Chrissy Oropeza
Goodreads Long Review
November 15, 2011
Susan Minot compiled twelve of her fiction short stories into a book entitled Lust and Other Stories. These pieces are narrated by different women in different scenes of their lives, following the trend of romance. It is a powerful compilation that snapshots love and the trials and joys that accompany it. This novel brings to life the intimate moments that pinpoint women’t lives.
The book opens with one of Minot’s most popular short stories, Lust. The narrator of Lust tells her tales of love, or at least, her search of love. In the start of the piece, the narrator describes boys by name and her relationships with them; she shares the significance of them, if any exists. However, as the piece continues, the narrator becomes more negative and unattached; she talks of her dating escapades only naming the boys with body parts. The piece ends with a continued negative view of sex: “You do everything they want. Then comes after...their blank look tells you that the girl they were fucking is not there anymore. You seem to have disappeared” (Minot 17).
Throughout the short stories, Minot uses both first and third person narrative. Sparks, the second story is told from a first person point of view, by a character named Lil. This story is about a party that Lil attends; throughout the evening she recalls significant events throughout her life with a past lover, Duer. These memories are told out of order which adds complexity to the tale of one evening.
The third story, Blow, is told by and unnamed narrator in the first person point of view. The story tells of an afternoon that she spends with an old friend, Bill. Her short, abrupt sentences and explanations throughout this piece make the pace quick. The interaction occurs in one afternoon, while Bill is high on cocaine and upset about his lost relationship with Helen. The cocaine makes his character energetic and scattered; however, her character is “in that stage of being in love when you’re up in the clouds...” (Minot 47). This piece, though upbeat, ends on a pessimistic note. Referring to the negativity of Bill’s reflection on love, the narrator says, “Later when I came down I found out all of it was true” (Minot 47).
City Night is the first piece in this compilation that is told in the third person point of view. This story is about the introduction of Ellen Greenough and Nicholas Dickson and their following sexual escapade. The greatest strength of this piece is the verb usage and description-very strong and visual. For example, Theo swaying and muttering, Tina Means lighting cigarettes with gusto. People came and went- exuberant greetings, moments without a word. Then they were downstairs slumped on a couch, music thumping in the next room” (Minot 56). The piece essentially is about a one-night stand with a man that all girls want and the feeling Ellen is left with the next morning.
Lunch with Harry is a creative piece because the entire story comes from lunch that lasts a couple of minutes. The story is told in third person point of view; the three characters being Harry, his lover, Jane, and Jane’s friend, Emma. The piece’s essential theme is discontent in Harry and Jane’s relationship. This is abruptly revealed as Henry calls to Jane saying, “Will you come on, Rachel?” (Minot 70).
The Break Up is narrated from the third person point of view; the plot of the story is that Owen and Liz are dating and their friend Tim whose relationship has just ended comes over for a visit. The piece is moved by dialogue primarily-strong conversations. The story carries a bit of mystery, an unreliable past and backstory. It ends with a vague suggestion, “What do you think he meant by that?” (Minot 81). I think this is a powerful way to tell a story, to leave loose ends for the reader to conjure up ideas with.
The Swan in the Garden is told in the third person. A creative technique within this story is that it opens with a scene shown through dialogue; this conversation gives the reader a glance at the two main characters, Evie and Albert. This story envelops the trend that girls fall in love more often and quicker than boys do and that girls want to know where their relationships are headed. The dialogue within this piece is very realistic and relatable.
The Feather in the Toque is the next piece and is probably the most unique of Minot’s pieces. The two main characters are simply referred to as “man” and “woman.” The piece also lacks a physical description of either of them; they are a generic couple. The story is laden with descriptions of the house though as being open and bright. The story’s central theme is shown within two found items: a toque and a comb. The picture of a toque belonging to another woman and the comb belonging to the woman in the story. There is an openness to this piece, an uncertainty. The vagueness allows the reader to create to wonder what the situation really entails.
The Knot is the following piece and is creative in form. The short story is divided into four acts, each consisting of the same two characters. They move quickly. The first scene: love. The second scene: fighting. The third scene: break up. The fourth scene: hope. It is a realistic story told almost entirely through dialogue. This is my favorite piece in this compilation.
The Thrilling Life is told in the first person narrative and is the story of a man named Frank. Frank is discontent and restless, continually changing girls; the narrator describes his personality very well and analytically. The narrator believes “she’ll be a turning point” (Minot 122-123). She isn’t, none of the girls are. The ending is effective; the narrator shares what she would tell Frank’s “new girl” (Minot 122).
Old Siche is a very traditional short story within this novel; it is told in the third person and focuses on Meg Gillian. Though her name is given and her lover, Charles Howe’s name is given, the narrator often refers to them as “the girl” and “the man.” Whats stylistically good about this piece is the consistency and circularity: the story starts where it ends, but with a change of emotion.
The Man Who Would Not Go Away is the last piece and is excellent. It is about the remnants of a relationship that continually creep into remembrance. The narrator and the man are unnamed and for the most part un-described. This piece is very effective and revealing and old relationship as haunting; the repetitiveness of “man” as she talks is also very captivating.
Each of Minot’s works in this novel have a distinctive feel to them; they are easy to relate to, follow, and understand. The characters, situations, and emotions presented are realistic. Minot’s style of writing is simple, yet compelling; the reader is very easily pulled into and connected to the stories. She often using generalities which allows her audience to be broad.