Chojin X Volume 4: This Is the Story of X
The first half of this continues the absolute insanity and brilliance that was the end of V.3. Azuma is a chojin! He's trying to kill everyone! He, or Tokio, might be the one-man-calamity of prophecy! The fight between Tokio and Azuma in chaos chojin forms is brilliantly choreographed and visually stunning. It's also emotionally devastating. Especially that aftermath portion when Azuma realizes that he is no longer Tokio's hero, but might be the villain in his friend's story :'( ... and when Tokio forgives him and invites him to develop his powers at Yamato Mori so they can be heroes together :)
The backstory drops on Ely and the Great Chojin War are also epic and gorgeously illustrated. It feels like we're really getting places with both the world building and character development.
However things fall off in the back third when it seems like, after hitting some real emotional peaks and *finally* starting to take itself seriously, CX falls back into its usual pattern of undercutting its violent, intense scenes by following them up with juvenile goofiness and fanservice jokes. So, we get the Obligatory Shonen Training Montage on the beach, and the Obligatory Female Characters In Bikinis Fanservice Scene, and a training drill in which a very sexy and considerably older female chojin ties up Tokio with brambles and "motivates" him in the most sexualized way possible, that should qualify as child abuse but somehow is played for laughs. Ugh, really, Ishida? You may be my favorite mangaka but sometimes you really, really tick me off.
We get some absolutely tragic backstory on Simon Kagomura at the very end. Poor baby. He deserves all the hugs. And I think Simon may actually be more interesting of a character than either of the male leads so far. I am pretty invested in Azuma and Tokio's friendship, and Ely continues to grow on me, but I'm still not 100% in love with the main 3 as characters yet the way I already was at this point for other manga like Tokyo Ghoul or Noragami. But if Ishida can keep up with the amazing superpowered teamwork and steady backstory drops, and not undercut things too much with jokes and tone shifts, I think we could eventually get there.
Things start to heat up and get serious again at the end, though, as more eccentric-but-terrifying chojin baddies show up to crash the party and set the stage for an epic, action-packed Volume 5.
For CX As A Whole (So Far):
I started reading Sui Ishida's absolutely incredible Tokyo Ghoul a few months ago, so when I found out the author has a second, still ongoing, manga series, I was eager to jump on the bandwagon.
At first glance, Chojin X (or Choujin X) shares a lot of surface similarities with the mangaka's previous smash hit, Tokyo Ghoul . An every-boy protagonist dealing with sudden, grotesque changes to his body, themes of alienation and injustice, rival organizations of super-powered folk with their own mysterious goals ... it's all here, too. At the same time, though, it isn't really fair to compare this series to TG. It is its own beast (or rather, its own bestial Chojin) and even in its early stages, there are already a few key differences.
For one, Chojin X feels a lot more like a shonen manga than its predecessor. The characters are several years younger, and their personal struggles feel more teenaged than young adult, though Ishida being Ishida, the psychology is still expertly well-drawn. The arcs feel more like self-contained adventures, there's more emphasis on big fights, and the themes feel more focused on friendship and figuring out one's purpose in life than the intense moral and psychological questions of TG. There's a school for young superhumans, and the accompanying training montage scenes, as well, all of which feels solidly shonen. There's also quite a bit more wacky humor, which I have mixed feelings about (see below). So rather than comparing Chojin X to TG, perhaps a better comparison would be to new gen shonen like Chainsaw Man, Demon Slayer, My Hero Academia, Jujitsu Kaisen, Dan Da Dan, Kaiju #8, Sakamoto Days, etc. -- and in comparison to the aforementioned titles, Chojin X, while less accessible or tonally consistent, manages to hold its own. Despite its other weaknesses, CX's outstanding art and psychological drama give it an edge in the world of new-gen shonen.
Tokio and Azuma's friendship, with its heady combination of mutual admiration and mutual resentment, is the real heart of Chojin X, and it is by far the best thing about this series, especially in its early parts. Tokio's decision to become a chojin is ultimately motivated by his desperate desire to be someone self-assured and accomplished like Azuma, and the hideous vulture form he takes is pretty much an externalization of his repressed feelings of shame and resentment towards his friend. As in TG, Ishida really excels at expressing his characters' complexes and hangups through beautifully insane body horror. Still, though, I'll also admit that I did not find Tokio, Azuma, or Ely as likeable or interesting as even the secondary characters in early Tokyo Ghoul, but we shall see.
The art is incredible, with cute but distinctive and detailed character designs and bold, sketchy strokes bringing the run-down world of Yamato, the Chojin body horror, and the subtle facial expressions of the human characters beautifully to life. It feels more stylized and shonen-y than Tokyo Ghoul, but it is still quite recognizably Ishida, and it is truly a cut above the typical manga illustration style. It's well-worth paying $15 each for the oversize tankobon volumes for the cover illustrations and artwork alone.
I think if there was one word I would use to describe Chojin X so far it would be "indulgent." That's both a criticism and a compliment. On the plus side, Ishida seems to be having a lot of fun with the process this time around, and his enthusiasm is infectious. An artist this talented being given this much freedom to let his imagination run wild is a joy to behold. The experimental art style yields some lovely surprises at every flip of the page. The sheer coolness factor of the Chojin powers and transformations (as well as the intricate worldbuilding that undergirds Chojin physiology and history) is pretty enjoyable. And even some of the sillier, what-the-hell-even-was-that sequences are at least visually fun.
But unfortunately, the level of authorial self-indulgence starts to become a bit of a problem for the story itself. To put it bluntly, Ishida just isn't as funny or clever as he seems to think he is. That's not to say he's not funny -- Tokyo Ghoul had its lighthearted and comedic moments, too, and those were deployed masterfully to make readers care about the characters (and give them a much-needed reprieve from the relentless violence and angst). But Chojin X's wild swings between genuinely affecting character drama and wacky shennanigans including superpowered baseball, an ill-fated attempt at eating pancakes while having a vulture skull for a head, and a high-speed tractor chase (yes, really), honestly felt more distracting than charming to me. So far, I feel like the silliness of this manga undermines the big story moments rather than building on them like TG did. It's like Chojin X can't decide whether to be a serious, dark drama like, say, Tokyo Ghoul or Attack on Titan, or a wacky, unhinged romp that never takes itself too seriously, like Kaiju #8 or Dan Da Dan. Instead it tries to split the difference and ends up falling short at both. It is unserious but it still takes itself way too seriously, if that makes sense. Though I will say around volume 5/6 it starts to become more serious for the most part and gets quite a bit better.
Oh and speaking of indulgent ... I feel obliged to say that the fanservice in Chojin X is absolutely heinous. Like I do not know how Sui Ishida managed to make the boob jokes in CX feel dirtier than the literal chapter-long sex scene in TG: re, but, somehow, he pulled it off. What's worse is when the fanservice jokes are at the expense of the younger female characters -- Ely, Maiko/Momo, and, eventually, Palma -- who are minors (Ely is stated to be 16 but looks like she's about 13. Momo is 18, and Palma is 16). Now, look, I know fanservice is just part of the deal with shonen manga/anime, considering that the primary audience is teenage boys, and, well, teenage boys like certain things. But I am genuinely pissed off because I know that my boy Sui Ishida-sensei is capable of better so I don't know why he doesn't just DO better.
The one saving grace is that Ely, the female co-protagonist, is a pretty solid character. She's funny, she's smart, she's brave, she's tough, and she's deeply endearing. She's also, at this point, the strongest protagonist of the three. Momo is also cool and likeable, if underutilized, and Zora, the former hero of Yamato Mori turned mad witch is a powerful female villain who is, thankfully, not sexualized at all. The female characters are *just* cool, smart, and likeable enough that I can overlook the fanservice and not throw the book across the room, but do be warned: Chojin X has a fanservice problem, and unfortunately it does not get better later in the series.
Still, despite its uneven start and some lingering issues, Chojin X is shaping up into a solid series that, recently (volumes 11/12 as of latest serialization) has been getting very good. So it's worth powering through the earlier volumes to get to the good stuff.