4.5 stars. I've noticed that when the best authors write fantasy they find a way to ground it in reality or find a way to solidly connect it to something that the very human readers can relate to. It feels to me like building a bridge I can use for my imagination to be able to travel accross to the story so that I can be a part of it. It might be an urban fantasy novel set in Chicago where the author tells me about real streets and restaurants, so I can see the places that are actually familiar to me. Or the way that J.K. Rawling created a secret shopping district in the center of London with a magic wall whose bricks shifted to open, and the image she created was so clear that everyone who saw the first movie based on her book all felt that it looked exactly how she described it. We all moved together from the regular London into Diagon Alley, or when we read about the kids taking the train to the school, we feel that we have moved from reality to a truly magical place.
In this book the foundation that connects the story so strongly to the real world is emotional. The city isn't a real city, it's based on somewhat on Cleveland from what I read but that seems more for the Lake Erie location than for any landmarks, political issues or other real connections. It seems like the world is supposed to be ours but it's changed so much since magic became an issue (why did that happen? I don't even know at this point) that it feels more like an alternate world, it would be easy to feel disconnected from this world and just read it as a fantasy that is fun, but not important, just a light read. But then there's Kate. After reading this second book in the series, I know Kate. I feel her struggles and I relate to her on a deep level. It doesn't matter that she can do magic or was raised totally differently from me or anyone I know. I know this woman, I get her. She's my bridge.
The best parts of the book are the parts that are the most frustrating, because they're the most real. When I was yelling at Kate for being a jerk, that was when Jaye did her job the best, because I was thinking of her as a person and not as a character. There was so much deeply emotional baggage flying around behind the scenes of this investigation, it was incredible. At the same time that I was turning the pages to try to figure out what was going on with the crazy guy who was going to do something awful to the city in a few days, I was also totally wrapped up with what was going on with Kate and her friends. And by wrapped up I mean talking back to the book the way I yell at the TV screen when my characters are doing something dumn. I was totally ticked off at Kate she was so judgmental of Pen wanting relief from the pain after her accident. I was sitting there in a lot of pain from my stupid broken toe, and let me tell you, it can get pretty darn bad and it's just a dang toe. Of course I have a chronic pain condition that exacerbates everything. Anyway, my stuff was nothing compared to what Pen was dealing with after her car accident with a concussion, sprained wrist, couple of broken ribs, contusions all down one side of her body, and whiplash. Kate wouldn't let up on her about using any kind of magic (whether she's right or not because Pen's an addict with a bad heart from her former use) in a world where they don't even make aspirin anymore because potions are too much easier/cheaper to make. I get that Kate wanted to help her friend be strong when she needed the support. But she was being such a bitch about it. She was taking so much of her own problems out on Pen because she felt guilty about having used magic to help save Danny's life. She felt like she'd relapsed on her committment to Arcane Anonymous and didnt deserve the big party everyone had just thrown her for her ten year anniversary. So she was being really harsh with Pen, who really was a potion addict and using did have serious risks for her, even using white magic.
And Baba, who refuses to listen. Even if Baba needed to be straightened out, she didn't deserve to be treated like that. Kate just kept taking her anger at herself out on the people who love her most. Sound like anyone you know? I'd be shocked if whoever is reading this hasn't been in a situation like this at least once in your life. And if Kate hadn't pushed it to the point where Pen was suffering so extremely then Pen might not have had to act so extremely. Being in pain is bad, really bad and people who don't know what it's like just stand there and judge, that's reality, but it bugs me. Just be stronger, they say, or when they don't say it, they think it. And then they get a little cold and whine for days. Right. And if Kate wasn't feeling so guilty about her own behavior she wouldn't have been so pushy with Pen anyway, Jaye knew exactly what she was writing, Kate was obviously overreacting because of her own fall off the wagon. Just like Kate was completely oblivious to the fact that her desire to drink whiskey at totally inappropriate times was a big problem. Like somehow because it wasn't potions it was OK. A lot of the deep, emotional baggage of addiction was dealt with in this book from several different angles, and it felt real, without feeling too heavy for a fun urban fantasy book. Both Kate and Pen were dealing with their pain, physical and emotional, in between dealing with all of their other commitments, just like real women do. And their friendship and love and frustration and anger felt absolutely real. Even if it hadn't read the first book and didn't know how close these two women had been for years I still would have felt the connection. And Kate's struggle with the role that magic plays in her life is critical to the book and the series, as well as to her relationships with Pen, her brother Danny, her uncle Abe. John Volos, her work, really it's the central theme of the series, so the way that the addiction theme played out in this book was a real breakthrough. And I found the scene at the end when Kate and Pen were at AA (Arcane Anonymous) to be very touching in a lot of ways.
Kate was just as screwed up in her relationships with her brother, or with Baba. She says all of the wrong things at the wrong times, she says the things she should say the wrong way, she's a typical single mother who's exhausted and frustrated with her totally cool and frequently annoying sixteen year-old kid/little brother. Her bosses range from pretty cool to really awful, adding to her stress. And this case shes working is as stressful as it gets. The personal relationships in the book are terrific and create a very real foundation for the fantastic and magical elements to float on top of, it's really just top notch.
And to make it really clear, the mystery and the fantasy stuff was also top notch! I love a good police procedural. Step by step trying to figure out what's going on, working as a team. And this team is terrific, all really interesting characters. Jaye could easily do a spin-off about Mez when this series is over, he has star potential written all over him. The partnership between Kate and Morales is very satisfying, with or without the sexy edge to their story. He feels like a good guy. I'm very interested to see what happens with him in the next book. The whole investigation was a real page-turner. With that weaving in and out of Kate's private life, it was just a terrific book.
Oh, and one more thing, there's no love triangle! Yay! Well, OK, it's there a little, tiny bit. But these books are actually about the investigations and about Kate's life. They're not paranormation romances, it's urban fantasy. There are two extremely handsome men. She has a connection to one that she's fighting and an attraction to the other that she probably should fight, she's not sure yet what she thinks about it. There might be a little tiny bit of romance building, or friendship, or maybe just a romp in the sack, but then again maybe not, we'll just have to wait and see. But Kate's love life is not the focus of this books, it's just another factor in what grounds the books in reality, she's trying to juggle everything that's going on in her life in between her very busy and stressful job and being a single mother, trying to be a friend to Pen when she needs her, and dealing with her own issues with magic. The woman is a mess, but a totally relatable one that I'd love to be friends with. If she ever had the time to even have a cup of coffee with me.
My only small complaint, not even complaint, just sort of a comment really, is that it is kind of weird that the city is based on Cleveland (or so I read in an interview once) but everyone from the city seems to be white. Not that the author described everyone, other than Harry being super pale, but it definitely felt that way. The MEA team is very diverse, but they're all imports, recently at that. This is just something that bothers me frequently in urban fantasy and science fiction. Especially in science fiction, where our entire future frequently seems to be whitewashed, but that's another story. Anyway, this is a fictional city, I do know that. Because if it was here way more of these characters would be people of color. Of many colors and ethnicities, and expecially with a whole lot of African Americans, in positions of authority and influence too, politicians, doctors, teachers, and certainly police officers. I know it's a fictional city, it's just something I've noticed more and more, or maybe less and less depending how you look at it. I do see that Kate's family and maybe her neighborhood or relations appear to be Greek, fine, but where's the rest of the city? The mayor, the police, the snitches, white white white.The MEA team is well balanced though, it looks like a children's show in it's diversity; two straight women, one gay woman, two straight men, on top of the ethnic diversity, so that's a good thing.
The only thing I really don't like about this series is that when the next book, Deadly Spells, come out in March 2015 the trilogy will be complete.