly has a bit of an analytical academic bent (as more than 50% of the text is modern biographical and historical information), but the actual ancient texts themselves are wonderful.
In particular, the writings here go a long way to make the early Fathers more accessible. Some early writings make the holiness and ascetic discipline seem completely unattainable, but I found here many consoling passages which were eager to point out that strict monastic discipline alone does not make one holy, and in fact could lead one down a path of pride and vanity if not done properly.
Overall, I liked it, but there aren't many people I would recommend this to for light Sunday reading.