What do you think?
Rate this book
A Science Fiction Omnibus
This new edition of Brian Aldiss's classic anthology brings together a diverse selection of science fiction spanning over sixty years, from Isaac Asimov's 'Nightfall', first published in 1941, to the 2006 story 'Friends in Need' by Eliza Blair. Including authors such as Clifford Simak, Harry Harrison, Bruce Sterling, A. E. Van Vogt and Brian Aldiss himself, these stories portray struggles against machines, epic journeys, genetic experiments, time travellers and alien races. From stories set on Earth, to uncanny far distant worlds and ancient burnt-out suns, the one constant is humanity itself, compelled by an often fatal curiosity to explore the boundless frontiers of time, space and probability.
590 pages, Kindle Edition
First published January 1, 1973
67 people are currently reading
890 people want to read
About the author
Brian W. Aldiss
834 books673 followersPseudonyms: Jael Cracken, Peter Pica, John Runciman, C.C. Shackleton, Arch Mendicant, & "Doc" Peristyle.
Brian Wilson Aldiss was one of the most important voices in science fiction writing today. He wrote his first novel while working as a bookseller in Oxford. Shortly afterwards he wrote his first work of science fiction and soon gained international recognition. Adored for his innovative literary techniques, evocative plots and irresistible characters, he became a Grand Master of Science Fiction in 1999.
Brian Aldiss died on August 19, 2017, just after celebrating his 92nd birthday with his family and closest friends.
Brian W. Aldiss Group on Good Reads
Brian Wilson Aldiss was one of the most important voices in science fiction writing today. He wrote his first novel while working as a bookseller in Oxford. Shortly afterwards he wrote his first work of science fiction and soon gained international recognition. Adored for his innovative literary techniques, evocative plots and irresistible characters, he became a Grand Master of Science Fiction in 1999.
Brian Aldiss died on August 19, 2017, just after celebrating his 92nd birthday with his family and closest friends.
Brian W. Aldiss Group on Good Reads
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 51 reviews
Want to read
January 15, 2018For now, this is just a review of Build Up Logically by Howard Schoenfeld. A story I rate 4*.
It's a very short story that cleverly twists fact, fiction, and time travel (maybe). Twisted in a good way and slightly reminiscent of Jorge Luis Borges, though Borges is the superior writer, imo.
The underlying concept quite good. Not entirely original, but an original take on ideas of art imitating life and vice versa, of fictional figures coming to life, or people literally entering fictional worlds. I was reminded of Jane's Adventures In and Out of the Book, which I loved as a child, and the delightful comical picture book I recently saw at a friend's, Who's Afraid of the Big Bad Book?.
The title is plain from the start: Frank's ability to "invent the rabbit... he built it up logically from the feel." Later, he builds the piano logically, but from the sound. That's the easy, straightforward stuff.
After that, things get more complicated, exploring reality, authorship, and the power (or not) to determine our fate. Watch the pronouns.
I was amused by the conceit of the time machine that allegedly , and the guy reminded me of poor paranoid android, Marvin, stranded at the car park at The Restaurant at the End of the Universe.
The convolutions at the end reminded me of Ronald Opus, a legal conundrum everyone should be familiar with: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ronald_....
There was a small logical flaw on the first page: .
This was a very quick buddy read with Apatt (though not his choice of story).
You can read Build Up Logically HERE, though it's given the title The Universal Panacea.
It's a very short story that cleverly twists fact, fiction, and time travel (maybe). Twisted in a good way and slightly reminiscent of Jorge Luis Borges, though Borges is the superior writer, imo.
The underlying concept quite good. Not entirely original, but an original take on ideas of art imitating life and vice versa, of fictional figures coming to life, or people literally entering fictional worlds. I was reminded of Jane's Adventures In and Out of the Book, which I loved as a child, and the delightful comical picture book I recently saw at a friend's, Who's Afraid of the Big Bad Book?.
The title is plain from the start: Frank's ability to "invent the rabbit... he built it up logically from the feel." Later, he builds the piano logically, but from the sound. That's the easy, straightforward stuff.
After that, things get more complicated, exploring reality, authorship, and the power (or not) to determine our fate. Watch the pronouns.
I was amused by the conceit of the time machine that allegedly , and the guy reminded me of poor paranoid android, Marvin, stranded at the car park at The Restaurant at the End of the Universe.
The convolutions at the end reminded me of Ronald Opus, a legal conundrum everyone should be familiar with: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ronald_....
There was a small logical flaw on the first page: .
This was a very quick buddy read with Apatt (though not his choice of story).
You can read Build Up Logically HERE, though it's given the title The Universal Panacea.
January 4, 2024
This revised omnibus of Science Fiction (curated by the wild and regal, Brian Aldiss) is a reminder of how vast, powerful, silly, and gut-wrenching raw the genre can be. There's so much depth in these pages that I have no idea where to begin....perhaps with the final inclusion, the novella by John Crowley, 'Great Work of Time.' Like most of Crowley's work, one reader begins reading his stories with rigor and befuddlement, only to remain on his wayward lines and then be pushed off the cliff into a multitude of wonder, epiphany, and haunted displacement. Here is a tale set in London about a group, The Otherhood, who try to create a better world by changing Britain's power in the global scheme, the global history of the world. A double-edge sword, no doubt, but what comes about is a narrative that eats itself, and where even dopplegangers multiply. How Crowley can cross-weave time (Victorian era, WWI, and then way forward to a gaslit London served by aliens and angels, and where humanoid women run the show yet remain unseen). Fantastically jaw-dropping ('the forest on the sea' dreamscape image, for example) only wraps up a collection that is pure enjoyment and historically rich. Wonder in all forms of pulp and literary co-exist, as they should. Deliveries differ, of course, but imagination remains ever-present.
Clifford D. Simak plays the orderly 1950s with the disorderly items of an office space betraying their masters. James Inglis takes his turn at playing Olaf Stapleton's 'Starmaker' and turns his tale, 'Night Watch', into a lonely meditation of universes expanding and contracting and ultimately dimming to the black. Greg Bear's 'Blood Music' shows how microbiology can turn science into outright horror - the vines of cancer run deep through all that we have built. Of course, Asimov's 'Nightfall' shows why it's been anthologized so many times. Harry Harrison's 'Alien Agony' turns a Jesuit pratfall into a true horror ending - how pariahs are made (and fallen) in the stars above -- brutal, actually. James Tiptree writes about alien sex and desire like nobody else - she plays masculinity with hermaphroditical aplomb. Bruce Sterling's 'Swarm' is a grotesque hive-mind wonder. Relatively unknown, Garry Kilworth's 'Alien Embassy' is a fantasy island short that has both spiritual enlightenment alongside the brutalism of Paul Bowles writing from the future. Ted Chiang's 'Story of your Life' is worthy of its merit, but more for its stylistics and framing than the its rather standard Invasion template. James Schmidt's 'Grandpa' is even stranger than R.A. Lafferty's work -- how an alien lifeform used as a raft becomes an episode of Robinson Crusoe in this aquatic funhouse of doom. Toss in classics about A.I. brains controlling mortals in A.E. Vogt's 'Fulfillment' and the domestic, suburban horror of departing doom via a station wagon in Ward Moore's 'Lot.'
Of course some of the tales don't shout above the crowd (in particular, Eliza Blair's modern tale is kind of a sloppy dud thanks to its not-so-clever linguistics), yet taken as a whole, 'A Science Fiction Omnibus' is brilliant, as much glorious ground is covered, both terrestrial and extra, inner and outer. Aldiss has reminded us that the scope of the genre is always in flux, and it shows from the golden age onwards. And where else do Steinbeck, Ballard, and H.B. Pyfe share pages.....
If you need to reignite your love of the genre (like I did), this is a good springboard back to where wonder resides...
Clifford D. Simak plays the orderly 1950s with the disorderly items of an office space betraying their masters. James Inglis takes his turn at playing Olaf Stapleton's 'Starmaker' and turns his tale, 'Night Watch', into a lonely meditation of universes expanding and contracting and ultimately dimming to the black. Greg Bear's 'Blood Music' shows how microbiology can turn science into outright horror - the vines of cancer run deep through all that we have built. Of course, Asimov's 'Nightfall' shows why it's been anthologized so many times. Harry Harrison's 'Alien Agony' turns a Jesuit pratfall into a true horror ending - how pariahs are made (and fallen) in the stars above -- brutal, actually. James Tiptree writes about alien sex and desire like nobody else - she plays masculinity with hermaphroditical aplomb. Bruce Sterling's 'Swarm' is a grotesque hive-mind wonder. Relatively unknown, Garry Kilworth's 'Alien Embassy' is a fantasy island short that has both spiritual enlightenment alongside the brutalism of Paul Bowles writing from the future. Ted Chiang's 'Story of your Life' is worthy of its merit, but more for its stylistics and framing than the its rather standard Invasion template. James Schmidt's 'Grandpa' is even stranger than R.A. Lafferty's work -- how an alien lifeform used as a raft becomes an episode of Robinson Crusoe in this aquatic funhouse of doom. Toss in classics about A.I. brains controlling mortals in A.E. Vogt's 'Fulfillment' and the domestic, suburban horror of departing doom via a station wagon in Ward Moore's 'Lot.'
Of course some of the tales don't shout above the crowd (in particular, Eliza Blair's modern tale is kind of a sloppy dud thanks to its not-so-clever linguistics), yet taken as a whole, 'A Science Fiction Omnibus' is brilliant, as much glorious ground is covered, both terrestrial and extra, inner and outer. Aldiss has reminded us that the scope of the genre is always in flux, and it shows from the golden age onwards. And where else do Steinbeck, Ballard, and H.B. Pyfe share pages.....
If you need to reignite your love of the genre (like I did), this is a good springboard back to where wonder resides...
July 8, 2012
Great collection of classic stories. Ratings for individual stories are listed below on a 5-star scale. Note the inclusion of a John Steinbeck tale, and a good one at that!
• Sole Solution (1956) • Eric Frank Russell - 4
• Lot (1953) • Ward Moore 4.5
• The Short-Short Story of Mankind (1958) • John Steinbeck 4
• Skirmish (1950) • Clifford D. Simak 4
• Poor Little Warrior! (1958) • Brian W. Aldiss 3.5
• Grandpa (1955) • James H. Schmitz 4
• The Half Pair (1957) • A. Bertram Chandler 3
• Command Performance (1952) • Walter M. Miller, Jr. 3.5
• Nightfall (1941) • Isaac Asimov 4.5
• The Snowball Effect (1952) • Katherine MacLean 3
• The End of Summer (1954) • Algis Budrys 3
• Track 12 (1958) • J.G. Ballard 4.5
• The Monkey Wrench (1951) • Gordon R. Dickson 2.5
• The First Men (1960) • Howard Fast 4
• Counterfeit (1952) • Alan E. Nourse 3
• The Greater Thing (1954) • Tom Godwin 3.5
• Built Up Logically (1949) • Howard Schoenfeld 4
• The Liberation of Earth (1953) • William Tenn 4
• An Alien Agony/The Streets of Ashkelon (1962) • Harry Harrison 3
• The Tunnel Under the World (1955) • Frederik Pohl 4
• The Store of the Worlds (1959) • Robert Sheckley 4
• Jokester (1956) • Isaac Asimov 3.5
• Pyramid (1954) • Robert Abernathy 3
• The Forgotten Enemy (1948) • Arthur C. Clarke 3.5
• The Wall Around the World (1953) • Theodore R. Cogswell 4
• Protected Species (1951) • H.B. Fyfe 3
• Before Eden (1961) • Arthur C. Clarke 3.5
• The Rescuer (1967) • Arthur Porges 3
• I Made You (1954) • Walter M. Miller, Jr. 3.5
• The Country of the Kind (1956) • Damon Knight 2
• MS. Found in a Chinese Fortune Cookie (1957) • C.M. Kornbluth 2
• The Cage (1957) • A. Bertram Chandler 3.5
• Eastward Ho! (1958) • William Tenn 3.5
• The Windows of Heaven (1956) • John Brunner 4
• Common Time (1953) • James Blish 2.5
• Fulfillment (1951) • A.E. van Vogt 2.5
• Sole Solution (1956) • Eric Frank Russell - 4
• Lot (1953) • Ward Moore 4.5
• The Short-Short Story of Mankind (1958) • John Steinbeck 4
• Skirmish (1950) • Clifford D. Simak 4
• Poor Little Warrior! (1958) • Brian W. Aldiss 3.5
• Grandpa (1955) • James H. Schmitz 4
• The Half Pair (1957) • A. Bertram Chandler 3
• Command Performance (1952) • Walter M. Miller, Jr. 3.5
• Nightfall (1941) • Isaac Asimov 4.5
• The Snowball Effect (1952) • Katherine MacLean 3
• The End of Summer (1954) • Algis Budrys 3
• Track 12 (1958) • J.G. Ballard 4.5
• The Monkey Wrench (1951) • Gordon R. Dickson 2.5
• The First Men (1960) • Howard Fast 4
• Counterfeit (1952) • Alan E. Nourse 3
• The Greater Thing (1954) • Tom Godwin 3.5
• Built Up Logically (1949) • Howard Schoenfeld 4
• The Liberation of Earth (1953) • William Tenn 4
• An Alien Agony/The Streets of Ashkelon (1962) • Harry Harrison 3
• The Tunnel Under the World (1955) • Frederik Pohl 4
• The Store of the Worlds (1959) • Robert Sheckley 4
• Jokester (1956) • Isaac Asimov 3.5
• Pyramid (1954) • Robert Abernathy 3
• The Forgotten Enemy (1948) • Arthur C. Clarke 3.5
• The Wall Around the World (1953) • Theodore R. Cogswell 4
• Protected Species (1951) • H.B. Fyfe 3
• Before Eden (1961) • Arthur C. Clarke 3.5
• The Rescuer (1967) • Arthur Porges 3
• I Made You (1954) • Walter M. Miller, Jr. 3.5
• The Country of the Kind (1956) • Damon Knight 2
• MS. Found in a Chinese Fortune Cookie (1957) • C.M. Kornbluth 2
• The Cage (1957) • A. Bertram Chandler 3.5
• Eastward Ho! (1958) • William Tenn 3.5
• The Windows of Heaven (1956) • John Brunner 4
• Common Time (1953) • James Blish 2.5
• Fulfillment (1951) • A.E. van Vogt 2.5
June 20, 2018
An outstanding collection of stories showing just how diverse the genre can be.
Herein really is contained some of the best short stories SF has to offer. My highlights include:
"Lot" by Ward Moore - An incredibly chilling and poignant account of a man trying to get his family out of the city as nuclear war breaks out and society begins to collapse. He is well prepared but perhaps a little to cool and calculating...
"Nightfall" by Isaac Asimov - A planet with five suns rarely experiences night time but now its coming and the people don't know what to expect. Perhaps their civilisation will collapse...
"Swarm" by Bruce Sterling - Humanity encounters a space faring non intelligent race. Perhaps it can be exploited...
"Blood Music" by Greg Bear - A man injects his body with self replicating, self learning nano bots with the only instruction to keep on improving everything...
"Story of your life" by Ted Chiang - A linguist is employed to attempt to desipher an alien language but in doing so it radically changes her perception.
These are just some of the great stories you'll find in here. A great overview of the genre.
Herein really is contained some of the best short stories SF has to offer. My highlights include:
"Lot" by Ward Moore - An incredibly chilling and poignant account of a man trying to get his family out of the city as nuclear war breaks out and society begins to collapse. He is well prepared but perhaps a little to cool and calculating...
"Nightfall" by Isaac Asimov - A planet with five suns rarely experiences night time but now its coming and the people don't know what to expect. Perhaps their civilisation will collapse...
"Swarm" by Bruce Sterling - Humanity encounters a space faring non intelligent race. Perhaps it can be exploited...
"Blood Music" by Greg Bear - A man injects his body with self replicating, self learning nano bots with the only instruction to keep on improving everything...
"Story of your life" by Ted Chiang - A linguist is employed to attempt to desipher an alien language but in doing so it radically changes her perception.
These are just some of the great stories you'll find in here. A great overview of the genre.
March 4, 2022
ENGLISH: In 1975 I read the first edition of this book, published in 1973. It contained 36 SciFi short stories by well-known authors. Now I have read the 2007 edition, where the number of stories has been reduced to 31, 21 of which were in the previous edition (which means that 15 of the old stories are missing), while 10 are new (7 short stories, two novellas and a full novel). Fortunately, my best-beloved five stories of the first edition are also included in the new one. These stories are:
1. "Grandpa," by James H. Schmitz (1955), also included in The Hub: Dangerous Territory.
2. "Nightfall," by Isaac Asimov (1941), frequently antologized.
3. "The Snowball Effect," by Katherine MacLean (1952).
4. "The Store of the Worlds," by Robert Sheckley (1959), an excellent post-apocalyptic story.
5. "The Rescuer," by Arthur Porges (1967), see this post in my blog: https://populscience.blogspot.com/201...
To this five I must add one of the new ones: Story of Your Life, by Ted Chiang, which is also excellent, even though I don't agree with its interpretation of time.
ESPAÑOL: En 1975 leí la primera edición de este libro, que se había publicado en 1973. Contenía 36 cuentos de ciencia ficción de autores conocidos. Ahora he leído la edición de 2007, en la que el número de cuentos se ha reducido a 31, de los que 21 estaban también en la edición anterior (lo que significa que faltan 15 de los cuentos antiguos), mientras que 10 son nuevos (7 cuentos, dos novelas cortas y una novela larga).
Afortunadamente, mis cinco cuentos preferidos de la primera edición también están incluidos en la nueva. Esos cuentos están enumerados en la versión inglesa de esta crítica (unas líneas más arriba).
A estos cinco debo agregar uno de los nuevos: Story of Your Life, de Ted Chiang, que también es excelente, aunque yo no esté de acuerdo con su interpretación del tiempo.
1. "Grandpa," by James H. Schmitz (1955), also included in The Hub: Dangerous Territory.
2. "Nightfall," by Isaac Asimov (1941), frequently antologized.
3. "The Snowball Effect," by Katherine MacLean (1952).
4. "The Store of the Worlds," by Robert Sheckley (1959), an excellent post-apocalyptic story.
5. "The Rescuer," by Arthur Porges (1967), see this post in my blog: https://populscience.blogspot.com/201...
To this five I must add one of the new ones: Story of Your Life, by Ted Chiang, which is also excellent, even though I don't agree with its interpretation of time.
ESPAÑOL: En 1975 leí la primera edición de este libro, que se había publicado en 1973. Contenía 36 cuentos de ciencia ficción de autores conocidos. Ahora he leído la edición de 2007, en la que el número de cuentos se ha reducido a 31, de los que 21 estaban también en la edición anterior (lo que significa que faltan 15 de los cuentos antiguos), mientras que 10 son nuevos (7 cuentos, dos novelas cortas y una novela larga).
Afortunadamente, mis cinco cuentos preferidos de la primera edición también están incluidos en la nueva. Esos cuentos están enumerados en la versión inglesa de esta crítica (unas líneas más arriba).
A estos cinco debo agregar uno de los nuevos: Story of Your Life, de Ted Chiang, que también es excelente, aunque yo no esté de acuerdo con su interpretación del tiempo.
January 1, 2022
I received this book as a present for Christmas 2007, the year it was published as an update to an original published in 1963. Brian Aldiss, the complier, is an author I’ve never heard of, and he appears to have taken very little trouble to refresh this anthology in the fifty years’ span. It’s overwhelmingly white, male, mid-century authors, of which Aldiss is unapologetically one; in his introduction, he says, ‘Lowering the technocratic threshold appears to account for SF’s widening readership among women nowadays, together with a weakening in faith in technological progress’. I highly resent the assertion that women are a hive-mind who all hate ‘high technocratic thresholds’, whatever the fuck that means in practice. However, on a personal level, I am one of these haters. The vast majority of this books’ stories rate one-star for me, being so boring and cold and uninterested in people. My touchstones for ‘good’ scifi are Lois McMaster Bujold, Anne Leckie, Mary Doria Russell, and Martha Wells, who all have a key trait in common! It doesn’t help that many of these stories don’t even qualify as scifi as far as I’m concerned – unsurprising, given that Aldiss categorises Pratchett and Rowling as scifi. Like. Hello.
Sole Solution by Eric Frank Russell, 1956: boring. Next.
Lot by Ward Moore, 1953. A compelling, if gaspingly grim, account of an impending dystopia in the wake of an alien invasion. Very typical mindset of the white mid-cench male, who always considers that the neighbour will come with a gun not a casserole, and that humans never help each other, and that aliens will only be interested in invasion and violence. You do you, Ward, but excuse me from considering this a vein worth pursuing.
Skirmish by Clifford Simak, 1950. Yet another for Team Gun Not Pie, which has been flatly contradicted by humanity’s relationship with actual robots – from singing Happy Birthday to the Mars Rover to apologising to the Roomba if you accidentally step on it.
And I Awoke and Found Me Here on the Cold Hill’s Side by James Tiptree Jr, 1971. An interesting – if predictably depressing – take on the evolution of human sexuality once alien races are brought into the mix. About the only story to have anything in the way of sex, let alone emotion. Surprise! Written by a woman.
Poor Little Warrior! by Brian Aldiss, 1958. Hands down the worst story in the book; the writing is practically unreadable. I certainly won’t be searching out more from this dude.
Grandpa by James H. Schmitz, 1955. Semi-interesting story about dangerous aliens, fluffs the finale.
Nightfall by Isaac Asimov, 1941. Five stars. A classic for a reason, and one of four stories bringing up the average on this collection from one star.
The Snowball Effect by Katherine Maclean, 1952. A solid story about unintended consequences, but how the fuck does it qualify as scifi? Does Aldiss really think that ‘sociology experiment’ is akin to wormhole travel and the Prime Directive? You know what, don’t answer that.
Swarm by Bruce Sterling, 1982. Man, men are obsessed with not having the biggest dick in the room, aren’t they? Have none of these people ever heard of the word ‘cooperation’?
Blood Music by Greg Bear, 1983. Grim, as per.
Answer by Fredric Brown, 1964. A metaphor for that (I think) American Dad scene where the two powerful white guys go, ‘We no longer have 100% of the power! We only have 99%! What shall we dooooo?’
The Liberation of Earth by William Tenn, 1953. Yeah, cool, very grimdark, much sarcasm, wow.
An Alien Agony by Harry Harrison, 1962. I know Orson Scott Card is problematic AF, but he did this so much better in Speaker for the Dead. Sorry not sorry.
Track Twelve by JG Ballard, 1958. This isn’t science fiction, it’s bad science.
Sexual Dimorphism by Kim Stanley Robinson, 1999. I appreciated the proselytising Robinson performed in Ministry for the Future, so I was disappointed at how thin the veneer over his default sexism proved. Hard no thanks on the ‘violence is innate’ concept.
The Tunnel under the World by Frederik Pohl, 1954. Highly predictive of the pernicious influence of advertising. I don’t think Fred would be surprised by social media. Marks for trying; I still hated the way the people were written.
Friends in Need by Eliza Blair, 2006. Sentient socialist cats! We love to see it. The Clockwork Orange style neologisms were trying, however. Being original doesn’t mean copying originality, Liz. PS I would die for Maximus.
The Store of the Worlds by Robert Sheckley, 1959. This is good. Well done Bob.
Jokester by Isaac Asimov, 1956. I’ll take it. I recall from I, Robot that Asmiov is a fan of the aul Singularity, and he leans in.
The Short-Short Story of Mankind by John Steinbeck, 1958. I wonder did Steinbeck do an Atwood on this and sniffily delineate it ‘speculative fiction’? Either way, this is one of the stories that isn’t scifi, wtf, and is very Steinbeckian into the bargain. Which, if you like that kind of thing…
Night Watch by James Inglis, 1964. This was apparently the only thing Inglis ever wrote. Thank god.
Story of Your life by Ted Chiang, 1998. Absolutely fantastic. I wept tears of joyful relief at finally seeing a piece of character-driven scifi. This story formed the basis of the excellent film Arrival, which changes aspects of it to better suit the scope of the production but is very true to the central message. I love them both.
Protected Species by HB Fyfe, 1951. What? What was that ending?!
The Rescuer by Arthur Porges, 1962. Kind of cool, but this obsession with killing God is so teenage boy, I cannot even.
I Made You by Walter M Miller Jr, 1954. Whatever. I haven’t even energy to hate this, so it’ll have to make do with my disdain.
The Country of the Kind by Damon Knight, 1956. LMAO why are these men always on the side of the psychopaths?
The Cage by Bertram Chandler, 1957. Better edit that to ‘only rational men’ – who knows what a race governed by women would have done with other beings?
Fulfilment by AE Van Vogt, 1952. Bad robot take, again.
Common Time by James Blish, 1960. Very much the scifi short story equivalent of a boring person recounting their bad acid trip. Which, in fairness, this probably was.
Alien Embassy by Garry Kilworth, 2006. Ah yes, because no matter what the setting is, no matter how far in the future we are, the womens are only ever motivated by babyeeeeeees.
Great Work of Time by John Crowley, 1989. I mean. Props for scope, I guess? This would work much better as a novel. In fact, David Mitchell’s written it. Read that instead.
At first I thought it was merely lazy that the date of publication was left off the stories within the book and relegated to the backend references. Now I think it’s intentional, to better disguise how lazy the whole project is. Look at this shit! 21 out of 31 stories were published between 1950 and the end of the 1960s – 67% of the contents! THREE are by women, and that’s only if you include Tiptree, and it’s debatable whether you could or should do so. I appreciate that the burst of scifi quality in the twenty-first century may have mainly occurred post-2007, and I’m not going to research this, but I fucking doubt it. This is the kind of scifi that forms the foundation of current scifi, but it’s so well buried at this point that you never need to look at it. Thank GOD.
Sole Solution by Eric Frank Russell, 1956: boring. Next.
Lot by Ward Moore, 1953. A compelling, if gaspingly grim, account of an impending dystopia in the wake of an alien invasion. Very typical mindset of the white mid-cench male, who always considers that the neighbour will come with a gun not a casserole, and that humans never help each other, and that aliens will only be interested in invasion and violence. You do you, Ward, but excuse me from considering this a vein worth pursuing.
Skirmish by Clifford Simak, 1950. Yet another for Team Gun Not Pie, which has been flatly contradicted by humanity’s relationship with actual robots – from singing Happy Birthday to the Mars Rover to apologising to the Roomba if you accidentally step on it.
And I Awoke and Found Me Here on the Cold Hill’s Side by James Tiptree Jr, 1971. An interesting – if predictably depressing – take on the evolution of human sexuality once alien races are brought into the mix. About the only story to have anything in the way of sex, let alone emotion. Surprise! Written by a woman.
Poor Little Warrior! by Brian Aldiss, 1958. Hands down the worst story in the book; the writing is practically unreadable. I certainly won’t be searching out more from this dude.
Grandpa by James H. Schmitz, 1955. Semi-interesting story about dangerous aliens, fluffs the finale.
Nightfall by Isaac Asimov, 1941. Five stars. A classic for a reason, and one of four stories bringing up the average on this collection from one star.
The Snowball Effect by Katherine Maclean, 1952. A solid story about unintended consequences, but how the fuck does it qualify as scifi? Does Aldiss really think that ‘sociology experiment’ is akin to wormhole travel and the Prime Directive? You know what, don’t answer that.
Swarm by Bruce Sterling, 1982. Man, men are obsessed with not having the biggest dick in the room, aren’t they? Have none of these people ever heard of the word ‘cooperation’?
Blood Music by Greg Bear, 1983. Grim, as per.
Answer by Fredric Brown, 1964. A metaphor for that (I think) American Dad scene where the two powerful white guys go, ‘We no longer have 100% of the power! We only have 99%! What shall we dooooo?’
The Liberation of Earth by William Tenn, 1953. Yeah, cool, very grimdark, much sarcasm, wow.
An Alien Agony by Harry Harrison, 1962. I know Orson Scott Card is problematic AF, but he did this so much better in Speaker for the Dead. Sorry not sorry.
Track Twelve by JG Ballard, 1958. This isn’t science fiction, it’s bad science.
Sexual Dimorphism by Kim Stanley Robinson, 1999. I appreciated the proselytising Robinson performed in Ministry for the Future, so I was disappointed at how thin the veneer over his default sexism proved. Hard no thanks on the ‘violence is innate’ concept.
The Tunnel under the World by Frederik Pohl, 1954. Highly predictive of the pernicious influence of advertising. I don’t think Fred would be surprised by social media. Marks for trying; I still hated the way the people were written.
Friends in Need by Eliza Blair, 2006. Sentient socialist cats! We love to see it. The Clockwork Orange style neologisms were trying, however. Being original doesn’t mean copying originality, Liz. PS I would die for Maximus.
The Store of the Worlds by Robert Sheckley, 1959. This is good. Well done Bob.
Jokester by Isaac Asimov, 1956. I’ll take it. I recall from I, Robot that Asmiov is a fan of the aul Singularity, and he leans in.
The Short-Short Story of Mankind by John Steinbeck, 1958. I wonder did Steinbeck do an Atwood on this and sniffily delineate it ‘speculative fiction’? Either way, this is one of the stories that isn’t scifi, wtf, and is very Steinbeckian into the bargain. Which, if you like that kind of thing…
Night Watch by James Inglis, 1964. This was apparently the only thing Inglis ever wrote. Thank god.
Story of Your life by Ted Chiang, 1998. Absolutely fantastic. I wept tears of joyful relief at finally seeing a piece of character-driven scifi. This story formed the basis of the excellent film Arrival, which changes aspects of it to better suit the scope of the production but is very true to the central message. I love them both.
Protected Species by HB Fyfe, 1951. What? What was that ending?!
The Rescuer by Arthur Porges, 1962. Kind of cool, but this obsession with killing God is so teenage boy, I cannot even.
I Made You by Walter M Miller Jr, 1954. Whatever. I haven’t even energy to hate this, so it’ll have to make do with my disdain.
The Country of the Kind by Damon Knight, 1956. LMAO why are these men always on the side of the psychopaths?
The Cage by Bertram Chandler, 1957. Better edit that to ‘only rational men’ – who knows what a race governed by women would have done with other beings?
Fulfilment by AE Van Vogt, 1952. Bad robot take, again.
Common Time by James Blish, 1960. Very much the scifi short story equivalent of a boring person recounting their bad acid trip. Which, in fairness, this probably was.
Alien Embassy by Garry Kilworth, 2006. Ah yes, because no matter what the setting is, no matter how far in the future we are, the womens are only ever motivated by babyeeeeeees.
Great Work of Time by John Crowley, 1989. I mean. Props for scope, I guess? This would work much better as a novel. In fact, David Mitchell’s written it. Read that instead.
At first I thought it was merely lazy that the date of publication was left off the stories within the book and relegated to the backend references. Now I think it’s intentional, to better disguise how lazy the whole project is. Look at this shit! 21 out of 31 stories were published between 1950 and the end of the 1960s – 67% of the contents! THREE are by women, and that’s only if you include Tiptree, and it’s debatable whether you could or should do so. I appreciate that the burst of scifi quality in the twenty-first century may have mainly occurred post-2007, and I’m not going to research this, but I fucking doubt it. This is the kind of scifi that forms the foundation of current scifi, but it’s so well buried at this point that you never need to look at it. Thank GOD.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
June 2, 2021
A good collection of stories, some of which are old favourites, while others haven't been read before but turn out to be interesting stories of speculation. Those I have read before and still like include those by Isaac Asimov, Greg Bear and Ted Chiang, while others encountered in the collection that are fascinating are those by James H. Schmitz, Katherine MacLean, Bruce Sterling, Harry Harrison, Eliza Blair, Robert Sheckley and John Crowley.
- "Sole Solution" by Eric Frank Russell: a short short story about a person becoming aware in a dark place. The person starts a process to 'escape' from the dark place, in a rather obvious way.
- "Lot" by Ward Moore: as civilization breaks down due to the start of a conflict, a man moves his family to the countryside to begin a new life. But the journey is full of family conflict that leads the man to make a decision about his family members at the end.
- "Skirmish" by Clifford D. Simak: a disquieting story about a newspaper reporter who goes to his office early one day to discover all is not right with the machines he sees. He eventually deduces he was chosen for a reason and humanity's fate may lie in the choices he may make.
- "And I Awoke and Found Me Here on the Cold Hill's Side" by James Tiptree, Jr.: a reporter attempts to interview a human who had travelled to the stars, only to learn that to the aliens, humans are primitive.
- "Poor Little Warrior!" by Brian W. Aldiss: a monologue on the poor life of a time travelling timid man from the future who goes back in time to shoot a dinosaur, only to be disappointed by the act.
- "Grandpa" by James H. Schmitz: on an alien world, a trip on an organic raft world turn dangerous, unless one person can figure out how the raft really works based on his observation of other organisms on the alien planet.
- "Nightfall" by Isaac Asimov: on a world surrounded by six suns and forever in sunlight, sunsets has left only one sun in the sky. But now the light from the remaining sun is being blocked and for the first time in thousands of years, man must face the darkness and the horrors it may hold.
- "The Snowball Effect" by Katherine MacLean: an entertaining story about a sociology department head being asked to justify its existence to the Dean. When it does, through a social experiment on exponential growth, the results are inevitably world changing.
- "Swarm" by Bruce Sterling: a human researcher enters the home of an alien swarm with a social structure similar to social inserts like ants. The purpose of the research is to enslave the swarm to do the bidding of humans. But the swarm has other ideas.
- "Blood Music" by Greg Bear: a researcher developing miniature sensors that can enter the body goes too far and develops biological computers. Then, he injects them into himself, and starts a process that would lead to a higher intelligence on Earth.
- "Answer" by Fredric Brown: a short short about linking all the computers in the known universe to ask a question that should not be asked.
- "The Liberation of Earth" by William Tenn: a tale passed down from generation to generation about the time the Earth came to the attention of alien beings who fought battle after battle on it to liberate it from each other, and the end results of the multiple liberations.
- "An Alien Agony" by Harry Harrison: a priest arrives at a world where aliens want literal proof of the truth, and pays the price. And so do the aliens.
- "Track 12" by J. G. Ballard: two men, who are also rivals, spend some time listening to recordings of sounds produced by microscopic objects, vastly amplified. But the last recording would be specially produced by one of the man for the other.
- "Sexual Dimorphism" by Kim Stanley Robinson: on another world, the relationship between two people turn sour, leading to a genetic difference between man and women bring interpreted in an unusual fashion.
- "The Tunnel Under the World" by Frederik Pohl: a man wakes up and goes about his day: again and again. When he wakes up to that fact one day, it leads him and a companion he meets to dig for the truth which would turn out to be stranger than they imagine, but hinted at throughout the story.
- "Friends in Need" by Eliza Blair: a young girl is excited as she is going to choose her pet. But in this future where pets are sentient, the choice of which pet to decide on may have more repercussions.
- "The Store of the Worlds" by Robert Sheckley: a man goes to a shack whose occupant says he can send a person to another world for some time. Is it for real, or is it a hoax? The man has to think about it as he goes on with his life.
- "Jokester" by Isaac Asimov: a man who likes to tell jokes wonders about where jokes come from. The answer given by a large computer named Multivac may not please him or mankind.
- "The Short-Short Story of Mankind" by John Steinbeck: a parody take is the rise of civilization from the cave man days.
- "Night Watch" by James Inglis: the story of an autonomous spaceship on a voyage through the universe on a mission of discovery and, ultimately, survival.
- "Story of Your Life" by Ted Chiang: a language specialist is working on understanding the language of aliens visiting the earth, while at the same time telling the story of the life of her daughter. It is only towards the end of the story that a change in how to perceive events and actions caused by understanding the aliens' language makes the connection between the two parts of the story explicit.
- "Protected Species" by H. B. Fyfe: an inspector on a newly colonized planet visits some ruins believed to have being built by ancestors of the natives on the planet. But the truth will turn out to be the opposite is what was expected.
- "The Rescuer" by Arthur Porges: two scientist blow up important equipment to stop it being used in a possibly world changing experiment, as they admit in the subsequent trial.
- "I Made You" by Walter M. Miller, Jr.: a military robot on the moon is tasked to keep watch over an important area and destroy intruders. But it is still satisfied to do is job even when failures render it unable to tell friend from foe.
- "The Country of the Kind" by Damon Knight: if you live in a world where everybody is kind, a man of violence might be considered its king. Or maybe not
- "The Cage" by A. Bertram Chandler: when human survivors from a spaceship that crashed on an uncharted planet get picked up and put in a cage by aliens, it would take skill and some luck to conduct to convince their captors that they are intelligent beings too.
- "Fulfilment" by A. E. van Vogt: in the future, a solitary machine contemplates its fate when it is contacted by another machine from the past. In following the other machine back in time, it makes plans to conquer the past while discovering its own future, which it has forgotten about.
- "Common Time" by James Blish: a traveller on a faster than light ship suddenly discovers himself unable to move. It is only by thinking about the situation that he discovers the truth which involves the flow of time; and maybe the flow of love?
- "Alien Embassy" by Garry Kilworth: a woman goes for a holiday on an island given to visiting aliens. But it all seems to go wrong then she develops a relationship and an appetite for the alien she meets there: or does it?
- "Great Work of Time" by John Crowley: a long tale about a man who works out how to travel through time only for his invention to be taken over by a society that intends to keep the British Empire alive and the world at relative peace: but only if one event at the start of it all were to take place.
- "Sole Solution" by Eric Frank Russell: a short short story about a person becoming aware in a dark place. The person starts a process to 'escape' from the dark place, in a rather obvious way.
- "Lot" by Ward Moore: as civilization breaks down due to the start of a conflict, a man moves his family to the countryside to begin a new life. But the journey is full of family conflict that leads the man to make a decision about his family members at the end.
- "Skirmish" by Clifford D. Simak: a disquieting story about a newspaper reporter who goes to his office early one day to discover all is not right with the machines he sees. He eventually deduces he was chosen for a reason and humanity's fate may lie in the choices he may make.
- "And I Awoke and Found Me Here on the Cold Hill's Side" by James Tiptree, Jr.: a reporter attempts to interview a human who had travelled to the stars, only to learn that to the aliens, humans are primitive.
- "Poor Little Warrior!" by Brian W. Aldiss: a monologue on the poor life of a time travelling timid man from the future who goes back in time to shoot a dinosaur, only to be disappointed by the act.
- "Grandpa" by James H. Schmitz: on an alien world, a trip on an organic raft world turn dangerous, unless one person can figure out how the raft really works based on his observation of other organisms on the alien planet.
- "Nightfall" by Isaac Asimov: on a world surrounded by six suns and forever in sunlight, sunsets has left only one sun in the sky. But now the light from the remaining sun is being blocked and for the first time in thousands of years, man must face the darkness and the horrors it may hold.
- "The Snowball Effect" by Katherine MacLean: an entertaining story about a sociology department head being asked to justify its existence to the Dean. When it does, through a social experiment on exponential growth, the results are inevitably world changing.
- "Swarm" by Bruce Sterling: a human researcher enters the home of an alien swarm with a social structure similar to social inserts like ants. The purpose of the research is to enslave the swarm to do the bidding of humans. But the swarm has other ideas.
- "Blood Music" by Greg Bear: a researcher developing miniature sensors that can enter the body goes too far and develops biological computers. Then, he injects them into himself, and starts a process that would lead to a higher intelligence on Earth.
- "Answer" by Fredric Brown: a short short about linking all the computers in the known universe to ask a question that should not be asked.
- "The Liberation of Earth" by William Tenn: a tale passed down from generation to generation about the time the Earth came to the attention of alien beings who fought battle after battle on it to liberate it from each other, and the end results of the multiple liberations.
- "An Alien Agony" by Harry Harrison: a priest arrives at a world where aliens want literal proof of the truth, and pays the price. And so do the aliens.
- "Track 12" by J. G. Ballard: two men, who are also rivals, spend some time listening to recordings of sounds produced by microscopic objects, vastly amplified. But the last recording would be specially produced by one of the man for the other.
- "Sexual Dimorphism" by Kim Stanley Robinson: on another world, the relationship between two people turn sour, leading to a genetic difference between man and women bring interpreted in an unusual fashion.
- "The Tunnel Under the World" by Frederik Pohl: a man wakes up and goes about his day: again and again. When he wakes up to that fact one day, it leads him and a companion he meets to dig for the truth which would turn out to be stranger than they imagine, but hinted at throughout the story.
- "Friends in Need" by Eliza Blair: a young girl is excited as she is going to choose her pet. But in this future where pets are sentient, the choice of which pet to decide on may have more repercussions.
- "The Store of the Worlds" by Robert Sheckley: a man goes to a shack whose occupant says he can send a person to another world for some time. Is it for real, or is it a hoax? The man has to think about it as he goes on with his life.
- "Jokester" by Isaac Asimov: a man who likes to tell jokes wonders about where jokes come from. The answer given by a large computer named Multivac may not please him or mankind.
- "The Short-Short Story of Mankind" by John Steinbeck: a parody take is the rise of civilization from the cave man days.
- "Night Watch" by James Inglis: the story of an autonomous spaceship on a voyage through the universe on a mission of discovery and, ultimately, survival.
- "Story of Your Life" by Ted Chiang: a language specialist is working on understanding the language of aliens visiting the earth, while at the same time telling the story of the life of her daughter. It is only towards the end of the story that a change in how to perceive events and actions caused by understanding the aliens' language makes the connection between the two parts of the story explicit.
- "Protected Species" by H. B. Fyfe: an inspector on a newly colonized planet visits some ruins believed to have being built by ancestors of the natives on the planet. But the truth will turn out to be the opposite is what was expected.
- "The Rescuer" by Arthur Porges: two scientist blow up important equipment to stop it being used in a possibly world changing experiment, as they admit in the subsequent trial.
- "I Made You" by Walter M. Miller, Jr.: a military robot on the moon is tasked to keep watch over an important area and destroy intruders. But it is still satisfied to do is job even when failures render it unable to tell friend from foe.
- "The Country of the Kind" by Damon Knight: if you live in a world where everybody is kind, a man of violence might be considered its king. Or maybe not
- "The Cage" by A. Bertram Chandler: when human survivors from a spaceship that crashed on an uncharted planet get picked up and put in a cage by aliens, it would take skill and some luck to conduct to convince their captors that they are intelligent beings too.
- "Fulfilment" by A. E. van Vogt: in the future, a solitary machine contemplates its fate when it is contacted by another machine from the past. In following the other machine back in time, it makes plans to conquer the past while discovering its own future, which it has forgotten about.
- "Common Time" by James Blish: a traveller on a faster than light ship suddenly discovers himself unable to move. It is only by thinking about the situation that he discovers the truth which involves the flow of time; and maybe the flow of love?
- "Alien Embassy" by Garry Kilworth: a woman goes for a holiday on an island given to visiting aliens. But it all seems to go wrong then she develops a relationship and an appetite for the alien she meets there: or does it?
- "Great Work of Time" by John Crowley: a long tale about a man who works out how to travel through time only for his invention to be taken over by a society that intends to keep the British Empire alive and the world at relative peace: but only if one event at the start of it all were to take place.
January 13, 2015
This volume collects two earlier Penguin SF collections from the 50s and 60s and is a pretty mammoth affair, coming to over 600 pages and containing 36 stories. Given the time period that the stories were written in (mostly the 1950s, with some outliers in the decade either side), some inevitable themes arise. These are primarily concerned with nuclear apocalypse and 'Reds under the bed' type allegories.
There are some great stories here and very few misses. Isaac Asimov's Nightfall is welcome at any time and William Tell's Eastward Ho! is a nice reversal of the conquest of America. I'm not necessarily a fan of John Steinbeck, but his The Short-Short Story of Mankind is excellent while Howard Fast's The First Men is a nice übermensch story in the vein of Olaf Stapledon.
That's just a brief skim through the selection. As I say, there are very few misses, so this is worth a read if you're a fan of Golden and Silver Age SF, or even if you're just curious about the history of the genre.
There are some great stories here and very few misses. Isaac Asimov's Nightfall is welcome at any time and William Tell's Eastward Ho! is a nice reversal of the conquest of America. I'm not necessarily a fan of John Steinbeck, but his The Short-Short Story of Mankind is excellent while Howard Fast's The First Men is a nice übermensch story in the vein of Olaf Stapledon.
That's just a brief skim through the selection. As I say, there are very few misses, so this is worth a read if you're a fan of Golden and Silver Age SF, or even if you're just curious about the history of the genre.
January 16, 2016
So, this isn't quite up to the standard of something like Dangerous Visions, but there are some pretty good stories in here. Some variations upon the them of "Astronaut as Creator" that aren't hackneyed and unoriginal, for example. A couple of good "Future Jesus"-style things, too. "Lot", the story of a family fleeing The Event (more or less) has stuck with me since I first read this. In fact, the whole book has. I imagine this is one of the biggest drivers in my love of short form scifi.
May 24, 2023
I'm not massively into science fiction but this is great collection of short stories that are generally easy and fun to read.
January 17, 2023
I will list all I enjoyed
Eric Frank Russell Sole Solution,
About God
Ward Moore Lot
A family at the start of an apocalypse
Clifford Simak Skirmish
Toasters taking over - or aliens?
James Tiptree Jr. And I awoke and Found me here on the cold hills side
Humanity and aliens
Brian Aldiss
Poor little warrior
Time travel holidays
James H.Schmitz Grandpa
Really enjoyed this one, creative well written, the best one in the book?
Isaas asimov Nightfall
A world which is in perpetual daylight reaches a point where the suns go out
Katherine MacLean The Snowball Effect
The power of sociologists!
Bruce Sterling Swarm
Have read before too interesting
Greg Bear Blood music
Altering cells in the human body ; fascinating
Frederic Brown Answer
Is there a God?
William Tenn The Liberation of Earth
Suck air! Suck air
Harry Harrison Alien Agony
Read before
JG Ballard Track
Very good, who knew a kiss could kill?
Kim Stanley Robinson Sexual Dimorphism
Very well written, more about a relationship
Frederik POHL The tunnel under the world
What a good idea! Ad men!
Robert Sheckley The Store of the world's
Enjoyed , can a store make you travel to another world?
Isaac Asimov Jokester
Humour lost forever
John Steinbeck The short story of mankind
Interesting tale
Walter M Miller Jr I made you
A robot in need of repairs
Damon Knight The country of the kind
Ostracism with science behind it
Betram Chandler The Cage
How many days did it take to go to savagery?
Eric Frank Russell Sole Solution,
About God
Ward Moore Lot
A family at the start of an apocalypse
Clifford Simak Skirmish
Toasters taking over - or aliens?
James Tiptree Jr. And I awoke and Found me here on the cold hills side
Humanity and aliens
Brian Aldiss
Poor little warrior
Time travel holidays
James H.Schmitz Grandpa
Really enjoyed this one, creative well written, the best one in the book?
Isaas asimov Nightfall
A world which is in perpetual daylight reaches a point where the suns go out
Katherine MacLean The Snowball Effect
The power of sociologists!
Bruce Sterling Swarm
Have read before too interesting
Greg Bear Blood music
Altering cells in the human body ; fascinating
Frederic Brown Answer
Is there a God?
William Tenn The Liberation of Earth
Suck air! Suck air
Harry Harrison Alien Agony
Read before
JG Ballard Track
Very good, who knew a kiss could kill?
Kim Stanley Robinson Sexual Dimorphism
Very well written, more about a relationship
Frederik POHL The tunnel under the world
What a good idea! Ad men!
Robert Sheckley The Store of the world's
Enjoyed , can a store make you travel to another world?
Isaac Asimov Jokester
Humour lost forever
John Steinbeck The short story of mankind
Interesting tale
Walter M Miller Jr I made you
A robot in need of repairs
Damon Knight The country of the kind
Ostracism with science behind it
Betram Chandler The Cage
How many days did it take to go to savagery?
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
January 31, 2025
This is an altered version of The Penguin Science Fiction Omnibus. For this version, Brian Aldiss chose to delete 15 old stories and add 10 new ones—and I suppose I might have done much the same, given the opportunity, but I’d have made very different choices!
There are now 31 stories in this revised collection, including 5 of my old favourites while deleting 4 of them. Some of the old ones that he chose to keep are ones that I don’t particularly value; and I don’t enjoy reading any of the new ones as stories, although a few of them are conceptually interesting.
So, this collection subtracts value from the old collection, and adds very little. I bought the Kindle version because I wanted it on Kindle, but now I have to hang on to my battered 1974 paper copy of the old collection. To add insult to injury, the Kindle version is missing two pages of text from A. E. van Vogt’s story “Fulfilment”.
However, if you don’t have the old collection and can’t find a copy of it anywhere, this version still contains a handful of decent stories; and maybe you’ll like the new ones better than I do. Taste in fiction is very personal.
There are now 31 stories in this revised collection, including 5 of my old favourites while deleting 4 of them. Some of the old ones that he chose to keep are ones that I don’t particularly value; and I don’t enjoy reading any of the new ones as stories, although a few of them are conceptually interesting.
So, this collection subtracts value from the old collection, and adds very little. I bought the Kindle version because I wanted it on Kindle, but now I have to hang on to my battered 1974 paper copy of the old collection. To add insult to injury, the Kindle version is missing two pages of text from A. E. van Vogt’s story “Fulfilment”.
However, if you don’t have the old collection and can’t find a copy of it anywhere, this version still contains a handful of decent stories; and maybe you’ll like the new ones better than I do. Taste in fiction is very personal.
March 25, 2023
It took me a little while to work through what is, here, quite a large collection of science fiction - but it's worth the effort. I'm especially pleased to have returned to my early days as a sci-fi afficionado, and to have rediscovered writers I'd long forgotten about, or who I had never read.
That said, it's quite unsettling sometimes to read so many short stories in so many different worlds. Each story distillates the purpose of science fiction down to its bare essentials, and my head swam when I tried to read more than two or three in a day.
That said, it's quite unsettling sometimes to read so many short stories in so many different worlds. Each story distillates the purpose of science fiction down to its bare essentials, and my head swam when I tried to read more than two or three in a day.
March 17, 2012
Mentally I'm ascribing this to the other, older 'Penguin SF Omnibus', which I had as a kid. All of the stories in that one were better, even when they were actually the exact same stories that were in this one.
December 31, 2022
Average, few outliers. 3½ stars.
My favorite stories:
Frederik Pohl - The Tunnel Under the World (1955)
Isaac Asimov - Nightfall (1941)
Ted Chiang - Story of Your Life (1998)
Bruce Sterling - Swarm (1982)
Fredric Brown - Answer (1954)
Harry Harrison - An Alien Agony (1962)
My favorite stories:
Frederik Pohl - The Tunnel Under the World (1955)
Isaac Asimov - Nightfall (1941)
Ted Chiang - Story of Your Life (1998)
Bruce Sterling - Swarm (1982)
Fredric Brown - Answer (1954)
Harry Harrison - An Alien Agony (1962)
July 29, 2009
I have the original of this. It doesn't have any stories later than 1973 in it. It's a good collection and a huge one. 616 pages.
February 10, 2023
An excellent selection by a Grand Master of the genre. The focus is on older SF stories but these are very diverse in their material.
October 9, 2020
As near as I can tell Brian Aldiss published and revised a number of these collections, this being the most recent edition, put out in 2007. Apart from half a dozen more contemporary pieces injected into the mix, it’s mostly the same collection of early sci-fi stories from the 1950s and ‘60s that I remember reading as a battered old paperback when I was a young teenager – possibly, I think, the first short stories I’d ever read.
Many of these don’t hold up, coming as they do from the golly-gee-whiz era of science fiction. (And some of the modern insertions, like Kim Stanley Robinson’s thoughtful Notes on Sexual Dimorphism, stand out against them like a sore thumb.) But highlights include:
Lot by Ward Moore, about a father packing his family into the car and onto a jam-packed highway to try to escape what’s implied to be a nuclear attack on Los Angeles; I must have remembered the tone and urgency of this story, since it’s subconsciously reflected in my own short story West Gate, but as a teenager I missed Moore’s subtle use of the father as an unreliable narrator, a bitter and hen-pecked man who secretly resents his family and fantasises that the collapse of society will finally usher in his time to shine;
The Liberation of Earth by William Tenn, a satirical story about Earth finding itself a battlefield between two opposing alien militaries, constantly taken and retaken and declared “liberated” each time while billions die and entire continents are vapourised;
An Alien Agony by Harry Harrison, about a human missionary arriving on a planet populated by peaceful and very literal-minded aliens;
The Store of the Worlds by Robert Sheckley, in which a man approaches a trader who has developed a drug that allows one to see their heart’s truest desire;
Night Watch by James Inglis, following the journey of a space probe launched off into the galaxy;
Great Work of Time by John Crowley, an 80-page novella capping off the anthology, which is one of the most thoughtful and literary time travel stories I’ve ever read, about a secret society which attempts to alter history to preserve the British Empire and the complications which arise from that. Crowley’s fantasy novel Little, Big is one of the few books I’ve ever given up on shortly after starting it, finding it not to be to my taste, but on the strength of this novella alone I’ll definitely be taking another look at Crowley’s work.
Many of these don’t hold up, coming as they do from the golly-gee-whiz era of science fiction. (And some of the modern insertions, like Kim Stanley Robinson’s thoughtful Notes on Sexual Dimorphism, stand out against them like a sore thumb.) But highlights include:
Lot by Ward Moore, about a father packing his family into the car and onto a jam-packed highway to try to escape what’s implied to be a nuclear attack on Los Angeles; I must have remembered the tone and urgency of this story, since it’s subconsciously reflected in my own short story West Gate, but as a teenager I missed Moore’s subtle use of the father as an unreliable narrator, a bitter and hen-pecked man who secretly resents his family and fantasises that the collapse of society will finally usher in his time to shine;
The Liberation of Earth by William Tenn, a satirical story about Earth finding itself a battlefield between two opposing alien militaries, constantly taken and retaken and declared “liberated” each time while billions die and entire continents are vapourised;
An Alien Agony by Harry Harrison, about a human missionary arriving on a planet populated by peaceful and very literal-minded aliens;
The Store of the Worlds by Robert Sheckley, in which a man approaches a trader who has developed a drug that allows one to see their heart’s truest desire;
Night Watch by James Inglis, following the journey of a space probe launched off into the galaxy;
Great Work of Time by John Crowley, an 80-page novella capping off the anthology, which is one of the most thoughtful and literary time travel stories I’ve ever read, about a secret society which attempts to alter history to preserve the British Empire and the complications which arise from that. Crowley’s fantasy novel Little, Big is one of the few books I’ve ever given up on shortly after starting it, finding it not to be to my taste, but on the strength of this novella alone I’ll definitely be taking another look at Crowley’s work.
June 11, 2025
11/06/2025 A Science Fiction Omnibus
It’s anthology and such there is always one or two stories that some readers will find wanting. This is better than most, covering seven decades, it has some brilliant stories from well-known authors to less so, and I was surprised to find stories I hadn’t previously read. For me, the standout stories were Ted Chiang’s Story of Your Life and John Crowley’s Great Work of Time.
This first disruption was Aldus; I like his work but dislike an anthologist who includes one of his own. The great disappointment was Asimov’s Nightfall, which I've read at least three times. The first when I was young (early 60s) and closer to era for which he wrote it, (early 40s) was the best, The idea is still great but in the mid 20s of this century, the story has dated, as has Chandler’s The Cage.
The quote on the back about SF not written for Scientist, came to mind with Greg Bear’s Blood Music. It has a story that a scientist would get more out of than I did, and this was my second reading. (again, I think I enjoyed it more on first reading) This time I found the science detracted from the story.
The other thing I found disconcerting were the stories presented by authors I really like: J G Ballard, James Blish, Walter M Miller Jr., Eric Frank Russell, Robert Sheckly, Clifford Simak, A E van Vogt, and the anthologist himself Brian W Aldus, did not live up to my expectations. Three that did were Kim Stanley Robinson’s Sexual Dimorphism, Frederik Pohl’s The Tunnel Under the World, and Bruce Sterling’s Swarm.
Overall, there is much more to like than not. If goodreads had half stars I’d give it 4½. For an SF aficionado, or even someone wanting to dip into it, this is a tour de force, a truly great read.
It’s anthology and such there is always one or two stories that some readers will find wanting. This is better than most, covering seven decades, it has some brilliant stories from well-known authors to less so, and I was surprised to find stories I hadn’t previously read. For me, the standout stories were Ted Chiang’s Story of Your Life and John Crowley’s Great Work of Time.
This first disruption was Aldus; I like his work but dislike an anthologist who includes one of his own. The great disappointment was Asimov’s Nightfall, which I've read at least three times. The first when I was young (early 60s) and closer to era for which he wrote it, (early 40s) was the best, The idea is still great but in the mid 20s of this century, the story has dated, as has Chandler’s The Cage.
The quote on the back about SF not written for Scientist, came to mind with Greg Bear’s Blood Music. It has a story that a scientist would get more out of than I did, and this was my second reading. (again, I think I enjoyed it more on first reading) This time I found the science detracted from the story.
The other thing I found disconcerting were the stories presented by authors I really like: J G Ballard, James Blish, Walter M Miller Jr., Eric Frank Russell, Robert Sheckly, Clifford Simak, A E van Vogt, and the anthologist himself Brian W Aldus, did not live up to my expectations. Three that did were Kim Stanley Robinson’s Sexual Dimorphism, Frederik Pohl’s The Tunnel Under the World, and Bruce Sterling’s Swarm.
Overall, there is much more to like than not. If goodreads had half stars I’d give it 4½. For an SF aficionado, or even someone wanting to dip into it, this is a tour de force, a truly great read.
January 8, 2020
A good concept spoiled by its editor.
Aldiss in the introduction to this collection comes across as pretentious and sexist and unfortunately that pretentious feeling follows into his choices of stories and in his own writing, this book is packed with filler stories (the last story being 80 pages felt like a panic decision to make the book larger) but its not all bad push through the filler and boring stories and there are some gems in here but im sure you could find them in much more enjoyable collections, these good stories are the reason its two stars because i dont want to downplay their positives, however i cannot recommend this book.
Individual ratings:
sole solution- 5
Lot - 3
skirmish - 5
And I awoke and found me here on the cold hills side- 4
poor litte warrior - 1
grandpa - 4
Nightfall- 5
The snowball effect- 4
swarm- 4
blood music- 4
answer - 1
the liberation of earth - 3
an alien agony- 5
track 12- 4
sexual dimorphism- 4
the tunnel under the world - 5
friends in need- 1
the store of the worlds- 5
jokester - 4
the short short story of mankind- 4
night watch -5
story of your life-5
protected species- 5
the rescuer - 2
i made you- 3
the country of the kind - 3
the cage -5
fulfilment- 1
common time - 2
alien embassy- 4
great work of time - 1
Aldiss in the introduction to this collection comes across as pretentious and sexist and unfortunately that pretentious feeling follows into his choices of stories and in his own writing, this book is packed with filler stories (the last story being 80 pages felt like a panic decision to make the book larger) but its not all bad push through the filler and boring stories and there are some gems in here but im sure you could find them in much more enjoyable collections, these good stories are the reason its two stars because i dont want to downplay their positives, however i cannot recommend this book.
Individual ratings:
sole solution- 5
Lot - 3
skirmish - 5
And I awoke and found me here on the cold hills side- 4
poor litte warrior - 1
grandpa - 4
Nightfall- 5
The snowball effect- 4
swarm- 4
blood music- 4
answer - 1
the liberation of earth - 3
an alien agony- 5
track 12- 4
sexual dimorphism- 4
the tunnel under the world - 5
friends in need- 1
the store of the worlds- 5
jokester - 4
the short short story of mankind- 4
night watch -5
story of your life-5
protected species- 5
the rescuer - 2
i made you- 3
the country of the kind - 3
the cage -5
fulfilment- 1
common time - 2
alien embassy- 4
great work of time - 1
October 12, 2024
I read this anthology almost 20 years ago and though I'd forgotten most of the stories, I was excited to find another copy.
Unfortunately, my positive memories of Asimov's Nightfall seem to have obscured the quality of the rest of the collection.
I enjoyed 20 of the 31 stories presented, and my rating reflects that.
The editor makes a big fuss about "SciFi" ruining "Science Fiction", then proceeds with some pretty painful selections. I can appreciate the time and circumstances of when stories are written, and take them in that context, but christ, the preponderance of explicitly awful, violent, sexist male protagonists living clear revenge fantasies across these stories was exhausting.
The other thing: while I enjoyed Blood Music and Common Time, I did not appreciate the inclusion of such long novellas in the collection. The joy of a sci fi short story is how quickly and effectively the author can pull you in and make their statement. The joy of a collection is getting a variety of ideas in rapid succession, so even if one misses the mark, it's over quick enough and you're on to the next.
Unfortunately, my positive memories of Asimov's Nightfall seem to have obscured the quality of the rest of the collection.
I enjoyed 20 of the 31 stories presented, and my rating reflects that.
The editor makes a big fuss about "SciFi" ruining "Science Fiction", then proceeds with some pretty painful selections. I can appreciate the time and circumstances of when stories are written, and take them in that context, but christ, the preponderance of explicitly awful, violent, sexist male protagonists living clear revenge fantasies across these stories was exhausting.
The other thing: while I enjoyed Blood Music and Common Time, I did not appreciate the inclusion of such long novellas in the collection. The joy of a sci fi short story is how quickly and effectively the author can pull you in and make their statement. The joy of a collection is getting a variety of ideas in rapid succession, so even if one misses the mark, it's over quick enough and you're on to the next.
May 16, 2025
A huge anthology of science fiction, expertly chosen by Brian Aldiss. Even through what came to almost 1,000 pages (in the ebook version I was reading), there are no duds in this collection. The writers are taken from a long range of the history of SF; Isaac Asimov and Arthur C. Clarke are given two contributions - a fair reflection of their influence in the genre (and they are among the shorter stories). Robert A. Heinlein and Philip K. Dick do not make it at all, despite their influence on the genre. The representation of women writers is low: but of course that was true of the genre generally for a very long time. But the treasure of this omnibus is that even for someone like myself, who has read SF for over 40 years, there are new discoveries as well as reminders of forgotten stories.
June 23, 2025
Bad science fiction is about technology, and ages badly. Good science fiction is about ideas, and if those ideas are interesting enough, good science fiction is practically timeless. There are a few nuggets of good science fiction in here.
Most of these stories were written in the 1950s by American men. Given that, it's perhaps not surprising that every single story features a male lead character. However, I was surprised at the near-total absence of female characters, even in minor roles. When they do appear, they're treated in an almost misogynistic manner - wives that are a drag, or get in the way (or occasionally need rescuing). I almost get the feeling that male American writers of this period were terrified of women!
Most of these stories were written in the 1950s by American men. Given that, it's perhaps not surprising that every single story features a male lead character. However, I was surprised at the near-total absence of female characters, even in minor roles. When they do appear, they're treated in an almost misogynistic manner - wives that are a drag, or get in the way (or occasionally need rescuing). I almost get the feeling that male American writers of this period were terrified of women!
August 14, 2024
This was both a delight and a disappointment. For some reason that I now can’t explain, I no longer had my 1973 edition of this great omnibus, so I was very happy to pick up this Modern Classics reprint. Except it isn’t. Brian Aldiss has added new stories and removed some of the older ones.
Yes it contains the great stories that I remember such as Nightfall and The Cage. And many of the stories written since the first version of this omnibus are very good indeed, but it isn’t the book that I wanted to revisit. So, I should give it the five stars it deserves but I can’t help feeling that bit of disappointment.
Yes it contains the great stories that I remember such as Nightfall and The Cage. And many of the stories written since the first version of this omnibus are very good indeed, but it isn’t the book that I wanted to revisit. So, I should give it the five stars it deserves but I can’t help feeling that bit of disappointment.
April 4, 2020
Fulfilment / A. E. Van Vogt 4/5
Thinking machines, a purpose, people and time travel.
Poor little warrior/ Brian Aldiss 3/5
Mocks the writer and the reader, but despite this (or because), rather enjoyed it. I’ll remember it, at least.
Swarm/ Bruce Sterling 3.5/5
The perfect SF story, futuristic with space travel and new species mixed in with human arrogance (of course). A major downside, which wouldn’t be so bad if it wasn’t so common, is the body horror relating to the human female.
Friends in Need/Eliza Blair 3.5/5
Finally! A unique and uplifting story that appreciates the innocent wisdom of the young and the small. I didn’t manage to parse all the kid speak though!
The short-short history of Mankind/John Steinbeck 3/5
I am biased as this is a favourite author. Hilarious, true, tragic and cynical.
Night watch/James Inglis 5/5
Utterly beautiful and it makes a change to read about the machines we make being without the worst of humanity. Also, I identified very strongly with Asov, of The Curious Mind.
Story of your life /Ted Chiang 4/5
Linguistics, time, physics and philosophy. These are a few of my favourite things. I appreciate a story that respects the readers intelligence. I certainly understand why the movie made the changes it did, better suiting it to the medium, but the original ambiguity is more philosophically thought-provoking.
Protected Species/H.B.Fyfe 3/5
A story that you can see in your minds eye, characters you can identify with, twists and a history lesson. Loses a point because only male characters (unnecessary) and ‘females’ are of course just objects. In the future, in space.
The Rescuer/Arthur Porges/ 1/5
If you know anything about Christianity and it’s history, then this story makes no sense. It would be forgivable if it was done well, but alas, I found it disappointing.
I made you/ Walter M. Miller Jr. /3/5
Action, poignancy and emotions from a machine. Done well.
Common time/ James Blish 3/5
I like this even more knowing that author writes Star Trek. Not sure what to say about this, except it is done well. It is an experience that is, and must be, experienced.
Alien Embassy/Gary Kilworth 3/5
A story of a step towards personal growth and fulfilment. Of healing . Of love and sacrifice, and the circle of life. Of good differences.
The Cage/ Bertram Chandler 4/5
Strangely hilarious, birds eye view of what a gaggle of intelligent (and nerdy, and old-fashioned) humans might do in such a situation. Slightly cynical and thought provoking, but feels like it tells the truth. Named men AND women are characters!
Sexual dimorphism / Kim Stanley Robinson / 3.5/5
This calls to mind Selkie mythology, and blends in science to lead to the true focus of this man’s character. Are men from the forest and women from the sea? This would benefit from being a novel.
An Alien Agony/ Harry Harrison 4/5
What happens when you hand over contradictions to a literal species?
Track 12 /J. G. Ballard 1/5
Predictable revenge of the nerd on the arrogance of the jock.
Thinking machines, a purpose, people and time travel.
Poor little warrior/ Brian Aldiss 3/5
Mocks the writer and the reader, but despite this (or because), rather enjoyed it. I’ll remember it, at least.
Swarm/ Bruce Sterling 3.5/5
The perfect SF story, futuristic with space travel and new species mixed in with human arrogance (of course). A major downside, which wouldn’t be so bad if it wasn’t so common, is the body horror relating to the human female.
Friends in Need/Eliza Blair 3.5/5
Finally! A unique and uplifting story that appreciates the innocent wisdom of the young and the small. I didn’t manage to parse all the kid speak though!
The short-short history of Mankind/John Steinbeck 3/5
I am biased as this is a favourite author. Hilarious, true, tragic and cynical.
Night watch/James Inglis 5/5
Utterly beautiful and it makes a change to read about the machines we make being without the worst of humanity. Also, I identified very strongly with Asov, of The Curious Mind.
Story of your life /Ted Chiang 4/5
Linguistics, time, physics and philosophy. These are a few of my favourite things. I appreciate a story that respects the readers intelligence. I certainly understand why the movie made the changes it did, better suiting it to the medium, but the original ambiguity is more philosophically thought-provoking.
Protected Species/H.B.Fyfe 3/5
A story that you can see in your minds eye, characters you can identify with, twists and a history lesson. Loses a point because only male characters (unnecessary) and ‘females’ are of course just objects. In the future, in space.
The Rescuer/Arthur Porges/ 1/5
If you know anything about Christianity and it’s history, then this story makes no sense. It would be forgivable if it was done well, but alas, I found it disappointing.
I made you/ Walter M. Miller Jr. /3/5
Action, poignancy and emotions from a machine. Done well.
Common time/ James Blish 3/5
I like this even more knowing that author writes Star Trek. Not sure what to say about this, except it is done well. It is an experience that is, and must be, experienced.
Alien Embassy/Gary Kilworth 3/5
A story of a step towards personal growth and fulfilment. Of healing . Of love and sacrifice, and the circle of life. Of good differences.
The Cage/ Bertram Chandler 4/5
Strangely hilarious, birds eye view of what a gaggle of intelligent (and nerdy, and old-fashioned) humans might do in such a situation. Slightly cynical and thought provoking, but feels like it tells the truth. Named men AND women are characters!
Sexual dimorphism / Kim Stanley Robinson / 3.5/5
This calls to mind Selkie mythology, and blends in science to lead to the true focus of this man’s character. Are men from the forest and women from the sea? This would benefit from being a novel.
An Alien Agony/ Harry Harrison 4/5
What happens when you hand over contradictions to a literal species?
Track 12 /J. G. Ballard 1/5
Predictable revenge of the nerd on the arrogance of the jock.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
December 28, 2022
I used to read a lot of Sci Fi - and maybe I've grown away the genre. I realise it's an updated version of an earlier compilation, but I found it difficult to get into any of these stories. Many seemed so dated & predictable. They reminded me of some of the old (terrible) sci-fi movies that used to be on 40 years ago.
Generally, disappointed. Maybe I need to find a more recent collection.
Generally, disappointed. Maybe I need to find a more recent collection.
July 24, 2024
An absolutely wonderful collection, with a number of great, unforgettable stories of varying lengths.
That's not to say perfect - I have never read a collection that didn't include some lesser works.
That's not to say perfect - I have never read a collection that didn't include some lesser works.
Read
May 12, 2025favourite stories:
Grandpa-James H Schmitz
Nightfall-Isaac Asimov
The Tunnel Under The World-Frederik Pohl
Story of Your Life-Ted Chiang
Common Time-James Blish
honourable mention to Blood Music by Greg Bear because it freaked me out
Grandpa-James H Schmitz
Nightfall-Isaac Asimov
The Tunnel Under The World-Frederik Pohl
Story of Your Life-Ted Chiang
Common Time-James Blish
honourable mention to Blood Music by Greg Bear because it freaked me out
May 28, 2017
Stand out stories: Blood Music by Greg Bear, The Cage by Bertram Chandler, The Tunnel Under the World by Fred Pohl, and the John Crowley one.
August 29, 2017
A very well curated collection. Stories that ponder how people would behave in extraordinary, speculative circumstances. Loved this collection of stories.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 51 reviews