Due to my contrary nature, I often read short story collections out of order. Blackwood's Ancient Sorceries and Other Weird Stories was no exception, although in this case I wasn't contradicting the author's wishes but rather the organizing principle of chronology, since this is a posthumous collection and the stories here have been arranged, more or less, from earliest to latest. I read the ninth and final story ("Sand") first, the sixth story ("The Wendigo") second, the seventh story ("The Glamour of the Snow") third, and the eighth story ("The Man Whom the Trees Loved") fourth...and only then turned to the beginning. Now having read the entire collection, it seems to me that stories seven through nine, easily my least favorite, represent the point in his career at which Blackwood abandoned the pretense of trying to entertain, bypassing the effort involved in revision in order to usher the reader toward what's truly important (for Blackwood, anyway), namely a main character's inevitable union/confrontation with nature/the mystical forces underlying the material world, a meeting that's tinged with both eros and thanatos. But Blackwood, or the later Blackwood of stories seven through nine at least, isn't precise or economical enough as a writer to make me feel the beauty and terror of what he's describing. I think it's there, but he doesn't make the effort to excavate it from the sands of dull, repetitive prose, leaving the reader to sift through it all. "Sand" and the seriously weird (unless you're into dendrophilia) and awkwardly-titled "The Man Whom the Trees Loved", for example, the two longest stories here, clock in at about 75 and 60 pages respectively, and they feel even longer- neither of these stories' conclusions offer the resolution of an idea or the sharpening of an ambiguity, or even a surprise, but a mystical feeling that by the time we arrive at it has already been telegraphed and belabored. I can just imagine being Blackwood's roommate, and him telling me over coffee in our spartan kitchen one morning (I picture this taking place in eastern Europe for some reason), steam rising towards his face in the gray early light, about how amazing the occult ritual he performed the night before in the woods or mountains was, but getting so lost in the rapture of the memory that he forgets I wasn't there, forgets in fact that he's speaking to another person...a person who, caffeinated or not, needs a certain artistry worked on him in order to get interested.
Two archetypes appear in almost every one of these stories- there's always a character drawn to that mysterious union/confrontation with nature, and always a skeptical character who denies the existence of anything that can't be rationally understood (inevitably proven wrong). Furthermore, every one of these stories deals with essentially the same theme- that the allure of nature is inseparable from the allure of both love and death. It's a fine theme, but I find it much more fully realized and convincingly expressed in a story like "The Wendigo", which really does feel like a ghost story you'd hear around a campfire, than in "The Glamour of the Snow." And yet the strange thing is that if you read these two stories back-to-back, in accordance with the principle of chronology, you'll see that they are pretty much identical- it's just that, in the former, the wendigo is a big scary dude, and in the latter, nature is personified by a ghostly, seductive woman- but the characters' conflicting emotions of temptation and dread are the same.
Another highlight for me is "The Insanity of Jones", a gratifyingly sinister tale of an office worker, Jones, who (disconcertingly) begins running into a deceased ex-colleague of his in bars and parks and other public places. This deceased ex-colleague convinces Jones that their boss, a tyrant who treats his subordinates almost as badly as Amy Klobuchar is reputed to treat hers, in a previous life tortured him (Jones) to death, and that he (Jones) must now either "deliver justice" or "rise to the heights of a great forgiveness." Unlike a later story in which the somewhat unsurprising surprise ending involves the discovery of two sets of footprints where there might have been expected to be only one, "Jones" implies that this communion with an underlying reality that so many of Blackwood's characters seek out may not be distinguishable from madness. "Ancient Sorceries", the collection's title track and the inspiration for the 1942 film Cat People, is mysterious, fairly perverse and surprisingly erotic, although I found the tension petered out towards the end when, in a few brief pages, everything is revealed (or almost everything), and a sort of paranormally-inclined Sherlock Holmes-type figure, John Silence, who's been listening quietly and smoking his pipe for the past forty pages or so, just as the reader has, pontificates on what it all means. As in the case of "Jones", however, we're left with a tantalizing ambiguity. "The Man Who Found Out", on the other hand, is quite funny (although I guess it depends on your sense of humor), a story about a man who, well, finds out- the secret meaning of life, that is- and becomes so consumed by despair, unable to imagine living for even one more evening with this dreadful knowledge, that he immediately takes measures to ensure he forgets it.
"The Man Who Found Out" also helps me to think about the collection as a whole. "Finding out" in all of these stories results in a kind of madness- you might even say that these (un?)fortunate characters have all "seen the wendigo." Many of the stories could therefore conceivably be read as cautionary tales. You're better off not reading that secret scroll; don't go back to that hotel in the rural French village, just let them keep your luggage, you can always get a new suitcase; don't go camping; and don't worry about what the mysterious lodger in the room directly below yours is chanting at 3 in the morning (no, really- put on your headphones, fall asleep to a podcast or something, but don't investigate).
Here's how I rank the stories, from my favorite to least:
1) The Wendigo
2) The Man Who Found Out
3) The Insanity of Jones
4) Ancient Sorceries
5) The Willows
6) Smith: An Episode in a Lodging House
7) The Glamour of the Snow
8) Sand
9) The Man Whom the Trees Loved