Poisoned Lives: English Poisoners and their Victims

by Katherine Watson

From Mary Ann Cotton, the Victorian serial murderess, to Dr Crippen, poisoners have attracted a celebrity unmatched by violent killers. Secretly administered, often during a family meal, arsenic (the most commonly-used poison) led to a slow and agonising death, while strychnine (with its characteristic bitter taste) killed very quickly. Poisoned Lives is the first history of the crime to examine poisoning and its consequences as a whole. Unwanted husbands, wives or lovers, illegitimate babies, children killed for the insurance money, relatives, rivals and employers were amongst the many victims of these calculating killers. Difficult to detect before 1800, poison undoubtedly had its heyday in the nineteenth century. In response to many suspected cases, forensic tests were developed that made detection increasingly likely, and the sale of poisons became more tightly controlled. Because of this, twentieth-century poisoning has become a crime largely associated with medical professionals including, most recently, Dr Harold Shipman, the world's most prolific serial killer.

Genres: Nonfiction, True Crime, Crime, Historical

272 pages, Paperback

First published March 4, 2004

Reviews

[Catie]

Mentioned in the acknowledgements of, The Lost Apothecary by Sarah Penner - March 2021

[Deanne · Rating 4 out of 5]

Interesting book which encompasses two of my favourite subjects, history and crime. There was a time when it was easy to bump off those pesky relatives who stood in the way of you inheriting a large lump of money. Then people came up with a way of discovering things like arsenic, no longer could you get a gullible doctor to agree that great aunt Doris had died of Asiatic cholera, especially when you had to sign a poison book and even worse they started dyeing the stuff blue.
This book traces not only the changes in the law, but other changes in the legal system and life which influenced why and who people bumped off.

[Susannah · Rating 4 out of 5]

A very interesting study of poisoners and the motives of various poisoners and how these motives change over time. I was a bit bored in the sections about courts and coroners, But was very interested in the links between poverty and poisoning and the Poor Law.

[MARTA · Rating 3 out of 5]

An other good reference book.

[A.L. Butcher · Rating 5 out of 5]

Many of the true crime books focus solely on the murders themselves, as one would expect. Usually the same twenty or so crimes are discussed and not often in detail. This book is different. Over 500 cases from 19th century to the early 20th century are included, although many as comparisons and not in detail. That said the author does a great job of discussing the 'whys and wherefores' of the crimes - the societal aspects, how they changed, the rise of the police force, and the increased awareness of poisoning as a crime. Before the 1900s sanitary conditions amongst the poor were dire, life expectancy short and infant mortality high. Many of the cases discussed, and the situations covered reflect this - people poisoning as to not have another mouth to feed, to get a few pounds from the 'burial clubs' which sprang up, ostensibly to help the poor, and the new 'life insurance' schemes which abounded. Poisoning is viewed as the most despicable of crimes; usually it is a slow and very painful process, and often the perpetrator is well known to the victim - spouse, parent, servant, nurse/doctor. It's easy to judge by the modern standards when life expectation is relatively high, health provision freely available (in the UK at least), a social security system, divorce attainable, much less stigma on illegitimacy and very few people are truly desperately poor. Oh and poison is much harder to get. But one must realise that sometimes disposal of an unwanted, violent spouse, was the only way out some people could see. There were simply no viable alternatives. 

Watson discusses the changing views and social ideas - the emerging rights of women; ideas pertaining towards mental illness; religious and moral ideology and the rise of the forensic scientist, the role of the coroner and much more. It's a potted history which changes vastly over time.  This, I think, is the most fascinating aspect. There is no sensationalisation of the cases - which sometimes appears in books on true crime - the subjects are dealt with in a sympathetic way. It's a book of tragedy - lost lives, destroyed lives, desperation and the depths of human misery, but there is also hope. Murder by poison is rare now and more easily diagnosed. And society is not as brutish, or terrifying as once it was for the common person. 

Well researched, well argued and highly interesting I'd recommend this book to anyone interested in true crime, 19th Century history, the rise of science and the social reasons for crime.