I would love to read Washington Irving’s texts to know how his stories go and to savour the 1856 language. He only lived three more years. I am giving my feedback on this omnibus’ three short stories individually, paired with the original author’s name.
I suspect and hope these 1995 versions of “The Legend Of Sleepy Hollow”, “Rip Van Winkle”, and “Golden Dreams” are inferior to Washington’s original stories. This collection’s adapter was Jack Kelly, its editor was Joshua E. Hanft, its publisher was Baronet Books, and this series was Great Illustrated Classics. Avoid this omnibus, which I attribute to the low quality of these stories. If you put your names on something, boys, complete your craft with excellence. I pay for my books and earned the freedom to review them with polite and candid honesty.
Under this omnibus record, I am singly grading the short story “Golden Dreams”, 1856. I liked it least of all, despite somehow giving the same two stars. The famous tales were spooky or mysterious. This one revolved around greed and the starkest stupidity I have ever read. I don’t remember why I gave it a second star in October at all. It is January 2025.
In the 1700s, New York lost the rural peace Mr. Webber cherished. Prices rose but they had the same cabbage yield. Amy loved Dirk Waldron but marriage might mean giving them some of the land. Instead of helping a Daughter’s happiness or seeing a husband as an earning asset; he asked them to be apart.
Further lunacy came from a sailor, saying you would strike gold if you dreamed of it. You couldn’t get me to risk digging a dependable cabbage patch, over a theory! How shitty, to honour a Daughter only if your circumstances panned out ideally.