What do you think?
Rate this book
Sexuality and Socialism: History, Politics, and Theory of LGBT Liberation
Sexuality and Socialism is a remarkably accessible analysis of many of the most challenging questions for those concerned with full equality for lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender (LGBT) people. Inside are essays on the roots of LGBT oppression, the construction of sexual and gender identities, the history of the gay movement, and how to unite the oppressed and exploited to win sexual liberation for all. Sherry Wolf analyzes different theories about oppression—including those of Marxism, postmodernism, identity politics, and queer theory—and challenges myths about genes, gender, and sexuality. “ Sexuality and Socialism is the most intelligent and enlightened discussion on sexuality to come from the Left in a long time. No other work that comes to my mind explains the history of sexuality and sexual repression in the United States as comprehensively and compellingly.”— Ron Jacobs , Dissident Voice “Sherry Lesbian, Activist, Communist & Badass-ist... spoke to a pre-National Equality March rally. She. Blew. It. Up.”— Austin Chronicle “Sherry speaks with such eloquence and plain common sense that I can't help but want to know more about her ideas and convictions.”— Derek Washington , “In the LV” radio host, Director of LGBT Outreach, Clark County Democratic Black Caucus “The icons of the new generation of activists are people like Lady Gaga, Dustin Lance Black, Judy Shephard, Lt. Daniel Choi (ret.) and Sherry Wolf (author of Sexuality and Socialism ).”— Don Gorton , Join the Impact Board Member “Surprisingly funny, very readable and a fitting tome for a new movement in these troubled times.”— Dave Zirin for Progressive 's Best Books of 2009 “‘What humans have constructed they can tear down.’ This is the powerful insight of this rare book that is at once politically important, theoretically and historically sophisticated, and clearly written. Sexuality and Socialism is enlivened in its engagement with a number of controversies, including those over the alleged biological determination of homosexuality, the myth of Black homophobia, and the consequences of postmodernist theories for the politics of gay liberation. Above all else, Wolf puts forward a cogent defense of the Marxist tradition—long and wrongly reviled as homophobic in itself—as a way to explain how LGBT oppression arose and what we can do to put it to bed.”— Dana Cloud , University of Texas at Austin Sherry Wolf is the associate editor of the International Socialist Review. She was on the executive committee of the National Equality March Oct. 11, 2009 and has written for publications including the Nation , MRZine , Counterpunch , Dissident Voice , and Socialist Worker and speaks frequently across the country on the struggle for LGBT liberation as well as a wide range of social and economic justice issue.
338 pages, Kindle Edition
First published June 1, 2009
56 people are currently reading
2295 people want to read
About the author
Sherry Wolf
12 books16 followersSherry Wolf is an activist for LGBTQ rights, author, public speaker and associate editor of the International Socialist Review. She has written articles on subjects ranging from abortion rights to the Iraq war. Her essays and lectures can be seen in Monthly Review, Znet, and on CounterPunch.org.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 30 reviews
February 1, 2020
I initially read this book about a year ago, and it's a decent introduction to Marxist analysis of LGBT issues. It's short, accessible, and it has a phenomenal chapter rebutting the outsized influence of postmodernism in queer theory. However, it's not without a handful of glaring flaws. Wolf is a Trotskyist, meaning her view of 20th century Socialist States is that they weren't socialist at all. This cripples her historical analysis of LGBT rights in these States, and leads to absurd assertions and mistakes.
For example, the author condemns Mao's China as 'Stalinist' and not socialist, while praising The Black Panther Party, who was very much ideologically aligned with China, on the very next page. This is never properly addressed, and sticks out as wolf simply being selective of historical leftist movements, based on their favorability towards queer people. Furthermore, Wolf makes no mention of the Cuban organization CENESEX, which had been around for years in Cuba, advocating for LGBT rights. Seemingly, Wolf's Trotskyism causes her to gloss over this subject as per the reasoning that cuba is 'stalinist', and not 'really socialist'.
Ultimately, I'd recommend this book as an introduction, but take the history segments with a heavy grain of salt.
For example, the author condemns Mao's China as 'Stalinist' and not socialist, while praising The Black Panther Party, who was very much ideologically aligned with China, on the very next page. This is never properly addressed, and sticks out as wolf simply being selective of historical leftist movements, based on their favorability towards queer people. Furthermore, Wolf makes no mention of the Cuban organization CENESEX, which had been around for years in Cuba, advocating for LGBT rights. Seemingly, Wolf's Trotskyism causes her to gloss over this subject as per the reasoning that cuba is 'stalinist', and not 'really socialist'.
Ultimately, I'd recommend this book as an introduction, but take the history segments with a heavy grain of salt.
November 26, 2014
Really clearly makes connections between the needs of capitalism, the family, the material construction of heterosexuality & couple-form. It's stridently materialist, which is a rarity & to be welcomed as a counterpoint to much present writing on these topics. I found the politics of the passages about gay marriage & queer politics unconvincing, and some of the causal relationships posited needed more fleshing out (just cos something would be good for the ruling class doesn't mean it just is like that). Thought the attack on postmodernism applied mostly to the worst of it & misrepresented Butler but still a fan of the author's vigorous anti-idealism. Wonderful sections on Marxist attitudes to sexuality (though I suspect a little self promoting in parts) & interesting bits on working class organising and alliance building wrt LGBT issues. Definitely worth reading!
March 28, 2024
I really enjoyed this book. It is not just an interesting political theory book it is also a great history of the LGBTQ movement in the United States. Since it was 2009 when this boon was written, a lot has changed since the book was published but I think it still holds a lot of value.
My biggest criticism is the author in the beginning seeming to blame homophobia on capitalism. I think it is a stretch to romanticize the past when we can clearly see that there is no for sure golden days of sexual liberation. So yes, some parts of the history I had questions about but overall very good.
My biggest criticism is the author in the beginning seeming to blame homophobia on capitalism. I think it is a stretch to romanticize the past when we can clearly see that there is no for sure golden days of sexual liberation. So yes, some parts of the history I had questions about but overall very good.
March 18, 2010
Sexuality and Socialism by Sherry Wolf is described as the ‘History, Politics and Theory of LGBT Liberation.’ A book like this that covers the issues of sexuality and homophobia under capitalism is a long overdue contribution to socialist politics, but especially timely given the struggles all over the world for same-sex marriage rights.
The book covers such a broad scope of different issues within the issues of LGBT oppression and liberation that I cannot possibly cover all of it in one review. It begins with the theoretical and historical origins of sexual oppression under capitalism and makes the argument that the repression of sexuality and things like homophobia are the product of the material conditions and the economic needs of capitalism. This is in stark contrast to explanations that homophobia is in our human nature or just from the religion and the bad ideas in our heads.
It goes on to cover the gay liberation movement of the 60s and 70s and the theory surrounding much of LGBT politics. It then goes on to cover contemporary struggles and debates today.
Sherry Wolf links in all of the arguments within the context of class society and the nature of capitalism. Homophobia and other forms of sexual repression are not divorced from other forms of oppression and the needs of exploiting workers to make a profit.
This is used to argue against the prevalence of ‘identity politics,’ the idea that all LGBT people have a common experience of oppression and a common interest in fighting it. In fact, LGBT workers need to organise separately from LGBT business owners who are tied to the existence of capitalism.
She argues that straight workers have more in common with LGBT workers because they both have a common interest in defending their conditions as workers and fighting their exploiters. Despite homophobia within the working class, Wolf argues that straight workers don’t benefit or gain an advantage by partaking in homophobia as it weakens the working class, divides and distracts workers from the class struggle.
Another aspect of the book that needs to be touched on is the fact that she covers issues of transgender and intersex. This is something that hasn’t really been touched on before in other Marxist literature about sexuality and it’s covered in quite an extensive way.
One point though that wasn’t touched that is sometimes controversial even within the socialist movement is that I think transgender can sometimes been seen as a product of capitalism and the gender norms that come in it. This isn’t to take away from the fact that trans people have the right to have sex changes of identify as another gender but the fact the capitalist society assigns ways of behaving to particular genders, such as women being feminine and men being masculine means that if you don’t fit into these norms then you can feel like you don’t fit into your body.
I would argue that under a socialist society that this feeling would be less prevalent because you wouldn’t need to conform to the gender norms and there wouldn’t be such a connection between gender biology and your behaviour.
Sexuality and Socialism covers a lot and does it clearly. It mixes theoretical and historical explanations with concrete and often emotive contemporary examples that make these issues feel real and connect with the reader. This book is also something that can be re-read in parts as a kind of reference book on Marxists’ attitudes to various issues of LGBT oppression and liberation.
I heartily recommend this book to anyone who is interested in the topics of sexuality, homophobia and LGBT politics.
Originally published @ http://www.benjaminsolah.com/blog/?p=...
The book covers such a broad scope of different issues within the issues of LGBT oppression and liberation that I cannot possibly cover all of it in one review. It begins with the theoretical and historical origins of sexual oppression under capitalism and makes the argument that the repression of sexuality and things like homophobia are the product of the material conditions and the economic needs of capitalism. This is in stark contrast to explanations that homophobia is in our human nature or just from the religion and the bad ideas in our heads.
It goes on to cover the gay liberation movement of the 60s and 70s and the theory surrounding much of LGBT politics. It then goes on to cover contemporary struggles and debates today.
Sherry Wolf links in all of the arguments within the context of class society and the nature of capitalism. Homophobia and other forms of sexual repression are not divorced from other forms of oppression and the needs of exploiting workers to make a profit.
This is used to argue against the prevalence of ‘identity politics,’ the idea that all LGBT people have a common experience of oppression and a common interest in fighting it. In fact, LGBT workers need to organise separately from LGBT business owners who are tied to the existence of capitalism.
She argues that straight workers have more in common with LGBT workers because they both have a common interest in defending their conditions as workers and fighting their exploiters. Despite homophobia within the working class, Wolf argues that straight workers don’t benefit or gain an advantage by partaking in homophobia as it weakens the working class, divides and distracts workers from the class struggle.
Another aspect of the book that needs to be touched on is the fact that she covers issues of transgender and intersex. This is something that hasn’t really been touched on before in other Marxist literature about sexuality and it’s covered in quite an extensive way.
One point though that wasn’t touched that is sometimes controversial even within the socialist movement is that I think transgender can sometimes been seen as a product of capitalism and the gender norms that come in it. This isn’t to take away from the fact that trans people have the right to have sex changes of identify as another gender but the fact the capitalist society assigns ways of behaving to particular genders, such as women being feminine and men being masculine means that if you don’t fit into these norms then you can feel like you don’t fit into your body.
I would argue that under a socialist society that this feeling would be less prevalent because you wouldn’t need to conform to the gender norms and there wouldn’t be such a connection between gender biology and your behaviour.
Sexuality and Socialism covers a lot and does it clearly. It mixes theoretical and historical explanations with concrete and often emotive contemporary examples that make these issues feel real and connect with the reader. This book is also something that can be re-read in parts as a kind of reference book on Marxists’ attitudes to various issues of LGBT oppression and liberation.
I heartily recommend this book to anyone who is interested in the topics of sexuality, homophobia and LGBT politics.
Originally published @ http://www.benjaminsolah.com/blog/?p=...
June 6, 2021
"We identify ourselves with all the oppressed: the Vietnamese struggle, the third world, the blacks, the workers...all those oppressed by this rotten, dirty, vile, fu*ked-up capitalist conspiracy.”-GLF
"... sexual liberation appears impossible without the political, economic, and social liberation that lies at the heart of socialism."-Sherry Wolf
"... sexual liberation appears impossible without the political, economic, and social liberation that lies at the heart of socialism."-Sherry Wolf
Read
April 25, 2021my one non-fiction book for the year is finished !
August 3, 2025
A lot of useful historical information and some good connections between queerness and leftist politics with a critique of rainbow patriarchy implicit.
The attack on what gets dubbed "identity politics" was not very well thought out. It was based on popular misuses of e.g. Butler and ignoring the extent to which trans folk and many other feminists do need the gender binary deconstructed for liberative/material reasons. I guess that was an argument of its time but it's good to see that many feminist materialists have got past the gender binary. In this and a few other issues the author tended to contradict herself.
Still because of some of the historical context it was very useful.
The attack on what gets dubbed "identity politics" was not very well thought out. It was based on popular misuses of e.g. Butler and ignoring the extent to which trans folk and many other feminists do need the gender binary deconstructed for liberative/material reasons. I guess that was an argument of its time but it's good to see that many feminist materialists have got past the gender binary. In this and a few other issues the author tended to contradict herself.
Still because of some of the historical context it was very useful.
June 1, 2024
Μπορεί να μου πήρε 2 χρόνια να ολοκληρώσω αυτό το βιβλίο αλλά τα κατάφερα!
September 8, 2010
This commentary will air on This Way Out, the LGBT radio syndicate, and also appears on http://amusejanetmason.com
Sexuality and Socialism:
History, Politics, and Theory of LGBT Liberation
Sherry Wolf
Haymarket Books (2009)
It is said that the personal is political and I find that the opposite – that the political is personal – is true also, perhaps more so. Consider, for example, the epithet Commie Pinko Queer. When the term originated and was hurled at artists and Progressives of all stripes during the McCarthy era, it certainly was personal. The Hollywood blacklisting by the House Un-American Activities Committee led to the ruin of legions.
More than half a century later, the connotations of the word “Pink” – now associated with post (haste) feminist stardom – are being hurled again in the term “socialist.”
Many decades removed from the McCarthy witch hunt for Commie Pinko Queers – I’ve joked that two out of three isn’t bad. Now, many of us are thinking, “What’s so bad about socialism?”
Let’s claim it.
I came to this thought after reading Sherry Wolf’s Sexuality and Socialism: History, Politics, and Theory of LGBT Liberation.
As Wolf points out, several early champions of the LGBT Liberation movement were involved in the struggle of workplace organizing as well as LGBT rights. “Harry Hay, the founder of the first U.S. gay organization, the Mattachine Society, got his start as a union organizer in the 1930s and 1940s in New York Department Store Workers Union with the International Workers of the World.”
And Harvey Milk, elected San Francisco supervisor in 1977, built a coalition of labor and gay activism by working with the labor unions in organizing a boycott of Coors Beer in the gay bars. In return, the labor unions supported activism against the 1978 Briggs Initiativethat threatened to ban gays and lesbians and anyone who supported gay rights from working in California’s public schools.
Sexuality and Socialism serves up quite a bit of LGBT history as well as political analysis and theory. Wolf touches on mid 19th Century accounts of women passing as men such as Bill in Missouri, the secretary of the International Brotherhood of Boilermakers, of whom it was said, “She drank…she swore, she courted girls, she worked hard as her fellows, she fished and camped, she even chewed tobacco.”
Wolf also points out that even though gays and Communist Party members were persecuted alike under McCarthy in the 1950s, that the Communist Party remained steadfast in its hostility toward homosexuality, denouncing it as a “bourgeois deviation.” She also points out that the word “socialism” is often used in vain, used in various contexts – from governments to splinter groups – to describe systems of thinking and ruling that do not, in fact, support liberation.
Ultimately, Sexuality and Socialism led this reader to the conclusion that given that theory is almost always separate from practice, then all political systems are flawed.
However, when words are used as epithets – whether it’s Socialist or Commie or Pinko or Queer – they are intended to create a climate of fear. And only when we stand strong and together, will this fear lose its power.
Sexuality and Socialism:
History, Politics, and Theory of LGBT Liberation
Sherry Wolf
Haymarket Books (2009)
It is said that the personal is political and I find that the opposite – that the political is personal – is true also, perhaps more so. Consider, for example, the epithet Commie Pinko Queer. When the term originated and was hurled at artists and Progressives of all stripes during the McCarthy era, it certainly was personal. The Hollywood blacklisting by the House Un-American Activities Committee led to the ruin of legions.
More than half a century later, the connotations of the word “Pink” – now associated with post (haste) feminist stardom – are being hurled again in the term “socialist.”
Many decades removed from the McCarthy witch hunt for Commie Pinko Queers – I’ve joked that two out of three isn’t bad. Now, many of us are thinking, “What’s so bad about socialism?”
Let’s claim it.
I came to this thought after reading Sherry Wolf’s Sexuality and Socialism: History, Politics, and Theory of LGBT Liberation.
As Wolf points out, several early champions of the LGBT Liberation movement were involved in the struggle of workplace organizing as well as LGBT rights. “Harry Hay, the founder of the first U.S. gay organization, the Mattachine Society, got his start as a union organizer in the 1930s and 1940s in New York Department Store Workers Union with the International Workers of the World.”
And Harvey Milk, elected San Francisco supervisor in 1977, built a coalition of labor and gay activism by working with the labor unions in organizing a boycott of Coors Beer in the gay bars. In return, the labor unions supported activism against the 1978 Briggs Initiativethat threatened to ban gays and lesbians and anyone who supported gay rights from working in California’s public schools.
Sexuality and Socialism serves up quite a bit of LGBT history as well as political analysis and theory. Wolf touches on mid 19th Century accounts of women passing as men such as Bill in Missouri, the secretary of the International Brotherhood of Boilermakers, of whom it was said, “She drank…she swore, she courted girls, she worked hard as her fellows, she fished and camped, she even chewed tobacco.”
Wolf also points out that even though gays and Communist Party members were persecuted alike under McCarthy in the 1950s, that the Communist Party remained steadfast in its hostility toward homosexuality, denouncing it as a “bourgeois deviation.” She also points out that the word “socialism” is often used in vain, used in various contexts – from governments to splinter groups – to describe systems of thinking and ruling that do not, in fact, support liberation.
Ultimately, Sexuality and Socialism led this reader to the conclusion that given that theory is almost always separate from practice, then all political systems are flawed.
However, when words are used as epithets – whether it’s Socialist or Commie or Pinko or Queer – they are intended to create a climate of fear. And only when we stand strong and together, will this fear lose its power.
December 21, 2009
A very important book for all people-- not just LGBT activists-- to read, giving a brief, critical history of the roots of LGBT oppression, the birth of an LGBT identity, a critique of post-modernist de-mobilization which divides rather than unites, and ultimately a history of the triumphs and solidarity which has involved LGBT activism. Many of the issues Sherry brings up I am confronting first-hand in attempting to bring together a viable, grassroots coalition of LGBT activists after the National Equality March. While Sherry makes a few mistakes in her writings, but these are of no consequence to her overarching point. Written in every-day, accessible language (as always with Haymarket publications), Sexuality and Socialism was a pleasure to read, and it's a pleasure to have Sherry Wolf as a comrade.
December 29, 2014
Sherry Wolf repeatedly miscites sources to construct a nonexistent history (citing party theorists who were censored for their pro sex views as exemplars of the communist tradition or ignoring information about the reconceptualization of sexuality under the early soviets & etc.) to then retread her misinformed argument against queer theory as anti materialist (while idealistically positing a unitary working class or pretending socially marginal queer folx make sense under the labor theory of value) this book wasn't a very good argument in 1992 and it has aged even worse
March 17, 2011
An absolute must-read for anyone serious about LGBT liberation.
Want to read
June 19, 2012I'm a few chapters in and I LOVE it so far. It's really appealing to my geeky history and queer theory loving activist heart.
April 17, 2021
Transphobic & Trotskyist 🙄
September 4, 2023
A work in which Sherry Wolf explores how capitalism affects sexuality and how socialism could offer a more inclusive and egalitarian vision of sexuality (ok, the book reminds us about the stalinism, maoism and castrism and their persecution of homossexuals). The book highlights the importance of uniting progressive movements to create a more just and diverse society. I would give 5 stars, but Sherry practically does not touch (in what for me is the most decisive point in the history of sexuality) the subject of religion and its harmful influence on people's hateful thinking and prejudices regarding other people's sexuality.
Only if the author wanted us to automatically understand that religion is a creation/monozygotic brother of capitalism, but still, the pernicious influence of religion should have been more prominent in this excellent work.
Only if the author wanted us to automatically understand that religion is a creation/monozygotic brother of capitalism, but still, the pernicious influence of religion should have been more prominent in this excellent work.
September 11, 2017
It was an interesting read, but it's definitely dated and I personally felt that Sexuality and Marxism would have been a more fitting title. The writer seemed to me (as a fairly socialist person myself) far more left leaning than the more commonly accepted definition of socialism. It often came across as borderline militant in the methods suggested by the author. That said, it would be interesting to read a more updated version of this, since this book was written pre-marriage equality, and prior to many of the other advances the LGBTQ community has made in the Obama era.
May 30, 2020
An engaging and fascinating history of both LGBT and socialist movements. We have always walked hand in hand together and our future lies in continuing to do so. This book was written a few years ago and it does offer a glimpse into how even as recently as 2009, the progress of today seemed far off.
My only major gripe is sometimes the text could get far too dense with academic jargon and even my pretentious eyes glazed over at some passages. Great content, however. A big recommend for any fellow queer or socialist who wants some insight into our history.
My only major gripe is sometimes the text could get far too dense with academic jargon and even my pretentious eyes glazed over at some passages. Great content, however. A big recommend for any fellow queer or socialist who wants some insight into our history.
June 23, 2021
Desperately in need of updating.
Half of the book is the best historic and philosohical overview; inter-party beef summary; and defense of "LGBT Marxism". Worth buying for the history and its analysis alone.
But the other half is rooted in the first year of the Obama presidency to the point of being irrelevent. How Wolf engages with gender, legal rights, and social attitudes was fantastic at the time, but a new generation of LGBT+ activists who were infants when this was written are now coming onto the scene.
Half of the book is the best historic and philosohical overview; inter-party beef summary; and defense of "LGBT Marxism". Worth buying for the history and its analysis alone.
But the other half is rooted in the first year of the Obama presidency to the point of being irrelevent. How Wolf engages with gender, legal rights, and social attitudes was fantastic at the time, but a new generation of LGBT+ activists who were infants when this was written are now coming onto the scene.
August 6, 2022
I read this book to gain more knowledge on topics of Sexuality, LGBT history, and Politics. It's the first book I read of the kind, and not being a knowledgeable person on this topics I think that the book becames a little too dense/complex at times. But that is probably my problem and it is only my take. Maybe I would have needed to read more on these topics before reading this book. But over all it is a good book.
Read
August 20, 2020One of only a handful of books I managed to read during my Marxist-Leninist phase. Also one of the first books I read about LGBTQ identity and its politics. I don't know how well it would stand up to what I know now, but it served as an accessible introduction.
June 15, 2017
I mean it's certainly not the most FUN book I've ever read but I think it was worth a read for queer people and leftists fighting for liberation from oppressive systems.
July 7, 2017
I recommend this book to anyone interested in sexuality and socialism, and how the two may be connected. The argument is clear and the book is well referenced.
June 25, 2020
Dili ve anlattıklarıyla güzel bir kitaptı ancak güncel bir versiyonu daha da keyifli olurdu. Zamanım şartları için muhteşem.
May 30, 2021
gets kinda boring, really had to push through. also says pretty broad things that I kinda disagree with
October 24, 2021
Really good clear, sharp and political. Focuses heavily on the US, but still does go for a world perspective.
Read
June 26, 2023thought-provoking and educational
April 10, 2025
A comprehensive dialectical materialist analysis. Really fantastic politics
Want to read
December 31, 2009Fairly balanced review from Christopher Phelps where he point out a lack of attention to anarchist viewpoints (Free Comrades Anarchism and Homosexuality in the United States 1895-1917 might be a good corrective to that) and some inaccuracy as concerns Harry Hay's activities : http://www.isreview.org/issues/68/rev...
(the review appears in the ISR, a publication of the ISO, of which Sherry Wolf is a member.)
(the review appears in the ISR, a publication of the ISO, of which Sherry Wolf is a member.)
November 7, 2013
Oh boy I finished this months ago.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 30 reviews