What do you think?
Rate this book
Highland Guard #9
The Arrow
NATIONAL BESTSELLERAs King Robert the Bruce of Scotland plots to retake his English-occupied castles, he needs the stealth and skill of his elite soldiers, the Highland Guard. Fearless and indomitable, no men are more loyal to their king, or more cherished by the women they love. The talents of legendary marksman Gregor “Arrow” MacGregor are crucial now, as Bruce moves to reclaim his Scottish holdings. Gregor is considered the most handsome man in Scotland, and his fame as an archer is rivaled only by his reputation with the lasses as a heartbreaker. But when his infamous face is exposed during a covert mission, Gregor is forced to lie low. He returns home only to find a new battle a daring game of seduction involving his now very grown-up and very desirable ward, Cate of Lochmaben. A born fighter, Cate was clinging to life when Gregor rescued her after a vicious English raid on her village left her mother dead. But five years later, the once scrappy orphan Gregor took under his protection has become a woman. Brave, strong, and skilled in warfare, Cate is determined to lay claim to the warrior who refuses to be trapped. The heat in his eyes tells her she has his attention . . . and his desire. But will Gregor allow his heart to surrender before danger finds them, and the truth of Cate’s identity is revealed?Praise for Monica McCarty and The Arrow “[Monica] McCarty’s gift lies in writing strong characters into wildly entertaining—often unexpected—scenarios. Readers can’t go wrong with her latest.” — The Washington Post “The Highland Guard come to life as McCarty fills her tales with historical accuracy and moving romance. The ninth in the series is well paced, emotional and powerfully told. Don’t miss it!” — RT Book Reviews (Top Pick!) “One of the best Highlander historical series out there.” —The Reading Cafe “Heart-wrenching . . . The Arrow made a lasting impression on me.” —Under the Covers “A mixture of passion, history, and great wit to create a tale to captivate your senses! To die for !” —Addicted to Romance “There is danger, laughter, and sweet love and secrets revealed. All the characteristics of a wonderful read.” —Tea and Book “Monica McCarty is an absolutely superior author! Her Highland Guard series has to be one of the absolute best Highland series out there! Fun, fast paced, fact driven and totally fantastic!” —Bodice Rippers , on The Raider “McCarty is a master at writing Highlander romance . . . keeping her Highland Guard series fresh, with spectacularly riveting plots and fabulously romantic couples. . . . If you’ve not read this series yet, then I strongly suggest that you do.” —Night Owl Reviews , on The Hunter
416 pages, Mass Market Paperback
First published August 26, 2014
134 people are currently reading
2977 people want to read
About the author
Monica McCarty
61 books2,966 followersWhat do you get when you mix a legal career, a baseball career, motherhood, and a love of history with a voracious reader? In my case, a Historical Romance Author.
Like most writers, I’ve always loved to read. Growing up in California there was always plenty to do outside, but all too often I could be found inside curled up with a book (or two or three). I started with the usual fare: The Little House on the Prairie series, The Chronicles of Narnia, The Hobbit, Watership Down, Nancy Drew, and everything by Judy Blume. Once I cleared off my bookshelf, I started swiping books from my mom. Some, like Sidney Sheldon’s The Other Side of Midnight, probably weren’t the most appropriate choice for a pre-adolescent—although they were definitely illuminating. I can still remember the look of abject horror on my mom’s Catholic-girl-face when I asked her what a virgin was. After that rather brief conversation, she paid a little closer attention to what had disappeared off her book shelf, and steered me in the direction of Harlequin and Barbara Cartland romances. I was hooked. I quickly read through the inventory of the local library and was soon buying bags of romances at garage sales.
In high school, with the encouragement of my father (who I think was a little concerned about the steady diet of romances), I read over eighty of the Franklin Library’s One Hundred Greatest Books ever written—including Tolstoy, Confucius, Plato, and the entire works of Shakespeare. Some of them were tough going for a teenager, but the experience would prove an invaluable foundation for college. After reading War and Peace, I wasn’t easily intimidated.
For some reason Monica decided to go into writing and not fashion.
After graduation, I loaded up the VW (Jetta not Bus) and trekked down I-5 to attend the University of Southern California, majoring in Political Science and minoring in English (see why all that reading helped!). I joined the Kappa Kappa Gamma sorority, and when I wasn’t studying or at football games, did my best to support the local bartending industry. Ah, the good old days.
With that kind of fun, four years of college wasn’t quite enough. So leaving Tommy Trojan behind, I traveled back up north to Palo Alto for three more years of study at Stanford Law School. Once I survived the stress of the first semester, law school proved to be one of the best times of my life—garnering me a JD, life-long friends, a husband, and an unexpectedly intimate knowledge of baseball. (See “The Baseball Odyssey” below).
Law School was also where I fell in love with Scotland. In my third year, I took a Comparative Legal History class, and wrote a paper on the Scottish Clan System and Feudalism. So I immediately dropped out of law school and went on to write Scottish Historical Romances…well no, not quite. You see, I always knew I wanted to be a lawyer. My father was a lawyer, I was a “poet” (i.e., not into math), and I love to argue. It seemed natural.
So I finished law school, got married, passed the CA bar, moved to Minnesota (with a few stops along the way), waived into the MN bar, worked as a litigator for a few satisfying years, moved back to CA, had a couple of kids, realized that a legal career and being a single parent for most of the year (due to husband's career) would be extremely difficult, and THEN decided to sit down and write.
And how did I end up writing romance? It’s not as divergent as it seems. What I loved about being a lawyer are the same things I love about being a writer—research and writing. The only thing missing is the arguing, but that’s what a husband and kids are for, right?
Like most writers, I’ve always loved to read. Growing up in California there was always plenty to do outside, but all too often I could be found inside curled up with a book (or two or three). I started with the usual fare: The Little House on the Prairie series, The Chronicles of Narnia, The Hobbit, Watership Down, Nancy Drew, and everything by Judy Blume. Once I cleared off my bookshelf, I started swiping books from my mom. Some, like Sidney Sheldon’s The Other Side of Midnight, probably weren’t the most appropriate choice for a pre-adolescent—although they were definitely illuminating. I can still remember the look of abject horror on my mom’s Catholic-girl-face when I asked her what a virgin was. After that rather brief conversation, she paid a little closer attention to what had disappeared off her book shelf, and steered me in the direction of Harlequin and Barbara Cartland romances. I was hooked. I quickly read through the inventory of the local library and was soon buying bags of romances at garage sales.
In high school, with the encouragement of my father (who I think was a little concerned about the steady diet of romances), I read over eighty of the Franklin Library’s One Hundred Greatest Books ever written—including Tolstoy, Confucius, Plato, and the entire works of Shakespeare. Some of them were tough going for a teenager, but the experience would prove an invaluable foundation for college. After reading War and Peace, I wasn’t easily intimidated.
For some reason Monica decided to go into writing and not fashion.
After graduation, I loaded up the VW (Jetta not Bus) and trekked down I-5 to attend the University of Southern California, majoring in Political Science and minoring in English (see why all that reading helped!). I joined the Kappa Kappa Gamma sorority, and when I wasn’t studying or at football games, did my best to support the local bartending industry. Ah, the good old days.
With that kind of fun, four years of college wasn’t quite enough. So leaving Tommy Trojan behind, I traveled back up north to Palo Alto for three more years of study at Stanford Law School. Once I survived the stress of the first semester, law school proved to be one of the best times of my life—garnering me a JD, life-long friends, a husband, and an unexpectedly intimate knowledge of baseball. (See “The Baseball Odyssey” below).
Law School was also where I fell in love with Scotland. In my third year, I took a Comparative Legal History class, and wrote a paper on the Scottish Clan System and Feudalism. So I immediately dropped out of law school and went on to write Scottish Historical Romances…well no, not quite. You see, I always knew I wanted to be a lawyer. My father was a lawyer, I was a “poet” (i.e., not into math), and I love to argue. It seemed natural.
So I finished law school, got married, passed the CA bar, moved to Minnesota (with a few stops along the way), waived into the MN bar, worked as a litigator for a few satisfying years, moved back to CA, had a couple of kids, realized that a legal career and being a single parent for most of the year (due to husband's career) would be extremely difficult, and THEN decided to sit down and write.
And how did I end up writing romance? It’s not as divergent as it seems. What I loved about being a lawyer are the same things I love about being a writer—research and writing. The only thing missing is the arguing, but that’s what a husband and kids are for, right?
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 452 reviews
March 1, 2016
Originally posted on The Book Nympho
Gregor MacGregor, known as the most handsome man in Scotland, is the archer for Robert Bruce's Highland Guard, code name Arrow. When he begins to notice changes in his precision, he takes leave to return home to figure out and resolve the problem. Gregor also needs to determine what he's going to do with his ward, Caitrina (Cate) Kirkpatrick, who he rescued five years before.
This is one of my favorite series, primarily because of the historical aspects. Unfortunately, there were numerous word usages and vernacular that were beyond the medieval period of 1312. Cate is repeatedly referred to as "cute," which has its origins in the 19th century, as well as "nightmare" and "wow." When I saw "chomping at the bit" instead of "champing," it immediately threw me out of the story. I've not experienced so many period errors in this series and these were only the ones I chose to research.
The story has an exciting start but then changes to focus on Gregor and Cait's relationship. Both are keeping some whopper of secrets and it was tough to connect with the romance because of them. When Gregor, in anger, retaliated against Cate in response to a misguided perception of a breach of trust, it was so awful I was ready for Cate to walk away permanently and that didn't change. What he did was unforgivable.
I was hoping for a much stronger story for Gregor as Cait seemed the ideal woman for him. But her duplicity was hard to get beyond and it was too protracted. The best aspects were when the Highland Guard were in action on missions and when they were otherwise part of the story. Unfortunately, the romance and historical parts were a miss though there were some very strong moments that struck an emotional chord that kept me turning the pages. It was interesting in spite of all of its flaws. 3.5 stars
(I received an ARC in exchange for an honest review)
Gregor MacGregor, known as the most handsome man in Scotland, is the archer for Robert Bruce's Highland Guard, code name Arrow. When he begins to notice changes in his precision, he takes leave to return home to figure out and resolve the problem. Gregor also needs to determine what he's going to do with his ward, Caitrina (Cate) Kirkpatrick, who he rescued five years before.
This is one of my favorite series, primarily because of the historical aspects. Unfortunately, there were numerous word usages and vernacular that were beyond the medieval period of 1312. Cate is repeatedly referred to as "cute," which has its origins in the 19th century, as well as "nightmare" and "wow." When I saw "chomping at the bit" instead of "champing," it immediately threw me out of the story. I've not experienced so many period errors in this series and these were only the ones I chose to research.
The story has an exciting start but then changes to focus on Gregor and Cait's relationship. Both are keeping some whopper of secrets and it was tough to connect with the romance because of them. When Gregor, in anger, retaliated against Cate in response to a misguided perception of a breach of trust, it was so awful I was ready for Cate to walk away permanently and that didn't change. What he did was unforgivable.
I was hoping for a much stronger story for Gregor as Cait seemed the ideal woman for him. But her duplicity was hard to get beyond and it was too protracted. The best aspects were when the Highland Guard were in action on missions and when they were otherwise part of the story. Unfortunately, the romance and historical parts were a miss though there were some very strong moments that struck an emotional chord that kept me turning the pages. It was interesting in spite of all of its flaws. 3.5 stars
(I received an ARC in exchange for an honest review)
August 11, 2025
1-1/2 stars. I got this book from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
Wow, I hated this book. I mean really hated it. Catriona is sly and manipulative. And incredibly childish. Through most of the book she’s trying to manipulate Gregor. She tries to trick him into seeing her, trick him into kissing her, force him into sexual activities with her. This is not at all attractive Seriously. She decided before she’s even seen him five times that she loves him. And then proceeds to plow through his life, not caring about anything as long as she can force things her way, in order to try to cram this man into the position that she wants him in, irrespective of what he would like. This is not love. It’s childish obsession.
Get the picture? She’s throwing herself at him constantly. Enough already. I had enough of her after a couple of chapters. I can‘t imagine how Gregor stood a whole book of her behavior! Also, Gregor is a very attractive man, known as the best looking man in all of Scotland. He’s had women chasing after him his whole life. Becoming just another in the throng of women throwing themselves at him is not the way to get yourself noticed, honey.
Gregor was ok. There were a lot of qualities in him that I did not care for. But near the end of the book, due to the usual romance novel wild-ass misunderstanding, he has decided to prove to Catriona that their having sex didn’t mean anything. So he goes to a tavern and gets drunk, and insinuates to others that he’s one of Robert the Bruce’s Phantoms. Smooth, dude. Way to fly under the radar and protect your king’s interests! Douchebag. Then he does something completely unforgiveable. He goes upstairs to have sex with a barmaid. He doesn’t go through with full intercourse, but allows the barmaid to perform fellatio on him. That’s it. Now you are NO HERO. In fact, you completely suck. I hope you get fleas, dystery, and gonorrhea! And Catriona sees the barmaid with his dick in her mouth. Not cool, dude.
I have been happy with Monica McCarty’s historical research in many of her previous books, but there were too many historical anachronisms or inaccuracies for my taste. Especially as I feel she’s done a much better job keeping to period in earlier books. There’s even a part where Catriona is bemoaning the whole “I like you but just as a friend” concept. Can you say jarring?!
So all in all, there’s very little of this book that meets my approval. The heroine is an immature and conniving hussy, the hero is an immoral ass, and the devil’s in the details for the time period. I give this book 1-1/2 stars, and that’s because I’m being nice. I loved this series when it started, but it has been slowly drifting downhill for me, and is no longer on my autobuy list.
Wow, I hated this book. I mean really hated it. Catriona is sly and manipulative. And incredibly childish. Through most of the book she’s trying to manipulate Gregor. She tries to trick him into seeing her, trick him into kissing her, force him into sexual activities with her. This is not at all attractive Seriously. She decided before she’s even seen him five times that she loves him. And then proceeds to plow through his life, not caring about anything as long as she can force things her way, in order to try to cram this man into the position that she wants him in, irrespective of what he would like. This is not love. It’s childish obsession.
...
Cate was going to have to up her vigilance and her efforts, it seemed, until he was ready to accept that there was something between them.
But her plans to have him realize how perfect they were together hadn’t progressed as quickly as she’d hoped, and she could not stand by and do nothing while he took more women to his bed. God knew, there had been enough of them. Cate could not change the past, but she was no longer willing to make excuses for him: you aren’t old enough, she would tell herself, he doesn’t see you yet; just be a little more patient, and it will be you. She was tired of being patient, and she wouldn’t let him do anything to break her heart before she’d had a chance to give it to him. He would thank her for it. Eventually. She hoped.
Cate’s adoration for him had always made him uneasy, but now that she was older it was worse.
She was out of patience. She wouldn’t let him marry her off to another man. It was time to force his hand—or rather, another part of him.
Get the picture? She’s throwing herself at him constantly. Enough already. I had enough of her after a couple of chapters. I can‘t imagine how Gregor stood a whole book of her behavior! Also, Gregor is a very attractive man, known as the best looking man in all of Scotland. He’s had women chasing after him his whole life. Becoming just another in the throng of women throwing themselves at him is not the way to get yourself noticed, honey.
Gregor was ok. There were a lot of qualities in him that I did not care for. But near the end of the book, due to the usual romance novel wild-ass misunderstanding, he has decided to prove to Catriona that their having sex didn’t mean anything. So he goes to a tavern and gets drunk, and insinuates to others that he’s one of Robert the Bruce’s Phantoms. Smooth, dude. Way to fly under the radar and protect your king’s interests! Douchebag. Then he does something completely unforgiveable. He goes upstairs to have sex with a barmaid. He doesn’t go through with full intercourse, but allows the barmaid to perform fellatio on him. That’s it. Now you are NO HERO. In fact, you completely suck. I hope you get fleas, dystery, and gonorrhea! And Catriona sees the barmaid with his dick in her mouth. Not cool, dude.
I have been happy with Monica McCarty’s historical research in many of her previous books, but there were too many historical anachronisms or inaccuracies for my taste. Especially as I feel she’s done a much better job keeping to period in earlier books. There’s even a part where Catriona is bemoaning the whole “I like you but just as a friend” concept. Can you say jarring?!
So all in all, there’s very little of this book that meets my approval. The heroine is an immature and conniving hussy, the hero is an immoral ass, and the devil’s in the details for the time period. I give this book 1-1/2 stars, and that’s because I’m being nice. I loved this series when it started, but it has been slowly drifting downhill for me, and is no longer on my autobuy list.
May 17, 2022
I saw some pretty great reviews about this series. She is a new-to-me author and even though this is the 9th book in the series, I thought I’d give this one a shot as I was in the mood for a guardian/ward trope. Unfortunately, I don’t think her books are for me.
Pros:
1. The easy to read writing style. Unfortunately, that’s about it.
Cons:
1. The language. It is way too modern for me. I practically cringed every time I came across the word ‘cute’ (I doubt that the word ‘cute’ even existed in the 1300s).
2. The main characters. The hero, Gregor and the heroine, Cate aren’t particularly likeable to me. Gregor is this handsome rake and would like to be loved for himself 🙄, but it seems that everyone just wants him for his looks (I guess that’s annoying?). Cate, whom he happened to save and took to his family, has been in love with him for the last five years and has absolute faith in her love for him. She kept accepting Gregor’s rubbish treatment of her because of her unassailable faith in him. Lady, you’re a doormat. Where’s your self-respect? Gregor tried to put you off by making out with another woman right in front of you and even told you that sex and love are two separate things for him. I simply couldn’t root for this kind of heroine.
Gregor was a big No-No for me when the author made him cheat on Cate.I’m actually fine with cheating, but this scene feels contrived to ramp up the angst factor.
3. I couldn’t get a feel of the time period. The events were supposed to occur in the 1300s, but they felt contemporary. If not for the dates in the prologue and Chapter 1, I wouldn’t know what the period is supposed to be.
I guess I’m not the intended reader, so I wouldn’t be continuing with the series. If you don't mind the anachronism, this should be an okay read.
Pros:
1. The easy to read writing style. Unfortunately, that’s about it.
Cons:
1. The language. It is way too modern for me. I practically cringed every time I came across the word ‘cute’ (I doubt that the word ‘cute’ even existed in the 1300s).
2. The main characters. The hero, Gregor and the heroine, Cate aren’t particularly likeable to me. Gregor is this handsome rake and would like to be loved for himself 🙄, but it seems that everyone just wants him for his looks (I guess that’s annoying?). Cate, whom he happened to save and took to his family, has been in love with him for the last five years and has absolute faith in her love for him. She kept accepting Gregor’s rubbish treatment of her because of her unassailable faith in him. Lady, you’re a doormat. Where’s your self-respect? Gregor tried to put you off by making out with another woman right in front of you and even told you that sex and love are two separate things for him. I simply couldn’t root for this kind of heroine.
Gregor was a big No-No for me when the author made him cheat on Cate.I’m actually fine with cheating, but this scene feels contrived to ramp up the angst factor.
3. I couldn’t get a feel of the time period. The events were supposed to occur in the 1300s, but they felt contemporary. If not for the dates in the prologue and Chapter 1, I wouldn’t know what the period is supposed to be.
I guess I’m not the intended reader, so I wouldn’t be continuing with the series. If you don't mind the anachronism, this should be an okay read.
November 16, 2025
4 Stars
My thoughts:
The second half of the book is what won me over. I especially loved the angsty situations that came after the 70% mark which were perfectly emotional and dramatic. And the fabulous grovel from the hero, that alone deserves all the stars. I absolutely loved it. This is how it's done, with lots of showing, not just telling like in most books. Well done, Ms. McCarty. ***** The heroine finally grew a backbone, thank goodness. It was a relief because for the entire first half, she was the one pursuing him, relentlessly (it grated on me how she constantly threw herself at him even after he rejected her). In my opinion, it had a slow beginning (this could totally be on me, not the story; I'm very impatient), and I'll admit, I almost DNFed. I'm glad I decided to continue on. It paid off bigtime. Everything about the last part of the book was 5 Stars. The hero was truly swoonworthy. The epilogue, too, was deeply touching and satisfying *sigh*
Not gonna lie, I skimmed the clan shenanigans and all the battle descriptions. Sorry not sorry.
Note about the cheating scene:
My thoughts:
The second half of the book is what won me over. I especially loved the angsty situations that came after the 70% mark which were perfectly emotional and dramatic. And the fabulous grovel from the hero, that alone deserves all the stars. I absolutely loved it. This is how it's done, with lots of showing, not just telling like in most books. Well done, Ms. McCarty. ***** The heroine finally grew a backbone, thank goodness. It was a relief because for the entire first half, she was the one pursuing him, relentlessly (it grated on me how she constantly threw herself at him even after he rejected her). In my opinion, it had a slow beginning (this could totally be on me, not the story; I'm very impatient), and I'll admit, I almost DNFed. I'm glad I decided to continue on. It paid off bigtime. Everything about the last part of the book was 5 Stars. The hero was truly swoonworthy. The epilogue, too, was deeply touching and satisfying *sigh*
Not gonna lie, I skimmed the clan shenanigans and all the battle descriptions. Sorry not sorry.
Note about the cheating scene:
April 16, 2018
3.75 stars
Enjoyed this enough, I just don't know how to rate this one. I would have loved it more if I didn't keep picturing the heroine Cate as a 15 year old scamp tomboy the entire time. :/
And I tried, really really tried but the visual in my head kept getting in the way of fulling connecting with the love story. And the number of times Gregor has to remind himself she's a grown woman and how adorable and cute she is didn't really help. I don't know I just couldn't get passed the way she's described as the impish orphan Gregor took in 5 years ago. The way she carries herself, gets in scruffles and sighs dreamily over the most handsome man in Scotland wasn't really enticing for me personally. I've always loved the 'guardian falls in love with his ward' trope and the fact that the heroine was the pursuer this time was a very nice change of pace. I liked that. But I wasn't 100% sold that these two fit well and that bugged me. At times it came off a *little* forced especially on Gregor's part. A big part of that was probably Cate's 'I love him and we are meant to be together and I'm gonna make him see that' determined mind set. It's a tricky angle to work with. I actually liked Cate, she had her bratty stubborn moments that were annoying but she was brave, independent and kind. Gregor was his usual gorgeous rakish arrogant self with a sweet playful heart. It was interesting to see him brought down a peg or two.
The two things I didn't really care for were the homeless orphans forced in here and the stunt Gregor pulled to prove Cate wrong. Orphans are the bane of my reading experience. Ugh how I loathe it. They are 99% of the time used as red herrings to paint the heroine in a favorable light and it never really works for me. It's underhanded and manipulating your readers. I have nothing against kids or babies in stories if written well and they add something to the story. Here it just did absolutely nothing and only managed to make Cate look high handed and controlling and Gregor the big mean growly brute for 'scaring' the wee foundlings. RME. Having the heroine force housebroken orphans on an unsuspecting put upon hero and giving him the wounded puppy look for daring to not go along with her plans was a little rage inducing. It just toes the line of manipulative and selfish for me. I personally couldn't stand bratty Pip or his sob story and the grief he gave Gregor. I didn't buy Cate's excuses of him being misunderstood and I certainly didn't appreciate the reckless 'cover up' story she used to keep the 3 kids in Gregor's home. So selfish and childish. You don't do that to a man you supposedly love and respect. SMH. And as for Gregor's big no-no moment it did color my opinion of him and made the story lose some steam for me. I got tired of the you did me wrong I'm gonna get you back song and dance between the two, it came across petty and juvenile.
Enjoyed this enough, I just don't know how to rate this one. I would have loved it more if I didn't keep picturing the heroine Cate as a 15 year old scamp tomboy the entire time. :/
And I tried, really really tried but the visual in my head kept getting in the way of fulling connecting with the love story. And the number of times Gregor has to remind himself she's a grown woman and how adorable and cute she is didn't really help. I don't know I just couldn't get passed the way she's described as the impish orphan Gregor took in 5 years ago. The way she carries herself, gets in scruffles and sighs dreamily over the most handsome man in Scotland wasn't really enticing for me personally. I've always loved the 'guardian falls in love with his ward' trope and the fact that the heroine was the pursuer this time was a very nice change of pace. I liked that. But I wasn't 100% sold that these two fit well and that bugged me. At times it came off a *little* forced especially on Gregor's part. A big part of that was probably Cate's 'I love him and we are meant to be together and I'm gonna make him see that' determined mind set. It's a tricky angle to work with. I actually liked Cate, she had her bratty stubborn moments that were annoying but she was brave, independent and kind. Gregor was his usual gorgeous rakish arrogant self with a sweet playful heart. It was interesting to see him brought down a peg or two.
The two things I didn't really care for were the homeless orphans forced in here and the stunt Gregor pulled to prove Cate wrong. Orphans are the bane of my reading experience. Ugh how I loathe it. They are 99% of the time used as red herrings to paint the heroine in a favorable light and it never really works for me. It's underhanded and manipulating your readers. I have nothing against kids or babies in stories if written well and they add something to the story. Here it just did absolutely nothing and only managed to make Cate look high handed and controlling and Gregor the big mean growly brute for 'scaring' the wee foundlings. RME. Having the heroine force housebroken orphans on an unsuspecting put upon hero and giving him the wounded puppy look for daring to not go along with her plans was a little rage inducing. It just toes the line of manipulative and selfish for me. I personally couldn't stand bratty Pip or his sob story and the grief he gave Gregor. I didn't buy Cate's excuses of him being misunderstood and I certainly didn't appreciate the reckless 'cover up' story she used to keep the 3 kids in Gregor's home. So selfish and childish. You don't do that to a man you supposedly love and respect. SMH. And as for Gregor's big no-no moment it did color my opinion of him and made the story lose some steam for me. I got tired of the you did me wrong I'm gonna get you back song and dance between the two, it came across petty and juvenile.
November 26, 2017
I loved this so much. Cate's crush on Arrow was so cute in the beginning. It was wonderful to see the infamous "most handsome man in Scotland" finally get married. I will always say, however, that my personal choice for most handsome man in the Highland Guard will always be Robbie Boyd or "Raider", followed by Tor or "Chief". I suppose that's because Gregor seems a little too much of the pretty faced type of handsome and I don't really find that type to be attractive. However Arrow's badass skills meant that he's much more than just a pretty face.
Cate's personal history was so sad. I didn't like the way Bruce had just left her and her mother and married his upper class wife. I know that's the way things worked in those days but it was so sad for the young girl whose peers made fun of her illegitimate status.
The romance itself was slow to develop and there wasn't as much intrigue as in the other novels in the series but it was an enjoyable novel nevertheless.
Cate's personal history was so sad. I didn't like the way Bruce had just left her and her mother and married his upper class wife. I know that's the way things worked in those days but it was so sad for the young girl whose peers made fun of her illegitimate status.
The romance itself was slow to develop and there wasn't as much intrigue as in the other novels in the series but it was an enjoyable novel nevertheless.
May 31, 2019
Reread. This was good but not great.
Rating it a 3.75
I thought it was good romance but not as great as some of her others. The story kept me engaged and I did like the overall plot line. The hero and heroines romance was engaging at times but a couple times somewhat frustrating. Nice sexual tention and good emotional depth.
The hero Gregor was not my favorite of the series but he was still likeable. He was somewhat stubborn on realizing his feelings for Cate and did make one mistake that I found dumb and infuriating.
I liked Cate, she was a determined young Lady who loved deeply and completely. She was strong, sassy, and had a tender heart.
I liked the secondary characters.
All in all an enjoyable read. I have always enjoyed Monica McCarty books. She does not disappoint.
Netgalley book for an honest review.
Rating it a 3.75
I thought it was good romance but not as great as some of her others. The story kept me engaged and I did like the overall plot line. The hero and heroines romance was engaging at times but a couple times somewhat frustrating. Nice sexual tention and good emotional depth.
The hero Gregor was not my favorite of the series but he was still likeable. He was somewhat stubborn on realizing his feelings for Cate and did make one mistake that I found dumb and infuriating.
I liked Cate, she was a determined young Lady who loved deeply and completely. She was strong, sassy, and had a tender heart.
I liked the secondary characters.
All in all an enjoyable read. I have always enjoyed Monica McCarty books. She does not disappoint.
Netgalley book for an honest review.
March 24, 2025
Give me a guardian Romance, age gap where the hero is a Scottish warrior ANYDAY!! Deep contented sighhh.
August 20, 2014
****Full Review****
I received this book for free in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.
This is book nine in the Highland Guard series and it's a foregone conclusion I'm going to do everything in my power to get my greedy little hands on the previous books. I would also like to say, as someone who hasn't read the other books, the list of characters, who they were, and the foreword relaying the back story was very much welcomed.
Gregor "Arrow" MacGregor has fought alongside Robert the Bruce for seven years in the war against England for Scotland's independence. He is part of the Highland Guard, also known as Phantoms, an elite group of warriors; his special skill is marksmanship with the bow. (His mother's name is Lady Marion so I imagine there is a sly wink to a certain mythical hero) He is also "The Most Handsome Man in Scotland". This moniker, along with certain events from his past, has led Gregor to become very jaded, cynical, and guarded. He doesn't think anyone truly knows him or cares to know him beyond his pretty face.
On a mission to try and save a village from being ransacked from the English, Gregor meets Cate. Cate, fifteen at the time, attacked an English soldier trying to save her mother from rape, who in turn kills her mother, and throws Cate into a well leaving her to starve to death. Gregor rescues her, thus giving Cate a serious case of hero worship. He brings Cate to his home and gives her to his mother to raise. He visits a handful of times and Cate's worship begins to mature into love.
The story really begins when Cate is twenty and Gregor thirty-one and he comes home for a little rest and relaxation from the war. Gregor wasn't around her much while she was growing up, I never found it icky or weird when he starts to develop and acknowledge his feelings for Cate, even when he calls himself her ward. Even though the title of this book is "Arrow" I would almost argue this is more of Cate's story. She is the open, honest, and fearless woman we all want to be. It may seem like her love for Gregor was born from childish feelings, they in fact may have been, but she proves over and over that she really sees the true man behind the pretty face. It may make you feel frustrated as Gregor refuses and pushes Cate away again and again and Cate comes up with reasons to justify his actions. I found it refreshing to have a character think why is he reacting this way instead of flying off the handle and creating melodrama after melodrama. However, I'm not saying you won't want to slap Gregor a time or two and yell at Cate to just give up. These characters have sizzling chemistry together and you're going to love and hate them at times. One thing I promise you is that you won't ever be bored.
The pace is steady and will keep you reading and while the overall tone is a little lighter than what I usually favor, I was still captivated. I also thought when Gregor capitulates to Cate, it felt slightly rushed. He finally allows himself to give in to his feelings for her and then they're sleeping together and marriage is being discussed. There is also a Big Misunderstanding and even though it is contrived, I thought it worked well in adding something to the story. Furthermore, there are times when the large cast of characters are mentioned along with their nicknames, I started to feel overwhelmed but if you have read the previous books you'll probably just enjoy the reunion.
Overall, this was a heartfelt, at times maddening couple, historical romance story. Your emotions will run the gamut throughout this book. In the end, however, you will feel a sense of fulfillment and a strong desire to go and read the other books in the series.
I received this book for free in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.
This is book nine in the Highland Guard series and it's a foregone conclusion I'm going to do everything in my power to get my greedy little hands on the previous books. I would also like to say, as someone who hasn't read the other books, the list of characters, who they were, and the foreword relaying the back story was very much welcomed.
Gregor "Arrow" MacGregor has fought alongside Robert the Bruce for seven years in the war against England for Scotland's independence. He is part of the Highland Guard, also known as Phantoms, an elite group of warriors; his special skill is marksmanship with the bow. (His mother's name is Lady Marion so I imagine there is a sly wink to a certain mythical hero) He is also "The Most Handsome Man in Scotland". This moniker, along with certain events from his past, has led Gregor to become very jaded, cynical, and guarded. He doesn't think anyone truly knows him or cares to know him beyond his pretty face.
On a mission to try and save a village from being ransacked from the English, Gregor meets Cate. Cate, fifteen at the time, attacked an English soldier trying to save her mother from rape, who in turn kills her mother, and throws Cate into a well leaving her to starve to death. Gregor rescues her, thus giving Cate a serious case of hero worship. He brings Cate to his home and gives her to his mother to raise. He visits a handful of times and Cate's worship begins to mature into love.
The story really begins when Cate is twenty and Gregor thirty-one and he comes home for a little rest and relaxation from the war. Gregor wasn't around her much while she was growing up, I never found it icky or weird when he starts to develop and acknowledge his feelings for Cate, even when he calls himself her ward. Even though the title of this book is "Arrow" I would almost argue this is more of Cate's story. She is the open, honest, and fearless woman we all want to be. It may seem like her love for Gregor was born from childish feelings, they in fact may have been, but she proves over and over that she really sees the true man behind the pretty face. It may make you feel frustrated as Gregor refuses and pushes Cate away again and again and Cate comes up with reasons to justify his actions. I found it refreshing to have a character think why is he reacting this way instead of flying off the handle and creating melodrama after melodrama. However, I'm not saying you won't want to slap Gregor a time or two and yell at Cate to just give up. These characters have sizzling chemistry together and you're going to love and hate them at times. One thing I promise you is that you won't ever be bored.
The pace is steady and will keep you reading and while the overall tone is a little lighter than what I usually favor, I was still captivated. I also thought when Gregor capitulates to Cate, it felt slightly rushed. He finally allows himself to give in to his feelings for her and then they're sleeping together and marriage is being discussed. There is also a Big Misunderstanding and even though it is contrived, I thought it worked well in adding something to the story. Furthermore, there are times when the large cast of characters are mentioned along with their nicknames, I started to feel overwhelmed but if you have read the previous books you'll probably just enjoy the reunion.
Overall, this was a heartfelt, at times maddening couple, historical romance story. Your emotions will run the gamut throughout this book. In the end, however, you will feel a sense of fulfillment and a strong desire to go and read the other books in the series.
July 18, 2021
Bu kurguya 400 sayfa çok fazlaydı.
September 5, 2014
5 stars!!!!
Wonderful story! Loved this book.
How this author is able to leave me feeling as if I just lost my best friend whenever I finish one of her books, I'll never understand.
Monica McCarty never disappoints.
The plot, and dialogue is fantastic. And the romance is hot, and steamy.
I loved the hero in this book, Gregor MacGregor "Arrow". I've been in love with him since the first book in the series, and I've anticipated this book so much since then, it felt surreal to have finally read his story. The picture I have of Arrow in my mind is perfection; I mean, there's no other hero more beautiful than him.
I loved how protective he was of Cate... And possessive. And if there's one thing I could say about all the books from this author is that her Heroes, all of them, have that in common, (the double Ps: Possessive and Protective) and is what I look for when reading about any hero in a romance novel. And this, Monica gives in abundance, which is why I love these books so damn much.
The heroine, Cate, was just simply adorable. I loved how determined she was to get Gregor to notice her, to prove to him he wanted her as much a she wanted him. And no matter how hard he fought himself, he never stood a chance against her determination to have him. Cate was very different from all the other heroines in the previous books of this series. It was truly refreshing to read about her character, and her fighting skills.
All the historical facts are AMAZING! The amount of research Monica puts into her books is really something else. I Love the Author's Notes as much as I love the story.
This book surpassed my exceptions, and left me thoroughly satisfied.
And now the wait...
Can I get Striker now???! Lol, I'll try to be patient.
Wonderful story! Loved this book.
How this author is able to leave me feeling as if I just lost my best friend whenever I finish one of her books, I'll never understand.
Monica McCarty never disappoints.
The plot, and dialogue is fantastic. And the romance is hot, and steamy.
I loved the hero in this book, Gregor MacGregor "Arrow". I've been in love with him since the first book in the series, and I've anticipated this book so much since then, it felt surreal to have finally read his story. The picture I have of Arrow in my mind is perfection; I mean, there's no other hero more beautiful than him.
I loved how protective he was of Cate... And possessive. And if there's one thing I could say about all the books from this author is that her Heroes, all of them, have that in common, (the double Ps: Possessive and Protective) and is what I look for when reading about any hero in a romance novel. And this, Monica gives in abundance, which is why I love these books so damn much.
The heroine, Cate, was just simply adorable. I loved how determined she was to get Gregor to notice her, to prove to him he wanted her as much a she wanted him. And no matter how hard he fought himself, he never stood a chance against her determination to have him. Cate was very different from all the other heroines in the previous books of this series. It was truly refreshing to read about her character, and her fighting skills.
All the historical facts are AMAZING! The amount of research Monica puts into her books is really something else. I Love the Author's Notes as much as I love the story.
This book surpassed my exceptions, and left me thoroughly satisfied.
And now the wait...
Can I get Striker now???! Lol, I'll try to be patient.
January 7, 2015
2.5 disappointing stars
This story started out great then fell flat for me. Cate is a ward after witnessing her mother's murder. Gregor is her guardian and the king's guardsmen. Cate was an interesting heroine. She has loved Gregor for as long as she has known him but he has always considered her a little sister who needs to be protected. He has never considered the fact that she has romantic feelings for him. Cate wants to prove to Gregor that she loves him and does ridiculous things to gain his attention. Gregor refuses to accept her feelings for him are deeper than a mere crush and attempts to find a prospective husband for her. Eventually he accepts the fact that Cate's feelings are true and decides he will marry her. They both have things they are keeping hidden from each other but when her secrets come to light he feels the need to prove himself by sleeping with another woman, the barmaid. He , and from this the reader is supposed to assume that it was due to his infidelity rather than the copious amounts of ale he had consumed. She sees this all and leaves but is captured. As she is she has even more value to her kidnappers, who also happen to be her mother's rapist and murderer.
I was really engaged in the story up to the 75% mark where Gregor becomes an idiot and Cate forgives him much too easily.
Not going to reread this one and would not recommend it.
This story started out great then fell flat for me. Cate is a ward after witnessing her mother's murder. Gregor is her guardian and the king's guardsmen. Cate was an interesting heroine. She has loved Gregor for as long as she has known him but he has always considered her a little sister who needs to be protected. He has never considered the fact that she has romantic feelings for him. Cate wants to prove to Gregor that she loves him and does ridiculous things to gain his attention. Gregor refuses to accept her feelings for him are deeper than a mere crush and attempts to find a prospective husband for her. Eventually he accepts the fact that Cate's feelings are true and decides he will marry her. They both have things they are keeping hidden from each other but when her secrets come to light he feels the need to prove himself by sleeping with another woman, the barmaid. He , and from this the reader is supposed to assume that it was due to his infidelity rather than the copious amounts of ale he had consumed. She sees this all and leaves but is captured. As she is she has even more value to her kidnappers, who also happen to be her mother's rapist and murderer.
I was really engaged in the story up to the 75% mark where Gregor becomes an idiot and Cate forgives him much too easily.
Not going to reread this one and would not recommend it.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
October 28, 2014
I am not as familiar with this author but Im a huge historical fiction reader. Especially with strapping Highlanders on the front cover that promise a clash of wills, sword-wielding, some dip into the pool of adventure, betrayal, a romantic liason, espionage, castle-storming, and/or other epic, clan-fighting badassery.
Instead, I got two main characters that I didnt care for. At all. She seemed selfish and he was downright stupid. Stubborness happened. Silly behavior happened. "If youre going to be reckless, well, Im going to act even more reckless" happened. The clincher? Cheating happened thus demoting a heroic character to a character I could give exactly zero cares over what happens next.
At least I got my castle-storming and kilted adventuring.
I hear many, many people love this author so Im not put off by a single book. I'm willing to try again. I just hope this is a one-off.
Thank you to Random House and Library Thing Early Reviewers for this copy in exchange for an honest book review.
Instead, I got two main characters that I didnt care for. At all. She seemed selfish and he was downright stupid. Stubborness happened. Silly behavior happened. "If youre going to be reckless, well, Im going to act even more reckless" happened. The clincher? Cheating happened thus demoting a heroic character to a character I could give exactly zero cares over what happens next.
At least I got my castle-storming and kilted adventuring.
I hear many, many people love this author so Im not put off by a single book. I'm willing to try again. I just hope this is a one-off.
Thank you to Random House and Library Thing Early Reviewers for this copy in exchange for an honest book review.
September 30, 2014
before release date
When I saw this series the first time, I just couldn't believe the high ratings. Not one of Ms. McCarty's books were below 4. Now I understand why! the premise of this story, the rich historical background, the smooth writing style, It's practically gold.
So when I saw the ninth installment of Highland guard and that it was Arrow's story, I jumped put of my shoes!!!!
I just fell in love with this series. I can't get enough of the Highland guards! I wish this never end.
August 28, 2014
This is still one of the best series I've ever read in my entire life. I have already reread this (last September 15) and this proves the prowess of Ms. Monica McCarty's writing.
When I saw this series the first time, I just couldn't believe the high ratings. Not one of Ms. McCarty's books were below 4. Now I understand why! the premise of this story, the rich historical background, the smooth writing style, It's practically gold.
So when I saw the ninth installment of Highland guard and that it was Arrow's story, I jumped put of my shoes!!!!
I just fell in love with this series. I can't get enough of the Highland guards! I wish this never end.
August 28, 2014
This is still one of the best series I've ever read in my entire life. I have already reread this (last September 15) and this proves the prowess of Ms. Monica McCarty's writing.
January 21, 2024
4.5 🌟's
ugh SO GOOD i loved this one.. one of my fave heroines in the series and honestly such a good love story
ugh SO GOOD i loved this one.. one of my fave heroines in the series and honestly such a good love story
April 27, 2014
Received an ARC from Netgalley for an honest review:
"The Arrow" by Monica McCarty is the 9th book in her Highland Guard series. Having read all of the previous books in the series, I highly anticipated reading Gregor MacGregor's story. Dubbed "the most handsome man in Scotland," Gregor's skill with the bow is unparalleled and he is a highly valued member of Robert Bruce's elite Highland Guard in his quest to wrestle back control of Scotland from England and claim the crown of the King of Scotland. Gregor's loyalty to Robert Bruce is as legendary as his reputation as a heartbreaker. However, his cover as one of Bruce's notorious "phantoms" has been compromised and he must lay low for a while. Taking the perfect opportunity to return home to address issues related to his ward, Cate of Lochmaben, he discovers a very grown-up and desirable Cate.
Five years earlier, Cate of Lochmaben is discovered by Gregor and members of his Highland Guard brethren, trapped inside a well after her village has been destroyed and her family killed by the marauding English. Gregor takes Cate under his wing, brings her to his home and makes her his ward for her protection. Cate is not immune to Gregor's astonishing good looks but, over the years, begins to learn about the man behind the face. She recognizes Gregor's insecurities, his reasons for proving himself and his guarded heart. She convinces herself that Gregor only needs to spend time with her to realize that she is the right woman for him. Cate has never forgotten, however, the Englishman who raped and killed her pregnant mother and wants vengeance. And, here our story begins.
I really enjoyed Cate's character. She is feisty, clever and independent. Because of what she witnessed as a young girl, she strives to be able to defend herself in case of an attack. She believes she was abandoned by her legitimate father as a young girl, and therefore opens her heart to other "orphans" to shower them with the love she lacked. She is completely goal driven and somewhat naive in the ways she tries to achieve her goals. She is definitely a survivor who is thriving.
We get to see much more behind "the face" of the handsomest man in Scotland in this book. In the first part of the book, Gregor is fighting his attraction to his ward with as much tenacity as he fights for the Bruce. When he finally succumbs to Cate's unusual character and charms, he is still filled with insecurity and is quick to lose trust. As the storyline evolves and as the layers of Gregor's past reveal themselves, you begin to understand why he feels and acts as he does.
Monica McCarty is an amazing writer. Her descriptions of the era, scenery and circumstances are beautifully written and you have no problem conjuring the "pictures" in your mind. The characters are always well developed. Ms. McCarty's storylines often take twists and turns, keeps you guessing and on the edge of your seat. I will say that in the previous books of this series, there was a lot of adventure and action early in the books. This storyline was developed as delving more into the characters' personalities, backgrounds and interactions in the beginning. However, as I couldn't wait to read more about Gregor MacGregor, almost from the beginning, I enjoyed that time learning more about him and his relationship with Cate. Be patient, grasshopper, there is plenty of action later in this book, along with a very interesting twist. And, it is always fun to read more about the other "phantoms."
I highly recommend "The Arrow," as well as Monica McCarty's entire series of fabulous books. I have been a fan since her very first book, "Untamed Highlander." She never disappoints!
"The Arrow" by Monica McCarty is the 9th book in her Highland Guard series. Having read all of the previous books in the series, I highly anticipated reading Gregor MacGregor's story. Dubbed "the most handsome man in Scotland," Gregor's skill with the bow is unparalleled and he is a highly valued member of Robert Bruce's elite Highland Guard in his quest to wrestle back control of Scotland from England and claim the crown of the King of Scotland. Gregor's loyalty to Robert Bruce is as legendary as his reputation as a heartbreaker. However, his cover as one of Bruce's notorious "phantoms" has been compromised and he must lay low for a while. Taking the perfect opportunity to return home to address issues related to his ward, Cate of Lochmaben, he discovers a very grown-up and desirable Cate.
Five years earlier, Cate of Lochmaben is discovered by Gregor and members of his Highland Guard brethren, trapped inside a well after her village has been destroyed and her family killed by the marauding English. Gregor takes Cate under his wing, brings her to his home and makes her his ward for her protection. Cate is not immune to Gregor's astonishing good looks but, over the years, begins to learn about the man behind the face. She recognizes Gregor's insecurities, his reasons for proving himself and his guarded heart. She convinces herself that Gregor only needs to spend time with her to realize that she is the right woman for him. Cate has never forgotten, however, the Englishman who raped and killed her pregnant mother and wants vengeance. And, here our story begins.
I really enjoyed Cate's character. She is feisty, clever and independent. Because of what she witnessed as a young girl, she strives to be able to defend herself in case of an attack. She believes she was abandoned by her legitimate father as a young girl, and therefore opens her heart to other "orphans" to shower them with the love she lacked. She is completely goal driven and somewhat naive in the ways she tries to achieve her goals. She is definitely a survivor who is thriving.
We get to see much more behind "the face" of the handsomest man in Scotland in this book. In the first part of the book, Gregor is fighting his attraction to his ward with as much tenacity as he fights for the Bruce. When he finally succumbs to Cate's unusual character and charms, he is still filled with insecurity and is quick to lose trust. As the storyline evolves and as the layers of Gregor's past reveal themselves, you begin to understand why he feels and acts as he does.
Monica McCarty is an amazing writer. Her descriptions of the era, scenery and circumstances are beautifully written and you have no problem conjuring the "pictures" in your mind. The characters are always well developed. Ms. McCarty's storylines often take twists and turns, keeps you guessing and on the edge of your seat. I will say that in the previous books of this series, there was a lot of adventure and action early in the books. This storyline was developed as delving more into the characters' personalities, backgrounds and interactions in the beginning. However, as I couldn't wait to read more about Gregor MacGregor, almost from the beginning, I enjoyed that time learning more about him and his relationship with Cate. Be patient, grasshopper, there is plenty of action later in this book, along with a very interesting twist. And, it is always fun to read more about the other "phantoms."
I highly recommend "The Arrow," as well as Monica McCarty's entire series of fabulous books. I have been a fan since her very first book, "Untamed Highlander." She never disappoints!
August 16, 2014
The Arrow by Monica McCarty
3.5 Stars
This is book nine in the Highland Guard series by Monica McCarty. The Highland Guard is a highly specialized private army fighting for Robert Bruce and his claim to the Scottish throne. This chapter in the saga is about Gregor "The Arrow" MacGregor. He a supreme archer, fighter, womanizer and "The Most Handsome Man in Scotland". At the beginning of the book, Bruce's Phantoms have just entered a village that was pillaged by the English army. All of its inhabitants are dead except for a little girl that was thrown in a well to starve to death. A little girl who had just witnessed the rape and murder of her pregnant mother. Her punishment for trying to stop it was this dumping of her in the well. She's rescued by The Arrow and after much pleading by her, he takes her as his ward.
She fell in love with him the day he rescued her. She waited for his visits home patiently. Always waiting for him to notice her but he never did. Cate isn't your average girl, she's a girl that vowed never to be vulnerable again. She trained with The Arrow's brother on how to defend herself. She's a warrior in her own right. When Gregor comes home after a disappointing battle, she knows it's time to make him see her as a woman. Gregor does see her as a woman but because of being hurt in his teen years, he pushes her away. But Cate will not be pushed aside.
I started off loving this book. I was once again craving a historical romance and I thought this would be all I wanted it to be. And it was for most of the book. Then there was a misconstrued situation and infidelity happened. INFIDELITY! In my historical romance! Never, never, never will I be accepting of this! Never! I know there was no completion of the act but the hero( I use this term loosely) had a woman on his lap, touching him intimately and he went to a room with her. To make matters worse, the heroine followed them and saw this woman go down on him! Seriously?! I don't know when this became an example of sexy or romantic to this author but she is absolutely mistaken. What could have easily been a four star book dropped to three and half stars and has left me contemplating finishing reading this series.
Reviewed by Naughty Book Snitch Kay.
3.5 Stars
This is book nine in the Highland Guard series by Monica McCarty. The Highland Guard is a highly specialized private army fighting for Robert Bruce and his claim to the Scottish throne. This chapter in the saga is about Gregor "The Arrow" MacGregor. He a supreme archer, fighter, womanizer and "The Most Handsome Man in Scotland". At the beginning of the book, Bruce's Phantoms have just entered a village that was pillaged by the English army. All of its inhabitants are dead except for a little girl that was thrown in a well to starve to death. A little girl who had just witnessed the rape and murder of her pregnant mother. Her punishment for trying to stop it was this dumping of her in the well. She's rescued by The Arrow and after much pleading by her, he takes her as his ward.
She fell in love with him the day he rescued her. She waited for his visits home patiently. Always waiting for him to notice her but he never did. Cate isn't your average girl, she's a girl that vowed never to be vulnerable again. She trained with The Arrow's brother on how to defend herself. She's a warrior in her own right. When Gregor comes home after a disappointing battle, she knows it's time to make him see her as a woman. Gregor does see her as a woman but because of being hurt in his teen years, he pushes her away. But Cate will not be pushed aside.
I started off loving this book. I was once again craving a historical romance and I thought this would be all I wanted it to be. And it was for most of the book. Then there was a misconstrued situation and infidelity happened. INFIDELITY! In my historical romance! Never, never, never will I be accepting of this! Never! I know there was no completion of the act but the hero( I use this term loosely) had a woman on his lap, touching him intimately and he went to a room with her. To make matters worse, the heroine followed them and saw this woman go down on him! Seriously?! I don't know when this became an example of sexy or romantic to this author but she is absolutely mistaken. What could have easily been a four star book dropped to three and half stars and has left me contemplating finishing reading this series.
Reviewed by Naughty Book Snitch Kay.
September 2, 2022
3.5 stars rounded up to ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ stars for goodreads.
This book broke my heart a bit. You see, I loved Gregor (Arrow) having read the entire series leading up to this one. I understood his insecurity, his hang up, his inability to believe that anyone would love him for him and not just for his pretty face or as a conquest. The deeper insecurities based upon never being accepted by his father and being seen as frivolous by his family, that amplified those insecurities. We also see that his role as Robert the Bruce’s sharp shooter (with a bow) is wearing on him and he Carrie’s tremendous guilt. This poor guy. I get it.
However, McCarty still broke my heart when she had Gregor act on that shame & insecurity in the way that he did. I agreed with Cate for not forgiving him right away, for making him suffer and grovel, but wow…that bad behavior from Gregor was hard to reconcile with his character over the years.
This book broke my heart a bit. You see, I loved Gregor (Arrow) having read the entire series leading up to this one. I understood his insecurity, his hang up, his inability to believe that anyone would love him for him and not just for his pretty face or as a conquest. The deeper insecurities based upon never being accepted by his father and being seen as frivolous by his family, that amplified those insecurities. We also see that his role as Robert the Bruce’s sharp shooter (with a bow) is wearing on him and he Carrie’s tremendous guilt. This poor guy. I get it.
However, McCarty still broke my heart when she had Gregor act on that shame & insecurity in the way that he did. I agreed with Cate for not forgiving him right away, for making him suffer and grovel, but wow…that bad behavior from Gregor was hard to reconcile with his character over the years.
July 11, 2020
I was loving this book until around 75%, at which point I wish it had just ended so I could give the book 5 stars in peace. The initial premise (gruff/grumpy guardian staves off his attraction to younger feisty "ward") is my catnip when it's done well. The relationship dynamics felt oddly reminiscent of Nalini Singh's Kiss of Snow, which is one of my favorite books ever. Unfortunately, the hero does something really annoying at the 75% mark and I found it hard to forgive him. Spoilers under the spoiler tag.
May 20, 2022
3 stars.
Story occurred mostly 1312 and onward in Scotland.
The King of Scotland, Robert the Bruce had an elite
secret military force the Highland Guard. I previously
read books # 1,2, 3, & 12 of this series. And now #9.
Gregor, a top-notch archer was called "Arrow" by
his fellow Highland Guard (HG) friends. He rescued
a 12 YO girl (in truth 15) Catherine from an abandoned
well, after her village was- decimated by the English
& her mother raped and murdered. Gregor's mother
housed orphan "Cate." Cate had a temper & trouble
became her. At times she used tears to manipulate
others.
Gregor, not easily ruffled, fought his attraction to Cate
and decided to find her a suitable husband. Meanwhile
he routinely took cold river baths.
Gregor had an unhappy love affair & thereafter distrusted
women. Before the 70% mark, the H unjustly accused the
h of also being a dishonest woman who considered him a
'prize.' Before the H & h wed, he assured his HG friends
"I'll be saying my vows but not taking them." Once wed,
the hero and another woman engaged in a sex act. Only
once. But still?
The HG bantering with each other moved the story along.
Story occurred mostly 1312 and onward in Scotland.
The King of Scotland, Robert the Bruce had an elite
secret military force the Highland Guard. I previously
read books # 1,2, 3, & 12 of this series. And now #9.
Gregor, a top-notch archer was called "Arrow" by
his fellow Highland Guard (HG) friends. He rescued
a 12 YO girl (in truth 15) Catherine from an abandoned
well, after her village was- decimated by the English
& her mother raped and murdered. Gregor's mother
housed orphan "Cate." Cate had a temper & trouble
became her. At times she used tears to manipulate
others.
Gregor, not easily ruffled, fought his attraction to Cate
and decided to find her a suitable husband. Meanwhile
he routinely took cold river baths.
Gregor had an unhappy love affair & thereafter distrusted
women. Before the 70% mark, the H unjustly accused the
h of also being a dishonest woman who considered him a
'prize.' Before the H & h wed, he assured his HG friends
"I'll be saying my vows but not taking them." Once wed,
the hero and another woman engaged in a sex act. Only
once. But still?
The HG bantering with each other moved the story along.
July 25, 2016
The heroine ruined the book for me. Now I don't think it's MM's strongest talent to write diverse male characters. They're quite interchangeable most of the time. I don't mind it that much, as I'm usually more fixated on heroines anyway. Cate, though....I could have just strangled her.
Again, the second star is for historical accuracy. Which reminds me that I should do the same for The Hunter too, but I can't be bothered after reading The Rock
Again, the second star is for historical accuracy. Which reminds me that I should do the same for The Hunter too, but I can't be bothered after reading The Rock
September 28, 2014
I love all the books in this series. The writing is once again perfect, the historical descriptions and the romance blew me away. We have one "big misunderstanding" that was a bit weak, but the resolution at the end was great. I've been wanting to read Arrow's story for a while and this was better than I had hoped. Cate is also a great, strong heroine. She has no problem going after what she wants and she can fight like a warrior. I loved how her faith in Gregor makes him a better person in the end, and the epilogue was wonderful. Looking forward to the next book!
July 29, 2014
***Review posted on The Eater of Books! blog***
The Arrow by Monica McCarty
Book Nine of the Highland Guard series
Publisher: Ballantine Books
Publication Date: August 26, 2014
Rating: 2 stars
Source: eARC from NetGalley
***Warning: this is an adult book, and for the eyes of mature readers***
Summary (from Goodreads):
As King Robert the Bruce of Scotland plots to retake his English occupied castles, he needs the stealth and skill of his elite soldiers, the Highland Guard. Fearless and indomitable, no men are more loyal to their king, or cherished by the women they love.
The talents of legendary marksman Gregor “Arrow” MacGregor are crucial now, as Bruce moves to reclaim his Scottish holdings. Gregor is considered the most handsome man in Scotland, and his fame as an archer is rivaled only by his reputation with the lasses as a heartbreaker. But when his infamous face is exposed during a covert mission, Gregor is forced to lay low. He returns home only to find a new battle waiting: a daring game of seduction involving his now very grown up and very desirable ward, Cate of Lochmaben.
A born fighter, Cate was clinging to life when Gregor rescued her after a vicious English raid on her village left her mother dead. But five years later, the once scrappy orphan Gregor took under his protection has become a woman. Brave, strong, and skilled in warfare, Cate is determined to lay claim to the warrior who refuses to be trapped. The heat in his eyes tells her she has his attention . . . and his desire. But will Gregor allow his heart to surrender before danger finds them, and the truth of Cate’s identity is revealed?
What I Liked:
First - thank GOODNESS they changed the cover. This new one is MUCH better than the first one. If haven't seen the original cover, be glad you didn't. It wasn't that great. Ab-licious, but not that great, aesthetically. I'm loving this guy's biceps. Arms are seriously important for "The Arrow" - Gregor, the skilled archer of the Phantoms.
Gregor saved Cait when she was fifteen and trapped in a well. She was hiding after seeing her mother brutally raped and murdered by a lord that she has been trying to locate for the past five years. At twenty, she's still in love with the man that saved her, even more so than before. When he returns home for a break, she is determined to show him how she feels, and that he feels the same way about her. But Gregor doesn't want to do wrong by his ward. He feels very strongly towards her, but love? It would be easier to rid himself of her wonderfully distracting self, and marry her off. But more is at stake - Gregor's identity as a Phantom may have been compromised, and the man that killed Cait's mother may be after Cait - and Gregor.
I really, really wanted to enjoy this book. Of all of the Phantoms, the Arrow is probably my favorite. I totally have a thing for archers, especially pretty ones. Blond hair, over-muscled, roguish attitude, arrogant - and an archer. Gregor is a perfect mix of the "best" qualities of a Scottish warrior. I had only read two of the eight books published in this series (before this one), but I was highly anticipating this one, because The Arrow is supposed to unattainable, impossible to ensnare. I just knew his love story would be epic.
Well, it wasn't. You already gathered that I really liked Gregor - I do. He doesn't trust women, and for good reason. Because he's so good-looking, women throw themselves at him all the time, and while he doesn't mind the, um, company (so to speak), he could never trust one to care about them, or more. I love his confident but cautious nature. I also love his perfect physical being, but that's neither hear nor there.
I also really enjoyed the story of this book, minus the romance. Of course, the romance and the story are intertwined, but I really liked how McCarty wove a story into the romance, and an interesting, surprise-filled one at that. I didn't see one of the twists at the end coming. Genius!
I love this series, guys. I've only read three of the nine, but I really enjoyed books seven and eight, and was really excited for book none (the Arrow)! But now, read on.
What I Did Not Like:
I. Hate. Cait. Love how that rhymes. Hate her. Hate hate hate. When I have a problem with the heroine (ESPECIALLY in historical romance novels), I'll very much likely have a problem with the book overall. And I do not like Cait.
She's overbearing, bossy, and annoying, and not in a "cute" way, as Gregor and others see her. Gregor took her in when she was fifteen, taking her off the battlefield, away from hurt and ruin. Years later, Cait takes it upon herself to "borrow"/invite in four random "orphans" (they're not orphans, they have families), and surprise Gregor with four new "children". Literally, she says, he's your father, you're their father, the children are yours. She even believes that biologically, they could be!
Right then, from the start, I knew that I would hate her. How dare she dump four children on her guardian's lap, like it's his job to take care of children that he's never seen before, that aren't his responsibility, that HAVE FAMILIES?! And she - she's not even his daughter or sister or cousin - how could she try his patience with her, when he doesn't even owe HER anything?!
It gets worse and worse with her, honestly. Her indolence and stupidity are ridiculous. Apparently she's strong and courageous and clever and intelligent - I saw none of that. I saw a coward, who forces children into a man's hands. I saw a fool, who forced a man to notice her, just like all of the other women were trying to do, always. I saw an idiot, whose feelings were hurt even though it was HER FAULT that Gregor walked away from her - SHE broke his trust. SHE knew what she was doing, trying to "trap" him, which is basically what all of the other women were trying to do. How was he supposed to know that she really loved him? As readers, we see it from her perspective, but looking at things without her perspective, she seems just like a brazen, irritating hussy, trying to catch a handsome, powerful lord.
Hate hate hate her. Sooo much.
Honestly, I hated the back-and-forth in this book. Gregor realizes that he indeed loves Cait about 50% into the book, which is totally fine by me. But then things get to be like a see-saw. Cait does something to try Gregor's trust, Gregor thinks the worst, they make up. Gregor misinterprets a situation, Cait does nothing to disprove it, HER feelings are hurt (God only knows why, since it's HER fault), his heart is broken, life sucks. Back and forth and back and forth.
Not the way I like my romance.
Basically, I hated Cait, and I really didn't like the romance. The male protagonist and the actual story were great, but not enough to save this one. This book was definitely a disappointment, since I expected so much more for Gregor. I expected his love story to be amazinggggggggg. Like, who could this girl be, that slays the dragon (so to speak). No one remarkable, apparently. I expected better, but Cait made me want to vomit everywhere, honestly.
Would I Recommend It:
Hmmm. Read it if you're loving the series, but seriously drop your standards and expect a pile of poo. I'm being totally serious and straight-faced right now. And no offense or disrespect to the author, publisher, etc. But readers, you might enjoy this book more if you weren't super excited to read it and expected little to nothing. I know, it's hard, because we're all like OMG GREGOR'S STORY, GREGOR'S STORY, THIS IS GOING TO BE GOOD.
Get that out of your head right now, and you *might* enjoy this book. Enjoy Gregor, at least. He is magnificent!
Rating:
2 stars. I'm so disappointed... but I still want to keep up with this series. And I still want to read the first SIX books of the series (must find timeeee). I seriously hope this wasn't the last book in the series? The epilogue kind of made it sound like it is... that would me so sad. Why end on such a horrible note? Sadness.
The Arrow by Monica McCarty
Book Nine of the Highland Guard series
Publisher: Ballantine Books
Publication Date: August 26, 2014
Rating: 2 stars
Source: eARC from NetGalley
***Warning: this is an adult book, and for the eyes of mature readers***
Summary (from Goodreads):
As King Robert the Bruce of Scotland plots to retake his English occupied castles, he needs the stealth and skill of his elite soldiers, the Highland Guard. Fearless and indomitable, no men are more loyal to their king, or cherished by the women they love.
The talents of legendary marksman Gregor “Arrow” MacGregor are crucial now, as Bruce moves to reclaim his Scottish holdings. Gregor is considered the most handsome man in Scotland, and his fame as an archer is rivaled only by his reputation with the lasses as a heartbreaker. But when his infamous face is exposed during a covert mission, Gregor is forced to lay low. He returns home only to find a new battle waiting: a daring game of seduction involving his now very grown up and very desirable ward, Cate of Lochmaben.
A born fighter, Cate was clinging to life when Gregor rescued her after a vicious English raid on her village left her mother dead. But five years later, the once scrappy orphan Gregor took under his protection has become a woman. Brave, strong, and skilled in warfare, Cate is determined to lay claim to the warrior who refuses to be trapped. The heat in his eyes tells her she has his attention . . . and his desire. But will Gregor allow his heart to surrender before danger finds them, and the truth of Cate’s identity is revealed?
What I Liked:
First - thank GOODNESS they changed the cover. This new one is MUCH better than the first one. If haven't seen the original cover, be glad you didn't. It wasn't that great. Ab-licious, but not that great, aesthetically. I'm loving this guy's biceps. Arms are seriously important for "The Arrow" - Gregor, the skilled archer of the Phantoms.
Gregor saved Cait when she was fifteen and trapped in a well. She was hiding after seeing her mother brutally raped and murdered by a lord that she has been trying to locate for the past five years. At twenty, she's still in love with the man that saved her, even more so than before. When he returns home for a break, she is determined to show him how she feels, and that he feels the same way about her. But Gregor doesn't want to do wrong by his ward. He feels very strongly towards her, but love? It would be easier to rid himself of her wonderfully distracting self, and marry her off. But more is at stake - Gregor's identity as a Phantom may have been compromised, and the man that killed Cait's mother may be after Cait - and Gregor.
I really, really wanted to enjoy this book. Of all of the Phantoms, the Arrow is probably my favorite. I totally have a thing for archers, especially pretty ones. Blond hair, over-muscled, roguish attitude, arrogant - and an archer. Gregor is a perfect mix of the "best" qualities of a Scottish warrior. I had only read two of the eight books published in this series (before this one), but I was highly anticipating this one, because The Arrow is supposed to unattainable, impossible to ensnare. I just knew his love story would be epic.
Well, it wasn't. You already gathered that I really liked Gregor - I do. He doesn't trust women, and for good reason. Because he's so good-looking, women throw themselves at him all the time, and while he doesn't mind the, um, company (so to speak), he could never trust one to care about them, or more. I love his confident but cautious nature. I also love his perfect physical being, but that's neither hear nor there.
I also really enjoyed the story of this book, minus the romance. Of course, the romance and the story are intertwined, but I really liked how McCarty wove a story into the romance, and an interesting, surprise-filled one at that. I didn't see one of the twists at the end coming. Genius!
I love this series, guys. I've only read three of the nine, but I really enjoyed books seven and eight, and was really excited for book none (the Arrow)! But now, read on.
What I Did Not Like:
I. Hate. Cait. Love how that rhymes. Hate her. Hate hate hate. When I have a problem with the heroine (ESPECIALLY in historical romance novels), I'll very much likely have a problem with the book overall. And I do not like Cait.
She's overbearing, bossy, and annoying, and not in a "cute" way, as Gregor and others see her. Gregor took her in when she was fifteen, taking her off the battlefield, away from hurt and ruin. Years later, Cait takes it upon herself to "borrow"/invite in four random "orphans" (they're not orphans, they have families), and surprise Gregor with four new "children". Literally, she says, he's your father, you're their father, the children are yours. She even believes that biologically, they could be!
Right then, from the start, I knew that I would hate her. How dare she dump four children on her guardian's lap, like it's his job to take care of children that he's never seen before, that aren't his responsibility, that HAVE FAMILIES?! And she - she's not even his daughter or sister or cousin - how could she try his patience with her, when he doesn't even owe HER anything?!
It gets worse and worse with her, honestly. Her indolence and stupidity are ridiculous. Apparently she's strong and courageous and clever and intelligent - I saw none of that. I saw a coward, who forces children into a man's hands. I saw a fool, who forced a man to notice her, just like all of the other women were trying to do, always. I saw an idiot, whose feelings were hurt even though it was HER FAULT that Gregor walked away from her - SHE broke his trust. SHE knew what she was doing, trying to "trap" him, which is basically what all of the other women were trying to do. How was he supposed to know that she really loved him? As readers, we see it from her perspective, but looking at things without her perspective, she seems just like a brazen, irritating hussy, trying to catch a handsome, powerful lord.
Hate hate hate her. Sooo much.
Honestly, I hated the back-and-forth in this book. Gregor realizes that he indeed loves Cait about 50% into the book, which is totally fine by me. But then things get to be like a see-saw. Cait does something to try Gregor's trust, Gregor thinks the worst, they make up. Gregor misinterprets a situation, Cait does nothing to disprove it, HER feelings are hurt (God only knows why, since it's HER fault), his heart is broken, life sucks. Back and forth and back and forth.
Not the way I like my romance.
Basically, I hated Cait, and I really didn't like the romance. The male protagonist and the actual story were great, but not enough to save this one. This book was definitely a disappointment, since I expected so much more for Gregor. I expected his love story to be amazinggggggggg. Like, who could this girl be, that slays the dragon (so to speak). No one remarkable, apparently. I expected better, but Cait made me want to vomit everywhere, honestly.
Would I Recommend It:
Hmmm. Read it if you're loving the series, but seriously drop your standards and expect a pile of poo. I'm being totally serious and straight-faced right now. And no offense or disrespect to the author, publisher, etc. But readers, you might enjoy this book more if you weren't super excited to read it and expected little to nothing. I know, it's hard, because we're all like OMG GREGOR'S STORY, GREGOR'S STORY, THIS IS GOING TO BE GOOD.
Get that out of your head right now, and you *might* enjoy this book. Enjoy Gregor, at least. He is magnificent!
Rating:
2 stars. I'm so disappointed... but I still want to keep up with this series. And I still want to read the first SIX books of the series (must find timeeee). I seriously hope this wasn't the last book in the series? The epilogue kind of made it sound like it is... that would me so sad. Why end on such a horrible note? Sadness.
February 16, 2019
When I started this one, I didn't like the premise; of Cate throwing herself at Gregor; it seemed common ... and then Cate developed and I saw that she was a strong woman who was not stupidly in love with him; rather, she knows him well and understands and believes in their connection ... Gregor did some very stupid things but he gets punished and he grovels; for a good bit ... Cate's background was so sad ... and loved the epilogue ... she has 5 sons and Gregor tells her he needs another son; she threatens him back ...
December 18, 2014
So I got to admit two things:
I did the blasphemous thing of reading this out of order. Yeah, I know! Terrible. I should really say I regret it- but I don't.
AND
I totally and utterly fell for the Highlander hottie fantasy. Yes, my dear reading buddies, you know who you are, shall gloat ever so happy over this one.
I kinda might have tried to disillusion them about Scottish men... and I might have kinda pointed out how unrealistic all those Highlander romances are....aaaand I might kinda have laughed about reading them, possibly said they weren't for me?
ok. I kinda just did that. Buuuut in my defense. I am actually right, in most of the cases.
Apparently McCarty did proof me wrong. In the latter rather than the former. Let's not go into the whole Highlander hottie thingy... I lived in the Highlands, I was thoroughly disillusioned. -And then I read McCarty's books.
The plot is a bit- well actually a lot (to be honest)- your classic romance run-down. It starts with some background to the MCs, then there are some sweet tensions, a wee bit of -in this case rather delectable- smut, the realisation of the big L, heartbreak at around 70%. and the HEA. But what makes this so much fun, is the setting and the action that is thrown in. McCarthy has done lots of research and while most of the characters a fictional, most of the plot is obviously totally fictional- she carefully set it in historical accurate circumstances and added several well portrait historical characters into the fold. This makes it somewhat not only a pleasure to read, it makes it feel realistic, like McCarthy is giving us a window to the past. Albeit it's a rather cute and fluffy one.
The world building is for the same reasons great. It's realistic, no thin silky gowns,- they do get cold, have drafty castles.Which gives me endless pleasure, cause frankly, one of my biggest issues in most of the Highlander romp, they portray Scotland as this warm and sunny place...which leaves me to question: have they been in Scotland?! It's an incredibly beautiful place, don't misunderstand me. But sunny and warm- it ain't not!
The character building is the best part. This is definitely a character driven series. Well, set around 10 awesome, hot and strong Men, I guess that is to be expected, isn't it? McCarthy however, manages to make each one of the guys distinct- and frankly with all the nicknames and the heavy list of characters, I kinda was worried I won't remember who is who. But no such problems, I only read three of these, but I know the Highland Guards and their families quite well actually. And more so I care! I really like them all. Each book is the story of one of them and their love interest. But the story weaves between them, they are linked by historical events, friendships evolve and one finds new sides to each character in each book, even when they are the support cast.
Which leaves me to admit- you could do this as a standalone- buuuut maybe don't. Also, maybe don't read these out of order? I mean it can be done. I don't think it's a biggy, no big spoilers or anything. But one does miss out on subtle little things, which are what I think makes this a good series.
The writing style is beautiful. McCarthy has found a way to express things appropriate for the historical and geographic setting without being to over the top so it's easy to read. But more so, McCarthy's prose evokes memories of my time in the Highlands, her descriptions are simply beautiful. She gets it just right.
So I have been officially proven wrong. I DO get what the hype over the Highland romps is about- well at least in this case I do.
And I shall be a good girl and go back and start reading them in order. And yes I intend to read every single one of them!
I did the blasphemous thing of reading this out of order. Yeah, I know! Terrible. I should really say I regret it- but I don't.
AND
I totally and utterly fell for the Highlander hottie fantasy. Yes, my dear reading buddies, you know who you are, shall gloat ever so happy over this one.
I kinda might have tried to disillusion them about Scottish men... and I might have kinda pointed out how unrealistic all those Highlander romances are....aaaand I might kinda have laughed about reading them, possibly said they weren't for me?
ok. I kinda just did that. Buuuut in my defense. I am actually right, in most of the cases.
Apparently McCarty did proof me wrong. In the latter rather than the former. Let's not go into the whole Highlander hottie thingy... I lived in the Highlands, I was thoroughly disillusioned. -And then I read McCarty's books.
The plot is a bit- well actually a lot (to be honest)- your classic romance run-down. It starts with some background to the MCs, then there are some sweet tensions, a wee bit of -in this case rather delectable- smut, the realisation of the big L, heartbreak at around 70%. and the HEA. But what makes this so much fun, is the setting and the action that is thrown in. McCarthy has done lots of research and while most of the characters a fictional, most of the plot is obviously totally fictional- she carefully set it in historical accurate circumstances and added several well portrait historical characters into the fold. This makes it somewhat not only a pleasure to read, it makes it feel realistic, like McCarthy is giving us a window to the past. Albeit it's a rather cute and fluffy one.
The world building is for the same reasons great. It's realistic, no thin silky gowns,- they do get cold, have drafty castles.Which gives me endless pleasure, cause frankly, one of my biggest issues in most of the Highlander romp, they portray Scotland as this warm and sunny place...which leaves me to question: have they been in Scotland?! It's an incredibly beautiful place, don't misunderstand me. But sunny and warm- it ain't not!
The character building is the best part. This is definitely a character driven series. Well, set around 10 awesome, hot and strong Men, I guess that is to be expected, isn't it? McCarthy however, manages to make each one of the guys distinct- and frankly with all the nicknames and the heavy list of characters, I kinda was worried I won't remember who is who. But no such problems, I only read three of these, but I know the Highland Guards and their families quite well actually. And more so I care! I really like them all. Each book is the story of one of them and their love interest. But the story weaves between them, they are linked by historical events, friendships evolve and one finds new sides to each character in each book, even when they are the support cast.
Which leaves me to admit- you could do this as a standalone- buuuut maybe don't. Also, maybe don't read these out of order? I mean it can be done. I don't think it's a biggy, no big spoilers or anything. But one does miss out on subtle little things, which are what I think makes this a good series.
The writing style is beautiful. McCarthy has found a way to express things appropriate for the historical and geographic setting without being to over the top so it's easy to read. But more so, McCarthy's prose evokes memories of my time in the Highlands, her descriptions are simply beautiful. She gets it just right.
So I have been officially proven wrong. I DO get what the hype over the Highland romps is about- well at least in this case I do.
And I shall be a good girl and go back and start reading them in order. And yes I intend to read every single one of them!
March 26, 2020
70% of the book is 5 stars, then everything is spoiled by the hero’s behaviour. Cate and Gregor are in love and are going to marry, then, at the first misunderstanding he decides to have sex with another woman. At the first problem between them, and it’s a misunderstanding which she denies and explains very well to him, he goes with another woman. And eventually she forgives him. No, this won’t do. Enough. Enough with women always forgiving weak and selfish men ten years older than them and acting like teenagers. No,this is something that spoils all the rest of the book that was simply perfect. I was not so fond of Cate, she tries from the beginning to make him understand that she is the right woman for him, but she didn’t deserve a narcisist selfish childish man like Gregor. She deserves more than this, this is not love nor respect.
June 24, 2022
3 stars ✨
I loved the angst, but the cheating went too far for me. He shouldn’t have gone as far as he did and that ruined the mmc for me.
I loved the angst, but the cheating went too far for me. He shouldn’t have gone as far as he did and that ruined the mmc for me.
June 29, 2014
I received this ARC from Net Galley in exchange for an honest review
3.5 Stars!!
Synopsis:
After her mother is killed, due to a raid on her village by the Englsh, Caitrina Kirkpatrick is taken under the wing of none other than Gregor "Arrow" MacGregor; legendary marksman and most handsome man in Scotland. A few years later, Caitrina is all grown up and wants to be with Gregor, who she's had stars in her eyes for ever since she was a young girl. However Gregor still sees her as a young girl - but Cate wants to change that. Will he see her as a mature woman? Will his allegiance to King Robert the Bruce come between them? Or will it be her past that come back to haunt her?
Writing
I'm not going to lie, I kept thinking of Stephen Amell/ Green Arrow as Gregor MacGregor lol (it must be the title). The book was better than I expected. It's not everyday that I read historical romances, and yet I found it to be quite refreshing. It was like killing two birds with one stone; romance and history all in one. That's probably one of the biggest reasons why I liked this book.
The writing seemed to match the Scottish accent fairly well, not to mention the time period. This book is a part of a series (which I didn't know beforehand) but you shouldn't be too lost (I wasn't). I felt like the climax and resolution of the story could have been better. It gave me the impression of being rushed IMHO.
Characters
Caitrina: I don't know. While I typically enjoy a heroine who is a fighter and courageous all the same, her naïveté bothered me. Its like she failed to see through anyone's eyes but her own. She came off as really selfish sometimes, but that could just be because of her age. She also lacked the proper understanding of how people are in the world . She came off as childish sometimes. I just wish she was better written.
Gregor: Oh Gregor....
Admittedly, It was difficult getting over the name. Especially since the name "Gregor" reminds me of "Gregor Clegane" from A Song of Ice and Fire series. So that makes it a double strike. Other than that, I liked him. I wasn't much of a fan with how he handled a certain conflict in the book, but men can be immature; even more so than women.
John: I liked John's character, as he turned out to be a good brother with an equally good heart
Pip: Didn't care for him at all. I cant stand ungrateful children with bad attitudes. I just wanted to...
Not a bad read altogether. Anyone who likes a little history with romance should check it out.
3.5 Stars!!
Synopsis:
After her mother is killed, due to a raid on her village by the Englsh, Caitrina Kirkpatrick is taken under the wing of none other than Gregor "Arrow" MacGregor; legendary marksman and most handsome man in Scotland. A few years later, Caitrina is all grown up and wants to be with Gregor, who she's had stars in her eyes for ever since she was a young girl. However Gregor still sees her as a young girl - but Cate wants to change that. Will he see her as a mature woman? Will his allegiance to King Robert the Bruce come between them? Or will it be her past that come back to haunt her?
Writing
I'm not going to lie, I kept thinking of Stephen Amell/ Green Arrow as Gregor MacGregor lol (it must be the title). The book was better than I expected. It's not everyday that I read historical romances, and yet I found it to be quite refreshing. It was like killing two birds with one stone; romance and history all in one. That's probably one of the biggest reasons why I liked this book.
The writing seemed to match the Scottish accent fairly well, not to mention the time period. This book is a part of a series (which I didn't know beforehand) but you shouldn't be too lost (I wasn't). I felt like the climax and resolution of the story could have been better. It gave me the impression of being rushed IMHO.
Characters
Caitrina: I don't know. While I typically enjoy a heroine who is a fighter and courageous all the same, her naïveté bothered me. Its like she failed to see through anyone's eyes but her own. She came off as really selfish sometimes, but that could just be because of her age. She also lacked the proper understanding of how people are in the world . She came off as childish sometimes. I just wish she was better written.
Gregor: Oh Gregor....
Admittedly, It was difficult getting over the name. Especially since the name "Gregor" reminds me of "Gregor Clegane" from A Song of Ice and Fire series. So that makes it a double strike. Other than that, I liked him. I wasn't much of a fan with how he handled a certain conflict in the book, but men can be immature; even more so than women.
John: I liked John's character, as he turned out to be a good brother with an equally good heart
Pip: Didn't care for him at all. I cant stand ungrateful children with bad attitudes. I just wanted to...
Not a bad read altogether. Anyone who likes a little history with romance should check it out.
September 21, 2014
The Arrow by Monica McCarty is a 2014 Ballantine Books publication. I was provided a copy of this book by publisher and LibraryThing in exchange for an honest review.
An English raid takes Cate's family and she is thrown in a well and left to die. When the Phantom brothers found her, she was caked in mud and near death from fright. The fierce warrior, Gregor, takes her in as his ward.
Now, five years later, the orphaned girl has matured into a lovely young woman. Lovely enough that her hero worship attraction to Gregor has begun to make him feel uncomfortable. He is distracted and has made a mistake that lands him back home for a little break, which means Cate and Gregor are under the same roof for a time. Cate intends to make the most of her unexpected time with Gregor.
But, Gregor believes the time has come to remove Cate out of his home and into marriage. There are plenty of men still who would marry Cate, but Cate only has eyes for Gregor, who believes she only has a young girl's crush on him, but he is tempted enough by her he can't seem to stop kissing her.
“He kissed her. It was a kiss unlike any he had ever given a woman before. It was a kiss to destroy any indecision and all fear. It was a kiss to woo, a kiss to persuade, a kiss to convince.”
I so enjoyed Cate's character in this one. Her observations were always spot on , she was honest, had her insecurities and doubts like any of us, suffered a little teasing because of her training, but knew her own mind. She loved fiercely, loved despite of Gregor's faults. She loved the whole man and never expected him to be perfect.
Gregor, like all of the Highlanders is the series is irresistible to women, a member of a top secret unit for the King called the phantoms and is proud, loyal and has a heart of gold hidden behind his tough exterior. I loved Gregor , but at times I wanted to slug him. Men! It doesn't matter what century or country it is, they can all be so arrogant and pigheaded. Does he redeem himself? Well... probably.
Cate and Gregor could have had a smooth go of things if not for the interference of others. Once a the seed of doubt of planted it looks as though all is lost, but betrayals and broken hearts will have to wait when Cate finds herself in grave danger and her true identity about to be revealed. Will Gregor be able to save her it time?
This is the 9th book in the Highland Guard series and they never lose their appeal. This one is very sensual and spicy, but with some of the best romantic lines I've read in awhile, especially coming from a warrior like Gregor. So, yes, Gregor does redeem himself and there is a wonderfully sweet sigh worthy HEA that will leaving you grinning ear to ear. Well done! 5 stars
An English raid takes Cate's family and she is thrown in a well and left to die. When the Phantom brothers found her, she was caked in mud and near death from fright. The fierce warrior, Gregor, takes her in as his ward.
Now, five years later, the orphaned girl has matured into a lovely young woman. Lovely enough that her hero worship attraction to Gregor has begun to make him feel uncomfortable. He is distracted and has made a mistake that lands him back home for a little break, which means Cate and Gregor are under the same roof for a time. Cate intends to make the most of her unexpected time with Gregor.
But, Gregor believes the time has come to remove Cate out of his home and into marriage. There are plenty of men still who would marry Cate, but Cate only has eyes for Gregor, who believes she only has a young girl's crush on him, but he is tempted enough by her he can't seem to stop kissing her.
“He kissed her. It was a kiss unlike any he had ever given a woman before. It was a kiss to destroy any indecision and all fear. It was a kiss to woo, a kiss to persuade, a kiss to convince.”
I so enjoyed Cate's character in this one. Her observations were always spot on , she was honest, had her insecurities and doubts like any of us, suffered a little teasing because of her training, but knew her own mind. She loved fiercely, loved despite of Gregor's faults. She loved the whole man and never expected him to be perfect.
Gregor, like all of the Highlanders is the series is irresistible to women, a member of a top secret unit for the King called the phantoms and is proud, loyal and has a heart of gold hidden behind his tough exterior. I loved Gregor , but at times I wanted to slug him. Men! It doesn't matter what century or country it is, they can all be so arrogant and pigheaded. Does he redeem himself? Well... probably.
Cate and Gregor could have had a smooth go of things if not for the interference of others. Once a the seed of doubt of planted it looks as though all is lost, but betrayals and broken hearts will have to wait when Cate finds herself in grave danger and her true identity about to be revealed. Will Gregor be able to save her it time?
This is the 9th book in the Highland Guard series and they never lose their appeal. This one is very sensual and spicy, but with some of the best romantic lines I've read in awhile, especially coming from a warrior like Gregor. So, yes, Gregor does redeem himself and there is a wonderfully sweet sigh worthy HEA that will leaving you grinning ear to ear. Well done! 5 stars
August 21, 2014
The Arrow by Monica McCarty is a period piece. I just love stories of the Highland Clans. Caty, a young girl, is rescued from death by Gregory MacGregor. She was dropped into the well while the rest of her townsmen were slaughtered. Her pregnant mom was taped and murdered. King Robert Bruce sent some of his elite phantoms to check out the town after hearing the English were seeking revenge. Caty fell instantly in love. Gregory took her home as his ward. His mother fell in love with her. His mom died of fever. Caty became the lady of the keep. Caty is actually Catherine the bastard daughter of King Robert. Gregor's brother John has been teaching Caty self defense. Shes quite good at it getting proficient at sword and dagger. Caty shows Gregory she's not a child but a woman. He tries to avoid her because he is attracted to her. They make mad passionate love and Gregory tells her they will marry. They have their ups and downs, falling outs and misunderstandings but when the English kidnap Caty, Gregory is beside himself. See how he gets his bride back and deals with his ftute father-in-law.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 452 reviews