Reading a book like The Butcher Boys by Chris Gill makes me wish that the big reviewing platforms like the Bookseller etc and all bookshops sang the praises and fully promoted books more from small indie presses to the general public instead of merely the so called bestsellers.
They're only best sellers because they are promoted.
The Butcher Boys should be a best seller. Could be a best seller. I hope you'll promote it!
Written in Yorkshire Dales dialect, both in dialogue and prose, we are completely immersed in the physical and mental worlds of the two main characters, the butcher boys, Michael and Jack.
We can not only see the settings, we can feel, smell and absorb them. Gill is superb in his descriptions.
Although set in a fictional Dales village, I recognise it. The Surge is Bolton Abbey's Strid. The village, Pateley Bridge. Alive and kicking and vivid.
I've not read a book where the characters are butchers, and if Gill isn't from butcher's stock, his research is authentic. That trimming of meat, that boning of a joint. The very different shops. Wonderfully done.
The story shifts from boyhood in 1976 to manhood in 1989 and we feel these times by reference to music and politics of the time, from film heroes to the cultural changes of how people shop with the rise of supermarkets. We see the effect made by people buying second homes in pretty villages.
But at the core: the Butcher Boys.
Michael and Jack have become real people for me. I know them.
The ending? I can see the story continuing but for this book, it is dramatic and perfect. The denouement depends on whether you are an optimist, realist or pessimist.
At times, I felt similarities to Maggie and Tom's relationship and the atmosphere in Mill on the Floss. At others, the emotion of the series of kitchen sink books which culminate in A Raging Calm.
One that could be made into a great film or TV series.
5*****s