Oh dear. Well, I’m realizing 3 months after finishing this that I never wrote a review. I’ll do my best to recall, but it’s been a minute, and I’ve read a good bit of Star Wars since then too.
Last time, I felt like it was a really solid Avengers situation, where it’s not so much about the story as getting the characters together for the next adventure. Well, I like Age of Ultron, myself, but after reading this, I understand the people who don’t, I think.
Maybe closer to home, in more ways than one, this could be considered an Episode VIII: The Last Jedi -lite. It takes the setup from last volume, and completely goes an entirely different direction. Rey is super important, no she’s not / Ulic is becoming a legendary Jedi, no he’s not. (To an extent,) I like Last Jedi, myself, but after reading this volume, I understand the people who don’t, I think.
In the briefest of terms, the first arc, “Dark Lords of the Sith”, is terrible. And it sets the basis for the rest of the book. It’s just spooky scary ghosts that pop up and turn people evil, and how freakin’ lame is that? There’s no drama or reason for the turn — there could’ve been, but they bail out instead of committing to it. It arguably ruins a good character from the previous volume in the worst way possible, like the inverse of ruining Kylo Ren by redeeming him for no good reason.
But.
If I just pretend there were good reasons for his turn to the Dark Side and start with “The Sith War”? Oh wow, it’s actually not bad. Now I still don’t think it’s worth walking this far back in time in the Star Wars Galaxy, but I’ll give you that it’s pretty entertaining, and — again, pretending he’s a Dark Sider for good reasons — a satisfying story of loss and regret. But as easily and contrived as he fell to the dark, it’s super easy (barely an inconvenience) for Ulic to turn back to the light at the end, and it just all feels so ridiculous.
But…
It’s really just the last arc that sells it, because it ends up being a more believable Episode VIII: The Last Jedi Luke situation. An old legendary Jedi Master (if we pretend he was such) is cut off from the force after being believably manipulated into becoming a Sith Lord (if we pretend it was believable) and finds himself years later tasked with begrudgingly training a young girl with great promise just in time to… well, not save the galaxy — that’s maybe the biggest negative to this arc, I feel like it’s missing a plot. There’s really no rush, and the only stakes are whether or not she becomes a Jedi through him or not. And sure, maybe the other girl will kill Ulic or maybe she won’t, but it’s a little thin for a whole arc. Too decompressed. Otherwise, this was a compelling story. I just wish it had a believable background of how and why Ulic let down the galaxy in the first place.
Each arc is better than the last, but also reliant on pretending the last was better than it was. It’s also harder to not include the first half of the first volume in this pseudo head-canon I’m imagining, because you need the creepy spooky ghosts. It’s just… a lot. And I don’t think it really enriches the universe as much as it could. I’m still not convinced this era is necessary (or really even all that good).
——
A brief aside, the new coloring is way better than the original coloring as included in the back of this volume, holy crap.