I have to say 2 stars because I skipped through a lot of the book. Antiquity writing and a culture of long ago just didn't keep up my interest. However I did enjoy reading The Tell Tale Heart, the first story in the book. It has been many years since I last read it.
Some of these were solid short stories. Some were worth the read. Others were hard to get through (I’m looking at you James Joyce). My favorites were stories i had already read (The Tell-Tale Heart, The Lottery)
As I think I commented before, this is mostly a dreary compendium of tedious characters! A few pieces may be suitable for classroom analysis, such as "Of this Time, Of that Place," "The Ledge," & "The Rocking-Horse Winner," however overall these do not reflect well either upon Western culture -- or the collective mind of writers and editors, if these are considered among our "best."
So glad I picked up this little gem of a book, although I had to keep taping it up to hold it together! So worth it though! I enjoyed all of the stories and I am going to look for more from certain authors, I.e., Frank O'Connor, Katherine Mansfield, Isaac Babel, Sherwood Anderson, and Joseph Conrad. I have the Viking Portable Library of D.H. Lawrence that I can't wait to read after The Rocking-Horse Winner. And I even enjoyed rereading James Joyce's The Dead! Amazing!