I really wanted to like this. And I did. In the beginning. I just could not hold onto that feeling the more I read.
Shay kept pissing me off, and the further I got into the story, the more I hated her. (She completely wiped away any ill will I felt toward Harper in Book 2 for refusing to communicate with Jaxson.) Here’s this guy, who is pretty perfect, going through one of the absolute worst times in his life, and she can only think about herself. The whole thing about missing her mom and best friend was so far out of left field. She left her mom in LA to live in SF, and she rarely saw or talked to the BFF/roommate. It seemed more like a fabricated excuse to end the relationship. For pretty much the entire second act, I felt as though she had one foot out the door, just waiting on the chance to bail. Then bam, all of a sudden, out of no where, she’s all in, and everything is tied up in a pretty little bow.
A huge disappointment for me but I don’t think it’s deserving of anything less than 3 stars. I didn’t hate the story. Just the one character.
Side note: I’m really curious how Grantham and Amy got together. We just had that little teaser in Book Two that they were talking at the launch party.