Librarian Note: There is more than one author by this name in the Goodreads database.
Charles Page Smith, who was known by his middle name, was a U.S. historian, professor, author, and newspaper columnist. A native of Baltimore, Maryland, Smith graduated with a B.A. degree from Dartmouth College in 1940. He then worked at Camp William James, a center for youth leadership training opened in 1940 by Eugen Rosenstock-Huessy, a Dartmouth College professor, as part of the Civilian Conservation Corps. Smith was awarded a Purple Heart for his service as a company commander of the 10th Mountain Division of the United States Army during World War II. (wikipedia)
I picked this randomly from the library, not realizing that it was the eighth and final volume of a series; that being the case, I still absolutely loved it. Smith gives an expansive recounting of the 20's up until America's involvement in WWII, through the dual lenses of the conflict between capital and labor, and the struggle of black Americans to fight for their voice and rights during this period. I was surprised to find so many parallels between this period and our own; a strong isolationist/populist movement, an economic recession, and the fear of those in power (white industrialists) that the oppressed would take as much as possible from them (spoiler, they did, in the victories of the labor unions).
Smith divides the two major consciousnesses of America into Classical-Christian and Secular-Democratic, which makes a lot of sense to me. I'm excited to read the first seven volumes of this work, and to see his take on the beginning of the country, as well as the Civil War.
To paraphrase MLK: after 8 volumes and 7966 pages ( minus 300 I just couldn’t wade through in a previous volume) of Page Smith’s “A Peoples History: “Done at last, Done at last, Lord God Almighty! I’m done at last.”
Yes, Volume 8 (written in 1987) of Page Smith’s epic American history saga is his last and covers the period 1920 to December 7, 1941. Although I’m glad I persevered, if I had to do it again, I doubt I would have started. Some of these volumes contain exquisite author expressions, but unfortunately, they are like needles in a large haystack. Too much redundancy is my biggest bugaboo here: a litany of obscure individuals in the arts, architecture, education , religion, and reform (strikes, strikes, strikes, and even more strikes).To paraphrase Tom Paine: “These are the pages that try my soul”.
Volume 8 is different than the others in that its major focus is on a political figure, FDR, someone who Smith obviously admired and the volume is nearly a hagiography. ( I was irritated by Smith’s implication that FDR reached out to Hoover between the 1932 election and inauguration to discuss remedial measures to address the Great Depression, but this is repudiated by 2 FDR biographers and a Hoover biographer -it was the other way around )
The author again reiterates that his major theme and purpose in the volumes (at least since the Civil War) is the eternal conflict between labor and capital (‘BigBusiness/Monopolists/the wealthy’) and he does an great job of drilling down into these particulars. But for me, there is another theme that percolates upward out of this history: the famous quote allegedly attributed to Mark Twain that “ History doesn’t repeat itself but it often rhymes “. Smith’s narrative demonstrates that history DOES in fact repeat itself as well as rhyme. A few examples out of the dozens throughout the series:
1)Immigration: since the 1840’s the U.S. has periodically opposed Catholics, Jews, Irish, Italians, Poles, Chinese and Japanese immigrants. 2026: Trump administration is deporting hundreds of thousands of immigrants “who are eating our cats and dogs” and Somalia is a shit-hole country (as is Norway but for different reasons)
2)Communism: Post 1917 & during the Great Depression, Socialist, communist, and anarchist groups formed in the U.S. with thousands of members advocating the utopia of collective societies’. 2026: ‘Democratic “socialists have made inroads into the Democratic party and advocate abolishing the Senate among other radical ideas.
3)Isolationism: during prewar WWI and WWII, there was a large minority of Americans opposed to entering the ‘European’ wars. 2026: MAGA’s ‘Make American First’ is an economic form of isolationism.
4)Tariffs: throughout U.S. history, the government has raised and lowered tariffs, and they have always created economic disruption. 2026: Trump administration ’s reincarnation of tariffs has produced retaliation, inflation, and discord with former allies worldwide.
Notable Quotes:
Author-“My purpose in this series was to take American history away from historians & return it to the American people. Despite disgusting elements of American life (greed, crime, imperial arrogance) I am convinced we are a more just people than even a few decades ago . Progress is not inevitable but we have wellsprings of kindness and decency to draw on, provided through the generosity of our forebears”
Author on FDR philosophy-“FDR declared himself in favor of a central role of government in regulating the economy to provide for common interests of all rather than special interest of a few. FDR saw the Great Depression as an ‘opportunity’, not just a disaster.”
Author on the New Deal-“each societal transformation must have an earlier version so it can happen in its appointed time. And there must always be an advance guard of radicals and innovators whose prescriptions are too extreme for society to swallow. The history of the United States can be seen as a prolonged contest between community values and the code of individualism.”
And finally the Author opines on history-“History is our collective memory & without memory we are apt to commit even more dangerous blunders than we commit with a substantial knowledge of history to draw on. I believe the tendency of history of all human institutions is downward towards complacency, decadence, obtuseness & coldness of heart and that we are saved only by the often obscure but heroic efforts of men and women whose passion it has been to redeem the world “
…And thus, author Smith closes with his deep respect for reform and reformers, essentially the objective of this entire work.
Great history of the period following the Progressive era.
Not quite as good as America Enters The World, much more focus on authors, poets, etc... rather then regular people, but very interesting none-the-less.
I really enjoy this series by Page. I've ordered the first 2 volumes, about the revolution, and looking forward to reading them.
I like that it covers several aspects of life and not just political/government focused, which most US history books tend to do. And the writing is most often interesting without getting bogged down in recitation of facts, he generally brings the story to life.