Most of it I've heard before, though I still found plenty of things I wanted to highlight. There were times when I was skeptical of the author's reasoning (and her overuse of Beth Moore quotes), and I had a few disagreements with some of the "truths":
Lie: "I can't."
Truth: "I can do all things through Christ who strengthens me."
I think it's oversimplified, and that can do a lot of damage. It simply does not work for every single situation. If someone said I should go on American Idol, I'm going to say "I can't" because I can't sing that well. The conditions have to be right for this verse to apply: Jesus has to empower me, and it has to be God's will.
As someone with an anxiety disorder, people use this all the time to argue with me when I say I can't. It trivializes my struggles and suggests that if I just had more faith I could do it.
Lie: I would be happy if...
This is again oversimplifying a more complicated issue. There is nothing wrong with bettering your life. It's more about being happier, not happy. I lost 70 pounds. Am I happy? No. But I'm a heck of a lot happier! My health has improved and I'm able to find clothes easier. I can wear dresses now!! I had a problem, and with God's help, I conquered it. I could stand to lose more, and it could become an obsession, but that doesn't mean I should treat the very concept as idolatry.
In this section, Jaynes suggests that people make their spouse their God when they seek something that's lacking in their marriage. Yes, people have unrealistic expectations, and sometimes that leads to cheating and adultery, but that doesn't make it wrong to want a happier marriage. What is there's no love? What if your spouse is abusive? What if he/she doesn't care about your needs or dreams? Those are major problems that absolutely should be addressed. It's okay to have needs that aren't being met and to acknowledge that. I fear that women will read this and think they're not allowed to ever seek something better because that equals idolatry. I think this "truth" is almost as bad as the lie it's trying to counter.
Likewise, "Money doesn't make you happy" is usually said by those who have enough. I spent years being too cold every winter because I didn't have a good enough coat. I was walking around sometimes in something not much better than a hoodie. I'm very petite and nothing fits me in the sleeves. It's hard to find something in a thrift store. One day someone gave me a gift card which allowed me to buy a down jacket that would fit me and keep me warm enough at least part of the time! You bet I'm happier now.
Maybe I'm missing the point. I just think this book could've used a decent dose of "but". There are always exceptions for everything.
I picked up this book because I have social anxiety, live at home, and don't have a proper job. I often feel unaccepted in society. While it is extremely important to understand our worth in Christ, the problem with books like this is that when we feel unloved or rejected by people, being loved and accepted by God doesn't take away the pain of feeling unacceptable. Jesus healed the lepers so they could go back to being in society; he didn't tell them that it was okay because he doesn't mind their leprosy. That's like your mom saying she loves you, so it doesn't matter if anyone else does. "Yeah, but you're my mom...." Jesus was a man of sorrows because he was despised and rejected. He had the closest relationship to God that a person could have but it still hurt to be unloved by those he loves so much. So while I appreciate the effort by all to show us how loved we are by God, I think it's equally important to remember that we were created as social beings. I hear this lie a lot: "All you need is God". No. We need people, too. Adam walked with God yet God said "It's not good for man to be alone."
I feel like this is a harsher review than is perhaps warranted. Since I read this a few months ago, I don't remember much of it. I remember liking it quite a bit and wanting to buy it for others. So please excuse the negativity. These are just some things that I found irritating from having heard them so much.