"The Ghost of Christmas past"by Catherine R. Daly was a really good book because it was little bit scary.It's good book for kids because that book is scary.I couldn't stop reading because I want to know who was the ghost.For example,"One night, about three years ago.He walk up and said that his room was so cold he could see his breath, even thought the heat was on.And he could make out shape of a girl,an old-fashioned-looking girl, standing next to his bed, reaching for him.he was so scared he couldn't even move"Now let's find out what's ghost going to do with Haley.